CS Paper Radar

Even Loose Proximity Constraints Make Makespan-optimal Unlabeled Multi-agent Pathfinding Hard

Takahiro Suzuki, Keisuke Okumura

cs.MA ·submitted 2026-11-16 15:46 UTC · v2

Abstract

We study $r$-Connected Unlabeled Multi-agent Pathfinding ($r$CUMAPF), a variant of MAPF where interchangeable agents have a proximity range $r\in \mathbb{N}$, and agents must form a single group in a given graph $G$ through limited-range communication at all times. The problem arises in fundamental applications such as self-reconfiguration and platooning, while standard MAPF does not capture proximity constraints. For the problem of finding a makespan-optimal solution, prior work shows NP-hardness for $r=1$ and polynomial-time solvability when $r$ is sufficiently large; the complexity for the intermediate case $2\le r$ is largely unknown. To narrow this gap, we show that finding a solution to $r$CUMAPF with makespan at most $2$ is NP-hard for $2\le r= O(|V|^{1-\varepsilon})$, where $0<\varepsilon\le 1$ is a fixed constant and $|V|$ is the number of vertices. As a consequence, we show that the labeled analogue of $r$CUMAPF is also NP-hard under the same condition.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Routing Multiple Agents Below the Sum of Distances

cs.DS cs.DM ·2026-09-16 ·Matthias Bentert, Eduard Eiben, Fedor V. Fomin, Petr A. Golovach
theory similarity 0.67
Abstract · Full version of the IPEC 2026 paper

We study Transient Multiagent Pathfinding, a variant of the classical Multi-Agent Pathfinding problem in which a set of agents must be routed without collisions from designated start vertices to designated destination vertices in a graph. We analyze the problem within the above-and-below-guarantee paradigm of parameterized complexity. In particular, we consider the natural upper bound \(L\), given by the sum of the shortest-path distances between pairs of agents' terminals (corresponding to sequential routing of the agents). The parameterization is given by the gap \(ζ= L - λ\) between this bound and the target makespan \(λ\), together with the number \(k\) of agents. Our main result establishes fixed-parameter tractability for the combined parameter \(k + ζ\). Matching lower bounds show that parameterization by \(k\) alone is W[1]-hard, and that parameterization by \(ζ\) alone is W[1]-hard when terminals are not required to be distinct. On the positive side, if all terminals are distinct, the problem becomes fixed-parameter tractable when parameterized solely by \(ζ\). Finally, we show that Transient Multiagent Pathfinding is unlikely to admit a polynomial kernel when parameterized by \(k + ζ\). Together, our results provide an almost complete characterization of the parameterized complexity landscape of the problem for the considered parameters.

0.20

Pivot-and-Station Multi-Agent Path Finding: Solvability, Complexity, and Algorithms

cs.AI ·2026-08-25 ·Andrea Di Nezza, Mihir Patel, Fabio Fagnani, Sara Bernardini
benchmarktheory similarity 0.65
Abstract

Automated high-density storage systems (warehouses, robotic parking, plant logistics, etc.) require fleets of agents to move through scarce task-critical resources and then park without obstructing future operations. We introduce Pivot-and-Station Multi-Agent Path Finding (PS-MAPF), a MAPF variant in which a subset of tasked agents must each visit one of a set of interchangeable pivots (e.g., workstations) before the entire fleet terminates at anonymous stations, one agent per station. We characterize solvability completely: every instance on a 2-edge-connected graph is solvable, and, on arbitrary connected graphs, a structural effective-distance measure relative to the number of unoccupied vertices gives a necessary and sufficient condition. We prove that minimizing station-makespan or station-flowtime is NP-hard already with a single pivot. We present three algorithms, a complete baseline, a SAT-based optimal solver, and Pivot-Prioritized Planning (PPP), the last solving 74-89% of benchmark instances with makespan and flowtime orders of magnitude below the baseline.

0.16

A Theoretical Framework for Parallel Lifelong MAPF Using Group Decentralized Planning

cs.MA cs.AIcs.RO ·2026-08-18 ·Alex DeWeese, Jiaoyang Li, Guannan Qu
similarity 0.65
Abstract

In the Lifelong Multi-Agent Path Finding (L-MAPF) problem, agents must repeatedly move from one destination to another while avoiding obstacles and inter-agent collisions. Widely regarded as one of the highest-performing solutions to this problem is the Rolling-Horizon Collision Resolution (RHCR) framework. However, commensurate with its quality solutions, it incurs a computational cost that limits its applicability to even modest agent counts. In this paper, leveraging theoretical methods from the Locally Interdependent Multi-Agent MDP literature, we first theoretically prove the near-optimality of RHCR in a discounted MDP formulation of the L-MAPF problem. Then, we leverage these results to naturally motivate an extended framework called Group Decentralized RHCR (GD-RHCR) which incorporates a group decentralized structure that partitions agents based on a transitive communication scheme and plans for each partition of agents in parallel. We show that both RHCR and GD-RHCR achieve similar exponentially close to optimal guarantees, establishing a theoretical duality between the time based restrictions performed by vanilla RHCR and the additional space based partitioning performed by GD-RHCR. Lastly, we show that across varying maps, GD-RHCR is able to attain high throughput that scales into higher agent counts while maintaining a significantly lower per plan cost.

0.14

The Cost of Classical Multi-Agent Path Finding

cs.MA ·2026-10-07 ·Alvin Combrink, Sabino Francesco Roselli, Martin Fabian
theory similarity 0.64
Abstract · 9 pages, 5 figures

Multi-Agent Path Finding (MAPF) is the problem of planning conflict-free paths for multiple agents in a shared space, each from its start to its goal. Classical MAPF has been the dominant formulation for many years, with its assumptions of discrete time and graph-based conflicts presumably easing the search for solutions. These assumptions limit the physical environments and agents for which a solution is truly collision-free, and also place an upper bound on solution quality that no algorithmic improvements can lift. This work investigates how much solution quality, and in what contexts, the classical MAPF formulation forfeits. Continuous-time MAPF (MAPF$_R$) relaxes these assumptions, making it a natural counter-formulation to compare against across various agent counts and sizes, and graph connectedness, topologies, and resolutions. We find that continuous time and agent shape consideration are worth relatively little on their own; their value comes from enabling an expanded range of move actions, on average improving solution quality by at least $5\%$ on narrow and constrained maps and $17\%$ on maps with open spaces. In some cases, the improvements exceed $20\%$. Doubling the map resolution with classical MAPF recovers less than $3\%$, meaning that little of what is forfeited can be bought back through more compute. This work therefore provides insight on when classical MAPF is a reasonable simplification, and when MAPF$_R$ unlocks significantly higher-quality solutions.

0.08

PSPACE-Completeness of Multi-Agent Path Finding for Large Agents

cs.CC ·2026-08-13 ·Maichi Zhang, Naoyuki Kamiyama, Kanae Yoshiwatari
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Multi-Agent Path Finding for Large Agents (LA-MAPF) is a geometric variant of MAPF in which agents are modeled as disks and conflicts are determined by physical overlap in the underlying Euclidean workspace. The goal of LA-MAPF is to decide whether there exists a sequence of conflict-free transitions from a start configuration to a goal configuration. Agafonov and Yakovlev proved that LA-MAPF is NP-hard. In this paper, we strengthen their result by proving that LA-MAPF is PSPACE-complete via a polynomial-time reduction from Restricted Sliding Tokens.

0.04

Goal Staying Makes Sum-of-Costs Anonymous Multi-Agent Path Finding NP-Hard

cs.MA cs.CCcs.RO ·2026-08-21 ·Hang Ma
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Anonymous Multi-Agent Path Finding (AMAPF) admits polynomial-time network-flow algorithms for several objectives, including makespan, total distance, and sum-of-costs (SoC) when agents disappear upon reaching goals. We show that standard goal-staying AMAPF is fundamentally different. We first formulate SoC minimization by augmenting the standard time-expanded flow model with goal-settlement constraints and show that the resulting linear programming relaxation is non-integral. We then prove that minimizing SoC in goal-staying AMAPF is NP-hard via a reduction from 3-SAT. Together with the polynomial-time result for the disappearing variant, this establishes a sharp complexity boundary determined by whether completed agents remain at their goals.

0.23

Conflict-Free Cuts: Exploring the Boundaries of Tractability

cs.DS math.CO ·2026-11-11 ·Subrahmanyam Kalyanasundaram, Subodh Kumar
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract · 48 pages, 9 figures

A conflict-free cut of a host graph $G$ is an edge cut containing no conflicting pair of edges. The conflicts are specified by a conflict graph $\widehat G$ whose vertex set is $E(G)$. The conflict-free cut problem asks if the given instance $(G, \widehat G)$ has a conflict-free cut. When restricted to planar $G$ and 1-regular $\widehat G$, the problem is polynomial time solvable when $G$ has maximum degree 4, but NP-complete already at maximum degree 5. We study the complexity of conflict-free cut problem under restrictions on the degrees of $G$, the components of $\widehat G$, and the locality of the conflicts. A conflict is local if its two edges share an endpoint in $G$. We prove the following results. * For $Δ(\widehat G)\le1$, a directed-cycle formulation gives a polynomial-time algorithm when $|E(G)|\le2|V(G)|$, hence for maximum degree four. The problem is NP-complete on $5$-regular hosts with exactly $1$-regular conflicts. * For $Δ(\widehat G)\le1$, we give a constructive FPT algorithm in $s_4(G)=\sum_v\max\{0,d_G(v)-4\}$, single-exponential for planar hosts. For arbitrary conflicts, we give an XP algorithm in $η=\max\{0,|E(\widehat G)|-|V(G)|\}$. * On $4$-regular hosts, local exactly $2$-regular conflicts with components $C_3,C_4$ give NP-completeness. For local conflicts at maximum degree four, pair or triangle components separately permit polynomial algorithms, but mixing them gives NP-completeness. We classify cases where $\widehat G$ is a union of cliques. * An $a$-COC is a vertex set whose deletion leaves components of order at most $a$. For local conflicts, the problem is FPT in the minimum $2$-COC size, but NP-complete with a supplied $3$-COC of size six. Without locality, hardness holds with a supplied $2$-COC of size six. Both hardness results use exactly $1$-regular conflicts.

0.20

Asymmetric Decomposition for Multi-Agent Path Finding with Unassigned Agents

cs.RO cs.MA ·2026-11-18 ·Xi Jin, Chen Qian, Renjun Zhang, Guowei Wu, Xiaobo Li +2 more
benchmarktheorycode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract

Robots without assigned tasks may obstruct active robots, while routing them to designated parking locations can cause unnecessary travel. This article proposes flow-oracle conflict-based search (FOCBS) for Multi-Agent Path Finding with unassigned agents (MAPF-UA). FOCBS searches over assigned-agent paths using conflict-based search (CBS) and routes targetless unassigned agents through a min-cost flow oracle. When the selected assigned-agent paths leave unassigned agents no collision-free paths, flow-conflict branching converts min-cut blockers into assigned-agent constraints, which guide the search without excluding optimal solutions. A batched zero-cost warm start accelerates the oracle, and start-avoiding tie-breaking reduces unassigned-agent movement. For feasible instances on finite graphs, we prove termination and global minimization of assigned-agent sum of service time, measured by last-arrival times. Unassigned-agent movement is minimized conditional on the selected assigned-agent paths, without a global lexicographic optimality guarantee. Benchmark experiments show that FOCBS scales well with the number of unassigned agents, and ablation studies show that, compared with discarding non-completable assigned-agent paths, flow-conflict branching solves substantially more instances while retaining optimality. Simulation and physical-robot experiments demonstrate plan executability, with laboratory tests reducing fleet travel by 40.8% relative to the parking-based coordination baseline. The source code and related resources are available at https://github.com/Chin-hsi/focbs

0.50