CS Paper Radar

A Unified Choice Model of News Selection: Experimental Evidence on Stance, Rank, and Engagement Cues

Jacopo D'Ignazi, Andreas Kaltenbrunner, Michele Starnini, Vicenç Gómez

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-11-17 17:04 UTC · v1

Abstract

Social media platforms often display visual engagement cues alongside ranked news articles, yet their influence on clicks remains poorly understood when considered jointly with ranking position and users' political preferences. We propose a unified discrete choice framework using a conditional multinomial logit model to jointly estimate and compare the influence of these factors on news selection. We evaluate the model using 1,480 choices from 370 human participants across four news topics in a controlled study with and without visual engagement cues. The framework allows us to assess the incremental contribution of each factor through nested-model likelihood-ratio tests. We find that including visual engagement cues significantly improves model fit across all topics after accounting for rank and stance. Engagement cues alone also predict clicks better than either of these features, although the full model achieves the highest held-out log-likelihood. Finally, we quantify via counterfactual analysis the impact of ranking position and displayed engagement counts on click probabilities. These findings can inform platform owners, researchers, and policymakers evaluating how platform design affects the selection of political news.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

How Different, or Different How? Stance Granularity in Viewpoint Selection for Dialog Systems that Engage Users with Alternative Views

cs.HC cs.CL ·2026-10-22 ·Morita Tarvirdians, Reeve Lorena, Catharine Oertel
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Systems that aim to help a user engage with viewpoints other than their own have to decide how different those viewpoints should be. Viewpoints are mainly represented on a scalar scale, too coarse to distinguish viewpoints that disagree with the user about different things. We introduce a selection policy in which a bandit sets how far viewpoints may sit from the user, and the policy selects the most novel viewpoint within that bound. We vary only its stance encoder, comparing a scalar score with Perspectivized Stance Vectors, which break a position into separate stances on concepts. We integrate it inside a dialog system and run a between-subjects study (N=63). Concept-level stance produces more varied exposure sequences and broader coverage of the topic's positions, but does not change how deeply users justify viewpoints or how accurately they reconstruct them. Finally, we analyze user--viewpoint relations at the concept level, showing that users reconstruct a viewpoint least accurately on concepts that one side took no position on, rather than on concepts where the two disagreed. Our findings open up opportunities for dialog systems that support engagement with alternative viewpoints by acting on which concepts a user and a viewpoint disagree on, rather than on distance alone.

0.26

Toward Collective-Centric Evaluation of Preference Inference for Participatory Democracy

cs.SI cs.AI ·2026-09-02 ·Pierre-Antoine Lequeu, Salim Hafid, Paul Lerner, Nazanin Shafiabadi, Laurène Cave +4 more
benchmark similarity 0.58
Abstract · 7 pages of content

To scale up collective decision-making, participatory democracy platforms such as Polis and Remesh enable online deliberation among thousands of participants. However, at this scale, participants cannot review every opinion submitted by others, producing highly sparse voting data that misrepresent patterns of consensus, conflict, and minority support. Platforms therefore increasingly rely on Preference Inference (PI) models to predict missing votes. Yet this automation is not neutral: inferred preferences can artificially amplify, suppress, or reorder existing patterns of support, ultimately reshaping how the outcomes of a deliberation are interpreted. More generally, we lack a systematic understanding of how existing PI methods affect the collective preference landscape. To address this gap, we benchmark several existing PI approaches in this context. Moving beyond conventional user-centric evaluations centered on the accuracy of individual predictions, we introduce a collective-centric evaluation framework that measures whether inferred votes preserve salient properties of the broader preference landscape. We further contribute the largest multilingual dataset of its kind: four consultations spanning over 90k participants, 1M votes, and 22 languages. Our experiments show that models with comparable predictive accuracy can differ substantially in the degree to which they preserve the collective structure. These results demonstrate that accuracy alone is insufficient for evaluating PI in democratic settings. By contributing a novel comprehensive and collective-centric evaluation benchmark for the task of PI, this work aims to support the development of AI systems that scale deliberation without compromising the integrity of its democratic outcomes.

0.09

LLM Recommenders Produce Demographic Inequality Through Content Preferences

cs.CY cs.SI ·2026-10-30 ·Nicolò Pagan, Petter Törnberg, Christopher A. Bail, Christopher Barrie
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly being integrated into systems that rank and recommend online content. We examine how this shift can produce demographic inequality in whose voices are surfaced. Using 10,000 Twitter/X posts written by 1,000 survey respondents and linked to verified self-reported characteristics across nine demographic attributes, we conduct a controlled recommendation experiment across three LLM providers, six recommendation objectives, and five levels of contextual information. By varying whether models receive post text alone, platform metadata, or explicit author demographics, we isolate three pathways to unequal recommendation: preferences for demographically patterned content, reliance on unequal engagement signals, and direct use of disclosed identity. We find that demographic inequality emerges from text alone. Models consistently favour longer, more negative, and more opinionated posts, particularly those concerning news and social issues, producing systematic differences in the demographic composition of recommended authors. Platform metadata generally amplifies these inequalities, while explicitly disclosing authors' demographic characteristics produces little additional change. Recommendation objectives mainly affect the magnitude of these patterns: controversial framing intensifies both content and demographic skew, whereas popularity-oriented framing dampens it, although for some attributes - most notably age - the objective can also reverse which group is favoured. LLM-based recommenders can therefore reproduce demographic inequality by proxy, not through explicit demographic targeting, but through preferences for content and engagement signals already structured by social inequality.

0.24

From institutional journalism to political extremes: Structural asymmetries in YouTube's news recommender during the 2022 French presidential campaign

cs.SI ·2026-11-13 ·Julien Figeac, Erwan Le Merrer, Marie Neihouser, Gilles Tr{é}dan
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Debate has intensified over how algorithmic recommendations shape news visibility, particularly regarding structural and ideological bias. This study examines YouTube's News Recommender System (NRS) in the French ``News'' section, using a large-scale audit based on automated browsing agents operating under cold-start conditions, without prior viewing history, to isolate the algorithm's structural baseline independently of user preferences. Our results reveal that YouTube's NRS operates within a structurally asymmetric visibility regime: even in the absence of prior user behaviour, recommendation outputs disproportionately privilege platform-native creators and politically engaged content over established journalism. Television channels retain some relative advantage, but institutional news outlets, particularly press and radio, are systematically marginalised across recommendation sequences. Among political content, figures affiliated with far-left and far-right movements occupy a disproportionately visible position in recommendation outputs. Rather than correcting this asymmetry, continuity effects reproduce and stabilise it across recommendation sequences. These results show that visibility in YouTube's News section cannot be reduced to accumulated user preferences alone, but is also shaped by a structural bias embedded in the platform's recommendation system, which plays an important role in sustaining the prominence of political actors affiliated with the far left and far right.

0.22

Echoes in the Algorithm: Analyzing the Fidelity of User Preferences Against Realized Platform Reach

cs.HC ·2026-09-08 ·Emelia Hughes, Tim Weninger
benchmark similarity 0.56
Abstract

What does popular content look like when platforms withhold the usual cues? On TikTok, users still form impressions about which videos are taking off even when likes and view counts are hidden, delayed, or pushed to the margins of the interface. We study this problem through TokOrNot, a web-based game in which participants compared pairs of TikTok videos and reported (i) which one they preferred and (ii) which one they believed had reached a larger audience. We benchmark these judgments against verified public view counts, which we use as a bounded proxy for realized platform reach. Across 3,513 judgments from 363 participants, participants identified the higher-reach video only modestly above chance (56.75%, 95% CI: 56.01-58.55). Preference aligned with the higher-view video at a similar rate, while preference and prediction matched in 83.48% of trials (95% CI: 83.12-85.95). Performance also varied across content categories. Taken together, these results do not suggest that users can reliably read platform success from content alone. Instead, they point to a looser and more uncertain interpretive process in which reach judgments often track personal taste or other weak heuristics when explicit popularity cues are absent. We discuss the implications for algorithmic literacy and for interface designs that reduce visible metrics without leaving users to infer reach from uneven or idiosyncratic cues alone.

0.23

OranSim: Simulating Consumer Response to Social Media Campaigns Before Launch

cs.SI ·2026-09-23 ·Jianxiang Ma, Mingfu Zhang, Xiaocui Yang, Yichen Gao, Junzhao Huang +1 more
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · 26 pages, 5 figures. Updated title and revised manuscript. Code: https://github.com/OranAi-Ltd/oransim

Social simulation studies how individual behavior and social interaction produce collective outcomes. In social media marketing, campaign actions shape which consumers encounter the content and how they respond; these responses then spread through the population. We propose OranSim, a social simulation framework that connects creative, creator, targeting, and budget choices to this process. Heterogeneous consumers receive exposure according to content matching and platform allocation and generate initial responses, which propagate among 60 population segments. Candidate campaigns share the initial population and aligned random numbers, making their response trajectories comparable under action changes. In a controlled synthetic campaign, doubling the budget approximately doubles reach while lowering mean content match and engagement probability among the reached consumers; mean 14-day cumulative simulated response mass rises to 1.96 times the baseline. LightGBM predictors fitted to 39,000 historical RedNote notes estimate platform engagement with log-scale $R^2$ of 0.56--0.62 in five-fold cross-validation; a separate 12,154-note corpus supplies temporal, unseen-creator, and held-out-niche test splits. Public-data experiments evaluate policy-value estimation and audience ranking, and paired synthetic outcomes test counterfactual scoring. Together, scenario trajectories and engagement estimates support campaign selection according to a prespecified marketing objective. Code is available at https://github.com/OranAi-Ltd/oransim.

0.73

Visual Framing for News Stance Detection via Image Generation

cs.CL cs.AIcs.CVcs.CY ·2026-09-01 ·Dahyun Lee, Jiyoung Han, Kunwoo Park
top venue similarity 0.55
Abstract · EMNLP 2026

Article-level news stance detection aims to identify the perspective of news articles toward social issues. Despite advances in stance detection and its importance for trustworthy media environments, news articles pose distinct challenges because their stances are often implicit, subtly conveyed through journalistic framing, and embedded in long, structurally complex texts. To address these challenges, we introduce VFStance, which leverages visual framing to make implicit stance cues more explicit via image generation. In evaluation experiments, we demonstrate the effectiveness of VFStance over existing methods and the contribution of visual framing to its performance. Finally, a controlled user study (N=200) in a snippet-based news consumption setting further demonstrates that VFStance can make stance signals visually salient and highlights its potential use beyond automated stance detection.

0.49

BiliPicks: Seven Years of Weekly Platform Curation on Bilibili with Video Metadata, Comments, and Danmaku

cs.SI ·2026-10-28 ·Ruomeng Liu
similarity 0.55
Abstract

BiliPicks documents seven years of Bilibili's Weekly Picks, a platform-curated editorial video series. The dataset covers 371 publicly listed issues and 13,758 curated videos from 22 March 2019 to 7 May 2026. It links issue dates, themes and editorial recommendations to video metadata, 47,799,657 top-level comments, 125,690,760 time-synchronised overlay comments (danmaku), and 13,739 cover images. Weekly issues provide a consistent unit for tracing changes in category composition, recurring creators and editorial framing. Corresponding comments and danmaku connect video-level discussion with audience expressions tied to particular moments, while covers add a visual dimension. We evaluate retrieval coverage and illustrate longitudinal analyses of selection, audience language and cover presentation. BiliPicks provides a dataset for future studies of platform curation, linking changes in published selections to their editorial framing and corresponding audience engagement.

0.13