CS Paper Radar

Colour Blinded by the Noise

Harriet Mason, Rachel Rogers, Alison Kleffner, Dianne Cook

cs.HC stat.ME ·submitted 2026-08-18 16:28 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Uncertainty visualisation is important for data transparency, especially for map visualisations where data is often aggregated. Despite the importance of this area, studies evaluating uncertainty visualisation lack consensus and produce conflicting results. This work introduces a new evaluation approach for uncertainty visualisation that attempts to assess uncertainty as noise, rather than signal. We evaluate five methods of visualising uncertainty: standard choropleth maps, value/variance bivariate maps, value-suppressing uncertainty palettes, overlaid sampling, and pixelated sampling maps. Built on principles of implicit testing, we put an 'uncertainty visualisation' spin on the classic Ishihara colourblind test to create a novel test that is able to evaluate uncertainty as noise. We compare signal visibility to conventional hypothesis tests at various levels of group separation. By building our experimental design on top of established graphics theory, we isolate the plot components that facilitate successful signal suppression and establish foundational theory for the perception of uncertainty visualisation.

Comment
To be presented at IEEE VIS 2026 and published in IEEE TVCG in 2027

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Adaptive Uncertainty Visualization With jk-Plots

cs.HC ·2026-10-22 ·Nikolaus Piccolotto, Daniel Pahr, Laura Lotteraner, Fatih Öztank, Markus Bögl
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 5 pages

An important task of uncertainty visualizations is to communicate how the number of available observations influences the precision of estimates, such as a Normal distribution's mean. In this paper, we propose an adaptive approach to visualizing univariate data that produces salient representations while highlighting the uncertainty introduced by the sample size. We introduce jk-plots, inspired by educational material of Bayesian statistics, that combine visualizations of plausible reference models (emulating popular uncertainty visualization idioms) and the observations. We describe a visualization pipeline to create jk-plots, which we implemented in an R package. We demonstrate jk-plots using synthetic datasets of varying size and discuss possible usage scenarios in domain expert interviews.

0.22

How Do Artificial Agents Make Decisions in Light of Visual Data?

cs.AI cs.HC ·2026-11-03 ·Keyty Loza, Shayan Monadjemi
similarity 0.61
Abstract · Presented at the Workshop on GenAI, Agents, and the Future of VIS, held in conjunction with IEEE VIS, 2026

Vision-language models (VLMs) have demonstrated significant advances in reasoning with visual data, which is particularly important given that much of human knowledge is encoded visually in scientific articles and other sources. However, a gap remains in understanding how artificial agents, powered by VLMs, perceive and navigate decision-making under uncertainty in the presence of visual data. This study explores this gap by evaluating and analyzing autonomous decision-making processes. Building upon prior work in visualization literacy and decision theory, we conducted two complementary studies: one examining how agents perceive and quantify uncertainty encoded in visualizations, and another investigating how artificial agents make decisions based on visual data in the form of images. We analyzed perception accuracy and decision performance across models and visualization types. Our results show that GPT-4o demonstrates the highest accuracy in perceiving uncertainty in pie and bar charts among the tested models. For decision-making, autonomous agents showed the best alignment with rational decision theory when uncertainty was represented through circle charts, icon arrays, or text.

0.34

Toward AI-Friendly Cartography: Understanding How Color Design Influences Foundation Model Spatial Reasoning on Sequential Choropleth Maps

cs.AI ·2026-08-16 ·Yonghe Sun, Zhenjia Liu, Hua Liao, Wenjia Xu, Nai Yang +2 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.60
Abstract · 42 pages, 12 figures, 13 tables

Foundation models (FMs) increasingly support multimodal and geospatial reasoning, yet it remains unclear whether cartographic principles designed for human perception are equally effective for machines. Focusing on sequential choropleth maps, we examine how hue palette, color ordering, and lightness contrast influence FM spatial reasoning. We construct a controlled benchmark of 5,760 maps and 28,800 questions spanning Attribute Identify, Spatial Recognition, Compare, Rank, and Pattern Delineate, and evaluate 21 open-source and proprietary multimodal FMs. Results show that hue choice has limited and inconsistent effects, whereas disrupting sequential color ordering substantially reduces performance, especially for comparison and ranking. Reduced lightness contrast also consistently impairs reasoning, while increasing contrast beyond sufficient separability provides only marginal gains. LoRA fine-tuning improves overall accuracy but preserves these relative sensitivities. Additional factorial experiments further indicate that errors arise from color-and-legend decoding, spatial reasoning, and the integration of thematic attributes with spatial structure. These findings show that conventional sequential ordering and sufficient contrast remain important for machine map understanding and provide empirical guidance for AI-friendly cartographic design.

0.26

Evaluating Just Noticeable Differences in Layered Opacity Visualizations

cs.HC ·2026-10-03 ·Caterina Ponti, Shano Liang, Lane Harrison, Alark Joshi
code/data similarity 0.59
Abstract

Opacity is a widely used channel in data visualization, but it remains less well understood compared to channels such as color, length, size, etc. Recent work from Meng et al. investigated the impact of opacity across competing color schemes, finding that certain color schemes were associated with better participant accuracy. We examine these effects further in a controlled two-alternative forced-choice setup to determine whether opacity differences are truly equal across possible opacity comparison ranges. In a within-subjects study with 96 trials, including two competing color schemes (best and worst from Meng et al.) and 48 opacity pairs, we find little differences between color schemes but larger individual differences in accuracy. Further, results show stable performance in middle opacity ranges, with more errors occurring when comparing extreme values. We discuss potential implications for design guidelines and further study and make our study materials, analysis scripts, and data available at https://osf.io/zv9dx/overview?view_only=38d03cea1b3d42788593e3e6b1016cfd.

0.36

Semantic Validity vs. Graphical Arrangement in Visualization Grammars

cs.HC ·2026-11-16 ·Cynthia A. Huang, Matthew Kay
similarity 0.58
Abstract · 5 pages (4 + references). Accepted at the Grand Unified Grammar of Graphics (GUGOG) workshop at IEEE VIS 2026

Systems for modular, declarative and compositional specification for data visualizations, otherwise known as visualization grammars, often claim Wilkinson's Grammar of Graphics as motivation, inspiration or foundation. However, despite the shared intellectual lineage, visualization grammars can vary greatly in design scope and focus. In particular, systems that strongly adhere to domain-specific notions of correctness must trade-off expressivity for validity. This trade-off between semantics and graphical flexibility is currently under-articulated, leading to difficulty integrating various GoG-inspired visualization contributions, especially between InfoVis and Statistical Graphics. We propose three new types of visualization contributions to support such integration: Semantic Validity Theories, Semantic Visualization Systems and Graphical Arrangement Systems. The first two prioritize the adherence of data visualizations to correctness conditions, such as statistical or mathematical transformations and data semantics, whilst the third largely leave validity concerns to the user. We illustrate these new contribution types using examples from two recent grammar of graphics inspired papers, and show how they supported more nuanced notions of expressivity and usability in evaluation and design of visualization systems.

0.19

Distribution-Agnostic Isocontour Confidence Bounds for Robust Uncertainty Visualization of Scalar Field Data

cs.CE ·2026-08-18 ·Timbwaoga A. J. Ouermi, Nina M. Gottschling, Alex Gorczowski, Tushar M. Athawale
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Uncertainty visualization has been shown to be pivotal for conveying the reliability of features extracted from scalar fields. Features represented by individual isocontours and mean isocontours lack an indication of spatial uncertainty, whereas spaghetti isocontour plots can become cluttered and difficult to interpret. Existing methods relying on specific distribution assumptions, such as Gaussian and nonparametric bootstrap, provide compact, clutter-free spatial confidence bounds but may underestimate uncertainty for ensembles with a limited number of samples. We introduce a robust, distribution-agnostic Hoeffding confidence band as a novel complementary (and not competitive) technique to mitigate potentially misleading uncertainty bounds that may arise from distribution-based assumptions. The approach constructs vertex-wise confidence bounds using Hoeffding's inequality and propagates them to generate isocontour confidence bands. Results on synthetic and real ensemble datasets show that the Hoeffding confidence bands are loose but accurately capture underlying true values that may be missed by the Gaussian and bootstrap alternatives, while remaining computationally efficient.

0.14

Predicting affective connotation of visualizations from their constituent colors

cs.HC ·2026-08-10 ·Karen B. Schloss, Halle C. Braun, Kushin Mukherjee, Anna L. Chinni, Seth R. Gorelik
published similarity 0.57
Abstract · To be published in IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics

With increasing evidence that affective connotation (emotional association) is an important aspect of visual communication, there is a need for methods to predict affective connotation of visualizations. Many aspects of visualization design, including colors, textures, and shapes, can contribute to affective connotation, and a key question is how multiple design properties combine to determine the emotion association of a whole visualization. In this study, we focused specifically on color and tested whether it is possible to predict the affective connotation of whole visualizations by aggregating the emotion associations of the individual, constituent colors (additivity hypothesis). We also tested whether accounting for the size of colored regions, as determined by the underlying dataset, improved predictions (data-dependence hypothesis). We found that for colormap data visualizations in which colors were well-distributed across all colors in the color scale, the mean estimated associations of individual colors effectively predicted emotional associations of the maps as a whole (additivity; Exp. 1). For colormaps whose underlying datasets were biased to map more to colors at one end of the color scale, emotional associations were better predicted by a weighted mean that accounted for color frequency in the colormap (data-dependence; Exp. 2). Effects of additivity and data-dependence generalized to dot plots and bar charts (Exp. 3). These results suggest it is viable to predict affective connotation of whole visualizations from their individual design components, which has important implications for automating affective visualization design to support visual communication.

0.16

What Cognitive Accessibility Reveals About Data Visualization

cs.HC ·2026-08-17 ·Keke Wu, Jinjuan Heidi Feng, Jonathan Lazar
publishedposition similarity 0.57
Abstract · Accepted to the 3rd Workshop on Accessible Visualization at IEEE VIS 2026

Data visualization aims to augment human cognition and make data accessible to diverse audiences. As data increasingly shapes participation and decision-making across many domains, there is a growing need to examine whether prevailing assumptions in visualization adequately reflect the diversity of human abilities, experiences, and needs. We argue that cognitive accessibility provides a critical lens for examining these questions and functions as a stress test for visualization theory. Drawing on cognitive accessibility research and our experiences studying accessible visualization, we identify three interconnected assumptions that shape visualization research and practice: assumptions about what forms of cognition visualization supports, how accessibility is defined and measured, and whose needs and abilities are centered in design and evaluation. Making these assumptions explicit reveals opportunities to rethink longstanding approaches and open new directions. Ultimately, we believe that cognitive accessibility can serve as a catalyst for innovation, expanding what visualization supports, whom it serves, and the roles it plays in people's lives.

0.25