CS Paper Radar

Factored One-sided Adam-Moment for Practical and Scalable SOAP

Jaemyung Yu, Byeongho Heo, Sangdoo Yun, Dongyoon Han

cs.LG ·submitted 2026-11-12 14:59 UTC · v1
publishedcode/data

Abstract

Second-order optimizers (e.g., Shampoo, SOAP) have emerged as compelling alternatives to Adam/AdamW and promise faster per-step convergence than AdamW in transformer training. However, they still remain costly in practice, and even SOAP still pays substantial optimizer-state memory and eigendecomposition overhead. We ask whether the benefits of SOAP can be retained at nearly the efficiency of AdamW. In this paper, we answer yes with a lightweight SOAP variant, Factored One-sided Adam-Moment (FOAM). The path to practical impact is twofold: first, FOAM employs input-only preconditioning, dropping the output-side Kronecker factor to reduce memory and remove one eigendecomposition. The Kronecker structure of the Hessian shows that this is exact for a diagonal output-side curvature and nearly lossless for a near-diagonal one, as we observe empirically. Second, FOAM replaces SOAP's dense rotated second moment with a factored Adam-moment estimator based on row-by-column statistics. Under the K-FAC Fisher assumption with a diagonal output curvature, this estimator exactly recovers SOAP's dense second moment, and we measure only a 15-20% K-FAC violation, with negligible effect on the update. Our empirical results support the claim that FOAM matches strong SOAP and Muon baselines in validation loss across scales of large language model (LLM) pre-training, uses half of SOAP's optimizer state, runs at Muon-class wall-clock time, and retains robustness across a three-fold learning-rate range. The results hold from 124M to 760M parameters, demonstrating that SOAP's gains need not require SOAP's cost. Code: https://github.com/naver-ai/foam

Comment
NeurIPS 2026. 17 pages, 5 figures, 11 tables. Code: https://github.com/naver-ai/foam

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Optimizer Memory Schedules for Outscaling the Overtraining Axis

cs.LG ·2026-09-04 ·Katie Everett, Shikai Qiu
similarity 0.63
Abstract

We investigate how optimizers scale across the overtraining axis and show that relative optimizer performance and optimal hyperparameters change substantially with training horizon. In particular, we study how matrix-preconditioned methods (Muon and SOAP) and a momentum-scheduled method (ADANA) scale relative to AdamW. We compare these four optimizers across models from 51M to 253M parameters and overtraining (OT) factors from 1x to 256x, sweeping the base learning rate at every setting. The preferred learning rate schedule can reverse across the overtraining axis, the best weight decay coefficient scales approximately as sqrt(OT), and longer horizons generally favor longer fixed memory. ADANA's scaling advantage over AdamW persists after tuning AdamW's fixed memory separately at each horizon. Log-time weight decay and momentum cooldown provide substantial gains for ADANA that compound as training increases. With this treatment, ADANA outscales AdamW with an exponent advantage close to that predicted by DANA theory on power-law random features. Muon and SOAP instead provide roughly constant token-efficiency advantages over AdamW across most of the measured range, although SOAP may gain further at the highest overtraining factors. ADANA begins behind both matrix-preconditioned optimizers but closes the gaps as training increases, surpassing Muon and becoming competitive with SOAP at our highest OT factors. These results establish training horizon as an essential axis for optimizer evaluation and design.

0.30

On the Principles Behind Neural Network Optimizers

cs.LG math.OC ·2026-08-17 ·Yushun Zhang
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract

Reliable optimization is central to neural network (NN) training, yet Adam, the default optimizer for modern LLMs, rests on a fragile foundation. This thesis develops a principled grounding for Adam and motivates new designs. First, we revisit Adam's divergence--convergence debate and show the existence of a problem-dependent phase transition: with properly chosen, batch-size-dependent hyperparameters, Adam converges, whereas under small-$β_2$ regimes it can diverge. Second, we investigate why Adam substantially outperforms SGD on Transformers through Hessian structure. We find that the Hessian evolves toward a near-block-diagonal form along training, accompanied by strong block heterogeneity. We prove that this structure makes Adam's diagonal preconditioner effective. We further show that this special Hessian structure originates from consecutive multiplications of large matrix variables, and we provide a rigorous analysis based on random matrix theory. Finally, these insights motivate Adam-mini, a new optimizer that reduces Adam's memory footprint by 50\% while preserving its performance. Our results also have broader implications beyond Adam: they reveal new local structures in matrix-based nonconvex problems, and also help understand and improve recent NN optimizers, such as Muon.

0.09

Low-Rank Friction for Memory-Efficient Transformer Pretraining

cs.LG stat.ML ·2026-09-24 ·Rajit Rajpal, Benedict Leimkuhler
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract

iKFAD is a recently proposed optimiser that replaces adaptive learning rates with adaptive friction in the momentum dynamics, yet performs as well as Adam. Its limitation is that the full friction tensor $ξ\in\mathbb{R}^{m\times n}$ carries the same $\mathcal{O}(mn)$ memory overhead per layer as Adam's second-moment buffer. Here we replace iKFAD's friction tensor $ξ$ with a rank-1 outer-product factorisation built from row and column momentum statistics, resulting in Rank-1 iKFAD (R-iKFAD). This reduces the friction memory footprint from $\mathcal{O}(mn)$ to $\mathcal{O}(m+n)$ per layer, which approximately halves iKFAD's total optimiser state. Despite this reduction, R-iKFAD maintains parity in performance with iKFAD: experiments on GPT2-Nano, TinyViT, DistilBERT and GPT2-S confirm that it matches or exceeds iKFAD while nearly halving the memory footprint and remaining comparably robust to hyperparameters. We analyse the continuous-time dynamics in two damping regimes. For linear damping ($γ>0$) we prove exponential convergence under strong convexity. For $γ=0$, the preferred option in our experiments, the friction is generated entirely from past momentum and switches off as the momentum vanishes, so geometric convergence cannot be shown. We nonetheless prove convergence to the minimiser, together with matching upper and lower bounds on the energy: of order $t^{-1}$ when the regularisation scale $ε_{\mathrm{stab}}$ is zero, and of order $t^{-1/2}$ when it is positive. To our knowledge this is the first convergence rate for a rank-1 factored optimiser in continuous time, and the first such result that does not require positive damping.

0.26

Clean: Second-order LLM Training at Linear Memory Cost via Nystr{ö}m Sketching

cs.LG cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-10-03 ·Beheshteh T. Rakhshan, Sahar Rajabi, Maziar Sargordi, Shikai Fang, Guillaume Rabusseau +1 more
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Training large language models (LLMs) entails a fundamental trade-off: memory-efficient optimizers such as Adam discard cross-parameter curvature, whereas full-curvature methods such as SOAP can accelerate convergence at prohibitive memory costs. We introduce Clean, a memory-efficient and full-curvature optimizer designed to resolve this bottleneck. Clean leverages the randomized Nystrom method to accurately approximate the left and right preconditioners in SOAP, and to reduce the optimizer's memory complexity from quadratic to linear in terms of model dimensions. We subsequently reintegrate the off-subspace components to capture curvature information beyond the low-rank approximation, preserving rich curvature at minimal memory cost. We further propose Q-Clean, a low-precision variant that aggressively compresses optimizer states. Q-Clean reduces optimizer memory consumption by over 50% compared to Muon when pre-training a LLaMA-1.3B architecture, all while maintaining strong and competitive predictive performance. Notably, Clean operates with a smaller optimizer-state footprint than standard AdamW while reaching AdamW's final performance 26% faster in wall-clock time. Furthermore, our methods uniquely enable the pre-training of a 13B-parameter model on a single 80GB GPU, providing a scalable, efficient, and accessible approach to large-scale model optimization.

0.13

Blog: Survey of Optimizers

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-08-28 ·Ruoran Xu
survey similarity 0.59
Abstract

Neural-network optimization in 2025-2026 is no longer well described as a succession of new Adam variants. The design space has expanded from coordinates to matrices and layers, from fixed training horizons to policies over time, and from mathematical update rules to state representations that must survive sharding and low-precision computation. This survey organizes recent optimizers and training optimization methods along four largely independent axes: temporal estimation, update geometry, horizon management, and representation and systems. It connects the spectral normalization of Muon, the historical matrix statistics of Shampoo and SOAP, adaptive and hybrid matrix methods, memory-efficient optimizers, schedule-free training, small-batch corrections, and quantized optimizer states. The central empirical conclusion is deliberately non-triumphal: matrix-aware methods represent a genuine advance, but there is no context-independent replacement for AdamW. Rankings change with model scale, data-to-parameter ratio, batch size, schedule, parameter partition, tuning budget, and whether the target metric is tokens, FLOPs, wall-clock time, or memory. The practical consequence is a compositional view of optimizer design and a stricter protocol for evaluating optimizer claims.

0.10

Do Pretraining Optimizer Gains Transfer to KL Distillation?

cs.LG cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-11-14 ·Lavinia Ghita, Dhruv Desai
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Matrix-structured optimizers can improve language-model pretraining, but it is unclear whether these gains transfer to short-horizon KL distillation from an instruction-tuned initialization. We compare AdamW and diagonal AdaGrad with two tractable Shampoo reductions, SOAP, and All-2D Muon across four dense Qwen student-teacher pairs under a common forward-KL objective and fixed training budget. Across scales, none of the evaluated matrix-structured recipes consistently improves the quality versus trainer-time trade-off over the elementwise references: AdamW generally attains the lowest validation KL, while AdaGrad can be slightly faster at larger scale. SOAP often tracks AdamW in KL but incurs substantial trainer-time overhead, and the two Shampoo reductions reverse ordering across model pairs, showing that conclusions depend on the feasible recipe. These results suggest that pretraining optimizer gains do not transfer automatically to KL distillation and should be re-established for the target objective and systems regime.

0.26

How Bregman Divergences Shape Shampoo

cs.LG ·2026-10-06 ·Bing Liu, Wenjie Zhou, Chengcheng Zhao, Hongtao Zhang, Boao Kong +2 more
similarity 0.56
Abstract

Understanding the principles behind Shampoo has recently guided the development of more effective neural network optimizers. These methods learn a preconditioner by optimizing the Frobenius or Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence against the gradient second moment. In this work, we investigate how the choice of divergence shapes preconditioning, which remains unclear and blocks further improvements. To do so, we develop a unified Bregman divergence framework that connects all popular divergences, allowing us to study them jointly. Through empirical spectral analysis of gradient second moments, we examine how divergence choice shapes Kronecker approximation and interacts with finite-sample error in preconditioning. We find that some divergences can better compensate for finite-sample underestimation of the empirical second moment, helping explain the differing behavior of their corresponding Shampoo variants. We further validate this explanation through GPT-2 pretraining experiments. By connecting divergence choice to practical training behavior, we believe our framework provides principled guidance for understanding the foundations of, and further improving, Shampoo.

0.24

Loss Landscape Features That Make Adam Stall: Definitions, Estimators, and the Preconditioned Hessian View

cs.LG math.NA ·2026-08-23 ·Rodion Podorozhny
hot direction similarity 0.56
Abstract

Across implicit-neural-representation (INR) architectures and analytic benchmarks we observe that a thoroughly tuned Adam (especially its learning rate (lr), e.g. in a hyperparameter sweep from $lr = 0.05$ to $10^{-8}$) can potentially reach a very low loss even on ill-conditioned loss landscape or converge at a plateau far above the loss attained by second-order methods. This report defines the measured metrics that help determine if Adam can mitigate the ill-conditioning on a given loss landscape. We provide the indicators by which each outcome is determined, that are: the condition number of the Hessian and of the Adam-preconditioned Hessian $D^{-1/2}HD^{-1/2}$ (with the derivation from Adam's update rule), the diagonal mass $ρ$ that distinguishes axis-aligned from cross-coupled ill-conditioning, the negative spectral mass estimated by stochastic Lanczos quadrature, and the gradient energy fractions over curvature bands, including the flat fraction that indicates the Adam stall. A worked out $2\times 2$ example and an illustration show the reasons why a diagonal preconditioning by Adam can remove axis-aligned ill-conditioning by rescaling and why it cannot do the same if the ill-conditioning is cross coupled. In addition, we present a case study of FINER image fitting architecture that goes over the whole loss landscape analysis framework: the fitting architecture description, reasons due to which its landscape stalls Adam at saddles, the measured PSNR values through our tuned baselines to the $120$--$134$\,dB results of the blockwise second order methods, the error maps behind those numbers, and description of the benefits such image fitting accuracy gives in practice.

0.42