CS Paper Radar

SoK: Motion Data Privacy in Extended Reality

Azim Ibragimov, Alina Vasina, Uliana Polshcha, Eric D. Ragan

cs.CR cs.HC ·submitted 2026-09-01 04:40 UTC · v1
survey

Abstract

Extended Reality (XR) provides immersive, interactive 3D experiences. To enable these experiences, the devices must track user motion so the system can respond to actions such as grabbing, looking at, or moving an object. However, motion tracking has raised privacy concerns since it records a person's motion patterns. These motion patterns have been studied extensively across various fields (i.e., gait identification and profiling) and have been shown to reveal sensitive information. With the adoption of XR, these patterns became easier to record and obtain than ever. This creates a fundamental privacy tension: motion tracking enables core XR functionality yet requires users to compromise their privacy. Prior systematization-of-knowledge (SoK) studies on XR privacy have examined the field broadly, with motion-related research distributed across several privacy domains rather than treated as a distinct area of study. However, XR motion privacy has gained significant momentum since the prior SoK, with the literature nearly quadrupling in size and thereby warranting a dedicated systematization of this topic. This SoK examines 134 relevant papers on privacy concerns in motion patterns recorded by XR headsets, including how adversaries can obtain users' motion patterns, the inferences they can draw from them, and methods for protecting users. Based on this review, we synthesize a taxonomy of motion modalities, representations, and inference risks; develop an XR motion threat model; systematize the attack and defense approaches in the XR motion literature; identify gaps in the literature; and provide guidelines for future studies evaluating motion privacy mechanisms. Together, our SoK clarifies the state of XR motion privacy and provides recommendations for future evaluations.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Why User Studies and Participant Experience Reporting Matter for VR Motion Privacy?

cs.HC cs.CR ·2026-09-11 ·Azim Ibragimov, Eric D. Ragan
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Public VR game leaderboards contain tracked motion recordings uploaded by hundreds of thousands of users. Once uploaded, these recordings are accessible to anyone and create privacy risks (i.e., identification and profiling). Prior work has proposed mechanisms that modify tracked movement to reduce these risks. Their utility is commonly evaluated through physical deviation, where smaller deviations indicate better utility, while user studies are less common. However, it remains unclear how well physical deviation explains users' acceptance of a mechanism compared to user studies. We examine this through a user study of three VR motion privacy mechanisms at five physical deviation levels. We find that user studies explain substantially more variation in mechanism acceptance than physical deviation, although physical deviation remains significant. We also find that prior VR experience and exposure to VR privacy mechanisms significantly affect acceptance. We recommend combining physical deviation with user studies and reporting participants' prior experience.

0.21

Dorsal Hand Images for Immersive (XR) and Privacy-preserving Age Assurance and Child Safety

cs.CV ·2026-08-21 ·Riccardo Bovo, George Loukas, Josh P. Davis
similarity 0.64
Abstract · v2: Revised data availability statement; dataset will not be shared. No changes to results

Ensuring that Extended Reality (XR) environments are age-appropriate is an important regulatory and safety challenge. However, current age assurance operates only at registration and cannot verify the age of the active user during a session. Face-based approaches, the dominant solution in social media and adult platforms, are impractical in XR, because they require removing the headset and taking a self-captured image, often on a mobile app. This both breaks immersion and introduces the privacy risk of sharing face pictures with third parties, which leaves XR platforms without a viable path to continuous, in-session and privacy-preserving age assurance. We propose the dorsal part of the hand as an alternative to the face, by exploiting the egocentric cameras that XR headsets inherently and naturally use to capture gesture interactions. To evaluate this, we collect an age- and sex-stratified, ethnodiverse dataset of 436 participants spanning the minor--adult boundary, captured under unconstrained lighting and orientation conditions. To characterise what is achievable with off-the-shelf methods at the minor--adult boundary, we evaluate standard neural network architectures for age assurance at the legally critical 18-year threshold. Analysis confirms performance is robust to skin-tone variation. On this dataset, the challenge-31 operating point achieves zero minor admission, making the system a viable first-stage filter for age assurance. These findings position dorsal hand morphometrics as an effective and more privacy-preserving biometric modality for in-session age assurance in XR.

0.28

MultiGait: A Multi-Sensor Multi-Perspective Multi-Session Biometric Inference Benchmark and its Dataset

cs.CR cs.CV ·2026-09-01 ·Julian Todt, Felix Morsbach, Philip Dissert, Thorsten Strufe
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

A lack of suitable datasets has limited the research into the privacy risks of novel smart city sensors, such as thermal cameras, depth cameras, and lidar. Given the number of unsubstantiated privacy claims and their potential widespread deployment into many people's everyday life, understanding the privacy risks of these sensors -- in isolation and in like-for-like comparisons -- is crucial. With MultiGait, we collected the first multi-sensor, multi-perspective, multi-session gait-focused dataset, for the corresponding, and additional more far-reaching investigations. The dataset, validated with multiple state-of-the-art recognition systems, comprises various walking modes and annotated personal attributes for 199 individuals, to ensure the benefit for advanced studies including cross-sensor recognition and anonymization at the edge. MultiGait represents a foundation for rigorous privacy investigations, demonstrated through an extensive identity inference benchmark across eight sensors, four perspectives, and three recording sessions. Our benchmark incidentally reveals that sensors often assumed to be privacy-friendly do still entail considerable identity inference risks, while the poor cross-session generalization of existing methods underscores an important research gap.

0.34

Hidden In Plain Gaze: Gaze Representations as Privacy Controls for Utility and Re-identification Risk in XR

cs.CV cs.ETcs.HCcs.LG ·2026-09-04 ·Cory Ilo, Brendan-David John, Doug A. Bowman
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Intelligent extended reality (XR) systems increasingly use eye and head tracking to infer user intent, task, and attention, but the same signals can also reveal biometric identity. We study whether gaze data representation choice can serve as a lightweight privacy control at feature extraction, before adding perturbation or formal privacy mechanisms. Using the egocentric HoloAssist dataset, we compare three gaze representations under matched model capacity: raw gaze, spatial attention heatmaps, and engineered eye-movement features. We evaluate each representation on action recognition as task utility and closed-set user re-identification as privacy leakage. Representation choice substantially changes the privacy-utility tradeoff. Engineered features retain roughly 85% of raw gaze's action-recognition accuracy while reducing re-identification by about an order of magnitude, to roughly four times the chance rate across 206 identities. This reduction attenuates rather than eliminates identity leakage, and the differences across representations show that abstraction alone does not guarantee privacy. Engineered features expose interpretable and auditable structure, giving designers a transparent privacy lever that complements mechanisms such as differential privacy.

0.16

A-GE: Privacy-Preserving Age Assurance via Fine-Grained Motion

cs.CR ·2026-10-23 ·Mohammed Gharib, Giovanni Cascone, Martin Zizi
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Age assurance faces a fundamental privacy dilemma: meaningful assurance typically requires revealing identity or other sensitive information, whereas privacy-preserving alternatives often provide little assurance. Existing approaches either disclose sensitive information directly or shift the disclosure and trust requirement to an identity provider, while self-declared age provides little meaningful assurance. Thus, a fundamental gap remains between establishing an age property and revealing information beyond what is necessary to establish that property. We present \textit{A-GE} (Age-Grounded Evidence), a privacy-preserving age assurance system that derives age-related evidence from fine-grained motion captured by commodity inertial measurement units (IMUs). A-GE exploits subtle motion dynamics that we hypothesize reflect underlying neuromuscular and physiological processes during ordinary device interaction. It requires neither identity information nor government identification and operates across available sensor sampling rates, including the approximately 60~Hz limit of web-based sensing, with configurable minimum-age thresholds ranging from 14 to 21 years. We evaluate A-GE on more than 600 participants, with separate participant-disjoint cohorts for model development and final evaluation. At a 16-year minimum-age threshold, A-GE achieves up to 93.8\% accuracy with a comparable F1 score across the evaluated configurations. We further demonstrate client-side deployment on Android, iOS, and the web, and examine unintended attribute inference and residual privacy risks, characterizing both the privacy benefits and limitations of deriving age evidence from commodity motion.

0.25

Position: Robot Privacy as Embodied Boundary Work. Connecting Capabilities, Contexts, and Design Responses in Everyday Robotics

cs.RO cs.HC ·2026-08-11 ·Liwen He, Shuning Zhang, Chengwen Zhang, Xin Yi, Chun Yu +2 more
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 8 pages, 1 figure, 3 tables. Accepted for publication in UbiComp Companion '26

Robots are increasingly entering everyday environments where privacy is shaped not only by data practices, but also by spatial, bodily, social, and relational boundaries. Their embodied capabilities allow them to reshape these boundaries through situated action, challenging privacy framings centered on data flows, interface settings, or one-time consent. Prior work has examined robot privacy through sensing, data collection, telepresence, transparency, consent, bystander awareness, and multi-stakeholder governance. Building on this work, we propose embodied boundary privacy as a capability-by-context framing for examining how physically present robots may reshape privacy boundaries in situated interaction. Specifically, this framing organizes privacy risks across seven robot capabilities and five deployment contexts, asking how embodied capabilities enable boundary crossings and how situated contexts shape who is affected, how these crossings are interpreted, and when they become contested. We use this perspective to outline design and research implications for embodied privacy mechanisms, including boundary checkpoints, viewpoint-aware sensing control, remote-presence disclosure, object- and body-level access rules, constraints on socially persuasive privacy influence, and local interruption rights. We encourage HRI research, design, and governance to treat robot movement, orientation, proximity, object access, remote presence, and social expression as privacy-relevant actions whose meaning depends on context.

0.19

Cloak of Invisibility: Real-Time Privacy-Preserving Volumetric Video Streaming

cs.CV ·2026-08-12 ·Hossein Khalili, Philip Do, Alexander Vilesov, Achuta Kadambi, Kittipat Apicharttrisorn +1 more
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Volumetric video streaming turns privacy into a 3D, multi-view problem. Unlike ordinary video, where sensitive content can often be redacted frame by frame, RGB-D volumetric pipelines capture people, rooms, and personal objects from multiple cameras and fuse them into a shared 3D representation. A private object missed in one view, or only partially removed before fusion, can therefore reappear in the reconstructed scene. This creates a privacy challenge for 3D telepresence, education, entertainment, and immersive applications: private content should be removed before raw visual and geometric data leave the camera side, while the public part of the scene should remain useful for real-time reconstruction. Existing volumetric streaming systems mainly optimize reconstruction, data movement, and latency, while privacy-preserving vision methods are designed for single-camera, single-frame images and do not directly address calibrated multi-view RGB-D fusion. We present InViStream, a real-time "privacy-from-source" system designed for this setting. InViStream addresses three challenges in volumetric capture: private objects may appear differently across views, RGB masking alone can leave geometric privacy leakage in depth, and public/private instances of the same class must be separated consistently before cloud-side fusion. To address these challenges, InViStream combines object detection with depth-aware masking, propagates public/private decisions across calibrated views, and fuses only sanitized point clouds. We evaluate InViStream on synthetic and real RGB-D scenes, including offices, conference rooms, living rooms, and settings with multiple public and private people and objects. InViStream achieves synthetic Dice/Recall of 0.799/0.891 and real Dice/Recall of 0.792/0.908, with synthetic SSIM above 0.98 and real-time streaming above 30 FPS.

0.04

Beyond the Headset: A Systematization of Knowledge on Extended Reality Privacy and Security in Healthcare

cs.CR cs.HC ·2026-09-29 ·Nafisa Anjum, M. Rasel Mahmud
publishedsurveybenchmarkhighly cited similarity 0.58
Abstract · Published in 31st ACM Symposium on Virtual Reality Software and Technology

Extended reality (XR) systems are increasingly used in healthcare applications ranging from surgical planning to remote rehabilitation and mental health support. However, the rich streams of sensor, biometric, behavioral, and environmental data that enable these applications also introduce substantial privacy and security risks. Adversaries may exploit insecure communication, sensor side channels, application-layer vulnerabilities, or data-processing pipelines to infer sensitive information or disrupt clinical workflows. Despite growing interest in XR security and privacy, the healthcare-specific literature remains fragmented. In this Systematization of Knowledge (SoK), we review 65 peer-reviewed studies published between 2017 and 2024 across XR, security, privacy, and healthcare venues. We develop a unified threat taxonomy spanning device, user, network, and cloud layers and introduce XR-PRISM, a quantitative Privacy and Risk Impact Scoring Metric for systematically characterizing security and privacy risks. Our analysis identifies several gaps in the literature: more than 70% of proposed countermeasures lack standardized risk evaluation, fewer than 15% of studied attacks require high attack prerequisites, and reproducibility is limited by the scarcity of publicly released artifacts and datasets. Based on these findings, we outline a research roadmap emphasizing shared benchmark datasets, stronger artifact-release practices, improved cloud-layer protections, and more comprehensive detection, mitigation, and recovery mechanisms. This SoK provides a structured and data-driven foundation for understanding existing risks and guiding the development of more secure, privacy-preserving, and usable XR healthcare systems.

0.57