CS Paper Radar

Comparing Domain-Model Similarity Metrics Against Human Expert Ratings

Vasiliy Seibert

cs.SE ·submitted 2026-08-15 14:15 UTC · v1

Abstract

Domain models are a primary artefact in model-driven software engineering, where they capture the shared understanding between stakeholders and serve as the contractual basis for downstream software development. Automatic comparison of these semantic models has diverse application areas such as requirements engineering, education, automatic generation of domain models and model reuse and repository mining. The literature offers a variety of presented metrics, but for practitioners there is no defensible way to choose between them. The contribution of this paper is the implementation of five such metrics, their execution on a fixed set of 39 domain-model comparisons and the comparison of each metric's output against the human expert ratings produced for the same comparisons. Two research questions are addressed. RQ1 asks how close, on average, each metric is to the human expert rating across the 39 comparisons. RQ2 asks how consistent each metric's per-comparison distance from the human expert rating is. The findings reveal that no single metric achieves dominance across all criteria; rather, different metrics each yield competitive results on individual criteria - some closest on average, others best preserving the per-pair ordering - which suggests that an ensemble approach combining multiple metrics may serve as a viable substitute for human expert grading. The metric implementations are an artefact of this work and are published in accordance with the FAIR4RS recommendations (DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.20942596).

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Towards Standardized Evaluation in Automated Domain Modeling: Introducing a Benchmark

cs.AI ·2026-08-15 ·Vasiliy Seibert
benchmark similarity 0.61
Abstract

Domain modeling plays an essential role in domain-driven design, capturing essential entities and their relationships within a specific domain. Despite advancements in automated domain modeling, the absence of standardized benchmarks has hindered the comparative assessment of existing approaches. This paper introduces a benchmark designed to address this gap. The benchmark combines the 45-record Golden UML Modelset (Verbruggen et al., 2025) on Zenodo, as distributed by the Text2UML project of Calamo, Mecella, and Snoeck (Calamo et al., 2025), with the 8-record reference archive of Chen et al. (Chen et al., 2023a,b), enabling the evaluation of automated domain modeling approaches across different levels of complexity and scale. Given a natural language description, the task is to generate a corresponding domain model. For each description, a reference domain model is provided as ground truth. A metric is used to compare the generated domain model with the corresponding ground-truth model. To demonstrate the utility of the benchmark, we evaluate multiple automated domain modeling approaches, including heuristic rule-based methods and LLM-driven strategies. In accordance with the FAIR4RS recommendations (Chue Hong et al., 2022), the benchmark is provided as a research artifact to encourage reuse and support future research on automated domain modeling.

0.04

ExpertCrowd-SWE: Measuring Frontier Coding Agents on Expert-Authored Engineering Tasks in Unfamiliar Codebases

cs.AI cs.SE ·2026-11-09 ·Josip Vrdoljak, Akash Singh, Bas Steunebrink, Alex Yarotsky, John Lorenzo +2 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.58
Abstract · 17 pages, 5 figures, 6 tables. Dataset: https://huggingface.co/datasets/ExpertCrowd/ec-swe ; leaderboard: https://www.toptal.com/expertcrowd…

ExpertCrowd-SWE (EC-SWE) is a benchmark of 100 expert-authored, multi-file software engineering tasks for evaluating autonomous coding agents in large, unfamiliar codebases. Each task is a change request written by a practising engineer against a pinned commit of a real repository, paired with a sealed reference solution and a task-specific grader whose weighted, mostly executable criteria award partial credit; must-pass blockers and pass/fail gates encode what a maintainer would refuse to merge. The tasks span 87 open-source projects and 11 languages. The median ticket is 148 words, while the median reference solution changes 471 lines. Every task image is calibrated before release so that the reference solution scores 1.0 and both the untouched repository and an inert change score 0; nearly half of the tasks also ship alternative, lazy and adversarial control patches that the grader must classify correctly. The final 100 tasks were selected for difficulty against current frontier models. We evaluate seven frontier models, five runs each (3,495 scored runs), in a single platform harness that gives each model its provider-native tool interface. Claude Opus 5.5 (67.3%) and GPT-6 Astra (63.7%) lead without a statistically significant gap, followed by Claude Fable 5.1 (46.5%), Gemini 3.8 Flash (40.0%), and a statistically indistinguishable group of Qwen 3.8 Max, DeepSeek V4.1 Flash and Grok 4.6 (32-34%). No task is fully solved by every model, and on 80 tasks no model earns full credit on all five runs. Scores span 35 points. Depending on the model, agents take a median of 33 to 166 steps per run, with little relation to score. We release 24 tasks with their environments, graders and results, and hold out 76 to limit contamination.

0.24

Ideation Arena: Evaluating LLM Generated Research Ideas with Battle-style Human Expert Assessment

cs.AI ·2026-08-30 ·Zhiyu Chen, Keyu Zhao, Jigao Fu, Dong Liang, Yanbiao Wu +6 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.58
Abstract

Evaluating research ideas generated by LLMs is difficult because their scientific value cannot be fully determined by objective criteria, and no single reference answer specifies what counts as a good idea. To address this challenge, we introduce Ideation Arena, a battle style platform that evaluates research ideas through pairwise human assessment. Ideation Arena evaluates ideas generated by 14 frontier LLMs and 5 research agent architectures built on 2 base models. To ensure a common starting point, Ideation Arena builds shared literature contexts from papers familiar to the participating researchers and provides the same contexts to all LLMs and agents. We collect over 6,000 double blind pairwise comparisons from 105 active computer science researchers and construct an Elo rating leaderboard of proposal-stage expert preferences in computer science under a shared closed-context protocol. We validate the rankings through interrater agreement and robustness analyses, showing that the leaderboard remains stable under changes in annotator composition and domain coverage. Our results show substantial variation in agent effectiveness, with some frameworks improving ideation quality over their backbones and others offering little benefit or even underperforming their base models. We further construct Ideation Arena Eval, a benchmark for assessing whether automated evaluators align with human preferences in research ideation. Experiments with current LLM judges show that they still cannot reliably reproduce expert preferences, with the best judge reaching 72.56% Soft Accuracy on Overall Quality. Our code, data, and leaderboards are available at https://github.com/foss12138/Research-Ideation-Arena.

0.51

Whose Data, Whose Benchmark? A User-Centric Framework for Auditing Evaluation Resources

cs.CL cs.AIcs.CYcs.ET+1 ·2026-10-13 ·Mir Tafseer Nayeem, Davood Rafiei
benchmark similarity 0.58
Abstract · Preprint

Benchmarks shape how model capabilities are measured and interpreted, yet their scores can obscure whose conventions, contexts, and judgments define successful performance. We introduce a user-centric audit framework that distinguishes users who contribute benchmark content from those whose needs evaluation results are intended to represent. The framework operationalizes seven dimensions across benchmark content, metadata, documentation, and scoring procedures. Across 16 resources, we find that American-centered conventions account for 62.4-94.4% of matched signals in 11 text benchmarks, while geographic visibility in five image-text resources is concentrated and strongly associated with national GDP share (mean Pearson r = 0.780; Spearman p = 0.778). Documentation reveals a systematic source-target gap: all 16 resources operationalize source-user context, but none operationalize target-user context. Paired scoring experiments further show that meaning-preserving answer variants reduce DROP exact-match accuracy from 100.0% to 33.3%, while TruthfulQA exhibits metric-dependent reductions in reference similarity. Our framework and documentation checklist make user assumptions auditable, clarifying what benchmark scores represent and where evaluation claims are supported.

0.26

From Metrics to Improvement: A Lifecycle-Aware LLM Feedback Framework for Research Software Quality

cs.SE ·2026-08-24 ·Nafis Tanveer Islam, Nafiseh Soveizi, Yutong Li, Zhiming Zhao
code/data similarity 0.57
Abstract

Research software is increasingly central to scientific workflows, yet it is often developed by researchers with limited software engineering expertise. This can lead to quality issues that hinder maintainability, reproducibility, reuse, and sustainability. Existing static analysis tools can identify such issues, but their outputs often require expert interpretation and provide limited support for translating quality assessments into actionable improvements. To address this gap, we propose a lifecycle-aware framework that integrates quantitative software quality assessment with Large Language Model (LLM)-based code refinement. The framework comprises two stages. First, a lifecycle-aware Quality Model is developed from established software quality standards and practitioner requirements. The model defines five quality dimensions and 25 candidate metrics, of which 14 are operationalized using existing analysis tools and custom measurements. Second, the resulting quality diagnostics are used as structured feedback within an iterative LLM-based refinement process, enabling generated improvements to be repeatedly reassessed against the Quality Model. We evaluate the framework on notebook-centric research software using multiple LLMs and compare iterative structured feedback with single-step feedback and unstructured prompting. The results show improvements in specific quality attributes, particularly code duplication and structural quality, while also revealing trade-offs among maintainability, code size, documentation, and complexity. These findings demonstrate the potential of metric-driven LLM feedback for research software quality improvement while highlighting its inherently multi-objective nature \footnote{The source code and experimental data are publicly available at https://github.com/QCDIS/Software_Quality_Control_LLM . }

0.20

EvalBuilder: Can LLMs Build Efficient Benchmarks?

cs.AI ·2026-10-14 ·Huaisheng Zhu, Hangfan Zhang, Teng Xiao, Siyuan Xu, Shijie Zhou +3 more
benchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract

Large language model (LLM) agents are increasingly used for long-horizon research and engineering, yet evaluating these capabilities remains expensive, time-consuming, and heavily dependent on human expertise. This motivates a natural question: can LLM agents themselves construct efficient benchmarks that preserve the conclusions of costly reference evaluations? We study this capability by formulating automatic benchmark development as a meta-evaluation problem, where an agent is given a task and an expensive reference benchmark and requested to construct a lower-cost proxy benchmark that faithfully distinguishes among candidate models and solutions. Based on this formulation, we introduce EvalBuilder, a framework for evaluating such benchmark-generation capabilities along three key dimensions: fidelity, efficiency, and robustness. Specifically, we assess whether generated benchmarks preserve model rankings, generalize to held-out models and freshly collected responses, and provide well-calibrated and discriminative scores while substantially reducing evaluation cost. We further provide an iterative environment in which agents can refine their benchmarks under a fixed time budget. Our framework provides a systematic testbed and benchmark for understanding when current LLM agents can develop useful evaluators and how benchmark construction itself can be increasingly automated.

0.19

Large Language Models for Requirements Engineering: A Cross-Task Empirical Evaluation

cs.SE ·2026-08-21 ·Jacek Dąbrowski, Manjeshwar Aniruddh Mallya, Alessio Ferrari, Mohammad Amin Zadenoori, Yijun Yu
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract

Requirements-related information is scattered across heterogeneous artefacts such as user feedback, developer discussions, and software repositories, making the extraction of actionable requirements knowledge labour-intensive and hard to scale. Large Language Models (LLMs) can support many Requirements Engineering (RE) activities, from classification and traceability identification to specification and explanation generation, but existing evidence is fragmented across tasks, artefact types, and evaluation settings, and studies rarely offer cross-task evaluations or replication packages. We present two complementary empirical studies evaluating LLMs across five RE-related activities. The first is a controlled experiment on five lightweight open-source LLMs for feedback-driven requirements classification and specification generation. The second is an exploratory industrial case study on two frontier LLMs for traceability link identification and traceability explanation generation using real project artefacts. Classification and traceability identification were assessed with quantitative metrics, and generation tasks through human evaluation. LLM performance is strongly task-dependent, ranging from moderate to high, and no single model consistently outperformed the others, indicating that effective adoption depends on selecting models and prompting strategies per task. Our contributions are: (i) the first cross-task empirical evaluation of LLMs spanning five RE-related activities, (ii) replication materials supporting reproducibility, and (iii) a broader understanding of the capabilities, limitations, and practical readiness of current LLMs for RE.

0.47

MARQ: A Modular, LLM-Agnostic Requirement Quality Assessor Infused with Systems Engineering Knowledge

cs.AI cs.SE ·2026-10-26 ·Jannatul Shefa, Alejandro Salado, Paul Wach, Taylan G. Topcu
similarity 0.56
Abstract

Requirements engineering (RE) is foundational to systems engineering (SE), as requirement defects can propagate downstream and adversely affect development outcomes. Although large language models (LLMs) are promising for requirement quality assessment, prior work shows that off-the-shelf models miss a large share of expert-identified defects, perform unevenly across quality criteria, and vary across executions. This study investigates whether infusing expert-derived SE knowledge can improve LLM-based requirement quality evaluation beyond off-the-shelf capability. We present MARQ, a modular, LLM-agnostic prototype that supplements LLMs with a criterion-specific knowledge stack operationalizing INCOSE requirement quality criteria and evaluated against off-the-shelf baselines on an expert-labeled NASA requirement set using Claude Opus 5, GPT-5.6 Sol, and the open-weight Gemma 3 12B, with 100 executions per model. MARQ achieves median F1 scores of 0.80 for Claude Opus 5, 0.62 for GPT-5.6 Sol, and 0.53 for Gemma 3 12B, compared with off-the-shelf baselines of 0.55, 0.52, and 0.18, respectively. However, the nature of these gains is model-dependent. Claude Opus 5 improves defect detection and false-alarm control; GPT-5.6 Sol gains detection and better execution-level consistency at the cost of more false alarms; and Gemma 3 12B reaches the performance of off-the-shelf proprietary models, although it remains highly variable. Criterion-level analysis shows gains concentrated in Correctness and Conformance, trade-offs between misses and false alarms within individual criteria, and model-dependent responses across several criteria. These findings position SE knowledge infusion as a promising model-agnostic pathway for strengthening trustworthy LLM-based RE support while underscoring the need for criterion-specific interventions and human-in-the-loop review.

0.04