CS Paper Radar

Trait Collapse in Text-to-Image Generation: Evaluating and Mitigating Personality Inconsistency in Visual Storytelling

Yuanbo Tong, Haoyuan Li, Jibiao Jiang, Zirui Wang, Yuchen Li, Jiamou Liu

cs.CV cs.CL ·submitted 2026-11-16 01:16 UTC · v1
top venuebenchmark

Abstract

In visual storytelling, a believable character must not only look consistent across scenes but also \textit{behave} in ways that reflect their personality. Current text-to-image (T2I) models preserve visual appearance effectively, yet consistently fail to maintain personality-relevant behavior---a failure we term \textit{trait collapse}. We show that conventional metrics (CLIP Score, DINO similarity) are blind to this failure, and that abstract personality descriptors and scene-level emotion labels do not produce consistent improvements over neutral prompts across models. To systematically diagnose trait collapse, we introduce \textbf{ViStoryBench-Personality}, a story-level benchmark combining an expert-validated Visual Cues Lexicon (Fleiss' $κ= 0.757$) with a six-dimensional metric suite covering personality alignment, cross-scene stability, and behavioral coherence. Evaluating seven T2I systems, we confirm a persistent semantic gap between abstract trait labels and visual evidence, and find that visual identity consistency does not imply personality consistency. To bridge this gap, we propose \textbf{Trait-Behavior-Visual (TBV)}, a training-free prompting framework that decomposes personality traits into renderable visual constraints. TBV improves Personality Alignment Score by up to $+22.1\%$, with larger gains in models with stronger language-conditioning capacity.

Comment
EMNLP 2026 Main Conference Paper. 26 pages, 5 figures
DOI
10.18653/2026.emnlp-main.362

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

PersonaShot: Benchmarking Person-Centric Narrative Continuity in Multi-Shot Video Generation

cs.CV ·2026-08-17 ·Yuji Wang, Yuheng Chen, Teng Hu, Ran Yi, Yijia Hong +5 more
benchmark similarity 0.70
Abstract

Video generation is rapidly evolving from single-shot clips to multi-shot narratives, where the human character serves as the core narrative anchor. However, existing benchmarks mainly assess character appearance or individual-shot quality, without measuring whether physical and emotional states remain coherent across cuts. They also rarely provide criterion-specific evaluation methods, although physical continuity, facial dynamics, and cinematic relations require different visual, temporal, and relational evidence. To address these limitations, we introduce PersonaShot, the first person-centric benchmark for narrative continuity in multi-shot video generation. PersonaShot contains approximately 1,000 multi-shot segments and 16 metrics spanning physical continuity, affective dynamics, and cinematic grammar. \textbf{\textit{1)} Narrative Continuity Benchmark:} We evaluate character coherence across three temporal levels: within-shot states, cross-shot transitions, and sequence-level trajectories. \textbf{\textit{2)} Human-Aligned Specialist Evaluators:} We distill reasoning from a large multimodal teacher into lightweight criterion-specific evaluators, each grounded in the visual, temporal, or relational evidence required by its metric, and align them with expert human judgments. \textbf{\textit{3)} Systematic Evaluation and Insights:} Our evaluation reveals distinct capability profiles across state-of-the-art models and a clear gap between perceptual quality and cross-shot narrative continuity. Even visually compelling videos frequently exhibit physical-state resets, abrupt affective shifts, and broken cinematic relations across shots. Human studies further demonstrate strong agreement between our evaluators and expert judgments.

0.39

Not Just a Subject: Capturing Adaptive Scene-Specific Variance for Visual Storytelling

cs.CV ·2026-10-15 ·SeungJu Cha, Ye-Chan Kim, Kwanyoung Lee, Dong-Jin Kim
publishedbenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted at ACCV 2026. Code: https://github.com/SeungJuCha/EOS-Story

Recent advancements in diffusion models have significantly improved text-to-image generation, enabling their application to visual storytelling, where coherent image sequences are generated from narrative prompts. However, existing methods primarily focus on identity preservation and often fail to adapt to diverse scene variations, resulting in semantic misalignment and structural inflexibility. We propose EOS-Story, a training-free framework that harmonizes identity consistency with scene-specific adaptation across text and vision spaces. In the text space, we decouple the narrative into identity and scene sub-prompts to prevent information dilution, but this leaves the scene without access to appearance cues. To bridge this gap, we introduce Cross-Contextual Bridging, which softly injects a phrase-level appearance residual into the scene's <EOS> embedding. In the vision space, we find that scale mismatch between identity and scene subjects causes a few identity tokens to be repeatedly transferred, producing structural artifacts. We address this with Adaptive Identity Preservation, which anchors identity features at the scene-specific scale (Identity Anchoring) and integrates them via Identity-Aware Self-Attention. To evaluate performance under varied spatial compositions, we extend the Consistory+ benchmark with diverse framing scenarios (Consistory+_+). Extensive experiments show that EOS-Story achieves competitive or superior performance on both benchmarks.

0.33

The Geometry of Simulated Perspectives: Dissociating Representation and Behaviour in a Multimodal Language Model

cs.AI cs.CLcs.CV ·2026-11-05 ·Mathis Immertreu, Fitim Abdullahu, Thomas Kinfe, Claus Metzner, Helmut Grabner +2 more
code/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · 30 pages, 10 figures, 2 tables. Code: https://github.com/MathisImm/persona-vlm-representations; data: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.2366482…

Multimodal language models can simulate different observers, yet it remains unclear how assigned perspectives reshape their internal representations and whether these changes govern their judgements. Here, we investigate the representational geometry of persona-conditioned visual interestingness in Qwen3-VL-8B-Instruct. Across 100 images and 53 prompting conditions, we systematically vary persona content and the linguistic framing used to introduce it, while recording behavioural ratings and layer-wise hidden states. We observe a systematic reorganisation of representational geometry across processing depth: early layers primarily encode image identity, whereas persona-specific structures emerge in later layers. Strikingly, prompt framing reshapes internal representations more strongly than persona identity, whereas persona content has a greater impact on behavioural judgements. This dissociation is further illustrated by minimal identity statements that alter representations even without changing responses. These findings demonstrate that representational distance does not necessarily reflect behavioural relevance. More broadly, they reveal how simulated perspectives emerge as distinct structures within the representational space of artificial cognitive systems, highlighting a fundamental distinction between the geometry of internal representations and their functional consequences.

0.28

ContextBias: Controlled Evaluation of Bias Persistence Under Context Shift in Text-to-Image Models

cs.CV cs.CL ·2026-08-30 ·Shaghayegh Kolli, Sina Emami, Moreno D'Incà, Pouyan Nejadi, Nicu Sebe +2 more
top venuebenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted to EMNLP 2026

Text-to-image models learn associations between concepts - in the case of this paper, people's professions, which we refer to as roles - and visual attributes. These associations can underpin many observed forms of stereotypical bias. A key open question in this area is whether these associations are stable or change when visual representations of people in professional roles are placed in different prompted contexts. We introduce ContextBias, a controlled evaluation framework, and ContextBench, a benchmark spanning 92 roles and 1,656 semantically controlled prompts, designed to isolate the effect of contextual variation on role-linked visual representations. Evaluating four state-of-the-art models on 66,240 generated images, we find that placing a role in a semantically unrelated context does not suppress role-linked attributes; instead, cross-role attribute concentration increases (pooled BI $+0.047$). Demographic cues, characteristic garments, and role-specific tools remain highly prevalent across context-free, related, and unrelated conditions, and are robust to semantic prompt reformulation. Scene composition and camera framing show the greatest context-sensitivity. These findings reveal a form of stereotypical persistence that remains largely invisible to context-free evaluations, highlighting the need for controlled contextual variation in bias benchmarking. Code and dataset: https://huggingface.co/datasets/shaghayegh/ContextBias , https://github.com/Sina-Emami/ContextBias

0.65

FACET - Facet Aware Contrastive Embeddings for Traits- Big Five Estimation from Life Narratives

cs.AI ·2026-11-17 ·Balakrishnan Arumugam, Priyen Parekh, Mehak Gupta, Joshua Oltmanns
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Personality is only weakly and inconsistently signaled by written language, and existing text-based methods typically combine language-model and psycholinguistic representations at the input or decision level. It remains open whether a more deliberate combination of the two views, and a decomposition of the prediction target, can recover more of the signal. We present a three-phase framework for estimating Big Five personality domain scores from life-narrative interview text. It encodes text and psycholinguistic features separately and combines them by concatenation or by a learned weighting, decomposes each domain into contrastively trained facet embeddings instead of predicting the domain directly, and pools the facet embeddings by attention into a domain-level prediction. We compare end-to-end with staged training and ablate the input modalities, their combination, and the facet-pooling strategy. On 1,332 participants from the St. Louis Personality and Aging Network (SPAN) study, facet embeddings reach AUC up to 0.740, and domain-level R2 reaches 0.328, highest for Openness. End-to-end training gives lower error than staged training in every domain, and attention pooling gives the lowest error in every domain. Combining the two views lowers error relative to text alone for Conscientiousness and Agreeableness, whereas a learned weighting of the views shows no consistent advantage over concatenation. The framework provides facet- level predictions that a domain-only model cannot, and it improves modestly on a regression from the raw features in four of the five domains.

0.22

HealBench: A Fine-Grained Benchmark for Evaluating Psychological Comfort in Text-to-Image Generation

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-10-20 ·Junjie Xu, Yuzhe Yang, Rui Yang, Luwei Xiao, Wenxin Wu +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract

Despite advances in photorealism, semantic fidelity, and aesthetics, text-to-image generation and image editing remain understudied in a human-centered dimension: whether their outputs feel psychologically comforting. Grounded in cognitive evaluation theory, we define psychological comfort as an affective response shaped by viewers' appraisal of restorative and emotionally supportive visual cues. We introduce HealBench, a fine-grained benchmark of 30,000 high-quality image-text pairs spanning 19 categories and 92 subcategories, selected from 100,000 candidates through a human- and expert-in-the-loop pipeline combining vision-language model matching, human preference models, expert filtering, and exemplar-guided augmentation. We also construct HealBench-Eval, a feature-clustered evaluation set of 1,095 instances. Using HealBench-Eval, we conduct objective and subjective evaluations of 14 representative image generation models and prompt-rewriting strategies. Results reveal a gap between conventional visual quality and perceived comfort: strong semantic alignment and aesthetics do not guarantee emotionally restorative images. Reinforcement learning experiments further show that HealScorer can serve as a reward signal for assessing and improving the emotional and restorative quality of generated images. These findings establish psychological comfort as a distinct dimension of human-centered image generation and position HealBench as a foundation for affect-aware generative models.

0.19

Do Emotion Concepts Generalize Across Sources, Modalities, and Architectures in Vision-Language Models?

cs.CV cs.LG ·2026-09-28 ·Bohao Xing, Xin Liu, Kaishen Yuan, Deng Li, Rong Gao +3 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Recent studies suggest that large language models encode emotion concepts as structured internal representations, but most existing work focuses on text and a single architecture. Therefore, we ask, do emotion concepts generalize across sources, modalities, and architectures in vision--language models (VLMs)? To address this, we construct CMES (Cross-Modal Emotion Stimuli), a multi-source collection of emotion-conditioned stories, real facial expressions, synthetic portraits, and synthetic emotion-evoking scenes. For each stimulus source, we extract a separate set of six Ekman emotion vectors from each of three VLMs. We report four main findings as follows: 1) Image-derived emotion vectors form a low-dimensional geometry similar to that of text-derived vectors. Valence is relatively stable across sources, while arousal varies more. 2) Text- and image-derived emotion vectors have modest cosine similarity but still show held-out cross-modal correspondence. Text-derived vectors can also steer image interpretation. 3) Cross-architecture correspondence remains even when native cosine is near zero. Transformations estimated from generic ImageNet activations recover both correspondence and causal transfer without using the six emotion vectors or their labels. 4) After aligning representations across architectures, we construct a shared emotion subspace that preserves affective geometry and selective steering effects. The corresponding consensus emotion vectors also generalize to a held-out fourth architecture at two model sizes. These results suggest that emotion representations can share relational structure and causal effects across sources, modalities, and architectures, even when individual vector directions differ.

0.19

Presence Is Not Faithfulness: Figurative Vehicle Intrusion in Text-to-Image Generation

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-09-26 ·Xiaoyu Ma, Chen Yang, Hao Chen
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract · submitted to ICLR 2027

Text-to-image (TTI) models increasingly generate high-quality images from natural-language prompts, yet figurative language exposes a failure: a vehicle that should guide the depiction of a tenor may instead be rendered as a visible object. We call this failure Figurative Vehicle Intrusion: the intruding content is textually licensed, but it is assigned the wrong visual role, showing that visual presence is not always faithfulness and that presence-oriented evaluation can miss such errors. To study it systematically, we introduce Vehicle Intrusion and Semantic Tenor Assessment (VISTA), a multilingual benchmark of figurative prompts organized by Figurative Form and Mapping Mechanism. We further propose V-Score, a diagnostic question-answering metric that evaluates role-aware figurative faithfulness in generated images. Evaluations on recent high-performing TTI models show that vehicle intrusion persists across languages and figurative categories. As a lightweight mitigation, we introduce VISTA-Guard, which partially reduces vehicle intrusion and suggests a practical path toward more figuratively faithful TTI generation. All resources will be released publicly.

0.21