CS Paper Radar

Goal Staying Makes Sum-of-Costs Anonymous Multi-Agent Path Finding NP-Hard

Hang Ma

cs.MA cs.CCcs.RO ·submitted 2026-08-21 05:31 UTC · v1

Abstract

Anonymous Multi-Agent Path Finding (AMAPF) admits polynomial-time network-flow algorithms for several objectives, including makespan, total distance, and sum-of-costs (SoC) when agents disappear upon reaching goals. We show that standard goal-staying AMAPF is fundamentally different. We first formulate SoC minimization by augmenting the standard time-expanded flow model with goal-settlement constraints and show that the resulting linear programming relaxation is non-integral. We then prove that minimizing SoC in goal-staying AMAPF is NP-hard via a reduction from 3-SAT. Together with the polynomial-time result for the disappearing variant, this establishes a sharp complexity boundary determined by whether completed agents remain at their goals.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Pivot-and-Station Multi-Agent Path Finding: Solvability, Complexity, and Algorithms

cs.AI ·2026-08-25 ·Andrea Di Nezza, Mihir Patel, Fabio Fagnani, Sara Bernardini
benchmarktheory similarity 0.65
Abstract

Automated high-density storage systems (warehouses, robotic parking, plant logistics, etc.) require fleets of agents to move through scarce task-critical resources and then park without obstructing future operations. We introduce Pivot-and-Station Multi-Agent Path Finding (PS-MAPF), a MAPF variant in which a subset of tasked agents must each visit one of a set of interchangeable pivots (e.g., workstations) before the entire fleet terminates at anonymous stations, one agent per station. We characterize solvability completely: every instance on a 2-edge-connected graph is solvable, and, on arbitrary connected graphs, a structural effective-distance measure relative to the number of unoccupied vertices gives a necessary and sufficient condition. We prove that minimizing station-makespan or station-flowtime is NP-hard already with a single pivot. We present three algorithms, a complete baseline, a SAT-based optimal solver, and Pivot-Prioritized Planning (PPP), the last solving 74-89% of benchmark instances with makespan and flowtime orders of magnitude below the baseline.

0.16

Divide and Collapse: MAPF-Collapse via Exact Decomposition into Independent Sub-Instances

cs.AI cs.RO ·2026-09-30 ·Oren Salzman
similarity 0.65
Abstract

In this work we study the problem of MAPFC, a post-optimization step for Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) plans where we are given a feasible plan produced by a modern MAPF solver and are tasked with removing avoidable moves while preserving feasibility. This NP-hard problem naturally arises when using learning-based state-of-the-art (SOTA) solvers which construct plans that contain redundant moves that can be removed. Recently, Tang et al. presented Judgelight, which uses Integer Linear Programming (ILP) to solve MAPFC. Importantly, the ILP is constructed over all agents jointly, so its cost is governed by the full instance rather than by the small coupled residue that actually requires joint reasoning. Our key insight, motivating this work, is that MAPFC instances naturally decompose into independent sub-problems, most of which involve a single agent and can be solved without any inter-agent reasoning. To this end, we first identify which agents need to coordinate their motion and partition the instance into sub-problems accordingly. For the cases where no coordination is required, we introduce an extremely lightweight solver that is $\approx\!1{,}900\times$ faster than Judgelight. For cases where coordination is required, Judgelight can be used but we introduce an alternative CBS-like solver which is more efficient on easier problems. The resulting framework is exact, uses no commercial ILP solver, and matches Judgelight's quality while running substantially faster on the coordination-light majority of instances; on the coordination-heavy instances we propose a regime-aware hybrid planner that falls back to Judgelight. Over all benchmarks tested, this planner achieves a median $10.5\times$ per-instance speedup over Judgelight.

0.20

Asymmetric Decomposition for Multi-Agent Path Finding with Unassigned Agents

cs.RO cs.MA ·2026-11-18 ·Xi Jin, Chen Qian, Renjun Zhang, Guowei Wu, Xiaobo Li +2 more
benchmarktheorycode/data similarity 0.64
Abstract

Robots without assigned tasks may obstruct active robots, while routing them to designated parking locations can cause unnecessary travel. This article proposes flow-oracle conflict-based search (FOCBS) for Multi-Agent Path Finding with unassigned agents (MAPF-UA). FOCBS searches over assigned-agent paths using conflict-based search (CBS) and routes targetless unassigned agents through a min-cost flow oracle. When the selected assigned-agent paths leave unassigned agents no collision-free paths, flow-conflict branching converts min-cut blockers into assigned-agent constraints, which guide the search without excluding optimal solutions. A batched zero-cost warm start accelerates the oracle, and start-avoiding tie-breaking reduces unassigned-agent movement. For feasible instances on finite graphs, we prove termination and global minimization of assigned-agent sum of service time, measured by last-arrival times. Unassigned-agent movement is minimized conditional on the selected assigned-agent paths, without a global lexicographic optimality guarantee. Benchmark experiments show that FOCBS scales well with the number of unassigned agents, and ablation studies show that, compared with discarding non-completable assigned-agent paths, flow-conflict branching solves substantially more instances while retaining optimality. Simulation and physical-robot experiments demonstrate plan executability, with laboratory tests reducing fleet travel by 40.8% relative to the parking-based coordination baseline. The source code and related resources are available at https://github.com/Chin-hsi/focbs

0.39

Mixed-integer flow formulations for motion planning and decision-making of networked multi-agent systems

cs.MA ·2026-09-21 ·Angelo Caregnato-Neto, Paul-Louis Delacour, Raf Van de Plas, Tamás Keviczky, Janito Vaqueiro Ferreira
similarity 0.63
Abstract

This work investigates the use of flow-based connectivity maintenance constraints in mixed-integer linear programming (MILP) trajectory planning and decision-making models for networked multi-agent systems (MAS). We integrate flow-based encodings for standard and k-hop connectivity into MILP multi-vehicle maneuvering models that are widely used alongside receding horizon planning strategies. Their necessity and sufficiency is demonstrated, guaranteeing full coverage of potential network topologies. The flow formulation for standard connectivity decreases the growth of the required inequality constraints from exponential to polynomial w.r.t. the size of the MAS when compared to the state-of-the-art subtour elimination (SEC) method. The flow-based k-hop connectivity constraints decrease the number of required binary variables and decouple its growth from the number of hops. However, the impact of these formulations in performance is not straightforward due to the introduction of a substantial number of continuous flow optimization variables and, in the case of k-hop connectivity, additional inequality constraints. We investigate this trade-off through a statistical evaluation of costs and optimization times using a conventional branch-and-bound commercial solver and trials performed with randomized environments for increasingly larger MAS. The results show that the flow formulation outperforms SEC in standard connectivity problems, enabling the solutions to be computed for larger MAS considering the imposed optimization time limit. The reduction in number of binary variables enabled by the k-hop flow formulations decreases the theoretical worst-case number of iterations required by the branch-and-bound algorithm to compute the global optimal solution. Our results show that this advantage did not translate into improvements in the average performance when compared to the baseline.

0.20

Routing Multiple Agents Below the Sum of Distances

cs.DS cs.DM ·2026-09-16 ·Matthias Bentert, Eduard Eiben, Fedor V. Fomin, Petr A. Golovach
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract · Full version of the IPEC 2026 paper

We study Transient Multiagent Pathfinding, a variant of the classical Multi-Agent Pathfinding problem in which a set of agents must be routed without collisions from designated start vertices to designated destination vertices in a graph. We analyze the problem within the above-and-below-guarantee paradigm of parameterized complexity. In particular, we consider the natural upper bound \(L\), given by the sum of the shortest-path distances between pairs of agents' terminals (corresponding to sequential routing of the agents). The parameterization is given by the gap \(ζ= L - λ\) between this bound and the target makespan \(λ\), together with the number \(k\) of agents. Our main result establishes fixed-parameter tractability for the combined parameter \(k + ζ\). Matching lower bounds show that parameterization by \(k\) alone is W[1]-hard, and that parameterization by \(ζ\) alone is W[1]-hard when terminals are not required to be distinct. On the positive side, if all terminals are distinct, the problem becomes fixed-parameter tractable when parameterized solely by \(ζ\). Finally, we show that Transient Multiagent Pathfinding is unlikely to admit a polynomial kernel when parameterized by \(k + ζ\). Together, our results provide an almost complete characterization of the parameterized complexity landscape of the problem for the considered parameters.

0.20

Travel Cost Calibration for Multi-Agent Target Assignment and Pathfinding

cs.AI ·2026-11-06 ·Yu Kumagai, Ryohei Banno, Keisuke Okumura
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Target assignment and pathfinding (TAPF) is an appealing extension of classical multi-agent pathfinding (MAPF): each agent has a set of targets, and the planner must both assign a target to each agent and plan collision-free paths for them. A trivial approach is to compute an assignment that minimizes the total single-agent shortest-path distance over agent--target pairs, and then solve the resulting MAPF instance. However, this approach falls short because the shortest-path distance remains a proxy that ignores interference among agents. Assigning targets based on the costs agents actually pay, which depend on how every other agent is assigned and routed, would yield a better final outcome. To this end, we propose an iterative TAPF method that improves target assignments by calibrating travel cost estimates from fast, suboptimal MAPF feedback. Experiments show that our method produces solutions close to optimal on small instances and outperforms existing planners in solution quality on larger ones.

0.15

Even Loose Proximity Constraints Make Makespan-optimal Unlabeled Multi-agent Pathfinding Hard

cs.MA ·2026-11-16 ·Takahiro Suzuki, Keisuke Okumura
similarity 0.61
Abstract

We study $r$-Connected Unlabeled Multi-agent Pathfinding ($r$CUMAPF), a variant of MAPF where interchangeable agents have a proximity range $r\in \mathbb{N}$, and agents must form a single group in a given graph $G$ through limited-range communication at all times. The problem arises in fundamental applications such as self-reconfiguration and platooning, while standard MAPF does not capture proximity constraints. For the problem of finding a makespan-optimal solution, prior work shows NP-hardness for $r=1$ and polynomial-time solvability when $r$ is sufficiently large; the complexity for the intermediate case $2\le r$ is largely unknown. To narrow this gap, we show that finding a solution to $r$CUMAPF with makespan at most $2$ is NP-hard for $2\le r= O(|V|^{1-\varepsilon})$, where $0<\varepsilon\le 1$ is a fixed constant and $|V|$ is the number of vertices. As a consequence, we show that the labeled analogue of $r$CUMAPF is also NP-hard under the same condition.

0.15

Generalized Flows over Time: Complexity, Structure and Algorithm

cs.DS ·2026-11-02 ·Siyuan Chen, Shengminjie Chen, Suixiang Gao, Zheyu Jiang, Dun Ma +1 more
publishedtheory similarity 0.61
Abstract · 43pages,7figures;An earlier version of this paper appeared at COCOON 2026

Generalized flows over time constitute a general network flow model that incorporates both transit times and flow losses or gains. We study their complexity, structure, and approximation. We prove that the generalized maximum flow over time problem remains NP-hard under standard binary encoding, even on lossy two-terminal series-parallel networks. The maximum temporally repeated restriction is APX-hard with general gains and NP-hard on lossy networks. We then consider the minimum source supply needed to satisfy a fixed sink demand within a given horizon, and prove that an optimal solution always exists without intermediate storage. On lossy networks, such a solution can additionally use only simple source--sink paths. These structural properties yield a fully polynomial-time approximation scheme via time condensation, with analogous schemes for generalized maximum flows over time and quickest flows with a source-supply budget.

0.38