CS Paper Radar

Evaluating Large Language Models for Scientific Paper Search: Retrieval Success and Inference Latency on Mac Studio and NVIDIA A100

Frederic Andriantseheno Rakoto, Yannis Bendi-Ouis, Xavier Hinaut

cs.AI ·submitted 2026-11-13 09:08 UTC · v1

Abstract

Scientific literature search can benefit from locally deployed LLM assistants, which reduce reliance on hosted model providers while giving research teams greater control over their data and infrastructure. This work investigates whether open-weight models can support web-assisted paper retrieval under practical computing constraints. We first characterize inference latency as the input context grows from 512 to 128k tokens on a Mac Studio and a server equipped with two NVIDIA A100 GPUs. We then evaluate eight models on the retrieval of 70 papers from seven scientific repositories, using queries that represent three levels of domain knowledge. The results show that retrieval success depends strongly on the selected model and the specificity of the query. And that A100 GPUs are generally faster than the Mac Studio, but its unified memory allows larger models that could not be loaded in the tested GPU configuration.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

AquiLLM: Evaluating Faithfulness in Open-Weight RAG-LLM Systems for Scientific Research

cs.AI ·2026-09-15 ·Bernie Boscoe, Srinath Saikrishnan, Vikram Seenivasan, Jack Stark, Andrew Lizarraga +4 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.67
Abstract · 14 pages, 1 figure

Scientific research increasingly relies on large, heterogeneous data sources, motivating interest in retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems that provide natural language access to scientific knowledge and research workflows. Researchers are exploring the viability of these systems as natural language interfaces for document search and for generating analysis code and pipeline components. At the same time, concerns about data privacy and control over research infrastructure have motivated interest in open-weight models and open-source deployments hosted within research institutions. In astronomy, this development follows a long history of computational infrastructure development, from archival databases and Structured Query Language (SQL)-based systems to large language model (LLM)-assisted research tools. This paper presents a domain-expert evaluation of faithfulness for AquiLLM, an open-weight, offline RAG-LLM platform designed to support scientific research groups in the use and preservation of tacit and formal knowledge. We define faithfulness as the extent to which generated responses remain grounded in retrieved scientific context without unsupported claims or omissions. We report results from an astronomy case study evaluating AquiLLM across retrieval and scientific analysis tasks. AquiLLM performs most reliably on explicit retrieval-oriented questions grounded in the RAG collection, while faithfulness degrades for queries requiring synthesis or ambiguity resolution. These results highlight both the promise and limitations of open-weight RAG-LLM systems for scientific research and demonstrate the importance of domain-expert evaluation beyond standard benchmark leaderboards.

0.52

EvoDuet: Bilevel Co-Evolution of Web Searching and Task Solving for Scientific Discovery

cs.CL ·2026-09-30 ·Young-Jun Lee, Jinheon Baek, Soyeong Jeong, Minki Kang, Seungyeon Jwa +3 more
code/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · Project page: https://open-galapagos.github.io/evoduet_project_page/

Evolutionary search with large language models (LLMs) can stall when progress requires external knowledge the model lacks. Supplying relevant documents helps, but simply adding web search tool can keep returning the same pages as solutions change. We introduce EvoDuet, a bi-level optimization method that co-evolves solutions and search queries with fixed model parameters. At each iteration, a retrieval gate lets the LLM assess its knowledge gap and choose to retrieve new documents, reuse stored ones, or proceed without them. An inner loop refines queries and ranks documents by the solution scores they are predicted to yield; an outer loop generates candidates in parallel from these documents and records the evaluated outcomes for later searches. Across 21 optimization tasks with one candidate per iteration, EvoDuet raises OpenEvolve's normalized discovery gain from 74.1% to 78.0% with GPT-5.6-Luna and from 61.3% to 82.3% with Gemini-3.8-Flash, whereas Qwen3.5-9B does not benefit. Our best runs surpass the previously reported best scores on eight tasks, including Swap Reduction on Q20 and Rosetta, and match them on three more. EvoDuet also improves with other scaffolds (e.g., Top-K, EvoX) on Sums/Diffs and Denoising, demonstrating its applicability across evolutionary search scaffolds.

0.54

Evaluating Open-Weight LLMs for Turkish Domain Documents Under Retrieval and Hardware Constraints

cs.CL cs.IRcs.LG ·2026-09-23 ·Imtiaz Ul Hassan, Öykü Akbulut, Onur Kaya, Ardhendu Behera, Swagat Kumar +2 more
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract · 6

Most Turkish-capable large language models (LLMs) are evaluated using general-purpose benchmarks rather than long, structurally complex domain documents. This paper evaluates five open-weight 7B-8B models for Turkish document question answering under a resource-constrained local deployment setting. The primary benchmark contains 100 systematically validated questions derived from a 109-page industrial R&D report, and the evaluation protocol is replicated using a second 112-page public-sector report and an independently constructed 100-question set. All models are evaluated locally on an NVIDIA RTX 3050 laptop GPU with 6 GB VRAM using controlled prompting, decoding, and 4-bit quantisation. The principal methodological contribution is an evidence-annotated evaluation protocol that separates retrieval failure from downstream model reasoning failure without requiring additional model calls. On the primary benchmark, end-to-end accuracy ranges from 49% to 75%. Seven lexical, dense, and hybrid retrieval configurations are additionally compared using 95% Wilson intervals and exact paired McNemar tests; none significantly outperforms the character TF-IDF baseline on either document. Evidence recall saturates differently across the two reports, showing that retrieval and effective context capacity can be binding constraints for some documents but not others. These results demonstrate that model selection, retrieval behaviour, and hardware limits must be evaluated separately when deploying open-weight LLMs for Turkish domain documents.

0.34

RATIO: A Benchmark for Retrieval Across Typed Ideation Operations in Scientific Literature

cs.CL cs.IR ·2026-08-27 ·Maayan Sharon, Tom Hope
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract

Retrieved scientific literature can serve as inspiration for both human and AI scientists. Inspiration can take different forms: prior work may directly suggest how to address a problem, or surface directions at different levels of abstraction---zooming out to a more general view or zooming in to a concrete realization. We introduce RATIO (Retrieval Across Typed Ideation Operations), a large-scale benchmark in which relevance is defined by three operations which we name ideation moves: Address retrieves potential approaches for stated problems, Broaden retrieves more general formulations, and Specify retrieves concrete instantiations. RATIO is constructed from millions of full-text scientific papers across CS literature via a general recipe that extends discourse-marker distant supervision---previously used only for classification---to corpus-scale retrieval, combined with extensive LLM and human vetting. Experiments show that operation-specific fine-tuning substantially boosts retrievers and LLM reranking helps further, but much room for improvement remains. Researchers blind to condition found the fine-tuned retriever's candidates more useful as inspirations. RATIO provides a scalable training and evaluation framework for retrieval components that support literature-grounded ideation, opening up new research avenues in scientific inspiration retrieval. We release full data, code, models, and annotations.

0.16

Can Retrievers Find the Same Paper from Different Aspects? A Multi-Aspect Full-Paper Scientific Retrieval Benchmark

cs.IR ·2026-08-16 ·Yiyang Wei, Fang Guo, Qiji Zhou, Zhizhang Fu, Mengru Ding +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract

Scientific papers contain multiple searchable facets such as background, methods. However, many paper retrieval benchmarks merely evaluate individual query-paper relevance, while overlooking other facets of the same paper. To bridge this gap, we introduce MAPLE, an expert-validated benchmark for multi-aspect, full-paper retrieval that evaluates whether retrievers can consistently recover the same paper from queries targeting its motivation, method, and experimental findings. MAPLE contains 2,095 queries about recent ML and NLP papers, grounded in both textual and multimodal content. We further propose MAPLE-Synth, a retrieval-based in-context learning pipeline that leverages OpenReview discussions and human-written query exemplars to generate realistic queries reflecting researchers' interests in different aspects of a paper. Our expert validation shows that these queries are comparable in realism to human-written queries and highly relevant to the target papers. Experiments across lexical, scientific-domain, general-purpose text, and multimodal retrievers reveal a substantial gap between retrieving a paper from any one aspect and retrieving it from all aspects: the strongest model achieves 98.1% AnyAspect@20 but only 15.7% AllAspect@20. Experiment/result queries and table-referenced queries are particularly difficult across retrievers. Although multi-chunk aggregation improves multi-aspect paper retrieval, considerable failures persist. MAPLE provides a testbed for evaluating and developing retrievers that represent scientific papers more comprehensively.

0.04

A Systematic Multi-Domain Evaluation of Document Retrievers

cs.IR ·2026-09-24 ·Valentin Velev, Andreas Spitz
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Document retrieval is a crucial component of many modern AI systems, directly influencing their effectiveness, robustness, and fairness in downstream tasks. While recent years have seen a growing number of retrievers, comparative studies in the literature are typically limited in scope or focused on singular benchmarks, domains, or model families. This fragmentation makes it difficult to draw reliable conclusions about the relative strengths, weaknesses, and trade-offs of document retrievers. To address this gap, we conduct a large-scale empirical evaluation of document retrievers, covering three families (sparse, dense, and expansion-based) and evaluating 33 retrievers across seven IR datasets, analyzing retrieval quality, runtime, and failure points. Rather than tuning each model individually, we evaluate every retriever off the shelf, under the configuration reconstructable from its public documentation and a uniform compute budget. Our results show that NV-Embed-v2 achieves the strongest performance on four of the seven datasets, albeit at the cost of substantial query latencies. Among sparse retrievers, we find that SPLADE-v3 rivals the top-performing approach despite much lower latency, and even achieves top scores on MS MARCO. On instruction-following datasets, GritLM delivers the best performance. Finally, an analysis of the retrievers' failure points reveals contrasts between models and families that indicate potential for unrealized gains in retrieval performance.

0.09

chATLAS: A Retrieval-Augmented Conversational Assistant for the ATLAS Experiment

cs.IR hep-ex ·2026-10-24 ·Joe Egan, Ben Elliot, Samuel Van Stroud, Alex Sopio, Ki Ryeong Park +9 more
benchmark similarity 0.65
Abstract · 20 pages, 6 figures

Large scientific collaborations produce extensive internal documentation spread across heterogeneous systems, making it difficult for collaborators to locate and reuse existing knowledge. We present chATLAS, a deployed Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) assistant developed for the ATLAS experiment at CERN. The system provides conversational access to more than 30,000 documents from several collaboration resources, material largely unavailable to general-purpose language models, using hybrid dense--sparse retrieval deployed on CERN infrastructure. A domain-specific benchmark built from automatically generated question--answer pairs is used to evaluate retrieval and generation performance and to guide design choices. We study the selection and domain-specific fine-tuning of an embedding model, contextual retrieval, ranking strategies, and generator choice. Fine-tuning combined with contextual retrieval more than doubles how often the correct document is returned as the top result on the most technically challenging documentation source. The deployed system also includes intent routing, safety handling, Mattermost integration, and an MCP server for future agentic workflows. chATLAS demonstrates that domain-adapted RAG can provide source-attributed, domain-specific access to collaboration knowledge, and offers a practical foundation for scientific collaborations and other organisations that rely on accurate, up-to-date retrieval from proprietary documentation.

0.26

RetrievalRouter: Joint Modality and Architecture Selection for Document Retrieval

cs.IR ·2026-08-26 ·Emre Kuru, Mehmet Onur Keskin, Reza Farahbakhsh, Noel Crespi
top venuecode/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted at EMNLP 2026

Document retrieval increasingly supports high-stakes information access in finance, healthcare, and law. Modern retrieval pipelines vary both in modality (text or multimodal) and in retrieval architecture (dense or late-interaction). These choices impose a hard compromise: the most effective pipelines are too slow and expensive to run at scale, while the fastest fail to retrieve evidence from complex documents. Practitioners must therefore choose between missed evidence and unusable latency, with no principled basis for adapting that choice at the query level. We show that this compromise is unnecessary. Not every query requires the same pipeline. Across benchmarks spanning financial and scientific corpora, no static pipeline dominates. We introduce RetrievalRouter, a lightweight query-aware router that learns, from the query text alone, which retrieval pipeline best fits each query. A single tunable parameter exposes the full accuracy-latency frontier, and for every static baseline, RetrievalRouter offers an operating point that is simultaneously more accurate and faster. Against the best static baseline, RetrievalRouter is 2.5% more accurate and 12.4 times faster. Furthermore, compared with prior adaptive strategy selection methods, RetrievalRouter achieves significantly higher nDCG@5 across accuracy-oriented settings, while matching or numerically outperforming them on both nDCG@5 and latency in latency-oriented settings. Our code and data are available at https://github.com/emrekuruu/retrieval-router.

0.52