CS Paper Radar

SoK: Design Choices in Tendermint BFT Consensus

Sanaz Taheri-Boshrooyeh, Yahya Hassanzadeh-Nazarabadi

cs.DC cs.CR ·submitted 2026-11-11 18:58 UTC · v1
survey

Abstract

Tendermint is a consensus protocol that tolerates Byzantine faults, implemented first by the Tendermint Core engine and now by CometBFT. Realizing the protocol's separation of agreement from execution, the Application Blockchain Interface (ABCI) of these engines keeps consensus apart from the replicated application, so one engine can serve many independent proof-of-stake chains. A sustained body of research proposes changes that span the protocol's mechanisms, from vote dissemination to block proposal and reward distribution, yet to our knowledge no survey studies the protocol and these works as one family, and broader surveys do not take Tendermint as their subject. We describe the baseline, the protocol as consolidated from its original descriptions, by its design choices. Each is a decision, such as how votes spread or how proposers rotate, through which the baseline provides safety and liveness or another property under its fault and timing model. We classify each work by the design choice it renegotiates, that is, modifies or replaces, by the properties it strengthens or weakens, and by whether its result needs a stronger model. Taking a broader perspective on that classification, we group the surveyed works' solutions into a few threads of concern in the baseline, namely its performance, the accountability of its validators, and the protection of exploitable information. For each thread, we identify the recurring strategies that their approaches follow. Together, these threads and strategies describe the current state of research on the Tendermint family. Where the strategies leave gaps, we pose future directions, each as an open question under an explicit fault and timing model.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Fast Tendermint: Speeding Up a Foundational Consensus Protocol

cs.DC ·2026-08-13 ·Preston Vander Vos, Daniel Cason
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Tendermint is among the most widely studied and deployed Byzantine fault-tolerant (BFT) consensus protocols, owing in part to its native leader-rotation mechanism that subsumes complex view changes. Like most partially-synchronous BFT protocols, Tendermint tolerates $f < n/3$ Byzantine processes and decides in three communication steps. Motivated by the push for lower-latency blockchains, a recent line of work shows that consensus can be solved in two communication steps when $f < n/5$. We present Fast Tendermint, an adaptation of Tendermint to the $n > 5f$ setting that decides in two communication steps in the good case, while preserving Tendermint's leader-rotation structure. Fast Tendermint collapses Tendermint's prevote and precommit steps into a single voting step and merges the $locked$ and $valid$ state. We give proofs of agreement, validity, and termination, and a formal specification in Quint, a modern surface syntax for TLA+, used to model-check the protocol.

0.40

Revisiting Fast Tendermint: An Agreement Violation and Two Repairs

cs.DC cs.CR ·2026-10-12 ·Alejandro Ranchal-Pedrosa
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Fast Tendermint reduces Tendermint's good-case latency to two communication steps for n>=5f+1. We show that its published round-change rule violates Agreement: one Byzantine process suffices for every f>=1, and for f>=2 two Byzantine processes suffice without double signing. The failure occurs when a process advances past a round without recording the value that may have been decided there. The Quint specification that accompanies the protocol does not allow this kind of round skipping and is not affected; the violation lies in the published pseudocode. We present two repairs. Walk requires a process to leave each round on a quorum of that round's precommits and to precommit before leaving. It keeps the recorded valid state and removes the wait after a precommit quorum. Justify carries the evidence needed to accept a proposal in the proposal itself, removing both the recorded valid state and the proposer's synchronization wait. Both satisfy Agreement and Validity under asynchrony and Termination under the partially synchronous gossip model of Tendermint and Fast Tendermint. Both retain proposal timeouts. The main text presents the executions that violate Agreement and explains the two repairs. The appendices provide proofs, a brief comparison with other round-change designs, and an extension to chains.

0.09

Vantage: Availability-Graded Broadcast for Signature-Free BFT

cs.DC cs.CR ·2026-08-17 ·Nikita Polyanskii
hot direction similarity 0.63
Abstract · 65 pages

Digital signatures make blocks and votes transferable evidence: one party can prove to another what a third party said. Authenticated channels convince only the direct receiver, so a proposer that references another party's block cannot prove to the voters who published it. High-throughput signature-free protocols therefore complete an availability vote or a reliable broadcast for every published data block before a proposer may reference it. We present Vantage, a partially synchronous Byzantine fault-tolerant protocol for $n \ge 3f+1$ parties, at most $f$ Byzantine, that uses only authenticated channels and collision-resistant hashing. Parties publish blocks on hash-linked author lanes; each view's proposer pairs a core manifest of lane prefixes that a quorum has acknowledged to it with an optimistic tip manifest of blocks it has just received. A new primitive, Availability-Graded Broadcast (AGB), makes the core irrevocable on a quorum of directly received acknowledgments while grading, rather than blocking on, the tip. A view that AGB leaves open or silent is decided by an on-demand instance of information-theoretic agreement. A block may thus be referenced in a proposal one message delay after publication, as in signed optimistic designs. Let $δ$ be the message delay after global stabilization (GST). With all parties correct, a proposal commits within $2δ$ of its send if all $n$ parties support it, and within $3δ$ on the quorum path, so a block published in time for the next proposal is sequenced $3δ$ to $4δ$ after publication. Safety holds under asynchrony; liveness holds after GST. On an emulated ten-region WAN with 100 parties, Vantage has the lowest p50 latency among compared signed and signature-free protocols at every offered load up to its peak, and sequences 250k 512-byte transactions per second at median end-to-end latency below 500 ms.

0.48

Competition, Collusion, and Corruption: The Spectrum of MEV Attacks on DAG-Based BFT Consensus Protocols

cs.CR cs.DC ·2026-09-17 ·Iliya Mirzaei, Heer Patel, Chenyuan Wu, Mohammad Javad Amiri
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 26 pages, 8 figures, 4 tables

Byzantine Fault-Tolerant (BFT) protocols guarantee safety and liveness despite the malicious failure of nodes. However, they do not prevent adversarial manipulation of transaction order, where the order a proposer assigns diverges from the order in which clients submitted their transactions. Exploiting this discretion for profit is known as maximal extractable value (MEV), and it is intensified in DAG-based BFT protocols, where every replica proposes blocks concurrently rather than routing transactions through a single designated proposer each round. The proliferation of MEV attacks on DAG-based BFT protocols has made the resulting landscape difficult to navigate: attacks are reported individually, on different protocols, and under different metrics, making it unclear whether two attacks differ fundamentally or merely in how they are described. This paper closes that gap by presenting an attack space for MEV on DAG-based BFT protocols, organized around four families: the adversary, the protocol, the target, and the deployment. For each family, we identify the dimensions that shape an attack's impact. Each point in the attack space fixes one value per dimension, thereby representing a distinct, potential MEV attack, which can then be instantiated on a specific DAG-based BFT protocol. We perform a set of experiments, each isolating a single dimension where the protocol permits it, to empirically measure its effect on the success rate of MEV attacks against six production DAG-based BFT protocols. Our experimental evaluation reveals that every protocol we evaluate is vulnerable to at least a subset of the MEV attacks in this space, and that which attacks succeed is mostly dictated by the protocol's own design rather than by attacker effort.

0.20

Systematization of Knowledge: Formal Verification of Consensus Protocols

cs.DC ·2026-08-22 ·Nikita Bondarev, Kirill Ziborov, Yury Yanovich
survey similarity 0.59
Abstract

Formal verification is increasingly critical for blockchain consensus protocols, where subtle bugs can cause irreversible financial loss and network failure. Yet the literature on verification methods is fragmented across tools, protocol families, and property classes, hindering cumulative progress. This Systematization of Knowledge paper analyzes over 20 verified consensus protocols--from crash-fault-tolerant Raft to Byzantine-fault-tolerant HotStuff, DAG-based FairDAG, and proof-of-stake Beacon Chain--to establish a unified taxonomy of verification approaches. We introduce a verification maturity scale ranging from informal reasoning to machine-checked code proofs, and present a Protocol--Property--Method matrix mapping protocols to verified safety, liveness, and economic properties. Our analysis reveals persistent gaps: liveness verification remains underdeveloped despite its importance for progress guarantees; specification-implementation disconnects undermine real-world assurance; and scalability limits restrict verification to small networks. We provide practical recommendations for tool selection and proof engineering, and outline a research roadmap toward scalable, economically-aware verification. This work aims to guide both researchers and practitioners in building more rigorously verified consensus systems.

0.24

Quantum Cadence: Post-Quantum Consensus with Multiple Concurrent Proposers

cs.DC cs.CR ·2026-10-23 ·Mohammad Mussadiq Jalalzai, Tobias Klenze, Jovan Komatovic
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 35 pages, 3 figures

The consensus protocols of most high-performance blockchains use quorum certificates, which bundle the signatures of a quorum of validators. Signature schemes such as BLS can aggregate the signatures of a whole quorum into a single short signature, which keeps these certificates small. A large-scale quantum computer would break these schemes, and no post-quantum scheme with comparable aggregate size and aggregation time is known. Without aggregation, a certificate holds one large post-quantum signature per member of the quorum, so it becomes infeasible for each validator to broadcast certificates, as modern consensus protocols often require. We present Quantum Cadence, a post-quantum consensus protocol with multiple concurrent proposers that avoids certificates altogether: every validator counts quorums among the messages it has received itself. Its safety and liveness do not even depend on signatures, although we add signatures to obtain accountability. Quantum Cadence builds on Cadence and replaces its slot consensus, Chorus, with Quantum Chorus, which keeps the optimal fast-path latency of Chorus: dissemination followed by two rounds of votes. When its fast path fails, Quantum Chorus runs Coda, our signature-free Byzantine agreement for multiple proposers. We also outline how the Conductor, which schedules the slots of Cadence, can be adapted to Quantum Cadence. In simulations with 200 validators, Quantum Chorus has a latency comparable to that of Chorus and scales better with the number of proposers.

0.50

Breaking Fault Lines: Unifying TEE-Assisted BFT Consensus in Partially Trusted Worlds

cs.DC ·2026-09-09 ·Xiaoqing Wen, Tong Liu, Jianyu Niu, Jialin Li, Cong Wang +2 more
published similarity 0.58
Abstract · Accepted to EuroSys 2027

This paper revisits TEE-assisted BFT under a universal partial-TEE model, where an arbitrary subset of replicas execute inside TEEs while the remaining replicas operate without hardware trust guarantees. We show that heterogeneous trust changes the structure of quorum formation and fault tolerance. In particular, we derive a tight resilience bound f < max {n/3, m/2}, where n is the total number of replicas and m is the number of TEE-enabled replicas. The result reveals a sharp threshold phenomenon: TEEs improve fault tolerance only once they exceed two-thirds of the deployment. Guided by this characterization, we introduce two protocol principles: (1) a dual-quorum construction that safely combines TEE-only and mixed quorums, and (2) a TEE-leader fast path that leverages hardware-enforced non-equivocation to reduce both consensus and view-change latency. We realize these ideas in Raftel, which is, to our knowledge, the first HotStuff-style BFT protocol designed explicitly for arbitrary partial-TEE deployments, and in chained-Raftel, a pipelined variant that further accelerates mixed-trust execution. We implement both protocols atop Intel SGX and evaluate them in LAN and WAN environments. Our results show that Raftel achieves up to 625 TPS with sub-670 ms latency in WAN settings, outperforming HotStuff by up to 308 TPS in throughput while approaching the performance of fully TEE-assisted protocols.

0.26

Asynchronous Verifiable and Complete Secret Sharing: From Design Patterns to System-Level Trade-offs

cs.CR ·2026-10-27 ·Joachim Bruneau-Queyreix, Martin Zivojinovic, Leo Mendiboure, Tom Claudel, Laurent Réveillère
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Modern secret sharing protocols promise robust secret sharing in fully asynchronous Byzantine systems, but their practical costs remain difficult to compare across papers, assumptions, and workloads. The difficulty is not merely experimental: protocols with similar asymptotic guarantees often place very different work on the critical path through their choices of dissemination, verification, batching, and recovery. This paper turns that fragmented research landscape into a corpus-backed designspace analysis and systems evaluation of asynchronous verifiable and complete secret sharing. We derive a design sieve, select seven representative protocols, and implement them in a common Rust framework. In our experiments on the Grid'5000 platform, we evaluate honest-dealer and faulty-dealer stress executions using latency, throughput, message count, bandwidth, and aggregate CPU-time. The results show that message complexity alone poorly predicts latency, that optimistic paths can be dominated by recovery cost, and that batching or packing helps only when verification stays off the critical path. These findings turn protocol-by-protocol comparisons into design-to-cost guidance for choosing, implementing, and extending asynchronous verifiable and complete sharing protocols.

0.28