CS Paper Radar

The urban right to AI: Pluralistic co-design and governance of public space

Rashid Mushkani

cs.CY ·submitted 2026-08-25 02:43 UTC · v1

Abstract

Cities are beginning to use AI not only to analyze public space, but also to define what counts as evidence about it. This thesis asks what follows when scores, maps, and generated images become part of municipal decision-making. I argue that contemporary urbanism operates through two coupled infrastructures: the material city and an epistemic, algorithmic layer that shapes what cities can perceive, compare, and act upon. Because public space is contested, this algorithmic layer cannot be governed through technical performance alone. The thesis develops a civic Right to AI and a pluralistic approach to alignment in which differences in public values are made visible rather than averaged into a single objective. Methodologically, the thesis moves between normative theory, participatory research, machine learning, and governance design. The empirical work is grounded in Montréal. Street Review combines participatory research with computer vision to examine how residents evaluate streets differently and how those judgments can be mapped at city scale using approximately 45,000 street-view images. LIVS (Local Intersectional Visual Spaces) extends the same problem to generative AI. Developed with 30 community organizations, it contains 37,710 pairwise comparisons across 13,462 images and is used to fine-tune and evaluate a Stable Diffusion XL model with Direct Preference Optimization. The results show that alignment can improve, but disagreement and neutrality persist. I treat these outcomes not as annotation noise, but as evidence that some values remain contested. The thesis concludes by translating these findings into municipal practice through lifecycle governance, procurement rules, oversight, recommissioning, and recourse. The resulting framework shows how cities can govern AI without treating plural values as measurement error or forcing them into a single objective.

Comment
Ph.D. dissertation, Université de Montréal, 231 pages, 59 figures, 28 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From Street View Imagery to Street Quality Indicators: Vision Language Inference for the Suburban 15-minute City

cs.CV cs.LG ·2026-08-20 ·Joan Perez, Giovanni Fusco
code/datahot direction similarity 0.58
Abstract · 16 pages, 4 figures

Streetscape quality has become a central concern in contemporary urban planning, particularly within the framework of the pedestrian-friendly 15-minute city, where walkability and public-space quality are increasingly recognized as key determinants of urban performance. However, assessing streetscape qualities across large suburban and peri-urban territories remains challenging due to the time and resource demands of conventional field surveys. This paper presents a planning-oriented assessment of streetscape qualities in the north-eastern periphery of Nice (France) using the latest release of SAGAI (Streetscape Analysis with Generative AI), an open-source workflow that leverages vision-language models (VLMs) for large-scale streetscape analysis from Google Street View imagery. The new release addresses limitations of the original framework through improved image acquisition, geographically consistent view generation, support for multiple VLM architectures, consensus-based inference, and an integrated analytical environment. The workflow is applied to several thousand street-level observations to evaluate qualities relevant to pedestrian-friendly urban environments: sidewalk presence, pedestrian entrance density, and vegetation. The resulting maps reveal that the desired streetscape qualities characterize only a fraction of today's suburban streetscapes, mainly in compact developments and traditional suburban faubourgs, while they are particularly lacking on residential hills. The analysis demonstrates the potential of contemporary VLMs to support urban diagnostics in extensive suburban territories where fieldwork would be prohibitively time-consuming. Beyond the case study, the paper illustrates how recent advances in vision-language models can contribute to evidence-based planning by enabling scalable, flexible, and interpretable assessments of urban public-space quality.

0.39

Govern, Map, Measure, Absorb: The Legibility Trap in Public Sector Participatory AI Governance

cs.CY cs.HC ·2026-10-02 ·Srijan Pandey, Devansh Saxena
published similarity 0.57
Abstract

Public sector agencies have adopted participatory design as a prominent procedural safeguard proposed against algorithmic harm. Across methods, institutional contexts, and well-intentioned implementations, the participation gap persists. Communities engage, input is documented, and systems are deployed largely unchanged. This paper locates the persistence of that gap in the mechanism institutions use to document participation itself. We develop the concept of the legibility trap, in which institutional mechanisms for documenting participation systematically select for forms of community input that fit institutional categories and filter out the forms that would most constrain state power, including foundational dissent, demands for non-deployment, and what Kelly Oliver calls witnessing to structural conditions of harm. Drawing on James Scott's theory of state simplification, we demonstrate the legibility trap through critical discourse analysis of twenty-two official, community-produced, and public-record documents across three public sector AI deployments: the Allegheny Family Screening Tool, Detroit Project Green Light, and the Community Control Over Police Surveillance (CCOPS) ordinances in Oakland. We identify the structural conditions under which participation partially escapes the trap, and we theorize that repeated non-response constitutes a harm to community subjectivity that AI ethics frameworks have not yet named.

0.21

Seeing the City or Recognizing the Place? What Street-View Imagery Adds Beyond Existing Urban Data in VLM-Based Urban Sensing

cs.CV ·2026-09-02 ·Kaizhen Tan
similarity 0.56
Abstract

Street-view imagery is increasingly analysed with vision-language models (VLMs) to infer urban attributes, but predictive accuracy alone does not show how much a photograph contributes beyond data already available for the same place. Using three VLMs, we compare image-based predictions with existing urban data for seven attributes drawn from five public resources. Each urban unit is evaluated with imagery, with location or text context, and against non-image predictions from nearby observations or public records. We also replace images and add conflicting records to test which source the predictions follow. Nearby observations or public records matched or exceeded image-only predictions for road damage, curb ramps, population, and house price. Images were more informative for building type, building function, and the floor count of low-rise buildings. For floor count, the advantage of images over nearby OpenStreetMap labels increased by 5.7 percentage points per doubling of distance to the nearest labelled building and declined for tall buildings whose rooflines often fell outside the frame. When images and records disagreed, predictions usually moved towards the supplied record. Released OpenFACADES floor annotations, generated with OpenStreetMap floor values as input, showed the same dependence: their agreement with the reference increased with building height, whereas that of image-only reruns decreased. The value of street-view imagery therefore depends on whether an attribute is visible and how well the place is already covered by existing data. Because machine-derived labels are often reused as references, these comparisons also bear on how urban datasets are documented and evaluated.

0.08

Towards Spatio-Temporal Intelligence Systems in Urban Space: A Twin-Agent Perspective

cs.CV ·2026-10-26 ·Zhen Dong, Haiping Wang, Wei Tu, Yuan Liu, Bing Wang +12 more
survey similarity 0.55
Abstract · A review of urban digital twins and urban agent systems

Cities must coordinate domains like infrastructure, mobility, environmental management, emergency response, and public services as conditions evolve. An urban Spatio-Temporal Intelligence (STI) system helps the city monitor citywide states, analyze problems, plan and execute interventions, and adapt through feedback, making urban governance more timely, effective, and transparent. Recent urban twinning and agentic AI techniques provide foundations for such systems. From a twin-agent perspective, this survey takes a system-level view of how these disparate techniques can be coherently integrated into an urban STI system. Specifically, we review how the twin reconstructs and represents a persistent, information-enriched urban environment, and how the agent understands the twin via interfaces, reasons over it, acts reliably, and continuously evolves with the city. Built upon this synthesis, we summarize a two-loop blueprint, where an inner agent loop for grounding, reasoning, and verification, and an outer system loop linking data, twin, agentic action, feedback, and update. We then use this to structure an STI research agenda and show how a shared prototype supports diverse urban domains.

0.20

You Cannot Photograph the Same Street Twice: Reliability Limits in Vision-Language Measurement of Urban Change

cs.CV ·2026-09-01 ·Kaizhen Tan
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Vision-language models (VLMs) are increasingly used to measure urban change from repeated street-level imagery, and the results are often mapped for individual sample points. Such maps assume that a perception score changes only if the street does. We test this assumption with repeated Google Street View captures of unchanged streets in five US cities and with controlled experiments that hold the photograph, scene or camera fixed. Re-photographing an unchanged street shifts its perception score by two-thirds of the average difference between two streets in the same city. Much of this shift arises in the scoring and averages out over question orders; the rest comes from the photographs and is not predicted by image statistics of weather and light. A single image measures a place moderately well, but the change at one location barely separates redeveloped from unchanged streets. All models tested score degraded images as worse-looking streets, and in crowdsourced imagery camera differences cause false reports of physical change unless both images are rendered through a common virtual camera. After aggregation, redeveloped streets are scored as wealthier and better maintained, with more enclosure and less greenery. Streets photographed in the same capture campaign share part of their error, which averaging within a district does not remove. For urban research and planning, VLM perception scores can support comparisons between groups of streets, such as redeveloped and unchanged streets photographed in the same campaigns, but not the identification of individual streets that improved or declined.

0.18

Infrastructure and its Discontents: Contestations of Power in Canada's AI Governance Scaffold

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-10-27 ·Christelle Tessono, Nusrat Jahan Mim, Shion Guha
similarity 0.54
Abstract

This paper develops a critical theoretical framework for understanding national Artificial Intelligence (AI) strategies through the lens of "Governance as Infrastructure." Integrating insights from Infrastructure Studies, Science and Technology Studies (STS), this paper employs Black Feminist Technoscience (BFTS) to reveal how AI governance infrastructures are assembled, maintained, and contested, and whose forms of knowledge, labour, and experience are rendered visible or invisible in these processes. We analyze the Canadian AI governance landscape through in-depth interviews with bureaucrats, civil society advocacy groups, academic researchers, and industry actors. Our inductive thematic analysis reveals how AI governance infrastructure enacts specific configurations of power, particularly through the politics of expertise; how actors navigate profound ambiguities related to AI's opacity, often involving strategic ignorance; and how mechanisms for justice and accountability struggle to address AI-related harms. We contend that a BFTS perspective highlights the limitations of current governance approaches and points toward alternative infrastructural designs prioritizing care, maintenance, participatory democracy, and adaptive temporalities to foster more equitable and accountable technology governance.

0.21

Co-constructing sociotechnical AI governance: participatory system mapping using algorithm registers

cs.CY cs.AIeess.SY ·2026-08-12 ·Íñigo de Troya, Maurus Enbergs, Neelke Doorn, Roel Dobbe
published similarity 0.54
Abstract

Algorithm registers have been championed as a means of providing transparency on the use of algorithms in public services. Yet potential publics differ in their expectations of what should be made transparent and how, as well as in their interest in and ability to parse the information currently published in the registers. Moreover, it remains unclear how these instruments can represent the sociotechnical systems in which these algorithms are embedded, and how system-level transparency can facilitate accountability. In this paper, we ask, what do algorithm registers reveal (and occlude) about the sociotechnical systems governing algorithmic systems, and how can diverse stakeholder perspectives inform a more pluralistic system-theoretic safety analysis? To do this, we probe the municipal algorithm register of a Dutch city through a case study of a decision-support tool for caseworkers' assessment of citizens' welfare benefits eligibility based on legal automation through a business rule engine. Through interviews, surveys, and participatory system mapping workshops (with municipal staff, civil society organisations, and ombudsmen, N=8), we seek to understand to what extent the register allows stakeholders to map the algorithmic system in question. These maps inform a System-Theoretic Process Analysis (STPA) that situates the register within a wider sociotechnical governance structure. Participants' contributions allow us to identify potential safety hazards which would not have been possible to see using the algorithm register alone, including benefits eligibility denial, system performance deterioration, and inability to contest wrongful decisions. By engaging both direct and indirect stakeholders, we reflect on the normative dimensions of algorithm governance efforts and how politics shape the practice of system safety analysis.

0.17

EJAI: Judgment-Preserving Civic AI for Data Center Environmental Justice

cs.HC cs.CLcs.CY ·2026-11-10 ·Evan Pačes-Wiles, Bryen Alvarez, Sara Gulabani, Akshara Kolipaka, Snehalkumar 'Neil' S. Gaikwad
benchmarkhot direction similarity 0.52
Abstract

Communities in the United States and around the world are contesting data centers, the physical infrastructure of AI. These disputes pose environmental justice issues: residents must weigh unevenly distributed burdens using evidence scattered across metrics, corporate claims, policy documents, and public testimony. A formative study with 10 users showed that dashboards and single-agent AI can settle questions before people examine that evidence. Here we present EJAI, a source-grounded system that links an interactive map, retrieved evidence, missing-data statements, and two stakeholder personas that allow people to inspect evidence and form their own policy recommendations. In a small functional benchmark of 21 queries, retrieved evidence supported 98.4% of factual claims and the system acknowledged missing evidence in 32 of 33 cases. Persona alignment carried a grounding cost: the Corporate Executive omitted some evidence that conflicted with its assigned priorities. In a within-subjects study, 15 participants acting as residents prepared for a simulated town hall. Some checked cited AI claims while treating map metrics as official, some made conditional recommendations with safeguards such as water-use disclosure, and some found the personas simplified or biased. Our results suggest that civic AI can support preparation for public reasoning when it makes evidence, gaps, and disagreement open to inspection, and that corpus imbalance and two-sided personas remain open justice concerns.

0.47