CS Paper Radar

Benefits and Barriers to Human-AI Teaming for Crisis Counseling

Ivy Pham, Akshay Swaminathan, Sebastian Garcia, Jaimie Lim, Gloria Ye, Divyanjali Verma, Alan Pham, Chastin Chung, Shreya Shah, Shaked Azzam, Sharang Phadke, Ivan Lopez, William Wang, Angelina Wang, Nigam H. Shah

cs.HC cs.CY ·submitted 2026-11-16 18:38 UTC · v1
hot direction

Abstract

Background: AI systems are increasingly deployed to support mental health clinicians, yet real-world evidence remains limited. In crisis counseling, where clients often seek human connection, understanding whether AI augmentation preserves or undermines meaningful human engagement is essential. Methods: In a mixed-methods study of a counselor-facing AI copilot on a WhatsApp-based crisis hotline in India (Mar.-Oct. 2025), counselors could request, edit, and send AI messages. We analyzed 20 interviews, 8 shadowing sessions, 56 survey responses, and edits in 27,778 copilot messages from 108 counselors via thematic analysis (Technology Acceptance Model 2, plus inductive coding of emergent factors), and survey statistics. Results: Counselors reported high copilot acceptance (survey): 98.2% found it helpful; 89.3% likely to continue use; 80.4% reported efficiency gains. Interviews highlighted sentence scaffolding, empathetic phrasing, stress reduction, catching missed details, and efficiency. Barriers (survey) included repetitive outputs (23.2%), lack of context (17.9%), and authenticity concerns (10.7%). While 69.6% (survey) reported skill enhancement, interviews surfaced skill atrophy concerns. Counselors frequently accepted copilot suggestions, editing to remove questions, adjust tone, or personalize style. Conclusion: In one of the largest real-world deployments of a counselor-facing mental health AI copilot, counselors reported reduced cognitive load, empathetic communication, and greater efficiency, alongside concerns about skill atrophy, authenticity, and over-reliance. In settings like crisis counseling where clients seek human connection, AI tools must balance operational support with preserving clinical skill and genuine therapeutic engagement. Designs soliciting approval or editing of complete drafts may overweight efficiency at the expense of sustained human engagement.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

"I Just Don't Want to Be a Burden": Investigating AI Chatbot Emotional Support Among People with Suicidal Ideation and Other Mental Health Concerns

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-11-17 ·Vasudha Varadarajan, Nathan S. Fishbein, Andrew Aquilina, Jordan Taylor, Hong Shen +1 more
survey similarity 0.70
Abstract · 41 pages, 9 figures

People experiencing high-acuity mental health concerns are turning to AI chatbots for emotional support, but little is known about what drives this use, their experiences, and their preferences. In a sequential mixed-methods study, we inductively analyzed Reddit posts and used the findings to develop a survey. We surveyed 202 adults with recent mental health concerns who had used AI for emotional support. Most participants were already receiving clinical care and reported turning to AI, most commonly because they did not want to burden others, rather than being driven by barriers to care. Benefits were broadly shared, but participants reporting past-year suicidal ideation described more harm-facilitating AI behavior and reliance than those without. Overall, participants ranked honesty above warmth, and preference for crisis escalation declined as clinical acuity rose. These findings motivate AI support that addresses perceived costs of disclosure, evaluates benefits alongside harms, and widens feasible paths to human connection.

0.23

Remembering Is Not Enough: Evaluating Timing and Omission in Longitudinal AI Mental Health Support

cs.CY cs.AI ·2026-11-05 ·Eli Min, Mohit Chandra, Aamogh Sawant, Mengting Tu, Freya Lin +6 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Evaluations of large language models (LLMs) for mental health support commonly focus on the clinical appropriateness of individual responses, potentially overlooking failures that emerge across extended interactions. As AI assistants accumulate memory of users' circumstances and prior disclosures, this raises an accountability question: Do AI chatbots provide appropriate support as users' needs evolve? We investigate by analyzing 14,256 longitudinal simulations grounded in donated chatbot histories from 22 users, examining how a memory-equipped assistant responds to suicidal ideation, self-harm, and anxiety crises across recovery trajectories and communication styles. We introduce the Context-Aware and Readiness-Evaluative (CARE) framework, developed with mental health professionals, to assess the timing and quality of advice, including omissions. Advice was less aligned with users' readiness after a crisis than in matched control stretches of the same conversation, largely because of premature recommendations, which were most common when recovery stalled. Revisiting a crisis reduced premature advice but not lagging advice, and users' communication style changed how often and when the assistant gave recommendations. Although explicitly unproductive advice was rare, the assistant frequently omitted clinician-expected support such as follow-up and planning for next steps. These findings show the limits of single response-level safety evaluation and the need to assess timing, omission, and consistency across users when holding AI systems accountable for longitudinal support.

0.07

Evaluating safeguarding in multi-turn conversations with AI assistants

cs.CL ·2026-11-19 ·Charlotte Peart, Franziska Sofia Hafner, Luc Rocher
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Conversational AI assistants are now used for personal and emotional support. Developers report improvements in how new models respond to sensitive conversations, yet users and civil society continue to raise concerns about their behaviour in real-world, repeated interactions that safety evaluations rarely capture. Often, evaluations present signs of distress clearly and in a single message, even though people may reveal their struggles gradually in otherwise ordinary conversations. We worked with three community mental health support workers to test if models provide the same level of safeguarding when cues are shared all at once or gradually over time. We designed nine scenarios in which a user shares cues related to depression, psychosis, or domestic abuse. For each scenario, the support workers established a gold standard response, ranging from signposting support to pausing the everyday task to address safeguarding. We presented five cues either together in one message or dispersed across a conversation. Across more than 7,400 conversations, we evaluated six widely used models from five developers. GPT-5.5, Grok 4.3, DeepSeek V4, and Llama 4 Maverick met the support workers' standards in just 26-59% of conversations when cues were concentrated, and only 3-6% when dispersed. Claude Sonnet 5 and Claude Opus 5 showed a smaller gap, meeting the standards in 68-97% of concentrated conversations and 59-87% of dispersed conversations. Even the best-performing model, Claude Opus 5, fell short of the gold standard in 13% of conversations when cues were dispersed. Safety evaluations centred on explicit, legible concerns can overstate how well safeguards protect people when signs of distress emerge gradually or indirectly through ordinary conversations. For claims of improved safety to be taken seriously, developers must design and assess safeguards around how people actually communicate.

0.20

Assessing AI Companion Chatbot Safety for Vulnerable Users: A Crisis-Stage Multi-Platform Evaluation

cs.HC ·2026-10-29 ·Huanyue Liao, Seok Min Lim, Yan Ling Lim, Shi Min Cheng, Kellin Pelrine +1 more
publishedcode/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted at the GenAI4Health Workshop at NeurIPS 2026 (non-archival)

AI companion chatbots are increasingly used by vulnerable individuals, including adolescents in suicidal crisis, for emotional support. Existing safety evaluations focus on base models, leaving gaps in product-level assessment, crisis-stage sensitivity, and comparisons between companion apps and general-purpose LLMs. We introduce MIRROR-Eval (Multi-turn Interaction Risk Review: Observing suicidal-crisis Responses), a dataset of 960 annotated 20-turn conversations across eight deployed platform configurations, six clinically grounded personas, and two crisis stages: ideation and explicit planning. An LLM-as-a-Judge pipeline applies an expert-reviewed rubric covering user risk severity, chatbot risk awareness, and intervention behavior. We observe a three-tier harm structure: companion apps (Character.AI and Replika) and Grok 4.3 form a high-harm tier; Gemini 3.1 Pro is mid-range; GPT-5.5 and Claude Sonnet 5 show substantially lower harm. At planning, companion apps show increased glorification and normalisation, advancement toward harmful action, and harmful methods and instructions. Crisis recognition and empathetic language do not ensure safe responses. These findings highlight the need for product-level safety evaluation across crisis stages. Dataset and code: https://huggingface.co/datasets/imda-biztech/MIRROR-Eval. Warning: this paper includes examples that may be offensive or harmful.

0.40

CAIA in Practice: Field Evaluation of an AI-Assisted Support System for Text-Based Online Counselling

cs.HC cs.CL ·2026-08-23 ·Philipp Steigerwald, Nico Bienlein, Jennifer Burghardt, Mara Stieler, Robert Lehmann +1 more
publishedhighly cited similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted at IEEE ICTAI 2025

Rising global demand for mental health support creates significant service delivery challenges, with asynchronous email counselling serving as a crucial low-threshold channel for accessing care. This paper presents CAIA, a co-designed AI-based tool suite that demonstrates responsible AI integration into counselling practice through seven LLM-driven functions enhanced by retrieval-augmented generation. A field evaluation involved 34 professional counsellors conducting authentic sessions with trained student counsellees (36 threads, 321 messages, 1,257 AI outputs). User behaviour analysis confirms substantial adoption, revealing that professional autonomy and information accuracy are decisive for sustained acceptance, with counsellors particularly valuing interpretive functionalities that provide new perspectives and stimulate professional reflection.

0.58

Beyond Reflection: Affirmation as a Promising Behavioral Marker Associated with Quality in Text-Based Counseling

cs.CL ·2026-08-27 ·Michimasa Inaba
top venuecode/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted to EMNLP 2026 Findings

While AI-assisted text-based counseling is gaining attention, it remains empirically unclear which counselor behaviors are associated with higher dialogue quality. Existing research often focuses heavily on Reflection, borrowing frameworks from Motivational Interviewing. To address this gap, we conduct a multi-layered analysis using KokoroChat, a large-scale Japanese text counseling dataset conducted by professional counselors and trainees, newly annotated with counselor strategy tags and client distress levels. Our results show that, under the quality indicators used in this study, Affirmation is more consistently associated with session quality than Reflection among the analyzed strategies. Cross-dataset transfer experiments further suggest that this quality signal can be observed to some extent on ESConv, an English dataset with non-expert supporters. These findings provide empirical implications for counselor training and emotional support system design. We release the additional KokoroChat annotations and experimental source code at https://github.com/UEC-InabaLab/BeyondReflection.

0.51

"We Are Tired of Explaining": Communication Practice and AI Roleplay Training for Community Health Workers in Rural India

cs.HC ·2026-09-15 ·Neil K. R. Sehgal, Sunny Rai, Sai Preethi Matam, Khushboo Gupta, Hamid Abdullah +2 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Community health workers (CHWs) in the Global South increasingly encounter AI-powered tools, yet the counseling work central to their role remains largely unsupported. We study communication practices among Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHAs) in rural Rajasthan, India, through simulated family-planning calls, semi-structured interviews, and an LLM chatbot roleplay design-probe with 20 participants. In calls, ASHAs often responded to social or material concerns by shifting to health-risk information, denying concerns, promising unspecified help, or listing medical solutions with limited explanation. A smaller set of responses instead engaged concerns, sought permission before involving family members, or left decisions with beneficiaries. We interpret these patterns through Motivational Interviewing, emphasizing restraint from correcting, persuading, or over-solving. Drawing across observed calls, interviews, and probe reactions, we derive design considerations for AI roleplay training: keep AI in a rehearsal role, provide descriptive rather than prescriptive feedback, and evaluate counseling process rather than agreement with prescribed responses.

0.25

Can LLMs identify and repair ruptures? Comparison between clinician practices and LLM behaviors

cs.HC ·2026-09-21 ·Jeongah Lee, Joy Qiuyue Zhong, Drishti Goel, Violeta J. Rodriguez, Dong Whi Yoo +2 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Ruptures represent common albeit critical moments in interaction where relational alignment breaks down, making them essential for evaluating AI where trust and engagement matter most. In a scenario-driven empirical study, we examined the performance of three LLMs at identifying and resolving ruptures across 21 mental health conversations and 22 experts' evaluation of the strategies. For identification, LLMs relied on explicit linguistic cues within single turns whereas experts integrated implicit, relational, and contextual information across the conversation. For resolution, LLMs tended to produce more directive and scripted responses whereas experts adopted process-oriented strategies such as validation, open-ended exploration, and psychoeducation. Overall, LLMs showed higher agreement with predefined labels in identification, but not in resolution where experts rated their responses only moderately effective, with consistent limitations in timing, depth, and contextual sensitivity. We discuss implications for the design of mental health conversational agents emphasizing relational awareness, pacing, and human-in-the-loop support.

0.30