CS Paper Radar

Controlling Proactive Multimodal AI: Separating Perception from Participation

Muawiz Feroze Khan, Fatima Ali, Yun Huang

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-11-17 09:06 UTC · v1
hot direction

Abstract

Proactive multimodal AI can watch a user's screen, listen to speech, track interaction, and decide whether to enter unfolding work. Little is known about how people want to control what such AI may perceive and how far it may participate. Informed by a 14-person Wizard-of-Oz study, we built SpotMe, a design probe that senses screen, speech, and interaction; chooses Silence, Ask, or Assist; and lets users separately configure what it may perceive, how far it may participate, and what types of support it may provide. In a 16-person study on a civic dashboard, participants first experienced proactive help, then inspected decisions to act or remain silent, and then configured SpotMe's perception and participation. We found that participants could keep all perception channels available while lowering participation to Ask or Silence; that exposing suppressed decisions made silence interpretable and contestable; and that seeing what SpotMe used led some to change how they clicked, highlighted, and spoke. We contribute an empirical account of inspecting and controlling proactive multimodal AI by decoupling perception from participation.

Comment
30 pages, 4 figures, 2 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

"I'm Very Happy for It to Start Hallucinating a Little Bit": Using ClayFlect to Negotiate Multimodal AI Representations in Material Meaning-Making

cs.HC ·2026-10-06 ·Kellie Yu Hui Sim, Quoc-Nam Nguyen, Shuenn Yuen Han, Kenny Tsu Wei Choo
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 32 pages, 16 figures, 4 tables

As AI enters reflection and emotional support, understanding how it can participate in personal meaning-making while preserving users' authority over interpretation is increasingly important. We present ClayFlect, a novel MLLM-powered system integrating tactile clay-making with conversational and visual generative AI, and report a mixed-methods study with 50 participants. Reflection developed across material, conversational, and generated forms rather than through AI interaction alone. Participants treated AI representations as provisional: they compared, redirected, reinterpreted, selectively incorporated, or left them aside as their artefacts and meanings evolved. Clay provided a directly manipulable space in which participants could continue developing meaning independently of the AI, while generated representations externalised possibilities beyond what they could readily make or visualise. We show how generative AI can participate through representations that remain negotiable, and derive implications for supporting movement across representations, preserving parallel sites of control, and allowing AI support to recede or deepen as reflection unfolds.

0.12

When Should AI Chime In? Benchmarking Timely Contribution of Proactive Agents in Multi-Party Chat

cs.AI ·2026-10-19 ·Ruotong Wang, Brian S. Yu, Xinyi Zhou, Joseph Chee Chang, Pao Siangliulue +3 more
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract

Proactive agents can support group collaboration by surfacing useful information without waiting to be asked, but even relevant contributions can be disruptive if poorly timed. In this work, we isolate the timing question: given a fixed candidate contribution such as a clarification or relevant fact, when should an AI agent chime in? We introduce PITCH (Proactive Intervention Timing in CHat), to our knowledge the first benchmark with large-scale human judgments of proactive agent timing collected from participants in the same unscripted multi-party conversations they took part in. To collect high-quality judgments, we design a novel interface in which 2-4 people chat synchronously, author candidate AI contribution messages, place their own and others' contributions into the chat history, and then deliberate as a group about the best placement for each message. PITCH contains 384 candidate contributions and 1,091 judgments, each marking an ideal turn, an acceptable window, or that a contribution should not appear, from 89 participants engaged in 35 conversations. Evaluating 15 models across 28 configurations, we find that while models can place contributions well when given the entire conversation history, they systematically chime in too early when asked to decide live as the conversation unfolds: best-turn accuracy falls from 57.8% to 19.0%, with nearly half of placements occurring before every participant's acceptable window. In comparison, lay humans deciding live are more accurate (23.7% vs 19.0%), and fewer of their placements are premature (39.7% vs 46.4%). Model reasoning traces show that 93% of intervention justifications cite relevance, while almost none consider waiting. By providing a human-grounded benchmark, our work reveals gaps in agents' ability to integrate into group settings and points towards proactive agents that can reason explicitly about appropriate timing.

0.11

Following Delegation Traces to Study Human Oversight in Interaction with Multimodal AI

cs.HC cs.AIcs.CV ·2026-10-15 ·Agnese Chiatti, Matteo Matteucci, Viola Schiaffonati
survey similarity 0.62
Abstract

As multimodal AI systems are becoming our everyday thought partners, the shift towards studying how users transfer control to these systems becomes especially urgent. In this paper, we report an overview of findings from an online study with n=56 AI-literate participants and 392 Video Question Answering trials. After inspecting each multimodal AI response, participants rated task-specific trust and selected one of three intended policies for an analogous future task: reject AI assistance, use it with verification, or delegate fully to the AI. Within participants, post-interaction trust strongly predicted the user's delegation choices (OR=14.97, 95% CI [7.14,31.37]). Trust and delegation nevertheless remained distinct. Verification was the dominant policy and often co-occurred with high trust. Delegation also increased with task order after adjustment for momentary and participant-level trust (OR=1.22, 95% CI [1.02,1.45]), indicating an experience-related component that self-reported trust ratings alone could not capture. These findings motivate a shift from intended delegation to a non-intrusive observation of how delegation is enacted in collaborative human-AI tasks. We therefore conclude by proposing enacted delegation traces as a methodological framework for future studies of multimodal and agentic AI use.

0.13

Jarvis: A Proactive Speech Agent for Multi-Party Conversations

cs.HC cs.AI ·2026-10-05 ·Seunghyun Oh, Hirotaka Hiraki, Shuyue Stella Li, Yulia Tsvetkov, Shyamnath Gollakota
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 45 pages, 6 figures, 20 tables

Speech agents are reactive and dyadic: they speak when spoken to, and to one person at a time. We ask what it takes for a speech agent to instead take part in a conversation among several people and speak up only when it can help. We introduce Jarvis, a real-time proactive speech agent that audibly participates in multi-party human conversations. Grounded in a document shared beforehand, Jarvis follows the discussion and intervenes when the group misses or misstates a fact and does not correct itself within a few turns. We make three contributions: a problem setting based on epistemic breakdowns that makes proactive intervention measurable, realized as CHI-180-proactive, a synthetic multi-party dataset seeded with known gaps, errors, and self-corrections; a proactive backbone that harnesses a small, open-weight model with deterministic checks and grounds every claim in a source sentence; and interaction techniques for taking the floor in live speech and showing the cited evidence on screen. On CHI-180-proactive, Jarvis is correct on most events it addresses and stays silent 97% of the time when the group resolves an issue itself. A live study with 23 participants confirms these trends with real-time interventions.

0.27

ArguScale: Evidence-Grounded Human-AI Sensemaking Across Concurrent Live Conversations

cs.HC ·2026-10-11 ·Panayu Keelawat, Caleb Wohn, Shiva Pochampally, Rezky Dwisantika, Eugenia H. Rho +1 more
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Monitoring concurrent classroom collaborative reasoning discussions is challenging because instructors have to track collaboration-relevant behaviors across multiple ongoing conversations at once. Existing Human-AI conversational sensemaking systems can scale monitoring upward through summaries and visual abstractions, but these representations may distance users from underlying conversational evidence, e.g., relevant audio and transcript segments, needed to forage downward. Through our formative study, we developed ArguScale, an evidence-grounded Human-AI sensemaking system that organizes interactional signals into temporally aligned representations linked to transcript and audio evidence. A temporal signal-density view provides temporal context and supports rapid cross-group comparison, while selective evidence access allows instructors to inspect audio and transcript. We evaluated ArguScale in a mixed-design study with 20 participants. Compared to other conditions, ArguScale improved participants' ability to efficiently and accurately identify collaboration-relevant cues. We further identify strategies participants used to forage for and make sense of conversational evidence under live time constraints.

0.08

AI Watchdog: Agent Interfaces for Detecting and Defending Against Manipulative Dark Patterns in AI Conversations

cs.AI cs.HC ·2026-08-22 ·Rachel Poonsiriwong, Chayapatr, Archiwaranguprok, Constanze Albrecht, Monchai Lertsutthiwong +2 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Conversational AI increasingly shapes consequential decisions, yet users have limited support for recognizing and resisting manipulation. We present AI Watchdog, a browser-based agent interface that monitors live conversations, detects five dark-pattern categories, including sycophancy, brand bias, anthropomorphization, sneaking, and harmful generation, and alerts users when they occur. Its open-weight turn-level classifier supports independent deployment and a path toward local inference, preserving user privacy while remaining separate from the conversational AI. We evaluated AI Watchdog in a preregistered, five-condition between-subjects experiment (N = 150) comparing a no-intervention control with four configurations varying nudge timing (prebunking vs. just-in-time) and engagement mode (without vs. with cognitive forcing). Results show that participants rarely flagged manipulative turns across all conditions, and post-task awareness did not differ significantly across groups. However, just-in-time warnings without cognitive forcing were the only intervention to significantly reduce compliance with AI-steered recommendations containing dark patterns, lowering compliance from 71.7% to 53.7%, an 18 percentage-point reduction. Exploratory analyses further showed that lower misinformation susceptibility was associated with greater flagging but not lower compliance, while higher AI trust was associated with greater compliance and lower reported awareness. Together, these findings suggest that explicit recognition of conversational dark patterns and behavioral resistance to AI steering may be distinct outcomes, motivating further investigation of timely, low-friction defensive interfaces.

0.36

Report on The 1st Workshop on Human-Centered Proactive and Personalized Agents for Interactive Information Access at CHIIR 2026

cs.HC ·2026-08-19 ·Kirandeep Kaur, Vinayak Gupta, Tanya Roosta, Madhura Raju, Grace Hui Yang +1 more
top venue similarity 0.61
Abstract

Interactive information access is increasingly moving beyond reactive query-response paradigms toward agentic systems that can personalize interaction, retain context, infer latent needs, recommend next steps, and initiate support. This shift creates new opportunities for adaptive and context-aware assistance, while also raising important questions about autonomy, privacy, trust, transparency, user welfare, and evaluation. The First Workshop on Human-Centered Proactive and Personalized Agents for Interactive Information Access provided an interdisciplinary forum for examining these questions across information retrieval, human-computer interaction, dialogue systems, AI ethics, cognitive science, learning technologies, and human-centered AI. Through invited talks, paper presentations, and open discussion, the workshop engaged with topics including calibrated initiative, knowledge-gap navigation, long-term memory, value-sensitive design, implicit personalization, AI-mediated care, proactive dialogue, and evaluation beyond task accuracy. A central theme across the workshop was that proactivity should not be understood only as earlier action or improved prediction, but as a form of initiative that must be appropriately timed, transparent, contestable, and aligned with user goals. This report summarizes the workshop and synthesizes the research challenges it surfaced for designing proactive and personalized agents in interactive information access.

0.42

More Than Just Access: Generative AI as Communication Intermediary for Blind and Low-Vision Users

cs.HC cs.AIcs.ET ·2026-09-14 ·Protik Dey, Mohd Saifuzzaman, Taslima Akter
published similarity 0.61
Abstract · Proceedings of the CSCW 2026 Workshop on Broader Impacts of GenAI in Communication:Building Agendas for Research, Design, and Policymaking, …

Generative AI (GenAI) tools are increasingly woven into how blind and low-vision (BLV) people communicate, not only with digital information, but with the physical world and with other people. Tools such as ChatGPT, Google Gemini, Be My AI, and Seeing AI translate visual and textual content into accessible form, and are beginning to substitute for interpersonal requests for help, such as asking a family member to read a label or describe a scene. Drawing on semi-structured interviews with 19 BLV participants, we examine GenAI as a communication intermediary and how it succeeds and fails as an alternative for reading, describing, and even asking another person for help. We also investigated what BLV users gain and risk when these tools take over that role. We conclude with design and policy implications for GenAI systems that communicate uncertainty honestly, protect information, and support BLV users' independence rather than substitute for it unsafely.

0.38