CS Paper Radar

Your Hypergradient is Skewed: Antithetic Neumann Estimation for Bilevel Optimization

Jason Bohne, Pawel Polak, Gary Kazantsev, David Rosenberg

cs.LG math.OC ·submitted 2026-11-11 19:01 UTC · v1
top venue

Abstract

Bilevel optimization is a core tool in practical machine learning workflows, including hyperparameter tuning, data reweighting, robust learning, reinforcement learning, and imbalanced classification. Hypergradient computation requires the inverse of the inner Hessian, typically estimated via a truncated Neumann series. While existing analyses focus on bias and variance, we show that the product structure of the Neumann series introduces a third source of error: skewness. We identify that, unlike ordinary gradients, whose asymmetry is suppressed by mini-batch averaging, the Neumann estimator amplifies skewness across factors, with the third-moment error growing, under weak contraction, with truncation depth, inner condition number, and per-factor noise asymmetry. This arises in many practical settings such as corrupted labels, outliers, heterogeneous or class-imbalanced datasets. To address this, we introduce the Antithetic Neumann Estimator (ANE), which pairs each Hessian sample with a mirrored counterpart around a reference Hessian and averages the resulting inverse-Hessian estimates. With an exact reference, the antithetic product retains only even-order noise, eliminating all odd-order perturbation terms; with an approximate reference, the residual odd-order contribution is bounded linearly in the reference error. ANE requires only a modification of the Hessian vector step and combines with existing stochastic or variance-reduced bilevel methods. We instantiate ANE-SGD and ANE-VR, the latter adding recursive variance reduction. Across robust regression, data cleaning, offline reinforcement learning, and imbalanced classification, ANE-based methods improve on stochastic and variance-reduced baselines on every task (20 seeds each), lowering loss by 4 to 25% relative to the best baseline; the largest gains, on robust regression, are a 25% lower test loss and a 54% higher test r-squared.

Comment
Accepted at NeurIPS 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

On Generalization in Bilevel Least Squares with Overparameterized Neural Networks

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-11-07 ·Fares El Khoury, Edouard Pauwels, Samuel Vaiter, Michael Arbel
top venue similarity 0.67
Abstract · 73 pages, 5 figures. Accepted at NeurIPS 2026

Bilevel optimization addresses machine learning problems in which the outer objective is a value function implicitly defined through the solution of an inner problem. While its algorithmic aspects are well developed, its generalization properties remain much less understood. In this paper, we study the generalization of inexact gradient methods when both objectives are least-squares regression problems and when the estimator of the value function's gradient, or hypergradient, is obtained by implicit differentiation in function space. This approach allows us to derive stationarity bounds for these methods in terms of the uniform generalization errors of the two regression functions needed to estimate the hypergradient. When these regression functions are defined as overparameterized two-layer ReLU networks trained by gradient flow with early stopping, we obtain explicit finite-sample bounds on these generalization errors in the Neural Tangent Kernel (NTK) regime. Combining these with our general inexact gradient analysis shows the effect of sample size on the overall convergence of the bilevel method. Numerical experiments on synthetic data illustrate our results. Beyond the NTK regime, further experiments reveal an initialization-dependent implicit bias induced by the bilevel structure, which can lead to feature learning at the inner level and overall performance improvements.

0.41

Lower-Level Agnostic Bilevel Optimization

cs.LG math.OCstat.ML ·2026-11-06 ·Peiwen Qiu, Prashant Khanduri, Jia Liu
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Bilevel optimization is a fundamental framework for machine learning problems, where an upper-level (UL) objective depends on the solution of a nested lower-level (LL) problem. Existing bilevel algorithms typically assume that the LL objective is available for evaluation, differentiation, or unrolling. However, this assumption can fail when the LL response is produced by a black-box solver, simulator, adversary, or learned predictor. In this paper, we study LL agnostic bilevel optimization, where the UL learner has access only to an approximate LL solution $\bar{\mathbf{y}}(\mathbf{x})$ and cannot query the LL objective, its gradients, Hessian/Jacobian information, or the procedure that generates the LL response. We propose LeGo-BiO, a coordinate-wise pseudo-hypergradient method that estimates the missing Jacobian $\nabla _{\mathbf{x}}\bar{\mathbf{y}}(\mathbf{x})$ using finite differences of $\bar{\mathbf{y}}(\cdot)$. For each UL coordinate, LeGo-BiO constructs a decision vector subject to 1-sparse updates, thereby isolating the corresponding Jacobian column needed in the UL gradient computation. This avoids the directional-projection limitation of full-parameter response differences and, unlike derivative-free/zeroth-order approximations of the entire UL gradient, preserves the available first-order gradient information with respect to the UL variables for more accurate UL gradient evaluation. We establish convergence guarantees for LeGo-BiO in both deterministic and stochastic settings under an LL error-bound/Polyak-Lojasiewicz-type condition, without requiring LL strong convexity. Our bounds yield an $O(T^{-1})$ rate in the deterministic setting and an $O(T^{-1/2})$ rate in the stochastic setting when the LL approximation error decreases geometrically. Experiments demonstrate competitive performance of LeGo-BiO despite being agnostic to the LL objective.

0.09

The Role of Gradient Modification in Heavy-Tailed Nonconvex Stochastic Min-Max Optimization

cs.AI math.OCstat.ML ·2026-09-05 ·Tianxi Zhu, Yi Xu, Xiangyang Ji
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Stochastic min-max optimization has attracted increasing attention due to its applications in modern machine learning, while existing theoretical studies mainly rely on the bounded variance assumption for stochastic gradients. Under heavy-tailed noise, where stochastic gradients only possess a finite $p$-th moment for $p\in(1,2]$, gradient clipping or normalization is commonly believed to be necessary to guarantee convergence. In this work, we revisit stochastic min-max optimization under heavy-tailed noise and provide a comprehensive theoretical study of stochastic gradient descent ascent (SGDA). We first show that vanilla SGDA, without any modification to its update rule, can converge under heavy-tailed noise in both nonconvex-strongly-concave (NC-SC) and nonconvex-concave (NC-C) settings, establishing the first convergence guarantees for SGDA in these regimes. Beyond unregularized problems, we further investigate regularized stochastic min-max optimization, where directly incorporating gradient normalization into proximal updates is nontrivial due to the incompatibility between normalization and proximal structures. We overcome this difficulty by developing new clipping-free algorithms, i.e., Stoc-TRGDAM and Stoc-TRGDmax, and they both can achieve the optimal dependence on the target accuracy without using gradient clipping.

0.09

Newton-Based Methods for Bilevel Optimization Beyond Lower-Level Strong Convexity

cs.LG math.OC ·2026-10-19 ·Youran Dong, Junfeng Yang, Wei Yao, Jin Zhang
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Bilevel optimization provides a framework for machine learning tasks such as hyperparameter optimization, data reweighting, and meta-learning. Existing Newton-based bilevel methods typically rely on the classical hypergradient formula, which is generally unavailable when lower-level solutions are nonunique and the lower-level Hessian is singular. We develop two Newton-based methods beyond lower-level strong convexity by exploiting curvature shared by the lower-level and multiplier updates. Newton-based GALET handles potentially singular lower-level curvature under a positive spectral-gap condition, exploiting its range structure to avoid the squared-Hessian multiplier system used in GALET. Newton-based BAMM uses a strongly convex aggregation model when the lower-level objective is convex and the upper-level objective is strongly convex in the lower-level variable. We establish convergence guarantees and improved complexity bounds relative to GALET and sl-BAMM under the corresponding assumptions. We further introduce GNBO, a generalized Newton-based framework that captures the shared-curvature structure of the proposed methods and several existing Newton and quasi-Newton bilevel methods. Experiments on synthetic problems, data hyper-cleaning, and GPT-2 data reweighting evaluate the proposed methods across different bilevel learning tasks.

0.07

Bi-ZOL: Bilevel Zeroth-Order Learning with Nonsmooth Responses

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-09-07 ·Zhisen Jiang, Saverio Bolognani
similarity 0.58
Abstract

This paper studies lower-level-constrained bilevel optimization in a response-oracle setting, where lower-level model information is unavailable and the induced response mapping is locally Lipschitz but potentially nonsmooth. In this setting, the classical response Jacobian and reduced hypergradient may fail to exist. We propose Bilevel Zeroth-Order Learning (Bi-ZOL), a structure-guided zeroth-order method for finding stationary points of the nonsmooth reduced problem. Instead of estimating the gradient of a fully smoothed reduced hyperobjective, Bi-ZOL separates the bilevel chain-rule structure: it keeps the exact upper-level partial gradients at the queried response and uses zeroth-order sampling only to estimate the response Jacobian. This construction yields an approximate hypergradient that is more directly aligned with the Clarke chain-rule subdifferential. We show that the Bi-ZOL direction admits a partial-smoothing interpretation, quantify its pointwise structural bias, and prove finite-time convergence to a $(δ,ε)$-Bi-ZOL Frank--Wolfe stationary point. The bias is $O(δ)$ for piecewise $C^{1,1}$ responses under local regularity and vanishes for piecewise affine responses on active-cell neighborhoods. Experiments on incentive-based tracking problems show that Bi-ZOL achieves smaller stationarity gaps and lower hyperobjective values than vanilla zeroth-order smoothing under comparable response-oracle budgets.

0.19

Understanding the Subspace Stabilization of the Hessian and Gradient Covariance Matrix

cs.LG math.OC ·2026-09-25 ·Fangshuo Liao, Anastasios Kyrillidis
similarity 0.58
Abstract

The phenomenon of the top subspace stabilization of the Hessian matrix is an surprising and critical aspect in study of the second-order information of neural network training. Prior work argues that the top subspace of the Hessian stabilizes by measuring the overlap between the top subspaces of the step-wise Hessian, and explains this stabilization with diminishing parameter change in the late phase of training. In this paper, we define a new instability metric for the subspace evolution, and use it to detect subspace stabilization that is independent of the magnitude of parameter change. In the meantime, we observe that the gradient covariance matrix has a similar property of its top subspace to the Hessian. By using a between-class and within-class decomposition of the gradient covariance matrix, we identify an explicit form that gives a near-perfect approximation of the top-$(C-1)$ subspace of the Hessian and the gradient covariance matrix. In the gradient flow set-up, we show that the slow evolution of the idenfied approximation is due to the separation between the outlier and the bulk eigenvalues of the Hessian matrix, thus providing an explanation to the phenomenon of the top subspace stabilization of the Hessian matrix.

0.16

Explaining f-Divergence-Based Regularization via Local Curvature and Sharpness-Aware Minimization

cs.LG cs.IT ·2026-09-08 ·Nour Jamoussi, Marios Kountouris
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract · Published at 5th Conference on Lifelong Learning Agents (CoLLAs), 2026

Divergence-based regularization and Sharpness-Aware Minimization (SAM) are two prominent approaches for improving generalization in deep learning, both motivated by robustness to perturbations. However, their relationship has remained largely unexplored. Building on classical second-order expansions of $f$-divergences, we show that the two methods are locally consistent under parameter-space perturbations: both induce curvature-sensitive penalties, with divergence regularization yielding a Fisher-weighted quadratic form and SAM penalizing sharpness through the dominant Hessian eigenvalue. For negative log-likelihood objectives with exponential-family output distributions, this correspondence becomes especially transparent, since the Fisher and Gauss-Newton matrices coincide. We further show that the same local geometric perspective extends to input-space perturbations, where divergence-based regularization is defined through transformations of the input. In this setting, the regularizer induces a pullback quadratic form on the input space, providing a more general perturbation framework than standard SAM while preserving the same local sensitivity interpretation. To validate the analysis empirically, we use the asymmetric $α$-skew Jensen-Shannon divergence (JSD) family as a controlled testbed. Its local curvature coefficient scales as $α(1-α)$ and is maximized at the symmetric point $α=\tfrac12$, which recovers the standard JSD. Loss-landscape visualizations in the input-perturbation regime show that stronger induced curvature penalization is associated with flatter local minima. Experiments on four benchmark datasets further demonstrate that both accuracy and negative log-likelihood are consistently best near this regime of maximal curvature penalization.

0.56

Characterizing the Edge of Stability in Variational Training Without Priors

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-11-11 ·Juraj Marusic, Jonathan Wenger, Beau Coker, John P. Cunningham
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract · Accepted at NeurIPS 2026. 21 pages, 7 figures

Variational approaches in deep learning promise to deliver improved uncertainty quantification and out-of-distribution generalization by inferring a distribution over weights, regularized by a divergence to a chosen prior. However, prior elicitation presents a significant challenge in deep learning, resulting in the common practice of significantly downweighting the regularization term in the variational objective. Recently, it was proposed to train solely via the expected loss by relying on implicit regularization from the optimizer, rather than explicit regularization from the divergence to the prior. While this approach largely sidesteps the issue of prior elicitation, current theory lacks an understanding of how key optimization hyperparameters impact the implicit regularization. Here, we theoretically and empirically demonstrate that larger learning rates and fewer parameter samples lead to flatter minima of the loss landscape, which are known to generalize better. We show that training on the expected loss operates at a modified edge of stability, characterized by the signal-to-noise ratio of the gradient estimates and the number of Monte Carlo samples. Experiments on out-of-distribution benchmark datasets confirm the practical significance of the theoretical results.

0.35