CS Paper Radar

The 11/6 supremum of the Wang-Sitters rounding scheme for graph balancing

Adam Y. Shavit

cs.DS math.OC ·submitted 2026-09-03 14:10 UTC · v3
code/data

Abstract

Wang and Sitters' 11/6-approximation for graph balancing (each job allowed on at most two machines) is not one algorithm but a set of permitted executions. Step 1 may return any feasible solution of the fractional relaxation. Step 3 may match remaining jobs to the rounding's slots in many ways. We determine exactly what that latitude permits: ratios arbitrarily close to 11/6, none reaching it, so 11/6 is the least constant bounding every permitted run. We then determine the worst-case guarantee, against the optimum itself, as a function of the big-job threshold beta, the fractional share at or above which Step 2 assigns a job. On Wang and Sitters' own range 1/2 < beta < 1 the guarantee is exactly max{3/2 + beta/2, 5/2 - beta}. We extend the same eligibility rule to 0 < beta <= 1/2, outside the range they state. There a big job's two shares can both reach the threshold, so Step 2 acquires a third choice. We determine it too: exactly 3/2 + (1-beta)floor(1/beta), hence unbounded as beta falls. The worst-case ratio is therefore known at every threshold in (0,1), and attained at none. Consequently 2/3 is the unique optimal threshold, and the guarantee jumps at one half and again at every threshold 1/k below it, rather than degrading smoothly. A companion note examines changes that leave the constant unchanged.

Comment
43 pages, 9 figures. v3: the beta < 1/2 seven-machine witness is certified in exact rational arithmetic; the strict-rule endpoint at beta = 1/2 is argued in full; the computational status cites the companion's NP-hardness of best-matching selection for a supplied fractional solution; smaller corrections. Companion to arXiv:2609.10004. Code and data: https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/SKX86

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Minimum-makespan completion and vertex selection leave the Wang-Sitters constant at 11/6

cs.DS math.OC ·2026-09-09 ·Adam Y. Shavit
code/data similarity 0.75
Abstract · 52 pages, 11 figures. v2: new results: where the cut-term bound 3/2+1/(r+1) is attained on the three-path family (correcting v1), and strong…

Wang and Sitters' rounding scheme for graph balancing (each job allowed on at most two machines) keeps the makespan, the busiest machine's load, within 11/6 of the optimum, and a companion note shows that no smaller constant holds. One suspected cause is Step 3's freedom to match leftover jobs to slots in any valid way. We show that removing that freedom does not improve the constant. An idealized oracle that always picks the valid matching with the smallest makespan still has worst-case constant exactly 11/6 against the optimum. Both natural 7/4 bounds for it, against the relaxation's target and against the optimum, are false. Requiring Step 1 to return a vertex (corner) of the relaxation does not help when that vertex is chosen adversarially. The loss therefore does not come from Step 3's freedom alone. We also prove a reduction confining every overload above 7/4 to two shapes, give a seven-machine instance on which the natural two-phase repair fails, and prove a strict 7/4 bound on the generalized three-path family.

0.38

A minimum witness for the 3/2 configuration-linear-program gap in two-weight graph balancing, unique at its size

cs.DS math.OC ·2026-08-13 ·Adam Y. Shavit
theorycode/data similarity 0.73
Abstract · 37 pages, 12 figures, 1 table. v3: corrects the infeasibility-verdict count behind the six-machine sweep (4,228,054, not 4,231,347), a false…

Restricted assignment minimizes makespan, the busiest machine's load, when each job has one size and a set of allowed machines. Its tightest studied relaxation is the configuration linear program, which fractionally gives each machine whole job sets that fit. Its integrality gap, the worst-case ratio of integral optimum to relaxation value, is open in general. On two-weight graph balancing (sizes 1 and 2, each job allowed on at most two machines) the gap is known: Jansen, Land, and Maack (2016) give both bounds. Their Table 1 instance attains 3/2, and their Corollary 11 bound of 2-s/b for sizes s < b matches it at {1,2}. We ask how small such an instance, a witness, can be. We give a six-job witness I* on the complete graph on four machines: unit jobs form a cycle through all four, and two weight-2 jobs take the remaining edges. I* has integral optimum 3 against relaxation value 2, one job fewer than the smallest earlier witness of this class. We prove I* minimum and unique at its size, on any number of machines: no instance with at most five jobs reaches gap 3/2, and at six jobs I* is the only witness, up to relabeling machines and adding unusable machines. At seven jobs uniqueness fails: we classify all thirteen witnesses, including the Jansen-Land-Maack instance. Eight jobs give 154, nine 1,662. At least four machines are necessary. Kartak et al. (2015) classified the extremal non-round-up instances of the same relaxation in one-dimensional cutting stock for small demand; the Discussion relates them. Recognizing witnesses at relaxation value 2, shared by all ours, is coNP-complete, so no min-max characterization with polynomially checkable conditions exists unless NP = coNP. Every feasibility decision behind the exhaustive claims was made twice, in floating-point and exact rational arithmetic, with identical results. We accept the pipeline's negatives only after it rediscovers I*.

0.64

Dynamic Load Balancing under Restricting Updates

cs.DS ·2026-10-16 ·Aaron Bernstein, Sayan Bhattacharya, Peter Kiss, Thatchaphol Saranurak
similarity 0.63
Abstract

We study the problem of load balancing in the dynamic setting. The input is a bipartite graph $G = (J \cup M, E)$ of jobs $J$ and machines $M$. Every job has a positive weight $w(j)$. The goal is to assign every job in $J$ to an adjacent machine in $M$ so as to minimize the maximum machine load, where the load of a machine is the sum of the weights of the jobs assigned to it. Although load balancing has been studied extensively in many models of computation, the only previous result in the dynamic model addresses the \emph{incremental} setting, where updates take the form of edge insertions and job deletions [BKS23b]. The authors show a $(1+ε)$-approximation for incremental \emph{fractional} load balancing with $\text{poly}(\log(n),1/ε)$ update time; they point out that their techniques do not extend to the decremental setting. Main Result: We obtain an algorithm which maintains a $(1+ε)$-approximate solution to the fractional load balancing problem under edge deletions and job insertions in $\tilde{O}(\log (n), 1/ε)$ update time. Our techniques are very different from those of the incremental algorithm of [BKS23b]. Instead, our algorithm is inspired by a load-balancing algorithm from the {\sc congest} model of computation [ALPZ21]. We develop a novel analytic framework for this algorithm, which allows us to show that it performs well in the dynamic setting. Rounding Scheme: We also present a black-box rounding scheme for dynamic load balancing. Plugging in our fractional algorithm, we obtain a decremental algorithm for $(2+ε)$-approximate \emph{integral} load balancing with $\text{poly}(\log(n),1/ε)$ update time. We also obtain the same bounds for incremental load balancing by plugging in the fractional algorithm of [BKS23b].

0.22

Consistency-Robustness Tradeoffs for Online Bipartite Allocation with Multiple Stages

cs.DS ·2026-09-14 ·Alexander Lindermayr, Nicole Megow, Lauren Paul
similarity 0.63
Abstract

We study learning-augmented online bipartite allocation with multiple stages. In the $k$-stage vertex-weighted fractional bipartite matching problem, demand vertices arrive in $k$ stages, and the algorithm receives possibly inaccurate predictions of the allocation in each stage. While tight consistency-robustness tradeoffs were known for the two-stage case, no nontrivial tradeoff was known for an arbitrary number of stages. Our main result is the first consistency-robustness tradeoff for $k$-stage vertex-weighted fractional bipartite matching with predictions, for every $k\ge2$. Let $R_k=1-(1-1/k)^k$. For every $R\in[0,R_k]$, our algorithm is $R$-robust and $C_k(R)$-consistent, where $C_k(R)=k(1-R)^{1/k}+R-(k-1)$. This simultaneously recovers the known tight two-stage tradeoff and the optimal prediction-free $k$-stage competitive guarantee $R_k = C_k(R_k)$, while strictly dominating the natural randomized coin-flip baseline between these endpoints. We also present an algorithm for the classical online setting, where demands arrive one by one and the number of demands is unknown in advance. It has a consistency ratio of at least $C_\infty(R)=1+R+\ln(1-R)$ for a given robustness $R\in[0,1-1/e]$, improving the best previously known tradeoff for this problem. Finally, we extend the framework to fractional AdWords and fractional predictions. Our algorithms are based on stage-wise convex programs with carefully calibrated vertex-dependent penalties. The penalties maintain a dynamic safety reserve for each supply vertex, balancing protection against adversarial future arrivals with the ability to exploit the predicted allocation.

0.21

Tight bounds for fractional and randomized truthful scheduling

cs.GT ·2026-11-04 ·Georgios Anastasiadis, George Christodoulou, Elias Koutsoupias, Annamaria Kovacs, Conrad Schecker
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract

We resolve one of the longest-standing open problems in algorithmic mechanism design by showing that randomization cannot yield a sublinear approximation for truthful scheduling on unrelated machines, even when truthfulness is required only in expectation. Our main technical result concerns fractional scheduling, where tasks may be split among machines. We prove that every deterministic truthful fractional mechanism on $n$ unrelated machines has worst-case approximation ratio at least $(n+1)/2$, even against the optimal integral makespan. This matches the known upper bound exactly and settles the optimal approximation ratio of truthful fractional scheduling. Since the expected allocations and payments of a truthful-in-expectation mechanism define a truthful fractional mechanism, the same lower bound applies to all truthful-in-expectation mechanisms and, in particular, to all universally truthful mechanisms. On the positive side, we give a universally truthful mechanism with approximation ratio $n/2+o(n)$. Together, these results establish the optimal leading constant $1/2$ for randomized truthful scheduling. Thus, randomization improves on the optimal deterministic approximation ratio by an asymptotic factor of two, and no more.

0.18

A New Lower Bound for Online Vertex Cover under Vertex Arrivals

cs.DS cs.GTmath.OC ·2026-08-10 ·Tianhang Lu
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract

We prove that no randomized integral or fractional algorithm for online vertex cover under general vertex arrivals achieves a competitive ratio strictly below $1+\sqrt{e}/2\approx1.824360635$, even on bipartite graphs and against an oblivious adversary. This improves the previous lower bound of approximately $1.753$. Our proof extends the complete-bipartite alternating construction of Wang and Wong to an arbitrary number of alternations. The resulting adversary is described by a monotone integral recurrence. If the recurrence never violates the competitive budget, its iterates converge to an integrable fixed point; classifying all such fixed points forces the excess ratio to be at least $\sqrt{e}/2$. A truncated discrete recurrence and a Riemann-sum argument convert every strict continuous violation into a finite, algorithm-dependent but realization-oblivious input. We also exhibit a critical fixed point showing that $1+\sqrt{e}/2$ is the exact limit of this homogeneous complete-bipartite recurrence, rather than a numerical artifact.

0.04

Online Correlated Exponential Clocks

cs.DS ·2026-11-08 ·Zhiyi Huang, Kalen Patton, Peilin Yang, Jiahao Zhao
similarity 0.60
Abstract

In online resource allocation, we seek to allocate an incoming sequence of requests $j \in J$ among a set of offline resources $i \in I$, where decisions must be made immediately without knowledge of the future. State-of-the-art results typically follow from relax-and-round methods. For many problems, recent advances have come from improved methods of online rounding with negative correlations. However, such rounding schemes have largely been implemented on a case-by-case basis, making it difficult to transfer improvements and new ideas between problem settings. This leads us to ask the question: Can we develop unified methods of online rounding with negative correlations which can obtain state-of-the-art guarantees across different resource allocation settings? We answer this question affirmatively by introducing the framework of Online Correlated Exponential Clocks (OCEC). In this framework, fractional allocations $x_{ij}$ are assigned exponential clocks $Y_{ij} \sim \mathrm{Exp}(x_{ij})$, and each request $j$ is allocated to the resource $i$ with smallest $Y_{ij}$. The key idea is that the sequence $(Y_{ij})_j$ for each fixed $i$ is negatively correlated via an OCEC generator, resulting in better-than-baseline guarantees. Our contributions are two-fold: First, we introduce OCEC rounding as a problem-independent interface which any online algorithm can use. This isolates the challenge of online rounding into the self-contained problem of designing an effective OCEC generator. Second, we demonstrate the flexibility of this method by giving a single OCEC generator which yields improved competitive bounds in three distinct problems: 0.556 for Display Ads, 0.530 for AdWords, and 4.69 for squared-load balancing. Previous best results were obtained by Blanc and Charikar (FOCS 2021), Chen, Huang, and Sun (FOCS 2024), and Borst and Kashaev (SODA 2027), respectively.

0.30

Metric Facility Location under Batched Random Order

cs.DS ·2026-11-03 ·Fabrizio Grandoni, Stefano Leonardi, Matteo Russo
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract

We study online metric facility location in the batched random-order model. An adversary partitions $n$ clients into $B$ nonempty batches, which arrive in uniformly random order. Each batch is revealed in full, and its clients must be connected to open facilities before the next batch arrives. Openings and assignments are irrevocable, and the objective is to minimize the total opening and connection cost. For both uniform and nonuniform opening costs, we prove that the tight competitive ratio is \[ Θ\!\left(\min\left\{\log(B+1), \sqrt{\log(n-B+2)}\right\}\right). \] Thus, the ratio is constant both when there is a single batch and when every batch is a singleton, but intermediate numbers of batches can require a $Θ(\sqrt{\log n})$ ratio. Our algorithms build on Meyerson's algorithm (2001) and do not need to know $n$ nor $B$. A key algorithmic novelty is that we process the clients in a batch one by one in uniform random order (hence neglecting the global properties of the batch). We present a novel analysis of this algorithm that hinges on the random order of the batches, as well as of the clients within each batch. We also provide a matching competitive ratio lower bound already for uniform costs, and even when the entire metric is known in advance.

0.21