CS Paper Radar

Technology, education and critical media literacy: potential, challenges, and opportunities

Mayte Santos-Albardía, Simón Peña-Fernández, Irati Agirreazkuenaga

cs.CY ·submitted 2026-08-11 10:30 UTC · v1
publishedsurveyhighly cited

Abstract

This study examines the impact of technology within media education, media literacy, and educommunication, and explores how these fields are perceived and understood by students and academic experts, focusing on the development of critical competencies and critical media literacy. Based on semi-structured in-depth interviews with leading experts in the field of critical media literacy, and a survey conducted with 141 university students in Communication and Education programs, this study explores how recent technological advances are linked to challenges in information consumption-such as disinformation, fake news, incidental exposure to information, and deepfakes-as well as the challenges and opportunities these issues present within educational contexts. The results reveal that, although such technologies provide opportunities to improve teaching-learning processes, their inclusion in the curriculum is limited and often superficial. In addition, we identify shortcomings in how teachers are trained to manage these tools effectively, hindering the development of critical thinking by students. The conclusions suggest a need for critical media literacy that not only educates students in the use of technologies but also allows them to question and evaluate the content they consume, all within an ethical and reflective framework that promotes participatory and critical citizenship.

Comment
12 pages, 6 tables
Journal ref
Frontiers in Human Dynamics (2025), 7, 1608911
DOI
10.3389/fhumd.2025.1608911

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Mediatised Participation: Citizen Journalism and the Decline in User-Generated Content in Online News Media

cs.CY ·2026-08-11 ·Simón Peña-Fernández, Ainara Larrondo-Ureta, Irati Agirreazkuenaga
publishedsurveyhighly cited similarity 0.57
Abstract · 15 pages

The second generation of web tools shook the journalist profession approximately two decades ago with the proactive incorporation of audiences into the media. Citizen journalism and user-generated content arose as an object of interest due to the democratising value of participation attributed to them, with empowered citizens who could emulate the professional and institutional practises of journalists. However, difficulties soon came to the surface, and audience participation in news media began to be limited. Within this context, this article conducts a critical review of studies on audience participation in news media based on a systematic literature review. The results indicate that, in general, audiences showed low interest in the creation of informative content and that their participation has grown increasingly problematic. In addition, journalists are reticent as they defend their professional role above all else, while company strategies have prioritised making participation profitable. For this reason, the idea of citizen journalism that offers user-created content through the media appears to be a thing of the past, with many characteristics that could define it as a failed innovation. Therefore, the text concludes that audience participation in the media could be defined as mediatised participation.

0.68

What does it mean to use AI critically? Unpacking critical AI literacy through students' evaluation of AI-generated content

cs.HC ·2026-10-07 ·Hyejeong Lee, Wonjin Yu
similarity 0.51
Abstract

Although critical AI literacy has emerged as an important educational goal, the construct remains conceptually broad and insufficiently specified for guiding students' day-to-day interactions with AI. This study examines how students critically evaluated AI-generated content. Drawing on an analysis of students' chatbot interactions and written reflections, we first identified seven stages of AI-supported academic task completion and five functional roles assumed by AI. More importantly, we identified eight evaluative lenses that students used to assess AI-generated responses (accuracy, completeness, task alignment/relevance, personalization, practicality, creativity, ethics, and bias). The findings suggest that critical AI literacy extends beyond verifying the factual accuracy of AI-generated information. Rather, critically engaging with AI involves situated and multidimensional judgment about the epistemic quality, contextual fit, practical feasibility, creative value, and ethical implications of AI-generated content. The framework offers both a conceptual contribution to the emerging literature on critical AI literacy and a practical tool for educators seeking to help learners move from passive acceptance of AI toward deliberate, context-sensitive, and responsible human judgment.

0.08

Playing Bias: Epistemic Games for Interpreting Text-to-Image Models

cs.CY cs.CVcs.HC ·2026-10-23 ·Amalia Foka
publishedposition similarity 0.49
Abstract · 11 pages. Accepted at iLRN 2026, the 12th International Conference of the Immersive Learning Research Network, Athens, Greece, June 2026. Vi…

Text-to-image (T2I) systems do not merely render prompts; they circulate defaults for "what X looks like," shaping recognition through pose, camera, costume, props, and setting. While technical audits quantify disparities, they rarely cultivate the literacy needed to argue how images assemble stereotypes and confer authority. This paper translates a three-stage, humanities-informed framework into a set of epistemic games that make this cultural work visible and debatable: Interpret (art-historical close looking with AI outputs), Interrogate (counter-intent prompting as artistic exploration), and Expose (creative misuse through paired prompts with a constant motif and a BiasSlot rule, in which only the bias cue varies). In a pilot with undergraduate fine-arts students, the games shifted discussion from impressionistic reactions to concise, warranted hypotheses grounded in visual evidence, supported by lightweight classroom instruments that enabled reproducibility and structured collaboration. We argue that such game-based approaches foster critical literacy across educational contexts, equipping learners to recognize, discuss, and contest how T2I models encode bias.

0.43

CRITICS - Critical Science Without Borders: Language Models to Promote Critical Thinking in Science Education

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-09-12 ·Rodrigo Agerri, Itziar Aldabe, Elena Cabrio, Mark Cieliebak, Jan Deriu +8 more
published similarity 0.47
Abstract · 9 pages

The CRITICS project addresses science accessibility and literacy by converging advanced Machine Translation (MT) based on Large Language Models (LLMs) with educational technology. By leveraging MT systems specifically optimized for scientific content, educational institutions can provide accurate, culturally relevant translations of scientific materials in students' native languages, ensuring that complex scientific concepts are comprehensible while maintaining technical accuracy. Building on these translations, the project explores the design and evaluation of innovative science teaching-learning proposals grounded in curriculum-aligned teaching-learning. Thus, CRITICS will investigate key components of scientific argumentation and critical thinking practices together with textual feedback aligned with learning objectives and assessment criteria inspired by competence-based evaluation frameworks. CRITICS aims to break down language barriers to accessing cutting-edge research and educational materials currently available only in high-resourced languages, thereby facilitating the democratization of scientific knowledge and fostering critical thinking in science education.

0.45

Without journalists, there is no journalism: the social dimension of generative artificial intelligence in the media

cs.CY cs.AI ·2026-08-17 ·Simón Peña-Fernández, Koldobika Meso-Ayerdi, Ainara Larrondo-Ureta, Javier Díaz-Noci
publishedsurveyhighly cited similarity 0.46
Abstract · 15 pages

The implementation of artificial intelligence techniques and tools in the media will systematically and continuously alter their work and that of their professionals during the coming decades. To this end, this article carries out a systematic review of the research conducted on the implementation of AI in the media over the last two decades, particularly empirical research, to identify the main social and epistemological challenges posed by its adoption. For the media, increased dependence on technological platforms and the defense of their editorial independence will be the main challenges. Journalists, in turn, are torn between the perceived threat to their jobs and the loss of their symbolic capital as intermediaries between reality and audiences, and a liberation from routine tasks that subsequently allows them to produce higher quality content. Meanwhile, audiences do not seem to perceive a great difference in the quality and credibility of automated texts, although the ease with which texts are read still favors human authorship. In short, beyond technocentric or deterministic approaches, the use of AI in a specifically human field such as journalism requires a social approach in which the appropriation of innovations by audiences and the impact it has on them is one of the keys to its development. Therefore, the study of AI in the media should focus on analyzing how it can affect individuals and journalists, how it can be used for the proper purposes of the profession and social good, and how to close the gaps that its use can cause.

0.52

Cutting out the middleman? Elon Musk and the rhetoric of citizen journalism in platform-mediated communication

cs.SI cs.CY ·2026-10-23 ·Urko Peña-Alonso, Koldobika Meso-Ayerdi, Simón Peña-Fernández, Jordi Morales-i-Gras
published similarity 0.45
Abstract · 13 pages, 5 figures, 4 tables

This article examines how Elon Musk constructed discourse about journalism and the media on X between the 2024 United States presidential election and Donald Trump's presidential inauguration. It investigates how references to journalism, media organisations, and platform-based communication were articulated within Musk's posts, and how users responded to these narratives during a period of intense political polarisation. The study combines computational classification, qualitative thematic coding, and inferential statistical analysis. A corpus of 2,906 posts published by Musk between 5 November 2024 and 20 January 2025 was compiled. From this corpus, 500 posts referring to journalism, media organisations, platforms, or media-related discourse were identified through AI-assisted filtering and subsequent manual review. In addition, 42,066 user responses were analysed from a stratified sample drawn from 3,233,112 interactions. The analysis examined patterns of agreement and disagreement with Musk's stance and their relationship with thematic, gender, and professional variables inferred from publicly available profile information. The findings show that Musk's discourse is organised around three recurrent dynamics: criticism of institutional journalism, the association of media organisations with political and ideological agendas, and the presentation of X as an alternative communicative space. Journalism is predominantly framed through accusations of bias, disinformation, propaganda, and electoral manipulation, whereas X is more often linked to participation, innovation, and direct communication. User responses largely converged with Musk's position, although disagreement remained visible. While thematic orientation and professional background showed statistically significant associations with agreement patterns, effect sizes were limited.

0.40

Show your work: An exploratory study of student experiences of Turnitin Clarity

cs.HC ·2026-09-28 ·J. Roe, M. Perkins
similarity 0.45
Abstract

Process-capture platforms promise to make the writing behind an assessed artefact visible, and vendors increasingly market them as a fairness measure rather than a detection tool. Their acceptability to the students who must write within them, however, is largely untested. This exploratory qualitative study examines how students' expectations of one such platform, Turnitin Clarity, compared with their experience of using it. Seven students at a UK university, given no onboarding to the platform, took part in pre-use focus groups. Six then completed an unassessed 500-word writing task over five days, before all seven returned for a post-use focus group. Data was analysed using reflexive thematic analysis, with Expectation-Confirmation Theory as an orienting frame. The overall pattern was one of mixed confirmation. Participants' functional expectations were largely met, and the sense of being watched that they had anticipated persisted after use: for some it was offset by perceived fairness, while for others it heightened self-monitoring. The bounded AI assistant divided them: its limits were welcomed for marking out acceptable use, but some felt it weakened their ownership of the work and worried it would flatten what they produced. Across both phases, participants weighed the costs of observation against perceived gains in fairness and asked for transparency to run in both directions. Several described already writing defensively in anticipation of accusations of AI misuse. Acceptance of process technologies was reported as being conditional on practice time, two-way transparency, and explicit data governance. Participants also questioned whether a single linear document can represent a writing process they described as messy and multimodal. Across these accounts, process capture did not sit outside the writing it recorded but reorganised the practice it set out to observe.

0.19

When Attention Guardrails Become Barriers to Learning: Towards the Tipping Point

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-09-30 ·Meenakshi V., Pavani Ayinampudi, Aditya B. M. V., Jinal Gupta, Prakash Hegade +3 more
position similarity 0.44
Abstract · 10 pages, 2 figures, 4 tables

Online learning offers flexibility but lacks the structure of a classroom, where a teacher's presence guides attention. The platform we study restores that structure by monitoring the learner through the webcam during ordinary coursework, interrupting or restarting a video when the learner appears distracted. What such monitoring does to a learner across a whole course, rather than in a single examination, is largely unexamined. We report a convergent mixed-methods study of one monitored course pipeline in a summer internship program. We read two free-text surveys alongside three platform channels. The dropout exit survey yielded 15 analyzable responses; the persisting-learner reflection survey, 36. The channels are camera-verification telemetry (14,529 flags from 448 students), an in-video emotion widget (615 submissions from 273 students), and a mandatory end-of-course survey (up to 634 respondents per item). Neither survey named monitoring, so every mention analyzed here was raised by the respondent. Focus-monitoring was raised by 18 of the 51 free-text respondents: 7 of 15 dropouts and 11 of 36 persisting learners. Among the dropouts who raised it, focus-monitoring was the stated primary cause of departure in 4 of 7 cases. None of the 18 questioned being observed in principle. What learners contest is the misreading of ordinary actions, drinking water or moving the head, and the severity of what follows a flag: a video already watched returns to the start of its segment. These findings identify two targets for redesign: the severity of the response to a flag, and the environment check, which can flag a learner before any content has been seen. We argue that the proportionality of that response marks the point at which an attention guardrail becomes a barrier to learning, the tipping point this study approaches.

0.33