CS Paper Radar

An AI-Based OSSE Framework to Evaluate Learned Physical Consistency: A Multi-Model Study Using FourCastNet, Aurora, Prithvi WxC, and GraphCast

Yash Diggikar, Milton Halem, Aishwarya Raman

cs.LG ·submitted 2026-11-17 00:29 UTC · v1

Abstract

Observing System Simulation Experiments (OSSEs) are a central methodology for evaluating future atmospheric observing systems. We present the first AI-based OSSE framework to test whether different AI weather models can reproduce comparable physical impact from new observations that traditional physics based models generate. We evaluate four distinct architectural AI models on the Charney conjecture that incomplete historical observations can infer the present state of the atmospheric. We considner- FourCastNet V2, GraphCast, Aurora and Prithvi WxC and integrate each autoregressively over a 60-day forecast horizon. After a 30-day spin-up, we insert ERA5 temperature fields to infer winds and related atmospheric fields. Similar OSSE experiments are conducted for wind insertion. We measure the performance of each model's response to observational information on a 30-day data assimilation cycle forecast with and without data insertion. Distinct architectural AI weather models respond differently to the same OSSE observations. Foundation models (i.e. Prithvi WxC and Aurora), produce the strongest impact. For example, while GraphCast is the weakest, all three of the four models capture the temperature-to-geopotential height response. The two foundational models retain a positive, non-trivial, tropical zonal wind at 500 hPa response to temperature insertion. Various data insertion experiments can vary significantly even within a given architecture. We identify an architecture-specific numerical instability in GraphCast's full 37-level configuration that produces a runaway feedback concentrated at the uppermost levels with ERA5 temperature insertion correctable by excluding levels at or below 100 hPa.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Aries: A Proprietary Medium-Range Weather Prediction Model for the Energy Industry

cs.LG physics.ao-ph ·2026-09-09 ·Lukas Hedegaard Morsing, Arian Bakhtiarnia, Jonas Lynge Olesen, Tómas Bragi Björnsson Leth, Christian Gøbel Bach
similarity 0.72
Abstract

Medium-range weather forecasting underpins operational and planning decisions across the energy industry. Developing competitive weather models was once the domain of national meteorological centers, but recent advances in machine-learned weather prediction (MLWP) have opened the field to industry. We present Aries, a SwinTransformer-based MLWP model developed at InCommodities. Aries is trained on ERA5 reanalysis data at 0.25\textdegree{} resolution, predicting 74 prognostic and 11 diagnostic atmospheric variables. We evaluate the model on 2025 ECMWF Analysis initializations, ensuring a recent and strictly out-of-sample test period for all models compared. On 10-metre wind speed, Aries outperforms both ECMWF HRES and AIFS in terms of RMSE for lead times up to four days, while on 2-metre temperature it achieves RMSE on par with AIFS operational. These results demonstrate that proprietary development of competitive weather models is technically viable, supporting a broader set of forecasts available for operational and planning applications in the energy industry.

0.10

WeatherDreamer: Learning a World Model from Multimodal Earth Observations

cs.LG physics.ao-ph ·2026-11-13 ·Kate Duffy, Elise Penn, Tristan Ballard, August Posch, Thomas J. Vandal
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Machine learning weather models now rival operational global forecasts but still start from analyses produced by separate, expensive data assimilation (DA) systems, which for global models are typically updated every six hours. Observation-to-observation models avoid this dependence, but most omit the recursive filtering cycle that lets DA systems carry a background state through sparse, irregular observations. We introduce WeatherDreamer, a world model that learns this cycle end-to-end from 18 global observing systems, without reanalysis. It infers a latent state from observations, carries it forward hour by hour with learned dynamics, corrects it each hour with new observations, and can predict what any of its observing systems would measure at any location. At held-out stations, its ensembles beat NOAA's Global Ensemble Forecast System (GEFS) for temperature, dew point and wind out to 12 h and are better calibrated than GEFS and the ECMWF ensemble. Precipitation, cloud-top height and solar irradiance, never inputs at inference, are inferred with skill matching or exceeding operational products at short leads. Against the first guess of NOAA's Gridpoint Statistical Interpolation (GSI) DA system, WeatherDreamer's short-range departures are within 10% of GSI's at surface stations and within 25% for moisture-sensitive microwave channels, but up to five times larger for temperature-sounding channels. Never given observation errors, its learned update assumes errors close to known instrument and retrieval errors of microwave sounders and scatterometer winds. WeatherDreamer also separates viewing geometry from atmospheric state, recovering 83-96% of observed limb darkening and producing seamless nadir-view imagery. Producing an hourly global analysis in about 1.5 minutes on one GPU, WeatherDreamer shows that assimilation and forecasting can be learned together directly from observations.

0.07

Uncertainty-Aware End-to-End AI Weather Forecasting: Disentangling Observation and Model Contributions

cs.LG physics.ao-ph ·2026-08-31 ·Rodrigo Almeida, Noelia Otero, Jost Arndt, Simon Baur, Wojciech Samek +1 more
similarity 0.71
Abstract · 25 pages, 16 figures

End-to-end weather forecasting systems produce skillful global gridded and station forecasts directly from raw Earth observations, replacing the numerical weather prediction pipeline, including data assimilation, at a fraction of its cost. These systems are deterministic and issue no uncertainty. Here we render the Aardvark Weather model probabilistic by attaching one stochastic mechanism to each component: learned, input-dependent noise at the observation encoder, aimed at the uncertainty inherited from the observing system, and Monte Carlo dropout in the processor, aimed at the uncertainty of the learned dynamics. The resulting nested ensemble attributes forecast spread to the two sources through a law-of-total-variance decomposition, cross-checked by withholding observation streams. Probabilistic finetuning significantly improves the mean forecast, by 11% on average across variables and lead times. The ensemble is close to calibrated against ERA5 through the medium range, is at least as accurate as the deterministic model at weather stations while beating it in relative economic value at every lead time, and remains considerably behind the operational ECMWF IFS ensemble. The encoder branch behaves as observation-driven uncertainty. Component-attributed uncertainty makes end-to-end forecasts more transparent, a step toward observation-driven digital twins of the atmosphere.

0.22

Domain-Adaptive Data Assimilation for Global AI Weather Forecasting

cs.CE ·2026-10-02 ·Minseok Seo, Noah Brenowitz, Doyi Kim, Hyesook Lee, Changick Kim
code/data similarity 0.70
Abstract · 27 pages, [This project is open source.]

AI weather forecasting models are commonly trained on the ERA5 reanalysis, which is unavailable in real time. Operational deployment therefore relies on initial conditions produced by numerical or AI analysis systems that differ from those encountered during training. This mismatch can degrade forecast skill, while retraining for every analysis system is costly. Here, we present Domain-Adaptive Data Assimilation (DADA), an observation-guided framework that adapts external analyses to pretrained AI weather models. Starting from a background state, DADA optimizes only an initial-state perturbation while keeping the forecast model frozen. The perturbed state is propagated through the model, and its short-range trajectory is constrained by real-world observations through a learned observation operator. The resulting initial condition is shaped jointly by observational constraints and the dynamics learned by the target model. We evaluate DADA across five global AI weather models using backgrounds from the Global Forecast System and the AI-based HealDA. Across deterministic and probabilistic forecasts, DADA substantially reduces short-range skill loss caused by changes in the initial-condition source. More broadly, DADA turns observations into a common interface between independently developed analysis and forecasting systems, enabling pretrained AI weather models to accommodate evolving operational initial conditions without reconstructing ERA5 or retraining the forecast model.

0.33

WeatherNext 3: Increasing resolution and performance of global weather models with raw observations

cs.LG ·2026-09-03 ·Stephan Rasp, Boris Babenko, Dominic Masters, Andrew El-Kadi, Samier Merchant +20 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract

State-of-the-art AI weather models have shown impressive medium-range forecast skill and computational efficiency, but suffer two key shortcomings: their forecasts have lower spatial and temporal resolution than the best physics-based models and they are exclusively initialized with and trained on analysis data. As a result, they cannot directly make use of observations, and any biases in the analysis are inherited by the forecast. WeatherNext 3 addresses these shortcomings and establishes a new state-of-the-art for probabilistic medium-range forecasting skill. First, WeatherNext 3 generates new forecasts every hour (rather than every 6 hours like traditional global models) by ingesting low-latency geostationary satellite data. Second, WeatherNext 3's temporal and spatial resolution are on par with physics-based global models, with hourly time steps and 0.1 degree resolution for single-level variables, including solar radiation and cloud cover. Third, WeatherNext 3 moves beyond traditional analysis variables by learning to predict satellite-derived precipitation estimates, as well as tropical cyclone and station observations. Modelling sparse station data allows WeatherNext 3 to make 2m temperature and dewpoint predictions at any location and time, conditioned on local geographical features, with substantially lower error than competing global models, even when evaluated against unseen stations. Together, WeatherNext 3's capabilities move operational AI-based weather forecasting beyond emulating the traditionally distinct stages of data assimilation, forecasting and post-processing, which helps to further push the frontier of performance and granularity for global weather prediction.

0.36

Half-precision inference of AI weather prediction models: negligible loss of skill at a fraction of the cost

cs.LG physics.ao-phcs.PF ·2026-11-06 ·Stefan Siegert
code/data similarity 0.68
Abstract · 40 pages, 15 figures, 9 tables. Code: https://github.com/sieste/ai-nwp-fp16

AI weather prediction models are released with 32-bit (fp32) weights and run in fp32 by default, although current GPUs compute much faster in 16-bit formats. We run five publicly available models -- Aurora, Pangu-Weather, FourCastNet, SFNO and FastNet -- on a single 16 GB GPU from 52 initial dates in 2024, in fp32 and with their networks in half precision (fp16), and verify the forecasts against ERA5. The physical state must stay in fp32: converting the whole model rounds it in physical units, which in fp16 overflows and in bf16 discards meaningful information. With the state, its normalisation and denormalisation in fp32, running the network in fp16 changes the global RMSE by at most 1.4%, and by about 0.5% or less for four of the five models, equivalent to less than one hour of lead time up to day 8 and at most two hours at day 10. The differences show no systematic pattern by region, scale or for tropical and extratropical storms, apart from a small tropical penalty in FourCastNet, and fp16 leaves the CRPS, spread and calibration of Aurora's ensemble almost unchanged. No value overflowed fp16's numeric range (+/-65,504); the largest stay 38 to 544 times below it. A 10-day forecast in fp16 is 1.3-3.5 times faster than in fp32 and uses 1.4-3.7 times less energy. Sensitivity experiments show that rules of thumb from other applications of reduced precision carry over only partly: the first and last layers dominate for some models but not for others, and no type of layer is sensitive on its own. For running AI weather models on a single GPU, fp16 with the state in fp32 is practically lossless at a fraction of the cost. bf16, often preferred for its wider range, is as fast but less accurate than fp16 for every model, and simple 8-bit quantisation costs far more skill.

0.28

Can AI Forecast the Extremes? Evaluating Probabilistic Weather Models on Tropical Cyclones

cs.LG physics.ao-ph ·2026-10-15 ·Nathan Chalumeau, Xavier Renard, Remi Meynadier, Hugo Rakotoarimanga, Marcin Detyniecki +1 more
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

Weather prediction is undergoing an important shift, with data-driven AI models outperforming leading numerical weather prediction systems on average at a fraction of the computational cost. Yet, whether this success extends to extreme events remains contested. Earlier evaluations have exposed important shortcomings, but have largely focused on deterministic models and metrics, leaving the capabilities of the latest probabilistic models less understood. We conduct an extensive benchmark of tropical cyclone forecasting, comparing GenCast, FourCastNet 3, and FGN with ECMWF's operational physics-based ensemble, IFS-ENS. We develop a suite of probabilistic metrics and diagnostic analyses to assess cyclone tracking, intensity biases, uncertainty, and the wind-pressure relationship that characterizes storm structure. We find that, despite remaining limitations in intensity and ensemble spread, leading AI models substantially outperform IFS-ENS in cyclone tracking: FGN achieves better probabilistic location scores for 90% of evaluated storms in 2025. Further analyses reveal model-specific failure modes and suggest a lingering influence of pretraining data, pointing to opportunities for targeted improvement. Nonetheless, these results suggest that AI models are capable of capturing physical relationships that remain predictive well beyond typical weather conditions, motivating further investigation into how these capabilities emerge and how to strengthen them.

0.12

Strategic Governance of AI Models in Earth Science

cs.AI physics.soc-phcs.LGphysics.ao-ph ·2026-10-01 ·Makoto Kelp, Amirhossein Arzani, Patricia Castellanos, Paul Griffiths, Ivan Higuera-Mendieta +4 more
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

AI foundation models pretrained on weather and climate data are increasingly fine-tuned to Earth science tasks well beyond weather forecasting. Their development and adoption are outpacing the scientific community's ability to evaluate them. These models are judged almost entirely by benchmark skill metrics, which measure how closely a forecast reproduces a reference product but not whether a model represents the physical processes governing the system it predicts. Forecast skill and physical reliability are therefore distinct properties. The distinction is most consequential under the nonstationary conditions of a changing climate for which these models were never trained. We identify five priorities for the physical evaluation of AI models in Earth science from task-specific emulators to foundation models, spanning training data, fine-tuning, behavioral testing, mechanistic interpretability, and output validation. We recommend three activities for the coming decade: 1) open AI-ready evaluation datasets, 2) a shared reporting standard for physics-based evaluation, and 3) a dedicated research program on the safety of these models.

0.37