CS Paper Radar

A counterexample to the soundness of the Flowering IOPP for codes on graphs

Hugo Delavenne

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-11-16 16:50 UTC · v1

Abstract

The Flowering protocol of Delavenne, Medevielle and Roussel (ISIT 2025, arXiv:2501.14337) and its generalization by Delavenne and Lallemand (CANS 2025, arXiv:2508.10510) are Interactive Oracle Proofs of Proximity (IOPPs) for codes on graphs with Reed-Solomon local codes. Similarly to FRI for Reed-Solomon codes, the graph is recursively cut into isomorphic subgraphs and the word is folded along the cuts. We show that the soundness claims of both papers are false. The commit soundness proofs identify the vertex distance of a word to the code with the fraction of its unsatisfied local constraints, while only one inequality holds, in the wrong direction. We furthermore give an explicit counterexample.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

On Proximity Gaps for One-Point Algebraic Geometric Codes

cs.IT ·2026-10-29 ·Songsong Li, Chaoping Xing, Chen Yuan, Ruiqi Zhu
theory similarity 0.69
Abstract · 43 pages

Proximity gaps and correlated agreement underpin the soundness of interactive oracle proofs. We establish these properties for general one-point algebraic geometry (AG) codes, extending corresponding results for Reed-Solomon codes. For codes of length $n$ over $\mathbb F_q$ with designed distance $n-m$, write $ρ=m/n$ and fix $ρ\in(0,1)$. For polynomial curves of degree at most $\ell$ and any $0<\varepsilon<1$, we prove correlated agreement with multiplicative slack $\varepsilon$ and soundness $O(\ell(\ell+1)/(\varepsilon q))$ whenever $e\le(1-\varepsilon)(n-m)/2$, with no additional genus penalty. This gives asymptotically good AG code families from Garcia--Stichtenoth tower of unbounded length over a fixed field with soundness bounds independent of $n$, beyond the RS restriction $n\le q$. We also establish mutual correlated agreement up to radius $(1-\sqrtρ-η)n$, with soundness $O(\ell n/(η^3q))$ for $0<η<1-\sqrtρ$. Our half designed distance proof combines auxiliary divisors, simultaneous Berlekamp-Welch interpolation, and error-incidence counting to obtain a common polynomial representation without a Polishchuk-Spielman divisibility lemma. Finally, two counterexamples on the Garcia-Stichtenoth tower show limitations beyond half the minimum distance, at radii below the Johnson bound and with positive slack. The first requires a positive constant soundness lower bound independent of $q$ and $n$, precluding a uniform $O(1/q)$ guarantee throughout the Johnson regime. The second fixes the field and lets the relative gap above half distance tend to zero while ruling out correlated agreement for every soundness parameter $σ<1$, with positive limiting rate and relative error radius.

0.22

Reed-Solomon Codes at Capacity: Algorithmic List-Decoding and Proximity Gaps

cs.CC cs.IT ·2026-10-06 ·Prahladh Harsha, Mrinal Kumar, Ramprasad Saptharishi
publishedhighly cited similarity 0.67
Abstract

Understanding the limits of list-decodability of Reed-Solomon codes has been one of the most important open problems in algebraic coding theory. Recently, Brakensiek, Chen, Putterman, Zhang, and Zheng, in a remarkable breakthrough, showed that Reed-Solomon (RS) codes over fields of large characteristic are algorithmically list-decodable all the way up to capacity. Building on this result, Jeronimo subsequently extended these techniques to solve the proximity-gaps question for RS codes. In this article, we give a unified and transparent exposition of these results.

0.51

Algebraic Geometry Codes Approach the Half-Singleton Bound with Constant Field Size

cs.IT cs.DSmath.CO ·2026-09-04 ·Neehar Verma, Camilla Hollanti, Razane Tajeddine
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract

We study linear codes for insertion and deletion (insdel) errors through the lens of evaluation codes. We develop a general framework for analyzing random puncturings of evaluation codes, where the edit distance is controlled by only the size of the evaluation domain and the maximum number of zeros of a nonzero function in the underlying function space. Our proof generalizes the results of Con, Guo, Li, and Zhang (ICALP 2025), and simultaneously simplifies their arguments by avoiding an in-depth analysis of longest common subsequences. We demonstrate the applicability of our core theorem by instantiating it with random puncturings of Reed--Muller codes. We then recover the result that random Reed--Solomon codes approach the half-Singleton bound over linear-sized fields while also improving the dependence on the additive gap $\varepsilon$ from $2^{O(1/\varepsilon^2)}$ to $2^{O(1/\varepsilon)}$. Finally, by applying the framework to algebraic geometry codes arising from asymptotically good towers of function fields, we show that there exist randomized families of structured linear codes over constant-sized fields that approach the half-Singleton bound.

0.35

On Nearly-Perfect Covering Codes Beyond Radius One

cs.IT math.CO ·2026-08-12 ·Gabriel Sac Himelfarb, Moshe Schwartz
theory similarity 0.63
Abstract · 26 pages

We study (binary) nearly-perfect covering codes, which are codes that attain the Van Wee bound with equality. They act as the covering counterparts to nearly-perfect error-correcting codes, which attain the Johnson bound with equality. These codes have been completely classified for covering radius $R=1$. We prove that no code with $R\geq 2$ can attain the original Van Wee bound with equality, since it omits the dependence on the minimum distance of the code. We refine the bound to account for the minimum distance and show some nearly-perfect covering codes. By proving some structural properties of such codes, we prove all nearly-perfect covering codes with $R=2,3$ must be equivalent to the codes we showed. We also prove that for any $R\geq 3$, there are at most a finite number of nearly-perfect covering codes.

0.38

On identifying codes on oriented graphs

cs.DM math.CO ·2026-08-27 ·Soura Sena Das, Sagnik Sen
similarity 0.63
Abstract

This article studies identifying codes in oriented graphs from a computational complexity perspective. We investigate the $\mathcal{F}$-Id Code problem, where given a simple graph $G$ and a vertex subset $C$, which induces a subgraph in the family $\mathcal{F}$, as inputs and ask whether it is possible to orient $G$ in such a way that $C$ becomes its oriented identifying code. Focusing on the family $\mathcal{F}_d$ of $d$-regular graphs, we establish a complete dichotomy by proving that the problem is polynomial-time solvable for $d\leq1$ and NP-complete for all $d\geq2$.

0.14

NP-Hardness of Bounded Distance Decoding for Reed-Solomon Codes

cs.CC ·2026-09-24 ·Daqing Wan, Jun Zhang
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract · 31 pages

For an $[n,K]$ Reed--Solomon code, the covering radius is $n-K$. Gandikota, Ghazi, and Grigorescu proved deterministic NP-hardness of bounded-distance decoding when the decoding radius is $d$ below the covering radius for every $1\le d\le c\log n/\log\log n$, where $c>0$ is an absolute constant. We prove that, for every fixed rational $0<α<1/2$, bounded-distance decoding is NP-complete under deterministic polynomial-time many-one reductions over explicitly represented finite extension fields for the additive gap $d=\lfloor n^α\rfloor$ below the covering radius. The hard codes have odd block length~$n$, dimension $K=(n+1)/2-d$, decoding radius $(n-1)/2$, and rate tending to $1/2$. The alphabet size is subexponential in the evaluation set size: for a fixed $0<η<1$ depending only on $α$, it is $2^{Θ(n^η\log n)}=2^{o(n)}$. The proof passes through moments subset sum on $n-1$ nonzero field elements, with required subset size $(n-1)/2$ and $d$ prescribed moments. The arithmetic ingredient is a uniform positive-completion theorem over prime fields $\mathbb{F}_q$ with $q\ge d^{2+ρ}$, for any fixed $ρ>0$. A sharper form follows from a higher-dimensional point-count estimate based on Deligne's theorem; the weaker form used in our reduction is proved more elementarily using additive-character orthogonality, the one-variable Weil bound, a moment identity of order $2d$, and Newton identities. A universal completion pool, an extension-field quotient construction, and a deterministic linear-size simultaneous power condenser complete the reduction.

0.10

Thresholds for Local Coordinate-Wise Linear Properties of Random One-Point AG Codes

cs.IT ·2026-10-08 ·Chen Yuan, Ruiqi Zhu
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract · 37 pages

Local coordinate-wise linear (LCL) properties provide a unified framework for studying list decoding, list recovery and other local properties of linear codes. We prove that random one-point algebraic geometry (AG) codes have the same LCL threshold rates as random linear codes under explicit alphabet and sampling conditions. More precisely, for a family of local profiles with random linear code threshold $R_{\mathcal P}$, a random one-point AG code avoids all such profiles below $R_{\mathcal P}-\varepsilon$ and contains one above $R_{\mathcal P}+\varepsilon$, with explicit failure bounds on both sides. Our proof also removes an auxiliary lower bound on the number of available rational places that arises in a direct adaptation of the Reed--Solomon argument and requires no additional genus-dependent rate gap. We also observe that the previously claimed above threshold proof for random Reed--Solomon codes does not establish the required probability lower bound. The containment relation used in that argument gives the probability comparison in the opposite direction from what is needed. We give a different above threshold argument, which in particular also yields an alternative proof in the genus zero case. Combining our threshold theorem with recent results for random linear codes gives a collection of new list decoding, average weight list decoding and list recovery guarantees for random one-point AG codes. We further obtain new correlated agreement and proximity gap results for polynomial curves. These results extend the LCL threshold framework from random linear and Reed--Solomon codes to random one-point AG codes.

0.18

Solutions to Three Conjectures and an Open Problem on Binary BCH Codes

cs.IT ·2026-09-01 ·Xiaoqiang Wang, Jiawei He, Boru Yi, Dabin Zheng
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract

BCH codes are among the most important classes of cyclic codes and have played a central role in coding theory and its applications. One of the fundamental problems in the study of BCH codes is to determine their exact minimum distances, which directly govern their error-correcting capability. Although the BCH bound provides a general lower bound, determining the exact minimum distance is often difficult, and many parameter families remain unresolved. In this paper, we investigate three conjectures and an open problem on binary BCH codes proposed by Chen, Xie, and Ding in \cite{Chen59}. We settle these conjectures on the exact minimum distances of three families of binary BCH codes by constructing codewords attaining the BCH bound. Beyond these conjectures, we further study the more difficult family codes and determine its minimum distance for some cases. We further study Open Problem 8.4: affirmative answers are obtained for the first two length families, while for the third family a sufficient condition is established and a counterexample shows that the unrestricted assertion does not hold in general.

0.20