CS Paper Radar

AI Tool Adoption and Loyalty among Product, Industrial, and UX/UI Designers across the Double Diamond

Sepideh Tajarmakan, Khashayar Hojjati Emami

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-11-16 04:44 UTC · v1
survey

Abstract

Designers share many AI tools, yet their roles produce different work. This survey compared 337 Product, Industrial and UX/UI Designers from 40 countries and regions across the four phases of the Double Diamond. It measured AI adoption, breadth and frequency, tool function and the number of tools named per phase. A tool was loyal when a role picked it in all four phases. Industrial Designers adopted AI less often (73.9% against 88.2% and 87.9%), a gap that went with physical projects once project type and country were held constant. Of 60 AI tools, 25 were common to all three roles and carried at least 90% of each role's picks. Tool function differed by role, most of all in Develop. A few loyal tools carried about half of the picks, led by ChatGPT. Tool counts fell across the phases in every role. A hurdle model found a Phase x Role interaction for using AI in a phase (p = 0.041), which was not shown for the number of tools (p = 0.080). Predicted adoption among UX/UI Designers fell from 87.2% in Define to 43.9% in Develop. Support for designers needs one shared core, role-specific tools and most attention in Develop.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

AI Tools Adoption across the Double Diamond Workflow: Phase, Mode, and Barriers in Designer Practice

cs.HC ·2026-09-28 ·Sepideh Tajarmakan, Khashayar Hojjati Emami
similarity 0.84
Abstract

Designers are adopting AI faster than the tools built for them can keep up. General-purpose conversational AI led AI use among designers in three of the four phases of design work, ahead of tools built for design. We surveyed 443 designers from at least 43 countries about AI use in each phase of the Double Diamond: Discover, Define, Develop and Deliver. Tools were classified by output and function. Of these designers, 79.7% confirmed AI use in at least one phase. Adopters used AI in a mean of 2.89 phases, and only 35.1% used it in all four. They added phases in workflow order, from Discover onward. Conversational tools led in Discover, Define and Deliver. AI-native image generation led in Develop, where AI-native tools peaked at 57.6% of tool picks. Embedded AI features in existing design software peaked later, in Deliver (37.5%). Fewer designers used AI in later phases, from 318 in Discover to 182 in Deliver. Those who did named a similar number of tools per phase. Low perceived usefulness was the only barrier that separated non-adopters (40.5%) from adopters (16.4%) after correction for multiple tests. Concern about accuracy was similar in both groups.

0.09

Does AI Save Time on Product Design? A Randomized Controlled Experiment of AI Prompt-to-Design Workflows

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-09-22 ·Remy Stewart, Olabode Anise, Andrew Hogan, Augustus Griffin
similarity 0.59
Abstract

AI tools for digital product design now offer prompt-to-design capabilities, allowing designers and their non-designer colleagues to create prototypes through conversational workflows with large language models (LLMs). While these tools promise time savings, experimental evidence in product design remains limited compared with evidence from software engineering. We conducted a randomized controlled trial with 50 product designers and 50 product managers to evaluate prospective time savings from leveraging Figma Make in design work. Participants attempted three standardized design tasks with or without access to Figma Make. Among participants who completed the study tasks, access to Figma Make was associated with approximately 20% shorter completion times, with larger gains among product managers. Our findings suggest that prompt-to-design tools may enable product managers to further contribute to design work, while the benefits for professional designers may be task dependent.

0.19

Engineering Signals of Human-AI Collaboration in the Agentic Coding Era: A Longitudinal Analysis of 33,228 Pull Requests from vLLM and SGLang with Implications for Biomedical AI Agents and Bioinformatics Pipeline Developmen

cs.SE cs.AIcs.ETcs.HC+1 ·2026-08-14 ·Jiada Li, Xuesong Ye, Olamide Olowoniyi
code/data similarity 0.57
Abstract · 24 pages, 9 Figures

The rapid adoption of AI coding assistants and autonomous agentic development systems has coincided with major changes in the pace and structure of open-source software engineering. Yet empirical longitudinal evidence of these changes at the team level remains limited. We present a descriptive longitudinal analysis of seven engineering metrics: pull request (PR) throughput, cycle time, contributor diversity, PR comment density, merge rate, new-author participation, and PR size. Metrics were computed from all merged PRs in two high-velocity AI infrastructure repositories, vLLM (February 2023-June 2026; 18,290 PRs) and SGLang (January 2024-June 2026; 14,938 PRs). We segment development into four eras aligned with major changes in AI-assisted software development and examine human- and bot-authored activities. Both projects show substantial increases in development velocity and AI-developer collaboration signals. PR throughput increased 21x in vLLM and 17.9x in SGLang, while bot-authored PRs accounted for less than 0.2% of this growth, indicating that the increase was overwhelmingly human-driven. In the latest era, median cycle time was 1.04 days for vLLM and 0.62 days for SGLang, while P90 cycle times reached 16.8 and 14.3 days, respectively. Monthly unique authors increased steadily in both projects, suggesting broader contributor participation. PR comment density increased 4.2x in vLLM and 3.8x in SGLang, with bot comments contributing an estimated 15-20% of the increase. In contrast, PR size remained relatively stable across eras. Overall, AI-assisted development is associated with higher throughput, broader contributor participation, and increased AI-developer collaboration signals in high-velocity open-source software development.

0.26

Helpful but Fallible: Developer Experiences of AI Tools Under a Coordinated Industrial Roll-out

cs.SE ·2026-09-17 ·Andreas Bexell, Rushali Gupta, Lo Gullstrand Heander, Emma Söderberg, Per Runeson +3 more
similarity 0.57
Abstract

AI-enabled software development tools (AI-devtools) are being industrially adopted under strong expectations of productivity gains, yet developers' experiences of such roll-outs are underexplored. Organizations commit budgets, evaluate staff, and revise practice on a partial picture, since the evidence base is mainly tool evaluations, productivity metrics, and surveys, with few qualitative in-situ accounts of ongoing, coordinated roll-outs. We report a case study of a coordinated roll-out of AI-devtools at a large Swedish telecommunications company, investigating how developers experience the roll-out and how they anticipate their profession will change. We conducted semi-structured interviews with 12 software professionals across three sites, analyzed with process coding and thematic analysis, and interpreted through the extended Technology Acceptance Model (TAM2) as a post-hoc analytical lens. Our findings on use cases, productivity, frustrations, and tool limitations corroborate prior survey work. Beyond corroboration, the interviews surface a management-developer expectation gap that maps onto the TAM2 constructs of subjective norm and voluntariness, and show that participants weigh perceived risk heavily, a factor that TAM2 and similar acceptance models do not represent. AI-devtools emerge as helpful but fallible assistants whose value is shaped by organizational expectations, system scale, and developers' skills.

0.05

Mapping E-textiles Design Pain Points and Generative AI Opportunities: Insights from Workshops in Shanghai and Winchester

cs.HC ·2026-10-05 ·Zhuchenyang Liu, Nianchong Qu, Yao Zhang, Marie O'Mahony, Qi Wang +1 more
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 10 pages, 2 figures, 2 tables

E-textile design involves complex decisions across materials, sensor and actuator structures, fabrication, garment integration, and data processing. It typically requires iterative prototyping and testing, which are time- and labour-intensive, while few practitioners possess cross-disciplinary expertise across all relevant domains. To identify current bottlenecks and explore how Generative AI (GenAI) might support the design process, we conducted two half-day co-design workshops, one in Shanghai and one in Winchester, with practitioners from materials science, electronics, garment design, human-computer interaction, and manufacturing. Twenty practitioners participated in the Shanghai workshop; ten of them had prior experience in e-textiles and form the contributing sample analysed here. A further ten practitioners participated in the Winchester workshop. Participants mapped their own design pipelines, annotated bottlenecks, and proposed where GenAI could provide support. Rather than presenting a ranked list of opportunities, we report a process map that indexes each proposed GenAI role to the pipeline stage at which practitioners located it, together with the conditions on which they stated its usefulness would depend. Across both sites, practitioners consistently identified domain-specific operational barriers, including data scarcity, the disconnect between prototyping and manufacturing, and trade-offs in material-hardware integration. They also emphasized that the primary barrier to GenAI-driven e-textile design is not general model capability, but the lack of standardized, machine-readable representations of e-textile designs. Based on these findings, we identify four classes of domain-tailored AI tools that could support future e-textile design processes.

0.24

Too Late to Prune: Generative AI, the Screen, and Team Creative Decisions

cs.AI econ.GN ·2026-10-10 ·Difang Huang, Shumin Yu, Fadong Chen, Weihua Zhou
position similarity 0.55
Abstract

Generative AI makes options cheap and shifts the bottleneck of creative work from generating options to screening them. We argue that AI's value depends on whether its options arrive before or after the team's screen. In our model, early options compete for a place in the portfolio; late options arrive after that competition and are kept unscreened. In a preregistered experiment, we randomly assigned 148 three-person teams to five schedules of access to the same language model during a product-design task with timed search and selection stages. Moving the same 15 minutes of access from search to selection lowered expert-rated creativity by 0.62 standard deviations, although teams used the model at similar rates. Platform logs locate the difference at the screen. Early access enlarged the pool of ideas fivefold, and teams pruned it. Late-access teams reached the screen with the same small pool as teams without AI and then searched again, devoting 29% of their selection-stage queries to generating new options, compared with 11% for teams with access throughout. Late access added breadth, not quality: these teams submitted 73% more proposals than did teams without AI. Language-model judges detected the benefit of access but not the cost of late timing.

0.31

Where Does the Human End? Creative Agency with Generative AI across Five Years of Chinese Digital Painting

cs.HC ·2026-09-08 ·Yibo Meng, Ruiqi Chen, Shuheng Cao, Weijia Zhang, Chengxi Zang
similarity 0.55
Abstract

As generative AI enters creative work, practitioners must decide where AI assistance ends and human authorship begins. Human-agent interaction (HAI) research has examined AI as a tool, collaborator, consultant, and competitor. The longitudinal problem is how these roles are revised as systems become more capable, public, and economically embedded. We report a five-year interview study with 17 Chinese digital painters, based on annual semi-structured interviews from 2021 to 2025. Participants described recurring but non-uniform patterns of protective resistance, pragmatic task delegation, and, for some, reflective agency repartitioning. Early resistance protected observation, originality, signature, and ownership from AI. Later delegation placed AI in bounded tasks such as references, backgrounds, rough sketches, and client-facing drafts. By 2025, some participants built hybrid workflows around human-only zones, while others described fatigue, precarity, or difficulty locating a remaining human role. Peer norms, emotional climates, and production pressures shaped which delegations felt useful, acceptable, or exhausting. Copyright, authorship, and creative labor remained recurring limits on what participants were willing to delegate. We frame these accounts as longitudinal agency partitioning, the situated work of deciding which stages, responsibilities, values, and claims remain human in creative human-agent interaction. We discuss design implications for revisable agency-boundary controls, provenance scaffolds, and community-facing authorship norms.

0.49

The Customer Is the Builder: How AI Coding Agents Are Rewriting the Economics of Software

cs.SE cs.CYecon.GN ·2026-10-21 ·Ripon Chandra Malo, Zimeng Yu, Tong Qiu
benchmarkcode/datahot direction similarity 0.54
Abstract · 37 pages, 24 figures, 7 tables. Code and data: https://github.com/riponcm/The-Customer-Is-the-Builder. Archived release: https://doi.org/10.…

AI coding agents could change whether organizations buy software or build the functionality they need. We focus on organizations and professional buyers whose domain knowledge can help them specify and evaluate tools for their work. We define the software substitution frontier as the functions customers could build and maintain at an acceptable standard for less than buying them. Using public data, we compare growing capacity to build with indicators of market change. Since 2023, the length of benchmark tasks that leading agents can complete at 50 percent success, measured in human working time, has doubled about every 129 days. A broad search identified 575 potential open-source alternatives to selected commercial products, although some functional matches still require independent validation. The Craft suite produced 12 application repositories over 12.0 days of public development, but these remain early versions with unverified completeness and reliability. Market evidence is mixed: purchased software gained US investment share and tracked commercial installations grew. Yet 32 percent of respondents to an organizational survey reported forgoing at least one software purchase because their organization could build the functionality with coding agents. These self-reports do not establish the spending displaced or the reliability of the resulting tools. The gap motivates a warning: customers' capacity to build could affect individual buying decisions before a broad purchasing shift becomes visible. We examine this possibility using benchmark projections and observable market tests. The projections are an extrapolation, not a forecast of customer switching.

0.43