CS Paper Radar

On the Degree of Safety: Beyond Safe or Unsafe with Control Barrier Functions

Ruoyu Lin, Fabio Pasqualetti, Magnus Egerstedt

eess.SY ·submitted 2026-09-03 03:13 UTC · v2

Abstract

A valid control barrier function (CBF) certifies if its represented safe set can be rendered forward invariant, and the sign of its value indicates whether a state is safe or not, but it does not quantify a degree of safety beyond the binary indication. In this paper, we show that among valid CBFs representing the same safe set, interior values and gradients can be changed arbitrarily, so neither quantity determines a degree of safety that is independent of how the set is represented. We also show that whether a candidate CBF-based inequality constraint is feasible does not by itself quantify a degree of safety. In particular, infeasibility can occur either because the safe set is not controlled invariant or because the candidate CBF representation fails. This motivates our distinction between intrinsic and representational infeasibility. Finally, we introduce the invariance authority demand (IAD), a representation-independent degree of safety that quantifies the control authority required for maintaining safety and can be used to guide actuator redesign or safe set repair.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A Recursive CBF Framework for Safety under State Uncertainty

eess.SY ·2026-09-16 ·Rahal Nanayakkara, Aaron D. Ames, Paulo Tabuada
similarity 0.72
Abstract · 8 pages, 4 figures, IEEE CDC 2026

The practical implementation of Control Barrier Functions (CBFs) for safety-critical control is often hindered by uncertainty in the knowledge of the state. While existing robust CBF methods address state uncertainty, they often lack recursive feasibility guarantees or fail when uncertainty levels are high, allowing the system to enter regions where no safe control input exists. To resolve this, we propose a novel framework of enforcing recursive CBFs. Rather than merely ensuring the invariance of the original safe set, this approach enforces the forward invariance of a subset of the safe region where a robustly safe control input is guaranteed to exist. This holistic framework ensures that the system never strays into ambiguous regions, providing continued feasibility and safety guarantees, regardless of the level of state uncertainty.

0.27

Exact Feasibility Certification and Optimal Responsibility Allocation for Multi-Robot CBF Safety Filters

cs.RO cs.MA ·2026-09-14 ·Chandan Kumar Sah, Jishnu Keshavan
hot direction similarity 0.65
Abstract

Multi-robot Control Barrier Function (CBF) safety filters can become infeasible, but a failed quadratic program (QP) does not indicate why the conflict occurred or how to resolve it. To address this, we develop an exact feasibility certificate for multi-agent CBF filters with heterogeneous control-affine dynamics and convex input sets. The certificate quantifies a feasibility reserve by separating the demand imposed by safety constraints from the available actuator supply. This decomposition shows when CBF gain tuning or increased actuation can and cannot resolve infeasibility, and identifies the agents and interactions responsible for the conflict. We further propose an algorithm to optimally allocate shared safety constraints by maximizing the worst local feasibility margin, yielding a linear program for polyhedral input sets. In $320$ paired closed-loop simulations, the proposed allocation reduces infeasible control steps from roughly $50\%$ to $6.2\%$, and reduces safety-violating runs from $118/160$ to $24/160$. In addition, across $52$ infeasibility events, the certificate identifies an interaction whose relaxation restores feasibility in $94\%$ of cases.

0.31

Unified Overview of Safety Certificate Functions: Techniques from Hamilton--Jacobi Reachability and Control Barrier Functions

cs.RO eess.SY ·2026-11-05 ·Hao Wang, Max Cohen, Zeyuan Feng, Donggeon David Oh, Oswin So +7 more
surveybenchmark similarity 0.64
Abstract

Safety is a central concern in modern autonomous systems. Safety certificates---functions whose existence guarantees that a system meets its safety specification---have long been used as a principled tool for rigorously reasoning about safety. Methods for synthesizing such certificates are scattered across research areas, with little guidance on when to use a particular approach. This tutorial provides a holistic treatment of safety certificate synthesis centered on two widely used families: Hamilton--Jacobi (HJ) reachability analysis and control barrier functions (CBFs). For each family of methods, we first introduce its general formulation, along with classical and learning-based tools for certificate synthesis. Next, we introduce two benchmark problems consisting of vehicle systems of differing complexity to assess the certificate quality of different synthesis methods and their effectiveness in safety-critical control. We use these benchmarks to compare various methods and provide practical guidance for selecting an approach.

0.24

Algebraic Characterization of Time-Varying Set Invariance

eess.SY ·2026-11-02 ·S. B. Alaoui, E. J. Wafo Wembe, A. Saoud
publishedtheory similarity 0.63
Abstract · The paper was accepted for publication in the CDC 2026

The verification of temporal forward invariance for dynamical systems subject to time-varying constraints is a foundational problem in the analysis of safety-critical systems. Existing methodologies rely on restrictive geometric assumptions, such as the Linear Independence Constraint Qualification (LICQ), or suffer from exponential computational complexity when applied to time-varying polytopes. This paper establishes a rigorous, unified, and computationally tractable framework for temporal safety verification. First, utilizing tools from nonsmooth analysis, we prove that a Nagumo-type geometric inclusion evaluated strictly on the boundary of the augmented graph is both necessary and sufficient for temporal forward invariance. Second, we provide an algebraic characterization of this condition requiring only the weaker Abadie Constraint Qualification (ACQ), generalizing standard Control Barrier Function (CBF) boundary conditions to non-smooth, multi-constraint domains. Finally, for the practical class of Linear Time-Invariant (LTI) systems with time-varying polytopic constraints, we deploy Farkas' Lemma to eliminate exponential vertex enumeration. By introducing a Lipschitz-bounded time-discretization scheme, we reduce the infinite-dimensional continuous-time verification problem to a finite, highly tractable set of decoupled Linear Programs (LPs).

0.39

Control Barrier--Value Functions under Partial Observability: Safety Guarantees via Conformal Prediction

eess.SY ·2026-08-13 ·Niloofar Jahanshahi, Mo Chen
similarity 0.62
Abstract

This paper studies safety analysis and controller synthesis for partially observable nonlinear control systems. We extend the control barrier--value function (CBVF) framework, which combines Hamilton--Jacobi reachability and control barrier functions, to settings where full state information is not available and control is based on an estimated state. Given an estimator, we apply conformal prediction to the estimation error and obtain an error bound at a user-chosen miscoverage level. We incorporate this bound into the estimator-space safety analysis and define a CBVF-based safety certificate for partially observable systems. We then derive a finite-horizon probabilistic safety guarantee for the true system state. Finally, we propose a QP-based online safety filter for systems affine in the control and disturbance, whose solution enforces the CBVF safety condition in real time against bounded disturbance. The proposed framework is illustrated on a partially observable obstacle-avoidance case study.

0.04

Latent Safety Filters: When a Lossy Encoder Admits a Transferable Certificate

eess.SY cs.LGcs.RO ·2026-10-03 ·Johannes Mootz, Zahra Nili Ahmadabadi, Reza Akhavian
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Latent safety filters certify safety on a learned low-dimensional representation of the state, enabling constraints that resist analytic description. Because the encoder is lossy, a filter can report safe while the physical state is unsafe, with no detectable model error. Existing transfer conditions leave the effect of discarded safety information implicit. We ask when a lossy encoder admits a safety certificate that transfers to the physical system, and show the answer is governed by the detectability of the discarded safety-relevant dynamics. We construct a system whose latent model is exact and whose latent signals always report safe, while the physical state becomes arbitrarily unsafe. For this system no certificate exists and no monitor downstream of the encoder can detect the failure. When the discarded dynamics contract, a latent barrier certifies true safety up to two explicit margins, one for the latent-model error and one for the variation of safety across states the encoder cannot distinguish. In the linear case and under boundedness and non-degeneracy conditions, every calibrated barrier transfers with a finite margin when the safety-relevant subspace is detectable, and none does otherwise. On learned cartpole encoders, the model error does not indicate for which representations the estimated bound is non-vacuous, while the second margin does.

0.33

Finite-Data Safety Informativity Under Dynamic Asymmetric Actuation

eess.SY cs.ROmath.DS ·2026-10-01 ·Abhinav Sinha, Praveen Kumar Ranjan, Yongcan Cao
hot direction similarity 0.61
Abstract

When the system model is not fully known, measurement error and limited excitation can leave several models consistent with the same finite data. A command judged safe for one model may fail for another, while limited control authority can prevent the corrective action needed to preserve safety. To ensure safety under model uncertainty and asymmetric input limits, we develop a finite-data certificate that determines whether a command can enforce a prescribed safety inequality. For a linearly parameterized safety channel with exactly known regressors and bounded aggregate residual error, we derive a support formula for the worst-case safety contribution of all data-consistent models. The formula identifies the regressor directions that admit a finite bound, allowing rank-deficient records to contribute to safety certification. Using certified componentwise bounds on actuator tracking error yields an affine inequality with a necessary and sufficient test for pointwise command feasibility. The affine inequality reduces computation of the closest certified command to a scalar root-finding problem. It also yields a closed-form gate that selects the largest certified fraction of a prescribed command segment. The proposed certificate guarantees output safety within its operating domain, provided the feedback is locally Lipschitz and the uncertainty bounds remain valid. Domain retention and full-state continuation extend this guarantee to all time. A vehicle study demonstrates that output safety can be certified from finite measurements in a safety-critical setting with model and actuator uncertainty.

0.31

Input-to-State Safety and Small-Gain Theorems for Large-Scale Nonlinear Systems

eess.SY ·2026-11-10 ·Jianqiang Wang, Tengfei Liu, Zhong-Ping Jiang
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract · 16 pages, 7 figures

This paper studies the safety verification problem for a general class of large-scale systems characterized by multiple safety indicator functions. Each safety indicator function satisfies a trajectory-based input-to-state safety (ISSf) estimate that provides a lower bound on its value along system trajectories in terms of the initial state, external inputs, and the other safety indicator functions, whose influence is quantified by continuous and nondecreasing gain functions. Within this framework, we establish a safety-oriented small-gain theorem and its corresponding corollaries that enable compositional and scalable safety verification of the interconnected system, provided that the interconnection gain functions satisfy a small-gain condition on the negative real axis. This condition concerns only the neighborhood of the safety boundary, thereby facilitating the application of our results to safety verification of multi-agent systems under distributed control. Our proof combines small-gain techniques with the lower-bound structure of ISSf estimates and develops an inductive comparison argument that establishes the ISSf property for the overall system throughout the maximal interval of existence. As an application, we establish robust safety for the natural distributed "half-spring" controller, theoretically supporting the computationally efficient and inspiring approach to safety-critical control of multi-agent systems in the presence of obstacles and external disturbances.

0.23