CS Paper Radar

Does the Voice Matter? Evaluating Frustration Detection on Deployed Clinical Voice-Agent Calls

Annika Michael, Zachary Ellis, Yuxiang Zhou, Samuel Thio, Yajie Vera He, Spencer Hazel, Jared Joselowitz

cs.CL cs.AI ·submitted 2026-11-16 12:27 UTC · v2
published

Abstract

Autonomous voice agents now conduct routine clinical follow-up calls, so some automated triage is unavoidable. A patient becoming frustrated is one thing that triage should catch. These systems typically read only the transcript the speech-to-text stage produces, not the voice, and whether that is enough is largely untested on real clinical speech. We study per-turn frustration detection on real patient calls from a deployed clinical voice agent: 150 turns from six calls labelled by three annotators, with a length-matched acted corpus as a control, and 714 turns from 30 calls. Patient turns are overwhelmingly short: across the deployed calls, roughly 59% are one or two words, against 13% in the full acted corpus, and a corpus accuracy gap remains even after the acted set is length-matched. On one-word turns, transcript-only detection does not exclude chance. Across five audio-capable language models, the transcript flags 3 or 4 of the 39 frustrated one-word turns in the 30 calls, and a classifier given only the word count reaches 57.3%. Whether audio helps depends on the model and on the instruction. Asked to attend to delivery, two Gemini 2.5 models gain 3.0 pp over the transcript across 30 calls (-1.0 to 7.5 pp). Of the turns they confidently clear, 6.9% were in fact frustrated for audio against 13.0% for the transcript, a difference of 6.1 pp (2.2 to 10.4 pp). Across the 30 calls, given one prompt identical for both inputs, no model's audio-text interval excludes zero. Under the input-specific prompts, a newer Gemini model and two smaller open models do worse with audio than with the transcript (-3.5, -8.6 and -10.6 pp). A WavLM probe trained on the clinical calls matches the best prompted model overall (71.6%) but misses every frustrated one-word turn in the 24 added calls. When a patient's turn is short, the transcript alone is not enough to rule out frustration.

Comment
Extended version of papers accepted at ML4H 2026 (Proceedings) and GenAI4H workshop @ NeurIPS 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Voice-Native LLMs Hear Frustration but Do Not Listen to It

cs.SD cs.AIeess.AS ·2026-11-02 ·Hanjun Luo, Yuhan Lu, Hanan Salam
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract · 27 pages, 14 figures, 30 tables. Data and code: https://github.com/Astarojth/hear-not-listen

Users convey frustration in what they say and in how they say it, and voice-native models, which hear speech instead of an ASR transcript, can register both. Existing evaluations read unchanged performance as robustness without checking perception. Following Brunswik's lens model, we measure on identical audio whether frustration is expressed, perceived, and utilized. We cross frustrated wording with frustrated voice in a within-item 2x2 design over 353 tasks and release the 1,412 clips as VoxAffect. Across 8 models, outputs look robust, with no detectable vocal effect on accuracy for 7. With neutral wording, all 8 label the frustrated voice frustrated in at most 3.1% of clips, although 7 of them detect acted anger in 73-100% of clips and human listeners classify the voice correctly in 65.3% of judgments. Yet linear probes decode the frustrated voice from the audio encoders of the 2 open-weight models, with paired accuracy 0.67 and 0.69, and in proprietary models too the voice raises perceived frustration once the words agree. The models thus hear the frustrated voice but do not listen to it, whereas their invariance to frustrated wording, perceived in 40-75% of clips, is genuine robustness. Our work is openly accessible at https://github.com/Astarojth/hear-not-listen.

0.32

Almost Human, Except When It Matters: VoxParity and the Decisions a Voice Should Change

cs.CL cs.AIcs.LGcs.SD ·2026-09-28 ·Bhavik Mangla
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract · 38 pages, 11 figures, 15 tables. Code, scorer and development-split data at https://github.com/bhavik-mangla/voxparity-bench and https://doi…

A voice agent can handle almost every call on the words alone and still fail the few its sector's rules were written for. Emergency-call standards, fraud guidance, radio phraseology and vulnerability rules recognise that how a caller sounds, or what else is audible, can change the right action. VoxParity tests whether agents act on it. In 183 scenarios from 14 sectors, one transcript stays fixed while the audio changes (a coaching voice, a medical monitor beeping, a mayday under a radio check, noise over a drug name, a child's voice placing a bet, a frightened whisper), and with it the correct typed tool call. A words-only null test credits a system only if hearing the call moves its actions more than it moves a pipeline that only reads the words. Only 11 of the 23 systems that can also be run on the transcript pass. Descriptively, errors run toward the words: when the audio calls for protection, all 28 systems carry out the routine request more often than they over-react on clean calls (41% against 12% pooled; the words-only pipeline, 58% against 15%). Exploratory analyses place most of the leading systems' misses on cues they heard; systems beat the null almost entirely on items that state the rule; the leading systems overrule heard resignation or confusion far more often than acute alarm; and, in the models tested, describing the voice and stating the rule each recover part of the shortfall, leaving a gap on emotion.

0.36

Same Words, Different Actions: Paired Turn-Taking Evaluation under Rewritten Dialogue Contexts

cs.CL ·2026-09-15 ·Shuofeng Zhao, Hongwei Cai, Wenke Fan, Qingxiang Guo, Zhou Wang +7 more
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

Real-time spoken dialogue systems must distinguish interruptions that require yielding the floor from backchannels that permit continued speaking. Existing benchmarks typically score events independently and may therefore assign high scores to systems with fixed action preferences rather than context-sensitive decision policies. We introduce ECHO, a paired diagnostic benchmark for Chinese turn-taking evaluation. ECHO pairs examples with the same overlap transcript but contrasting preceding multi-turn dialogue contexts, with one requiring Yield and the other Keep. It additionally includes off-talk examples for diagnosing unnecessary yielding. We introduce pair accuracy, which requires correct decisions on both members of a pair and assigns no credit to constant-action policies. Experiments on four speech systems show that three exhibit a severe over-yielding bias: they correctly keep the floor on fewer than 13% of backchannels, resulting in near-zero pairwise success rates equal or less than 4%. While the remaining system remains comparatively balanced across contexts, these findings broadly demonstrate that interruption-only evaluation can severely overestimate practical turn-taking reliability.

0.43

When Does a Spoken Agent Have Enough Evidence to Act? The PACT-SLM Contract Test

cs.SD cs.CLeess.AS ·2026-09-28 ·Mengzhe Geng
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Streaming spoken agents may produce the correct final action after acting too early. Final-turn scores do not reveal whether each observed speech prefix supports an exposed action. We introduce the Partial Speech Action Contract for Turn Taking in Speech Language Models (PACT-SLM), a controlled test that assigns the first valid action time and evaluates both action identity and timing. In the primary test, 80 paired contrast groups from four held-out semantic families yield 1,600 prefix predictions across clean and 15 dB noise renderings. Using source-utterance semantic targets rather than counterbalanced branch codes, WavLM Base Plus reaches 26.03% pooled post-onset semantic-label accuracy (95% group-bootstrap interval [22.14%, 29.68%]), exposes an action on 18.99% of pre-onset prefixes, and predicts 5.94% of complete trajectories exactly. Its pooled label score is at the 96th percentile of 100 within-prefix label permutations, below the 97.5th-percentile reference (26.73%). It exceeds matched text, scalar-acoustic, and shuffled-representation probes in pooled post-onset label accuracy. Elapsed time is more onset-exact (36.25% versus 23.13%) but less accurate about action identity (9.92% versus 26.03%). These results motivate separate measurement of action identity and onset timing in partial-speech evaluations.

0.20

VocalAffectBench: Evaluating Vocal Emotion Recognition in AI Audio Models

cs.CL cs.SD ·2026-08-28 ·Luc Debaupte, Tyler Baumgartner, Brandon Tai, Candice Fan, Bill Wang +1 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.67
Abstract · 6 pages, 6 tables. Benchmark, baseline predictions, and aggregate results are publicly available

Voice products increasingly need affective cues that are present in speech but absent from transcripts. We introduce VocalAffectBench, a public, test-only benchmark for evaluating whether AI audio models can identify expressed vocal emotion from raw audio. The benchmark contains 273 human-recorded English WAV clips from 51 speaker accounts totaling 1.95 hours across seven labels: angry, disgusted, fearful, happy, neutral, sad, and surprised, with 39 clips per class. All baselines are evaluated from audio alone, without transcripts or contextual metadata. Across six released baselines, average accuracy is 35.5%. The strongest baseline, gemini_3_5_flash, reaches 46.5% on the seven-way task, above the 14.3% random baseline but far from robust emotion recognition. A secondary valence-bucket analysis maps labels into positive, neutral, and negative classes, excluding surprised because its valence is ambiguous. Aggregate accuracy under this coarser view is 50.9%. Performance is highly uneven across classes. By recall, neutral is identified most reliably at 75.6% averaged across baselines, while surprised and fearful reach only 10.7% and 15.4%, respectively. These results show that the evaluated baselines can extract some affective signal from speech, but discrete expressed-emotion recognition remains fragile, especially for non-neutral emotions that are often most important in voice agent workflows.

0.59

$τ$-Elicitation: Benchmarking multi-turn entity extraction in voice agents

cs.AI ·2026-09-11 ·Soham Ray, Victor Barres
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

Voice agents often need to collect names, addresses, identifiers, dates, and times exactly, yet end-to-end benchmarks obscure where capture fails. We introduce $τ$-Elicitation, a 200-task voice benchmark spanning 10 entity types, controlled difficulty, caller realisms, and three environments. A matched text agent passes all tasks, but four voice configurations achieve robust exact success from 0.14 to 0.41. Agents increase verification for hard and unfamiliar entities and sometimes for incorrect captures, but not for their weakest caller voice; only 24 to 37 percent of verified errors are repaired. A scaffold that prescribes spelling, read-back, correction, and confirmation raises robust Pass$^3$ by 14 to 31 points, at a cost of 21 to 28 seconds per call. Realisms such as spelling variations and restarts do not detectably affect exact success; mispronunciation increases repair effort. These results identify strategy selection and successful recovery as the central bottlenecks in exact spoken entity collection.

0.44

When Should a Voice Agent Speak? End-of-Turn Detection in Turkish

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-11-19 ·Ahmet Tuğrul Bayrak, Fatma Nur Korkmaz, Mustafa Sertaç Türkel, Nur Yağmur Tuncer
similarity 0.67
Abstract

A voice agent that waits for a fixed silence before replying either interrupts users who pause mid-utterance or responds late to users who have finished. This study examines the decision at the onset of silence, using turn ends and turn-internal pauses extracted from the Real-TurnTurk corpus of Turkish dyadic video calls. A fine-tuned Turkish TurnGPT model, a zero-shot Turkish language model and a deployed multilingual detector are compared, together with voice-activity timing and facial features, under recording-disjoint and speaker-disjoint evaluation with paired cluster bootstrap tests. On held-out recordings, the fine-tuned model separates turn ends from pauses better than both text baselines and is the best calibrated of the three. Timing features of the current speaker are similarly informative, and their combination with the fine-tuned text score gives the best timing-based results; with logistic regression, this combination also outperforms the same combination with either text baseline. In a latency simulation, adding the text score to a silence timeout shortens the mean response delay at the same interruption rate. On automatic Whisper transcripts, the fine-tuned model retains its advantage over the zero-shot model.

0.04

IndicFDB: Benchmarking Full-Duplex Voice Agents across Indian Languages

cs.CL ·2026-09-25 ·Rajarshi Roy, Shobhit Banga, Jonathan Raiman, Supriya Paul, Bhaskar Singh +10 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Full-duplex voice agents must handle pauses, take turns, backchannel, and respond to user interruptions in real time. Full-Duplex-Bench evaluates these behaviors, but its English-only corpus and reliance on word-timestamped ASR and an English-prompted LLM judge make it difficult to extend to Indian languages. We introduce IndicFDB, which extends it to ten languages spoken in India with 12,350 samples, nearly 17 times as many as the original. We address three challenges: finding conversational events in multilingual speech, evaluating their timing without reliable word-level alignment, and judging responses across languages. We mine pause handling, turn taking, and backchanneling samples from roughly 50,000 hours of channel-separated conversations using voice activity detection (VAD), and construct human-validated synthetic user interruption samples. Language-independent VAD heuristics evaluate timing, while an open-weight transcription and translation pipeline converts responses to English for LLM ratings of relevance and quality. Across seven voice agents, commercial APIs show unexpectedly consistent behavior across languages but are either fast or robust to pauses, never both, while monolingual open full-duplex models expose further tradeoffs among backchanneling, response quality, and latency.

0.41