CS Paper Radar

Task-Based Evaluation of Raw Radar Data Compression: A Pre-Registered Study of Where Classical Codecs Fail to Preserve Target Detection, and Why

Eric Michael Chrabot

eess.SP ·submitted 2026-08-18 01:51 UTC · v2
code/data

Abstract

Synthetic aperture radar (SAR) systems collect raw I/Q echo data at rates that exceed downlink capacity; fielded systems compress onboard with block-adaptive quantization (BAQ/FDBAQ). Proposed replacements, including learned compression, are evaluated with image-quality metrics (PSNR, SSIM, SQNR); none measures whether the data still supports its operational use. We introduce a task-based evaluation methodology for raw radar compression, with a published pre-registration trail: codecs are scored after SAR focusing against a two-sided criterion -- a CFAR detection-retention floor and a spurious-detection budget at matched threshold -- using frozen task models trained once on uncompressed data. On Sentinel-1 stripmap Level-0 data the evaluation brackets the fielded FDBAQ operating point at the resolution of the BAQ grid (3-bit BAQ sustains utility at 6.12 bits per complex sample; 2-bit does not), with a reported lattice artifact found to change retention by at most 0.004. Under the final plane-mapping rule no classical configuration sustains utility below 4.86 bits per complex sample on this scene. Energy concentration after focusing delivers the predicted retention gain (0.888 vs 0.691 at 2 bits) but converts it into target-adjacent false alarms for wavelet and block-transform codecs alike: a retention-only rule certifies focused-domain JPEG2000 at 4 bits while it produces 2.5 times the tolerable spurious count. On AFRL Gotcha GMTI data (airborne, never compressed onboard) the frontier is bracketed at 7.4-8.0 bits per complex sample and the same trade reappears; on an Umbra spotlight image JPEG2000 passes the retention floor at 2, 1, and 0.5 bits while producing 10-14 times the spurious budget. We report the full pre-registration trail, including the chronology of the criterion's two clauses, one retracted overclaim, and a bounded negative result for a small learned codec.

Comment
16 pages, 9 figures, 5 tables. v2: corrects the retention-only counterfactual (Secs. I, III-A, V-C); states the criterion's commit chronology; adds an Umbra image-domain scene and previously unreported learned-codec runs; scopes the frontier to its mapping rule and grid resolution; reconciles numbers. No new experiments. Code and results log: https://github.com/signalcurrent/radar-codec-eval

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Learned Compression of SAR Phase-History Data: A Rate-Honest Feasibility Study on GOTCHA

cs.LG eess.IVeess.SP ·2026-09-25 ·Alizishaan Khatri
similarity 0.76
Abstract

On-board compression of synthetic aperture radar (SAR) phase history is bandwidth-critical, and block-adaptive quantization (BAQ) remains the operational standard. We test whether a small convolutional autoencoder, with its encoder on the sensor, can compete with BAQ on complex phase-history patches from the AFRL GOTCHA collection. Every method is charged for all transmitted bits, rates are reported in bits per complex sample (b/cs), and detection is scored by one-to-one matching of CA-CFAR detections. The autoencoder (28,656 encoder parameters) loses at every rate. At 16 b/cs it reaches -2.87 dB NMSE, against -35.5 dB for 8-bit BAQ with $\pm 3σ$ clipping and -41.0 dB with a tuned clipping range. It also loses to a $16 \times 16$ block Karhunen-Loève transform (KLT), a local linear coder with a tenth of its encoder cost (-5.39 dB). Running the network in a companded Fourier domain helps, but its detection F1 remains bounded at 33%. The evidence points to this model, its normalization, and its objective, not to a fundamental limit of learned coding. Per patch, the data have modest lag-1 coherence ($|ρ| \approx 0.3$) and patch-specific spectral concentration. Two findings concern evaluation itself. First, 97% of CFAR crossings on raw $64 \times 64$ patches are border artifacts of the zero-padded detector. Second, on interior cells BAQ's clipping range decides detection: 8-bit BAQ keeps 69% F1 with tuned clipping but 17% at $\pm 3σ$, and at 8 b/cs or less adaptive FFT thresholding preserves more detections than BAQ. We close with an evaluation protocol for learned radar compression.

0.08

Hardware-Aware Deployment of Joint SAR Compression and Despeckling on FPGA

eess.IV cs.LG ·2026-08-11 ·Cédric Léonard, Francescopaolo Sica, Martin Schulz
code/data similarity 0.70
Abstract · Submitted to IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing (TGRS). 11 pages, 8 figures, 4 tables

Next-generation Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) missions will generate data far faster than they can downlink, making onboard data reduction essential for near-real-time Earth observation. Learned Image Compression (LIC) offers better rate-distortion performance than handcrafted codecs used operationally today, and recent work shows that simultaneously despeckling and compressing SAR imagery enables better representation capacity while unlocking higher compression rates. These methods, however, have yet to be confronted with the strict power, compute, and operational constraints of spaceborne systems. In this work, we bridge this gap by deploying a joint SAR Despeckling and Data Compression (DDC) framework on an embedded ZCU102 FPGA-based platform, introducing model adaptations that respect the accelerator's fixed-point arithmetic and limited set of supported operations. We evaluate four model topologies across precision levels and across CPU, GPU, and FPGA platforms, revealing several findings with direct design implications. We find that replacing conventional GDN activation functions with plain ReLU improves quality on SAR, suggesting that design principles established for compression of natural images do not necessarily transfer to SAR imagery. In addition, we demonstrate that residual blocks offer little representational benefit for ten times the compute, and show that the FPGA is the most energy-efficient of the platforms tested. Together, these results set a functioning edge deployment workflow and an evidence-based starting point for onboard SAR compression. The code is available at https://github.com/CedricLeon/SAR_DDC_FPGA.

0.32

Enabling Emergency Communication via Semantic Radar-Centric ISAC

cs.NI ·2026-09-06 ·Mohaimin Al Barat, Chaoyu Zhang, Hexuan Yu, Kai Zeng, Y. Thomas Hou +1 more
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · 6 pages, 1 figure, 5 tables. Accepted by IEEE MILCOM 2026

Combat aircraft and other modern military platforms field two co-located RF assets: a radar for sensing and a dedicated radio for communication. In contested battlefield environments, however, the dedicated communication path is highly likely to be targeted and disrupted by jamming, blockage, or physical damage, while the radar remains fully operational. A natural fallback is to repurpose the surviving radar aperture as an emergency communication channel. The difficulty is that radar is purposely engineered for sensing rather than communication, so loading any information onto its waveform perturbs the beampattern and inevitably erodes sensing performance: the more bits we push, the more sensing we lose. We identify the core problem as enabling emergency communication via a radar-centric integrated sensing and communication (ISAC) link while preserving the radar's primary sensing function. Therefore, we propose a semantic radar-centric ISAC framework that pairs a learned vector-quantized semantic encoder, which compresses task-relevant content into a few tens to a few hundred bits, with a wideband phased-MIMO radar restricted to a conservative spatial-spectral configuration subset that respects a bounded sensing-degradation budget. Experiments on SAR target classification and text classification show that our framework supports reliable emergency communication for downstream tasks while keeping the radar beampattern almost unchanged.

0.38

Diffusion Meets Unrolling: Compressive SAR Image Reconstruction with Interleaved Learned Corrections

eess.IV ·2026-10-05 ·Odysseas Pappas, Andrew C. M. Austin, Perla Mayo, Mohammad Golbabaee, Alin Achim
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Compressive Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) imaging, typically formulated as an inverse problem and solved with traditional iterative optimisation methods, can be very computationally expensive. We investigate the use of denoising diffusion probabilistic models (DDPMs) for compressive SAR image reconstruction, where the diffusion model is guided by a poor initial reconstruction from sub-sampled data obtained via standard imaging methods. We augment this data-driven method with model-driven interleaved refinement processes, inspired by traditional compressed sensing (CS) methods, to enhance sparsity and heavy tails in SAR images. Experimental results on real ERS-1 SAR datasets demonstrate consistent improvements over baseline DDPM and state-of-the-art methods, with notable gains in reconstruction fidelity and structural similarity, while incurring only modest computational overhead. The proposed hybrid framework effectively combines the representational power and efficiency of diffusion models with the interpretability and robustness of model-based optimisation, enabling accurate compressive SAR imaging.

0.30

SAR-TopoGuard: Training-Free, Speckle-Aware Topological Verification for Structure-Preserving SAR-to-Optical Translation

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-11-14 ·Satabarto Sarkar, Debojyoti Ghosh, Subhranil Biswas, Kaustav Mandal, D. Sobya
publishedcode/data similarity 0.59
Abstract · 10 pages, 4 figures, 7 tables. Accepted manuscript of the article published in IEEE Geoscience and Remote Sensing Letters (2026). \c{opyrigh…

SAR-to-optical translators often synthesize detail that the radar measurement does not support, and pixel metrics alone cannot reveal it. We propose SAR-TopoGuard, a training-free inference-time layer for frozen generators: a stochastic sampler draws K candidates (Monte Carlo dropout for GANs, seed variance for diffusion), a speckle-aware verifier ranks them by gradient-magnitude correlation with the SAR input and a hallucination-frequency index, and a SAR-guided frequency gate admits high-frequency detail only where SAR edges support it. With all five hyperparameters frozen and three training seeds, we evaluate on 500 scene-disjoint SEN1-2 test patches, 500 patches of a held-out summer scene, and 200 cross-dataset SEN12MS winter pairs. The layer improves Pix2Pix by +0.060, +0.012, and +0.077 dB PSNR and by +0.0034, +0.0057, and +0.0135 SSIM, respectively (Wilcoxon p < 1e-6), and it improves CycleGAN and CUT on all three sets (+0.013 to +0.076 dB). It raises edge precision at the cost of edge recall (edge F1 -1.3% on the test set). On the latent diffusion model COP-GEN, it adds +0.33 dB (base) and +0.16 dB (Beta) on the winter set, the only set with dual-polarization SAR. An ablation shows that the gate produces the gain for MC-dropout GANs, whose candidates are nearly identical, whereas verifier selection contributes up to +0.26 dB for diffusion, whose samples differ. The layer has zero trainable parameters and adds 0.4 ms per patch beyond the K=5 generator passes.

0.42

STAR: Scene- and Task-Aware 4D Radar Preprocessing Towards End-to-End Cognitive Radar

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-09-21 ·Seung-Hyun Song, Dong-Hee Paek, Seung-Hyun Kong
benchmark similarity 0.58
Abstract

Four-dimensional (4D) Radar has emerged as a key sensor for environmental perception, providing range, azimuth, elevation, and Doppler measurements while remaining robust to illumination changes and adverse weather conditions. However, conventional Radar preprocessing methods, such as constant false alarm rate (CFAR) detection, select measurements primarily based on signal-level criteria and may therefore discard information valuable for downstream perception during point cloud generation. In addition, existing 4D Radar perception pipelines typically optimize Radar data processing and downstream perception independently, preventing task objectives from directly guiding the preprocessing stage. To address these limitations, we propose a Scene- and Task-Aware Radar (STAR) Preprocessor together with an end-to-end training framework. The STAR Preprocessor incorporates scene context and downstream task objectives to generate task-relevant Radar points, enabling the Radar representation to be optimized directly for perception. On the K-Radar benchmark, the proposed method achieves 74.3 AP, outperforming the previous state of the art by 5.6 AP points. Furthermore, applying the task-relevant points generated by STAR to various existing 3D detectors improves detection performance in most evaluation settings and yields an overall positive average gain over point clouds produced by conventional preprocessing.

0.28

SyntheIce: A Synthetic Radargram Annotation Benchmark for Englacial Layer Reconstruction

cs.CV ·2026-11-10 ·Muhammad Behroze Hassan, Bayu Adhi Tama, Sanjay Purushotham, Vandana P. Janeja
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract · 10 pages, 10 figures, 3 Tables, accepted in IEEE International Conference on Big Data (BigData) 2026

Englacial layers in radio-echo-sounding radargrams (subsurface ice images) encode the climate and flow history of ice sheets and glaciers. However, large-scale extraction is hindered by time-consuming manual annotation and semi-automated detectors that produce fragmented rather than continuous horizons. We address two challenges: reconstructing complete layers from partial detections across radargram profiles and validating layer continuity across adjacent tile boundaries. We introduce a slope-aware greedy fragment-linking algorithm that reconstructs full-width layers using row-similarity gating and an exponentially weighted moving average (EWMA) slope predictor. Each reconstruction receives a content-based hash ID for stable cross-radargram identification. For quantitative evaluation, we generate SyntheIce, a synthetic dataset of 600 radargrams spanning multiple complexity levels and realistic noise conditions, including 150 wide radargrams divided into four adjacent tiles. All samples include exact ground-truth annotations. We evaluate the dataset using XCheck, a consistency-based validation framework, extending its original two-image setting to four consecutive tiles and enforcing continuity at every boundary. This demonstrates the dataset's utility for developing and evaluating real-world annotation algorithms. Our findings extend beyond ice science: when spatial features are fragmented but retain consistent local geometry, trajectory-based linking is more reliable than appearance-based matching. Evaluation against expert-labeled real radargrams demonstrates high precision, recall, F1-score, and mean IoU, supporting the method's transfer to real-world data.

0.30

Preserving the Manifold: Frozen Expert Alignment for Label-Efficient SAR Scene Understanding

cs.CV ·2026-10-18 ·Eli A. Underwood, I. Taylor McKechnie, Leslie M. Collins
published similarity 0.57
Abstract · 10 pages. A shorter version of this work was presented at the ECCV 2026 Workshop TerraBytes II: Towards Global Datasets and Models for Earth…

Cross-modal alignment of synthetic aperture radar (SAR) imagery to natural language is constrained by two distinct failures. The first is modality mismatch: text encoders pre-trained on optical imagery, such as CLIP, cannot be efficiently fine-tuned on SAR, because active microwave backscatter is physically incompatible with passive optical reflectance and the available SAR caption datasets are orders of magnitude too small to bridge this gap without substantially degrading the learned semantic manifold. The second is physical forgetting: SAR encoders pre-trained on large-scale self-supervised objectives encode radar physics that are progressively erased when the encoder is fine-tuned for text alignment on limited caption data. A single design principle addresses both failures: keep both encoders frozen and learn only a constrained, structure-preserving bridge. Our Frozen Expert framework aligns a frozen CROMA SAR encoder with a frozen CLIP text encoder via a lightweight constrained residual bridge. We formally define physical forgetting via Procrustes disparity and show our bridge preserves SAR geometry significantly better than fine-tuning (disparity: 0.210 vs. 0.351). We validate generality across multiple SAR backbones and text encoders. On zero-shot SAR scene classification, our approach outperforms fine-tuned baselines using up to 8x less training data: DFC2020 (+10.3% R@1, +15.5% mAP), EuroSAT-SAR (+15.7% R@1, +12.2% mAP), BigEarthNet-MM (+14.7% R@1). These results establish frozen manifold alignment as a principled, data-efficient alternative to fine-tuning in high-disparity cross-modal settings.

0.35