CS Paper Radar

Toward AI-Friendly Cartography: Understanding How Color Design Influences Foundation Model Spatial Reasoning on Sequential Choropleth Maps

Yonghe Sun, Zhenjia Liu, Hua Liao, Wenjia Xu, Nai Yang, Weihua Dong, Zhiwei Wei

cs.AI ·submitted 2026-08-16 13:24 UTC · v1
benchmarkcode/data

Abstract

Foundation models (FMs) increasingly support multimodal and geospatial reasoning, yet it remains unclear whether cartographic principles designed for human perception are equally effective for machines. Focusing on sequential choropleth maps, we examine how hue palette, color ordering, and lightness contrast influence FM spatial reasoning. We construct a controlled benchmark of 5,760 maps and 28,800 questions spanning Attribute Identify, Spatial Recognition, Compare, Rank, and Pattern Delineate, and evaluate 21 open-source and proprietary multimodal FMs. Results show that hue choice has limited and inconsistent effects, whereas disrupting sequential color ordering substantially reduces performance, especially for comparison and ranking. Reduced lightness contrast also consistently impairs reasoning, while increasing contrast beyond sufficient separability provides only marginal gains. LoRA fine-tuning improves overall accuracy but preserves these relative sensitivities. Additional factorial experiments further indicate that errors arise from color-and-legend decoding, spatial reasoning, and the integration of thematic attributes with spatial structure. These findings show that conventional sequential ordering and sufficient contrast remain important for machine map understanding and provide empirical guidance for AI-friendly cartographic design.

Comment
42 pages, 12 figures, 13 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

SpheriColor: Colormaps for Spherical Geospatial Input Topographies

cs.HC ·2026-10-08 ·Julius Rauscher, Johannes Fuchs, Daniel A. Keim, Frederik L. Dennig
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · 4 Pages, 3 Figures, to be published in IEEE Visualization Conference (VIS)

Multivariate geospatial data visualization often relies on multiple coordinated views, where color can be used to either link views or encode data attributes. Encoding spatial locations through color can reveal patterns in non-spatial visualizations, yet most applications of colormaps focus on high-dimensional attribute encodings instead. While 2D colormaps have been studied extensively, color encodings designed for spherical geospatial data have received much less attention, even though all locations lie on a sphere. To address this, we propose SpheriColor, a colormap generation approach for mapping geospatial references guided by the design goals of distance preservation and colorspace exploitation. We project a geospatial distance function into a perceptually linear colorspace, followed by two different gamut-constrained optimization strategies. We perform a quantitative evaluation using both real-world and synthetic datasets, demonstrating superior performance over 2D colormaps and HSLuv double cone encodings. The simplex-based optimization excels at distance preservation, whereas the ray-based approach provides better colorspace exploitation.

0.45

Colour Blinded by the Noise

cs.HC stat.ME ·2026-08-18 ·Harriet Mason, Rachel Rogers, Alison Kleffner, Dianne Cook
published similarity 0.60
Abstract · To be presented at IEEE VIS 2026 and published in IEEE TVCG in 2027

Uncertainty visualisation is important for data transparency, especially for map visualisations where data is often aggregated. Despite the importance of this area, studies evaluating uncertainty visualisation lack consensus and produce conflicting results. This work introduces a new evaluation approach for uncertainty visualisation that attempts to assess uncertainty as noise, rather than signal. We evaluate five methods of visualising uncertainty: standard choropleth maps, value/variance bivariate maps, value-suppressing uncertainty palettes, overlaid sampling, and pixelated sampling maps. Built on principles of implicit testing, we put an 'uncertainty visualisation' spin on the classic Ishihara colourblind test to create a novel test that is able to evaluate uncertainty as noise. We compare signal visibility to conventional hypothesis tests at various levels of group separation. By building our experimental design on top of established graphics theory, we isolate the plot components that facilitate successful signal suppression and establish foundational theory for the perception of uncertainty visualisation.

0.53

Sophon: A Procedural Diagnostic for Spatial Reasoning in Vision-Language Models

cs.CV cs.LG ·2026-11-10 ·J. Zach Gazak, Ryan Swindle, Justin Fletcher
publishedcode/data similarity 0.60
Abstract · NeurIPS 2026 (Evaluations & Datasets Track). 10 page main text, 44 pages total. Code and data: https://github.com/zgazak/sophon

Open-weight Vision-Language Models (VLMs) score 85-94% on spatial benchmarks (BLINK Spatial, What's Up CLEVR) yet collapse to chance on simple geometric questions when object, scene, and texture priors are stripped away. We introduce and open-source Sophon, a procedurally generated diagnostic of paired colored point-cloud stimuli across three coordinate systems (1D linear, 2D Cartesian, 2D polar) and four question types (binary, categorical, comparative, quantitative). Across four open architectures (LLaVA-NeXT, LLaVA-OneVision, Qwen2.5-VL, Idefics3), accuracy clusters at 47-52% while frontier models (Opus 4.6, Gemini 2.5 Pro, GPT-5.4) clear 77-83% and humans reach 84-94%. We use linear probes and low-rank adaptation (LoRA) to trace the open-weight failures. Probes of the vision encoder (ViT) and language decoder (LLM) recover Sophon spatial information at 83-85% and 80-86% accuracy, respectively, and the language tower's reasoning circuit answers text-only controls (point clouds as sets of coordinates) at +40 pp over visual stimuli. Language tower per-layer attention attribution localizes visual integration to mid-stack layers. At readout, models elevate the correct answer-set tokens but select among them randomly. We localize the mechanism by tuning individual and grouped components across every architecture's stack, including the vision tower (ViT workspace and reader), the projector, and the language tower (LLM workspace and reader). These experiments demonstrate that this mid-stack workspace holds circuitry capable of organizing the spatial signal so that the frozen reader can decode it. LoRA fine-tuning adjusts that circuitry such that 7B-class VLMs answer Sophon spatial reasoning questions at frontier aggregate accuracy. This work suggests that these models do not have a capability gap for spatial reasoning but suffer from a routing bottleneck that targeted fine-tuning repairs.

0.49

Predicting affective connotation of visualizations from their constituent colors

cs.HC ·2026-08-10 ·Karen B. Schloss, Halle C. Braun, Kushin Mukherjee, Anna L. Chinni, Seth R. Gorelik
published similarity 0.60
Abstract · To be published in IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics

With increasing evidence that affective connotation (emotional association) is an important aspect of visual communication, there is a need for methods to predict affective connotation of visualizations. Many aspects of visualization design, including colors, textures, and shapes, can contribute to affective connotation, and a key question is how multiple design properties combine to determine the emotion association of a whole visualization. In this study, we focused specifically on color and tested whether it is possible to predict the affective connotation of whole visualizations by aggregating the emotion associations of the individual, constituent colors (additivity hypothesis). We also tested whether accounting for the size of colored regions, as determined by the underlying dataset, improved predictions (data-dependence hypothesis). We found that for colormap data visualizations in which colors were well-distributed across all colors in the color scale, the mean estimated associations of individual colors effectively predicted emotional associations of the maps as a whole (additivity; Exp. 1). For colormaps whose underlying datasets were biased to map more to colors at one end of the color scale, emotional associations were better predicted by a weighted mean that accounted for color frequency in the colormap (data-dependence; Exp. 2). Effects of additivity and data-dependence generalized to dot plots and bar charts (Exp. 3). These results suggest it is viable to predict affective connotation of whole visualizations from their individual design components, which has important implications for automating affective visualization design to support visual communication.

0.16

Representing the Unseen: Rethinking Visual Imagination for Spatial Reasoning

cs.CV cs.AIcs.CL ·2026-10-27 ·Zengqi Zhao, Zun Wang, Shoubin Yu, Mohit Bansal, Yue Zhang
benchmark similarity 0.59
Abstract · Webpage:https://imagirep.github.io/

Visual world models increasingly support spatial reasoning by generating RGB views of unobserved states. However, RGB has become the default interface largely because it is well suited for visual generation, rather than necessarily being the most effective representation for downstream reasoning. Different spatial questions may benefit from different representations of the same imagined state: top-down geometry can facilitate global distance comparisons, while panoramic views provide broader context for reasoning about open space. To isolate the role of representation in spatial imagination, we introduce ImagiRep, a simulator-grounded benchmark of 922 questions spanning seven question types across two settings, Viewpoint Imagination and Cross-view Integration, providing oracle RGB and six alternative representations (e.g., depth, panoramic views, and top-down geometry) of the same unobserved state. This controlled comparison reveals that even accurate imagined RGB does not guarantee accurate spatial reasoning, and different questions benefit from different representations. Similar trends hold for representations derived from world-model-estimated states. Notably, estimated RGB alone can mislead spatial reasoning, while alternative representations retain complementary benefits. Building on these findings, we introduce GEARS, a lightweight test-time strategy for adaptive representation selection, outperforming existing spatial imagination methods and showing that reasoning about unseen states requires more than generating RGB views.

0.23

How Do Artificial Agents Make Decisions in Light of Visual Data?

cs.AI cs.HC ·2026-11-03 ·Keyty Loza, Shayan Monadjemi
similarity 0.58
Abstract · Presented at the Workshop on GenAI, Agents, and the Future of VIS, held in conjunction with IEEE VIS, 2026

Vision-language models (VLMs) have demonstrated significant advances in reasoning with visual data, which is particularly important given that much of human knowledge is encoded visually in scientific articles and other sources. However, a gap remains in understanding how artificial agents, powered by VLMs, perceive and navigate decision-making under uncertainty in the presence of visual data. This study explores this gap by evaluating and analyzing autonomous decision-making processes. Building upon prior work in visualization literacy and decision theory, we conducted two complementary studies: one examining how agents perceive and quantify uncertainty encoded in visualizations, and another investigating how artificial agents make decisions based on visual data in the form of images. We analyzed perception accuracy and decision performance across models and visualization types. Our results show that GPT-4o demonstrates the highest accuracy in perceiving uncertainty in pie and bar charts among the tested models. For decision-making, autonomous agents showed the best alignment with rational decision theory when uncertainty was represented through circle charts, icon arrays, or text.

0.34

A Stevens's Power Law Check-up of GPT-5.5's Implicit Reading of Visual Encoding

cs.CV ·2026-10-06 ·Kaichun Yang, Jian Chen
similarity 0.58
Abstract · 9 pages, 6 figures, including supplementary material. Accepted by the VISxGenAI workshop at IEEE VIS 2026

We adapt Stevens's power law to measure the implicit ability of AI models to read visualizations, which can reveal the built-in perceptual mechanisms of algorithmic models. In our pilot study, AIs see no legend. In the color conditions, no colormap name is provided either. GPT-5.5 first views a reference visual representation and estimates its magnitude, then estimates the magnitude of each subsequent image of the same representation relative to that reference. Our evaluation of twelve visual variables makes how algorithmic models read visual encodings measurable, comparable with human perception, and more transparent to humans.

0.31

Mind the Spatial Gap: A Benchmark for Geospatial Reasoning and Constrained Spatial Editing

cs.AI ·2026-10-09 ·Zheng Ren, Yanning Wang, Ziheng Huang, Fei Huang, Shiqi Wang +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract · 15 pages, 6 figures, 4 tables. Under Review at ICLR 2027

Understanding and manipulating spatial relations is fundamental to AI systems that reason about physical environments and construct grounded world models. However, existing evaluations of multimodal large language models (MLLMs) for spatial reasoning rely predominantly on static question-answering (QA) over small-scale or synthetic scenes, rarely probing whether models can modify spatial configurations while satisfying explicit geometric constraints. We introduce GeoSpatialBench, a benchmark designed to evaluate an escalating progression of spatial cognition, ranging from spatial relation understanding and geometric reasoning to constrained spatial editing. Grounded in real-world urban data across six geographically diverse cities, GeoSpatialBench evaluates a comprehensive taxonomy of 28 topological, directional, metric, and ordering relations across structured GeoJSON and map image modalities, with ground-truth references and constraints verified via GIS operations. Our empirical evaluation across frontier MLLMs uncovers a stark spatial gap: structured GeoJSON consistently outperforms map images, with multimodal combinations offering no reliable gain over GeoJSON alone, and while models show reasonable competence on qualitative topological and ordering, performance drops on quantitative metric relations. Crucially, editing performance on ordering relations declines relative to QA, and most failed edits violate at least one specified spatial constraint. These results highlight a gap between passively recognizing spatial relations and actively manipulating geometric configurations. GeoSpatialBench provides an open, rigorous diagnostic testbed to benchmark these spatial limitations, laying essential empirical groundwork for physically grounded world models and embodied spatial AI.

0.21