CS Paper Radar

Evaluating Just Noticeable Differences in Layered Opacity Visualizations

Caterina Ponti, Shano Liang, Lane Harrison, Alark Joshi

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-10-03 01:02 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

Opacity is a widely used channel in data visualization, but it remains less well understood compared to channels such as color, length, size, etc. Recent work from Meng et al. investigated the impact of opacity across competing color schemes, finding that certain color schemes were associated with better participant accuracy. We examine these effects further in a controlled two-alternative forced-choice setup to determine whether opacity differences are truly equal across possible opacity comparison ranges. In a within-subjects study with 96 trials, including two competing color schemes (best and worst from Meng et al.) and 48 opacity pairs, we find little differences between color schemes but larger individual differences in accuracy. Further, results show stable performance in middle opacity ranges, with more errors occurring when comparing extreme values. We discuss potential implications for design guidelines and further study and make our study materials, analysis scripts, and data available at https://osf.io/zv9dx/overview?view_only=38d03cea1b3d42788593e3e6b1016cfd.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Ten Years Later: Replicating Two Color Discrimination Studies

cs.HC ·2026-08-25 ·Shadmaan Hye, Andrew M. McNutt, Katherine E. Isaacs
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 5 pages, 4 figures. Accepted in the VisXVision workshop at the IEEE VIS conference

Color discrimination is a fundamental aspect of visualization as it influences how people interpret visual encodings. Many visualization guidelines are informed by perceptual studies, yet relatively few have been replicated. Acknowledging that the interaction between human perception, visual tasks, and display technology can change over time, we replicate two crowdsourced color discrimination studies conducted 10 years earlier. Specifically, we replicated a visualization-focused color discrimination task (N=144) and a more general perceptual discrimination task (N=394). In both studies, our results reproduced the original perceptual effects. We further use the replication to investigate whether color-related practice influences color discrimination. Specifically, we extended our replication studies by adding questions about participants' engagement with color practices. We then examined whether diverse color-related practices (e.g., artistic hobbies, knowledge of color theory, and cosmetic makeup use) influenced color discrimination. We found no significant difference between participants who reported engaging in color-related practices and those who did not, suggesting that design guidance regarding color discrimination may generalize across viewers regardless of their regular color practice.

0.28

Colour Blinded by the Noise

cs.HC stat.ME ·2026-08-18 ·Harriet Mason, Rachel Rogers, Alison Kleffner, Dianne Cook
published similarity 0.59
Abstract · To be presented at IEEE VIS 2026 and published in IEEE TVCG in 2027

Uncertainty visualisation is important for data transparency, especially for map visualisations where data is often aggregated. Despite the importance of this area, studies evaluating uncertainty visualisation lack consensus and produce conflicting results. This work introduces a new evaluation approach for uncertainty visualisation that attempts to assess uncertainty as noise, rather than signal. We evaluate five methods of visualising uncertainty: standard choropleth maps, value/variance bivariate maps, value-suppressing uncertainty palettes, overlaid sampling, and pixelated sampling maps. Built on principles of implicit testing, we put an 'uncertainty visualisation' spin on the classic Ishihara colourblind test to create a novel test that is able to evaluate uncertainty as noise. We compare signal visibility to conventional hypothesis tests at various levels of group separation. By building our experimental design on top of established graphics theory, we isolate the plot components that facilitate successful signal suppression and establish foundational theory for the perception of uncertainty visualisation.

0.53

ColorA11Y: Enhancing Creative Design Workflows with Just-in-Time Color Accessibility Recommendations

cs.HC ·2026-08-24 ·Alexa Siu, Rajiv Jain, Abhinav Kannan, Jose Echevarria, Mary Ann +5 more
top venue similarity 0.57
Abstract · To appear in ASSETS '26: The 28th International ACM SIGACCESS Conference on Computers and Accessibility (October 25-28, 2026, Vila Nova de G…

Effective color contrast in visual design is essential for content accessibility. While existing tools can identify contrast issues, they often operate in isolation from design workflows or are used as an afterthought. We present ColorA11Y, a system that supports designers in creating accessible content by providing just-in-time feedback and actionable recommendations throughout the authoring process to meet accessibility color contrast guidelines. Our system analyzes the visual properties of text and background elements and offers recommended changes, including text color adjustments, background modifications, and opacity changes. Through two user studies, we evaluate ColorA11Y's effectiveness. A user preference study (n=40) revealed varying effectiveness of different recommendations based on design context, while a qualitative study with designers (n=8) indicated a more seamless workflow experience in comparison to a baseline using a color contrast checker. This work advances a born-accessible approach to design, where accessibility considerations are seamlessly integrated into the creative process rather than treated as an afterthought.

0.30

Trade-offs in Data Color Palette Design Tools

cs.HC ·2026-08-19 ·Shiyi He, Andrew M McNutt
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 2 pages, IEEE VIS 2026 POSTER

Designing a color palette for data requires designers to balance multiple constraints, including accessibility and aesthetics. Color palette tools support this process through features including direct manipulation, automated palette generation and evaluation, previews, and so on. Despite their prominence, relatively little is known about how these different mechanisms shape design across contexts. We conducted an exploratory think-aloud crowd work study with 40 self-identified designers. Each participant used one of four palette tools selected to span different interaction modalities to complete a series of accessibility- and aesthetics-oriented design tasks. We observed two preliminary patterns. First, tool differences were more pronounced in accessibility-constrained tasks. Second, even when accessibility was not explicitly required, some tools produced more accessibility-friendly palettes and prompted more accessibility-oriented thinking. In this tool genre, then, system design shapes outcomes both via built-in functionality, as well as by directing designers' attention toward particular constraints and design considerations.

0.21

Predicting affective connotation of visualizations from their constituent colors

cs.HC ·2026-08-10 ·Karen B. Schloss, Halle C. Braun, Kushin Mukherjee, Anna L. Chinni, Seth R. Gorelik
published similarity 0.56
Abstract · To be published in IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics

With increasing evidence that affective connotation (emotional association) is an important aspect of visual communication, there is a need for methods to predict affective connotation of visualizations. Many aspects of visualization design, including colors, textures, and shapes, can contribute to affective connotation, and a key question is how multiple design properties combine to determine the emotion association of a whole visualization. In this study, we focused specifically on color and tested whether it is possible to predict the affective connotation of whole visualizations by aggregating the emotion associations of the individual, constituent colors (additivity hypothesis). We also tested whether accounting for the size of colored regions, as determined by the underlying dataset, improved predictions (data-dependence hypothesis). We found that for colormap data visualizations in which colors were well-distributed across all colors in the color scale, the mean estimated associations of individual colors effectively predicted emotional associations of the maps as a whole (additivity; Exp. 1). For colormaps whose underlying datasets were biased to map more to colors at one end of the color scale, emotional associations were better predicted by a weighted mean that accounted for color frequency in the colormap (data-dependence; Exp. 2). Effects of additivity and data-dependence generalized to dot plots and bar charts (Exp. 3). These results suggest it is viable to predict affective connotation of whole visualizations from their individual design components, which has important implications for automating affective visualization design to support visual communication.

0.16

Opacity Is Not Just Opacity

cs.GR cs.HC ·2026-09-14 ·Chunran Zhang, Tianrui Li
code/dataunusual similarity 0.55
Abstract · 10 pages, 8 figures, 1 table. Code: https://github.com/ln-one/opacity-is-not-just-opacity

Web graphics travel with content across pages and themes, where changing backgrounds can require recoloring and maintenance. Opacity already makes a fixed object's appearance depend on its background, yet is usually understood only as how much the object obscures it. In fact, opacity controls the scaling of the object-background color difference; transparency is only one effect of this relationship. Zero places the output at the background and one at the source color, but difference scaling need not stop at either position. We retain the compositing expression and extend the coefficient domain from $[0,1]$ to the real numbers: negative values reverse the difference, whereas values above one expand it in the same direction. We focus on same-direction expansion for reusing Web graphics across backgrounds. Each object carries a fixed source color and coefficient, while the actual background determines the enhancement direction. Background-adaptive contrast enhancement thus becomes part of the object's compositing properties, reducing the design and maintenance of separate color variants. The implementation reuses the original equation without increasing the per-pixel arithmetic operation count within the same pipeline. Enumerating all 8-bit sRGB source colors on 16 predefined light and dark canvases, a fixed $α=1.1$ increases the contrast ratio in 99.8145% of combinations. Without changing source colors, 4.8346% of all combinations newly reach the $3:1$ contrast threshold. Output validation and timing across three browsers demonstrate implementation in the same WebGL pipeline, with no sustained additional runtime observed.

0.46

CatPAL: Task-Aware Learning for Categorical Palette Recommendation

cs.HC ·2026-08-10 ·Chin Tseng, Arran Zeyu Wang, Yunqi Li, Danielle Albers Szafir
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Designing effective categorical palettes requires balancing a range of factors, including perceptual distinctiveness, category count, and task effectiveness. The effectiveness of categorical encodings can vary substantially depending on the target analytical tasks; however, existing recommendation tools largely ignore task context when evaluating palette quality, resulting in inconsistent performance across tasks. We synthesize findings from a series of multi-stage user studies into a unified model of task-based effectiveness for color encodings, shape encodings, and their redundant combination across category counts and seven common scatterplot tasks. Our results show that task and palette choice jointly influence perceptual accuracy: different color and shape palettes exhibit varying levels of robustness across tasks, indicating that palette effectiveness is task-dependent. We estimate task-specific perceptual strengths for 39 colors and 39 shapes using Bradley-Terry models, refined through adaptive sampling to target uncertain and task-sensitive comparisons. We further quantify cross-channel interactions using a redundant gain Delta G metric to model performance across color and shape pairings. We then train a predictive model that scores candidate palettes based on task, category count, and perceptual features. This model drives effective palette recommendations in CatPAL, a task-aware palette recommendation system grounded in empirical data responsive to user constraints. Our findings highlight the importance of selecting categorical palettes aligned with specific analytical tasks and demonstrate how task-aware modeling enables more reliable palette design. CatPAL translates empirical results into a practical tool that supports user-specified colors or shapes and returns ranked palette recommendations adaptable to a range of tasks.

0.04

Toward AI-Friendly Cartography: Understanding How Color Design Influences Foundation Model Spatial Reasoning on Sequential Choropleth Maps

cs.AI ·2026-08-16 ·Yonghe Sun, Zhenjia Liu, Hua Liao, Wenjia Xu, Nai Yang +2 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.51
Abstract · 42 pages, 12 figures, 13 tables

Foundation models (FMs) increasingly support multimodal and geospatial reasoning, yet it remains unclear whether cartographic principles designed for human perception are equally effective for machines. Focusing on sequential choropleth maps, we examine how hue palette, color ordering, and lightness contrast influence FM spatial reasoning. We construct a controlled benchmark of 5,760 maps and 28,800 questions spanning Attribute Identify, Spatial Recognition, Compare, Rank, and Pattern Delineate, and evaluate 21 open-source and proprietary multimodal FMs. Results show that hue choice has limited and inconsistent effects, whereas disrupting sequential color ordering substantially reduces performance, especially for comparison and ranking. Reduced lightness contrast also consistently impairs reasoning, while increasing contrast beyond sufficient separability provides only marginal gains. LoRA fine-tuning improves overall accuracy but preserves these relative sensitivities. Additional factorial experiments further indicate that errors arise from color-and-legend decoding, spatial reasoning, and the integration of thematic attributes with spatial structure. These findings show that conventional sequential ordering and sufficient contrast remain important for machine map understanding and provide empirical guidance for AI-friendly cartographic design.

0.26