CS Paper Radar

Causal Overtaking in Fair Transaction Ordering

Haozhe Feng, Di Wu, Jian Liu

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-11-19 13:33 UTC · v1

Abstract

Fair transaction ordering protocols aim to mitigate front-running using replica-local arrival orders, but prior work often assumes a single submission origin for each responsive transaction. We identify causal overtaking, in which corrupted replicas observe a target and submit identical signed copies of a responsive transaction through multiple client entries. The copies' first arrivals at different replicas can collectively provide ordering support that no individual path achieves, allowing the response to execute before its target. We formalize a class of receipt-order protocols, including Themis, characterize the timing and network conditions under which the attack is feasible, and show that delayed gossip does not rule it out. We further prove that, under our network model, histories requiring opposite transaction orders can produce identical receipt evidence. Thus, receipt-only mechanisms cannot always preserve earlier-submission priority while preventing responsive overtaking. We propose a mitigation and analyze its assumptions and limitations. Finally, we evaluate the attack and mitigation on Themis through simulations driven by AWS and WonderProxy latency measurements.

Comment
22 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Breaking Cycles for Scalable Fair Ordering in Blockchain Systems

cs.DC ·2026-09-01 ·Jinchun He, Wangjie Qiu, Yizhong Liu, Shengda Zhuo, Kwok-Yan Lam
similarity 0.66
Abstract

In blockchain systems, transaction order directly determines financial outcomes: unfair ordering enables front-running and sandwich attacks that have extracted over \$686M from Ethereum users. Current fair-ordering protocols aggregate pairwise receive-order evidence from replicas. Under contention or adversarial manipulation, however, Condorcet cycles force them into global strongly connected component (SCC) condensation, causing delays, coarse batches, and scaling failures. We present FlashOrder, a deterministic fair-ordering engine that localizes cyclic ambiguity before it propagates across the batch. FlashOrder embeds pairwise preferences into one-dimensional canonical positions, clusters nearby transactions with a partition hypergraph, and performs hierarchical inter- and intra-cluster serialization, replacing batch-wide SCC condensation with localized sorting and aggregation. Evaluated against Themis (CCS '23) and Rashnu (VLDB '24) on a libhotstuff-based prototype, FlashOrder achieves up to 10.5$\times$ higher throughput than Themis and 4.8$\times$ higher than Rashnu, with the latency gap widening as network scales. In controlled adversarial simulation, it reduces maximum rank displacement by 88.7\%, and under Condorcet attacks it sustains 12.0$\times$ and 9.7$\times$ higher throughput than Themis and Rashnu on average. These results show that localizing cyclic ambiguity yields stronger fairness at substantially higher throughput.

0.18

Byzantine Reliable Broadcast with Causal Ordering

cs.DC ·2026-09-15 ·Mariarosaria Barbaraci, Christian Cachin
publishedtheory similarity 0.62
Abstract · 23 pages, 2 figures

Reliable and total-order broadcasts in the Byzantine-fault model are well studied, but adding causal order has received comparatively little attention, largely due to the complexity that stems from actions of Byzantine processes. Existing solutions almost exclusively build causal ordering on top of total-order broadcast. The combination of causal order with reliable broadcast remains rare, and the few solutions that exist adopt the classical definition of causality based on events occurring at individual processes (the happened-before relation). This definition is not sufficient to enforce causal ordering among broadcast messages: Byzantine processes can lie about, omit, and forge dependency information and thereby violate the causal order among self-reported events. Such manipulations remain indistinguishable from correct behavior to any single observer. We demonstrate the issue and its consequences via a front-running attack. To close this gap, we extend the notion of reliable broadcast to externalize local potential knowledge. We use this to formalize the first complete definition of causal message ordering in reliable broadcast under Byzantine faults. Unlike the classical formalization, this notion is grounded in the joint observations of a sufficiently large group of correct processes rather than a process's own view. Building on this definition, we characterize the properties of a Byzantine reliable broadcast channel that guarantees causal ordering. We then present an efficient protocol that satisfies these properties: it is resilient to the optimal number of $f < n/3$ Byzantine faults and for one instance that broadcasts payload message~$m$, it has bit complexity $O(n^2(|m| + λ+ n))$, where $λ$ denotes the maximal size of a unique (cryptographic) label for~$m$. Finally, we prove the protocol achieves Byzantine reliable broadcast with causal ordering.

0.28

Mitigating Front-Running Attacks through Fair and Resilient Transaction Dissemination

cs.DC ·2026-09-21 ·Wassim Yahyaoui, Joachim Bruneau-Queyreix, Jérémie Decouchant, Marcus Völp
publishedhighly cited similarity 0.61
Abstract

In modern blockchains, efficient, fair, and faulttolerant information dissemination is critical for performance and security. Several stages of the transaction lifecycle are affected, from the creation and dissemination of transactions to the dissemination of blocks in the consensus layer. Mempool protocols, such as L{Ø}, already address some of modern blockchains' security threats. However, others remain unless fairness is embedded most fundamentally in the dissemination layer used by these protocols to share transactions and blocks and to reconcile mempools. This paper introduces HERMES, a novel dissemination protocol for mempools that leverages robust minimal structures to optimize data propagation, balance load, and ensure fairness despite faults and Byzantine actors. Specifically, we address front-running attacks by randomizing the choice of an overlay structure while forcing nodes to prove adherence to the mempools' dissemination policies and the random choice made. Experimental results show significant performance improvements compared to traditional broadcast protocols for both permissioned and permissionless blockchains.

0.57

A Deterministic Commitment Rule over Unstructured DAGs for Optimistic Replication

cs.DC ·2026-10-30 ·João Paulo Bezerra, Petr Kuznetsov, Léo Olivier, Sara Tucci-Piergiovanni
similarity 0.60
Abstract

In optimistic replication protocols, each replica uses the local state to execute requests from its clients in a wait-free manner, without synchronizing with other replicas. The outcomes may be revised later, making optimistic protocols only eventually consistent. To compensate for this consistency loss, an additional commitment mechanism can be employed: an underlying atomic broadcast protocol that allows replicas to periodically agree on the evolution of the object state. In this paper, we introduce a simple framework for optimistic replication based on a causality DAG: every replica represents the object state via a causally ordered set of client operations. The framework incorporates a deterministic commitment rule that incurs virtually zero message overhead beyond the basic dissemination of submitted operations.

0.22

Attacking P2P Networks: Liveness Attacks on the GossipSub and DOG Gossip Protocols

cs.CR ·2026-11-02 ·Jiaheng Li, Anton Paramonov, Yann Vonlanthen
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Peer-to-peer (P2P) networks form the communication layer of large decentralized systems such as Ethereum, and the correctness of higher-level protocols depends on the gossip layer delivering messages to honest nodes. We study the robustness of two gossip protocols against adversaries whose only goal is to violate liveness, that is, to prevent honest nodes from receiving fresh messages, without forging, altering, or invalidating any message. For GossipSub, the publish-subscribe protocol used by Ethereum, we show that an adversary operating a constant number of geographically distributed nodes with a fixed latency advantage can take over the ``First Message Deliveries'' peer-scoring term and separate a constant fraction of nodes from the honest mesh. We analyze the attack under a geographical model, address the random-peer and outbound-connection mechanisms, and show that the separation can be maintained under realistic churn. For DOG, a transaction-dissemination protocol designed for CometBFT, we first give simple counterexamples in which route filtering disconnects the dissemination graph even without failures or Byzantine participants, and then present a practical attack that uses only a single physical node with a constant number of identities and legitimate actions to disable every forwarding route, separating the full network while allowing only direct publisher-to-neighbor delivery. We verify the attack in a simulated network and analyze its cost, assumptions, and possible mitigations.

0.11

How Not to Be Censored: Inclusion Safety in Client-Led Consensus

cs.DC ·2026-10-21 ·Yackolley Amoussou-Guenou, Andrea Canidio
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Blockchain consensus protocols implicitly follow a client-server architecture: validators are the only active participants, while clients (i.e., users) merely submit transactions and rely on validators to include them. This abstraction obscures a fundamental question: what should a client do to guarantee the timely inclusion of its own transaction? We study this question by introducing a leaderless consensus protocol in which clients are active. We define inclusion safety: the guarantee that a client's transaction enters some of the blocks produced for an epoch, and that every block omitting it belongs to a fork that is eventually abandoned. Because every transaction carries a reference to a block of the previous epoch, clients help select the surviving fork. This yields two paths to inclusion: reaching sufficiently many honest replicas within an epoch, or relaying a block containing the transaction across epochs until the corresponding fork becomes canonical. In a generalized model spanning synchrony and asynchrony, the client's and the replicas' connectivity are substitutes for inclusion safety: it is achieved either if the client is well connected, or if the client is poorly connected but honest replicas communicate reliably, provided the client reaches at least one of them. However, the substitution is imperfect: when inclusion safety rests on the replicas' connectivity, it requires a longer epoch compared to when the client is well connected.

0.29

Breaking Fault Lines: Unifying TEE-Assisted BFT Consensus in Partially Trusted Worlds

cs.DC ·2026-09-09 ·Xiaoqing Wen, Tong Liu, Jianyu Niu, Jialin Li, Cong Wang +2 more
published similarity 0.58
Abstract · Accepted to EuroSys 2027

This paper revisits TEE-assisted BFT under a universal partial-TEE model, where an arbitrary subset of replicas execute inside TEEs while the remaining replicas operate without hardware trust guarantees. We show that heterogeneous trust changes the structure of quorum formation and fault tolerance. In particular, we derive a tight resilience bound f < max {n/3, m/2}, where n is the total number of replicas and m is the number of TEE-enabled replicas. The result reveals a sharp threshold phenomenon: TEEs improve fault tolerance only once they exceed two-thirds of the deployment. Guided by this characterization, we introduce two protocol principles: (1) a dual-quorum construction that safely combines TEE-only and mixed quorums, and (2) a TEE-leader fast path that leverages hardware-enforced non-equivocation to reduce both consensus and view-change latency. We realize these ideas in Raftel, which is, to our knowledge, the first HotStuff-style BFT protocol designed explicitly for arbitrary partial-TEE deployments, and in chained-Raftel, a pipelined variant that further accelerates mixed-trust execution. We implement both protocols atop Intel SGX and evaluate them in LAN and WAN environments. Our results show that Raftel achieves up to 625 TPS with sub-670 ms latency in WAN settings, outperforming HotStuff by up to 308 TPS in throughput while approaching the performance of fully TEE-assisted protocols.

0.26

Revisiting Fast Tendermint: An Agreement Violation and Two Repairs

cs.DC cs.CR ·2026-10-12 ·Alejandro Ranchal-Pedrosa
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Fast Tendermint reduces Tendermint's good-case latency to two communication steps for n>=5f+1. We show that its published round-change rule violates Agreement: one Byzantine process suffices for every f>=1, and for f>=2 two Byzantine processes suffice without double signing. The failure occurs when a process advances past a round without recording the value that may have been decided there. The Quint specification that accompanies the protocol does not allow this kind of round skipping and is not affected; the violation lies in the published pseudocode. We present two repairs. Walk requires a process to leave each round on a quorum of that round's precommits and to precommit before leaving. It keeps the recorded valid state and removes the wait after a precommit quorum. Justify carries the evidence needed to accept a proposal in the proposal itself, removing both the recorded valid state and the proposer's synchronization wait. Both satisfy Agreement and Validity under asynchrony and Termination under the partially synchronous gossip model of Tendermint and Fast Tendermint. Both retain proposal timeouts. The main text presents the executions that violate Agreement and explains the two repairs. The appendices provide proofs, a brief comparison with other round-change designs, and an extension to chains.

0.09