CS Paper Radar

Data-Free Metrics Don't Work: The Missing Invariance Under Functionally Preserving Reparameterisations

Gabryel Mason-Williams, Israel Mason-Williams, Fredrik Dahlqvist

cs.LG cs.AI ·submitted 2026-11-11 15:38 UTC · v1
publishedcode/data

Abstract

Data-free methods for analysing and understanding the layers of neural networks offer many metrics for quantifying notions of 'strong' versus 'weak' layers, with the promise of increased interpretability. In particular, random matrix theory (RMT) offers data-free metrics that claim predictive power over the quality of pre-trained models at a layerwise precision and the ability to identify model pathologies, indicating a unique relationship with generalisation. As a result, metrics from RMT are championed for pre-training optimisation strategies and post-training compression. We establish that RMT-based metrics are unrelated to performance or training by showing that functionally preserving reparametrisations of a pre-trained model can have arbitrary metrics. We show this across a range of architectures and scales. To create functionally preserving reparametrisations, we exploit the well-established phenomenon of criticality: some layers can be re-initialised or re-randomised without affecting the functional behaviour of the model -- they are called robust -- while others cannot -- they are called critical. Re-initialising or re-randomising robust layers provides functionally preserving reparametrisations for which RMT-based metrics are arbitrary. Moreover, we show that relationships between metrics offered by RMT are spuriously related to generalisation. We conclude by showing that if many pre-trained models have data-free metrics in a 'good' range, it is, in part, dependent on model initialisation. Project page available at: https://gmw99.github.io/data-free-metrics-dont-work

Comment
NeurIPS 2026 (Negative Results Track), 44 pages, 21 figures and 18 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Transferable Graph Metanetworks

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-09-30 ·Yuxin Ma, Adir Dayan, Yam Eitan, Haggai Maron, Soledad Villar
theory similarity 0.65
Abstract

A weight space network (or metanetwork) takes the weights of another neural network as input and predicts properties of it. Most prior work trains such models on input networks of one or a few fixed sizes and evaluates them in-distribution. The few attempts at out-of-distribution size generalization remain limited in scope and have achieved only modest success. Consequently, the potential efficiency gains of training on small networks and evaluating on much larger ones remain largely unrealized. We propose Transferable Graph Metanetworks, which extend the graph metanetwork paradigm with a set of modifications that make performance transferable across input networks of different widths. The modifications follow two principles: invariance to the ways in which networks of different widths represent the same function, and continuity, such that weights representing similar functions receive similar predictions. We further study whether size generalization is possible for input networks trained independently from random initialization. Empirically, our modifications significantly improve size generalization on every task we consider. Performance is strongest on input networks trained under the maximal-update parameterization ($μ$P), where it remains robust up to $42\times$ the training width. Theoretically, we explain these observations with infinite-width limit theory: we prove size-generalization guarantees for our model on $μ$P-trained inputs, and explain why it can fail under other parameterizations.

0.52

A Comparative Study of Label-free Representation Quality Metrics in Deep Learning

cs.LG cs.CV ·2026-08-24 ·Daniel Richards Arputharaj, Daniel Jönsson, Gabriel Eilertsen
published similarity 0.64
Abstract · Published in Transactions on Machine Learning Research (TMLR). OpenReview: https://openreview.net/forum?id=yknkAksqr1

We present a comparative study of label-free metrics for assessing the quality of representations in deep neural networks to understand their reliability under a wide variety of configurations. We group existing label-free metrics into three families based on their construction and analytically establish connections between metrics within the same family. We then characterise the sensitivity of spectral metrics through controlled synthetic experiments. Finally, all label-free metrics are evaluated against downstream task accuracy across a diverse set of 260 vision models on six datasets spanning generic object classification, fine-grained object classification, scene recognition and geospatial task, stratifying results by architecture class and training objective. We find that intrinsic dimensionality (ID) is the most reliable predictor among the metrics considered. However, the reliability of all metrics, including ID, is moderated by architecture class and training objective. Our results provide a clearer understanding of what label-free representation quality metrics measure, when they are reliable, and how to interpret them in practice.

0.62

Statistical Benefits of Fine-Tuning from Pretrained Initialization in Diagonal Linear Networks

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-09-28 ·Alexandre Declèves, Etienne Boursier, Nicolas Flammarion
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Adapting pretrained models to downstream tasks with limited data has become a central paradigm in modern deep learning. Yet, despite its widespread practical success, how fine-tuning leverages information from pretraining remains poorly understood theoretically. We study fine-tuning from pretrained weights through the lens of sparse linear regression and two-layer diagonal linear networks. In our setting, pretraining provides information through the support (and signs) of the initialization predictor, which may contain coordinates relevant to the downstream task. We show how pretrained information reshapes the implicit bias and training dynamics, and can thereby reduce the sample complexity of recovering the target parameters and support. In particular, for a clean initialization with correctly inherited signs, we show that the required sample size is comparable to that of a weighted Lasso estimator that explicitly exploits the pretrained support through a suitably chosen regularizer. Our results thus show how information encoded in pretrained weights can be implicitly exploited by gradient-based fine-tuning, reducing the amount of data needed to recover a downstream task.

0.26

Compute-optimal data scaling for neural surrogates via multi-fidelity training

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-10-12 ·Paul Setinek, Fabian Paischer, Nils Thuerey, Johannes Brandstetter, Felix Koehler
top venuecode/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted at NeurIPS 2026. Project page: https://psetinek.github.io/multi-fidelity-neural-surrogates/ Code: https://github.com/psetinek/multi…

Neural surrogates for Partial Differential Equations (PDEs) are usually trained on synthetic data from numerical simulators. As models grow and scaling laws demand larger datasets, the cost of data generation often outweighs the training cost and becomes the bottleneck in the scaling quest. Unlike data in other domains, however, each PDE sample has a tunable cost that depends on its numerical fidelity, with the resulting cost-accuracy trade-off governed by known convergence rates. We exploit this property by formalizing neural surrogate training as a function of both data quantity and fidelity under a fixed data generation compute budget, treating fidelity as a fine-grained discrete spectrum rather than a binary distinction. Building on this, we show that multi-fidelity training enables Pareto-optimal error scaling against data generation compute. By using simulations at lower fidelities as an additional training signal, training on the optimal fidelity mixture matches the accuracy of high-fidelity-only training, with up to $6.3\times$ less data generation compute across our settings. We validate these findings across six PDE problems spanning structured grids and unstructured meshes, two distinct error sources (discretization and iterative-solver error), and four surrogate architectures, totaling over 7,000 training runs.

0.60

Two-Timescale Fine-tuning Provably Learns New Features for Two-Layer ReLU Networks

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-09-28 ·Etienne Boursier, Nicolas Flammarion
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Fine-tuning pre-trained models on specialized tasks with scarce data is central to modern deep learning. Despite its empirical success, theoretical understanding of fine-tuning remains limited. We introduce a Gaussian multi-index setting to study fine-tuning from pre-trained weights, where the teacher network has $m+1$ features, $m$ of which are learned during pre-training and one of which must be learned during fine-tuning. For two-layer ReLU networks, we show that two-timescale training, i.e., updating the outer weights infinitely faster than the hidden ones, learns the new task-specific feature while preserving the pre-trained ones in the model representation. Moreover, only $\mathcal{O}(d)$ fine-tuning samples are required for this recovery, independently of the number of pre-trained features. In contrast, with random initialization, the same number of samples is insufficient to recover the target parameters. Our results therefore demonstrate that pre-training can induce an implicit bias with a clear statistical advantage over random initialization, enabling feature learning from scarce fine-tuning data.

0.31

Train to Stitch: Topology-Preserving Regularization for Interoperable Representations

cs.LG cs.CVeess.SP ·2026-10-14 ·Akshay Malhotra, Nicolas Zilberstein, Shahab Hamidi-Rad
similarity 0.62
Abstract

As large, powerful pre-trained models become more prevalent, there is growing interest in developing methods that allow different neural networks to be seamlessly combined with little or no direct communication between them. Take autoencoder-based data compression as an example: the ability to independently choose architectures and train encoder and decoder models, while still ensuring they work together, could fundamentally transform how such models are built, deployed, and updated. In this work, we introduce a novel approach that leverages topological regularization to align the latent spaces of two independently trained autoencoder models, entirely eliminating the need for coordination during training. We provide a conditional theoretical analysis showing how the structural agreement encouraged by our regularizer can translate into approximate geometric compatibility between independently learned representations. Reconstruction experiments validate this approach empirically, substantially narrowing the interoperability gap across multiple datasets.

0.20

Representational Geometry as a Diagnostic for Adversarial Robustness

cs.LG cs.CR ·2026-11-13 ·Brandon Ismalej, Alex Cloninger, Gal Mishne
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Adversarial training is a common technique for making neural networks more robust to small, intentionally crafted input perturbations, and robustness is commonly measured through accuracy under attack. By exploring inter-network representations across different adversarial training objectives, we can analyze whether multiple networks organize their latent representations similarly. We study Multilayer Perceptrons trained on MNIST under three adversarial training regimes and compare the resulting population training dynamics and geometry to those of a vanilla network. We use M-PHATE to embed data samples across training epochs and examine how the geometry of the data changes during training under adversarial objectives. On penultimate-layer representations we measure displacement between clean and perturbed points, distributional distance through maximum mean discrepancy, and nearest-neighbor recovery. Our visualizations and quantitative analyses show that adversarial training leads to structural changes in how networks organize internal data representations, and robust accuracy and representational stability can rank the same defenses in opposite ways. These findings support a discussion of re-evaluating how practitioners approach the auditing of model robustness by treating latent representations and their training trajectories as diagnostic artifacts across sets of networks.

0.13

When Pruning Meets Interpretability: Preserving Sparse Autoencoder Robustness in LLMs

cs.LG ·2026-08-26 ·Suchit Gupte, Xueru Zhang, Mohammad Mahdi Khalili
code/data similarity 0.61
Abstract

Sparse autoencoders (SAEs) are widely used to interpret the internal representations of large language models (LLMs), yet their reliability under post-hoc model compression remains poorly understood. We present a systematic study of how pruning affects SAE behavior and theoretically show that, for a fixed SAE, its impact is governed by perturbation energy, a covariance-weighted norm. This perspective exposes a key limitation of magnitude pruning: by ignoring activation geometry, it distorts the learned representation space and degrades SAE functionality. Activation-aware methods such as Wanda and SparseGPT, in contrast, implicitly control perturbation energy and are therefore substantially more robust at preserving SAE behavior. We further reveal a consistent structural vulnerability across all pruning methods: middle layers are significantly more sensitive to pruning than early or late layers. Guided by this insight, we propose a layer-wise sparsity allocation strategy, achieving lower perplexity under the same average pruning sparsity. Experiments across four model architectures validate our theoretical findings. Code is publicly available at https://github.com/osu-srml/sae-robustness-under-pruning/tree/main.

0.51