CS Paper Radar

A Station-Based Evaluation of Machine Learning-based Weather Forecasting Models in Northern Norway

Siyan Chen, Lars Uebbing, Eirik Mikal Samuelsen, Georgios Leontidis, Arnt-Børre Salberg, Sébastien Lefèvre, Robert Jenssen, Kristoffer Wickstrøm

cs.LG physics.ao-ph ·submitted 2026-08-25 13:32 UTC · v1

Abstract

Recent machine learning weather prediction (MLWP) models have demonstrated remarkable forecasting skill on global reanalysis-based benchmarks. However, their performance remains unclear in challenging environments such as Northern Norway, where narrow fjords and rapidly changing weather result in highly variable local wind conditions. In this case study, we evaluate FourCastNet3 (FCN3), GraphCast, and ECMWF High Resolution Forecast (HRES) for wind speed forecasting using multi-year station observations from Northern Norway, focusing on their relative performance, generalization beyond the training period, and performance under high-wind conditions. Our results show that HRES slightly outperforms FCN3 and GraphCast, with an overall RMSE of 2.89 $\mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$, compared to 2.96 $\mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ for FCN3 and 2.94 $\mathrm{m\,s^{-1}}$ for GraphCast. Notably, the MLWP models maintain comparable performance beyond their respective training periods, with no clear evidence of noticeable degradation. FCN3 performs best under high-wind conditions, although all models substantially underestimate strong winds. Our findings suggest that MLWP has become competitive with NWP for local wind, but further refinements are still needed to capture complex terrain better.

Comment
19 pages, 10 figures, 8 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Statistical versus machine learning-based spatial interpolation of post-processed ensemble weather forecasts

cs.LG stat.APstat.ML ·2026-09-07 ·Mária Lakatos
similarity 0.69
Abstract · 25 pages, 3 figures, 15 tables

Statistical post-processing improves ensemble weather forecasts, but generating calibrated predictions at locations without observations remains challenging. This study compares statistical and machine-learning-based methods for post-processing ECMWF 2-m temperature and 10-m wind speed forecasts at observed and unobserved stations in Germany. We consider EMOS-based approaches, distributional regression networks, Transformers, and graph neural networks under both limited and extended predictor settings. For temperature, we also investigate linear forecast combinations and propose an altitude-aware linear pool (ALP). The results show that post-processing improves upon the raw ensemble in most settings, but no single method performs best across all variables, station groups, and evaluation metrics. The proposed ALP provides a small but significant improvement over the standard linear pool at unobserved locations.

0.14

GraphCast-Mamba: Learning Non-Markovian Corrections for Weather Forecasting

cs.LG ·2026-10-20 ·Ilya Vilkoviskiy, Liang-Hong Mo, Suozhi Huang, Dmitry A. Abanin
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 27 pages, 10 figures

Unresolved atmospheric processes can introduce history dependence beyond the short input windows used by many weather forecasting models. We introduce GraphCast--Mamba, which augments a frozen, pretrained $1^\circ$ GraphCast backbone with a trainable Mamba correction branch combining graph message passing and Mamba layers. The branch retains a temporal memory state across successive six-hour forecast steps, learning corrections informed by temporal context beyond GraphCast's two-frame input. Training is confined to the correction branch, using ERA5 data from 2015--2021. After 2,500 optimizer updates, including warm-up, the selected model achieves substantial improvements relative to the uncorrected GraphCast backbone. It reduces the GraphCast loss (normalized weighted mean-squared error; MSE) by 14.42% when aggregated over the full ten-day forecast and by 21.66% at day 10 (240 h after forecast initialization). At this final forecast lead time, root-mean-square error (RMSE) decreases by 7.09--14.60% across all 11 evaluated variable groups, spanning temperature, wind, pressure, geopotential, specific humidity, and precipitation. These results demonstrate broad improvements in ten-day weather forecasts through a short correction-training schedule while retaining the pretrained backbone.

0.16

TaiJi: State-Conditional Adaptive Combination of Machine-Learning and Physics-Based Global Weather Forecasts

cs.CE ·2026-09-25 ·Jiale Wang, Yining Li, Guihua Wang
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 45 pages, 11 figures, 2 tables. Revised: global precipitation verification; new TaiJi-TC section on tropical-cyclone track and landfall fore…

Machine-learning weather models now rival or surpass operational numerical weather prediction (NWP), yet no single model dominates across variables, pressure levels, lead times, or regions, and the returns from ever-larger individual models are diminishing. We present TaiJi (after the yin-yang concept of complementary opposites), a spatiotemporal adaptive ensemble framework that recasts optimal model-weight combination as a learned prediction problem: a lightweight convolutional neural network, conditioned on the recent atmospheric state, predicts at every grid point and lead time affine combination weights and an additive residual for the constituent forecasts. The combiner is trained end-to-end over Pangu-Weather, GraphCast, FuXi, IFS-HRES, and the IFS-ENS ensemble mean, a hybrid set of ML and NWP constituents, at less than a tenth of the cost of training any of its ML constituents. Under the WeatherBench 2 protocol (2020 test year), TaiJi outperforms the strongest baseline in nearly every combination of the eight core variables, lead times up to 10 days and two skill metrics (RMSE and ACC), and this advantage extends to heavy-precipitation extremes. The same state-conditional principle transfers to tropical-cyclone track forecasting: by fusing constituent tracks rather than gridded fields, TaiJi-TC reduces track error relative to the equally weighted multi-model consensus at lead times up to 96 h, by about 10% at 36 h, halves the slow along-track bias shared by all constituents up to 60 h, and lowers landfall position error by 13-15% at 60-84 h. The learned weights vary coherently with latitude, season and lead time rather than following a fixed rule. TaiJi thus offers an inexpensive route to better global forecasts that builds on, rather than replaces, existing forecast models.

0.23

Aries: A Proprietary Medium-Range Weather Prediction Model for the Energy Industry

cs.LG physics.ao-ph ·2026-09-09 ·Lukas Hedegaard Morsing, Arian Bakhtiarnia, Jonas Lynge Olesen, Tómas Bragi Björnsson Leth, Christian Gøbel Bach
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Medium-range weather forecasting underpins operational and planning decisions across the energy industry. Developing competitive weather models was once the domain of national meteorological centers, but recent advances in machine-learned weather prediction (MLWP) have opened the field to industry. We present Aries, a SwinTransformer-based MLWP model developed at InCommodities. Aries is trained on ERA5 reanalysis data at 0.25\textdegree{} resolution, predicting 74 prognostic and 11 diagnostic atmospheric variables. We evaluate the model on 2025 ECMWF Analysis initializations, ensuring a recent and strictly out-of-sample test period for all models compared. On 10-metre wind speed, Aries outperforms both ECMWF HRES and AIFS in terms of RMSE for lead times up to four days, while on 2-metre temperature it achieves RMSE on par with AIFS operational. These results demonstrate that proprietary development of competitive weather models is technically viable, supporting a broader set of forecasts available for operational and planning applications in the energy industry.

0.10

Suitable Measures for the Potential Operational Utility of AI NWP Rainfall Forecasts Over Africa

cs.LG stat.APphysics.ao-ph ·2026-09-24 ·Shruti Nath, Docko Sow, Koomi Toussaint Amoussouvi, Fenwick Cooper, Josiah Kiarie Kimani +3 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 19 pages, 11 figures (excluding supplementary and references)

Artificial intelligence (AI)-based weather prediction is approaching the skill of physical numerical weather prediction (NWP) systems at a fraction of the computational cost. This is particularly promising for Africa, where rainfall extremes are intensifying and many forecasting centres lack the infrastructure to run physical models at extended lead times. We present a calibrated comparison of GraphCast, GenCast and the Functional Generative Network (FGN) against the physical NWP model IFS for rainfall prediction across Africa. Deterministic and probabilistic forecasts are postprocessed using Isotonic Distributional Regression and evaluated with the Continuous Ranked Probability Score against IMERG, RFEv2 and CHIRPS across seasons, wet and dry regimes, elevation zones and lead times. All models retain skill beyond climatology across most seasons and at extended lead times. AI models generally outperform IFS in wet regions, whereas IFS performs better in dry, high-elevation areas, where its finer resolution better represents orographic controls on rainfall. Across observational datasets and seasons, AI models achieve a median improvement of approximately 5% over IFS. GraphCast achieves calibrated skill comparable to the ensemble-based FGN, although FGN provides greater significant skill at longer lead times. These results highlight the potential of calibrated AI weather prediction to provide accessible and computationally efficient rainfall forecasts across Africa, while demonstrating the continuing importance of spatial resolution, ensemble design and regional characteristics.

0.15

Short-Term Forecasting of Heterogeneous Wind Power Fleets: Global Temporal Fusion Transformer Leveraging Static Covariates

cs.LG ·2026-11-04 ·Viktor Walter, Andreas Wagner
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 18th International Green Energy Conference (IGEC-XVIII) & the 7th International Conference on Energy and AI (ICEAI-VII)

Accurate short-term wind power forecasting is critical for grid stability and electricity trading. While transformer-based deep learning is state of the art, industry practice relies mostly on local models trained for individual assets. This study investigates whether a global temporal fusion transformer (TFT), trained jointly on a heterogeneous portfolio of wind farms across Germany, outperforms site-specific local models in 48-hour-ahead forecasting. Using numerical weather prediction (NWP) data from the regional ICON-D2 and the global ECMWF HRES models, we compare the global TFT against local models and a linear regression baseline. The global model leverages static covariates, such as farm age, altitude above sea level, hub height, rotor diameter and power curve parameters, to learn shared representations across sites. We evaluate on 100 synthetic wind farm profiles and a real portfolio of 11 German wind farms, across two seasonal test periods with intermediate retraining. The global TFT outperforms the local models for 87% of the synthetic and 77% of the real wind farms and clearly surpasses the linear baseline. Wilcoxon signed-rank tests confirm that these gains are significant across both seasons and datasets. Crucially, this superiority depends on static covariates: without asset-specific context, the global model fails to generalize. The TFT's variable selection network (VSN) reveals the learned feature selection. Altitude emerges as a relevant static discriminator on both datasets, while hub height is decisive on the real portfolio. For dynamic inputs, the encoder prioritizes historical power, whereas the decoder combines upper-level wind speeds from both NWP models, consistent with averaging out model-specific errors. These findings support a shift from single-site to scalable multi-site forecasting, reducing operational complexity while improving accuracy in large portfolios.

0.20

Reconstructing Boundary Layer Wind Profiles with Machine Learning: A Comparative Study on IGRA Radiosonde Data

cs.LG cs.NEphysics.ao-ph ·2026-11-09 ·Fedor Buzaev, Dmitry Efremenko, Daria Pugacheva, Fedor Ratnikov, Egor Bugaev +2 more
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract · 10 pages, 8 figures. Accepted at the 2nd Workshop on AI-Ready Data for Science Discovery (ADSD), IEEE ICDM 2026

Wind profiles in the atmospheric boundary layer (ABL) drive short-range forecasting and wind-energy siting, yet sparse radiosonde coverage forces practitioners to interpolate them from a handful of physical predictors. We benchmark modern tabular learners against analytical parameterizations on 158,097 IGRA soundings. CatBoost, TabM, and FT-Transformer reduce RMSE to 1.3-1.6 m/s, against approximately 3 m/s for power-law and Monin-Obukhov fits; once the predictor set is fixed the three architectures differ by less than 0.05 m/s, so accuracy is driven by predictors rather than architecture. A cohort analysis of within-bin profile dispersion places an empirical floor of approximately 1.77 m/s on any point-wise predictor that uses standard radiosonde features, consistent with prior eddy-viscosity inversions. A one-dimensional Fourier Neural Operator applied as a post-hoc corrector to frozen tabular predictions reduces near-surface RMSE on U.S. stations from 1.5 to 1.2 m/s, while leaving upper-layer error unchanged. Further gains should come from new predictors rather than larger models.

0.28

Varda-single-1.0: deterministic data-driven weather forecasting at 1 km resolution over Switzerland's complex topography

cs.LG physics.ao-ph ·2026-10-01 ·Alberto Pennino, Francesco Zanetta, Michele Cattaneo, Claire Merker, Radi Radev +26 more
code/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · 24 pages, 13 figures, 2 tables. Model weights: https://huggingface.co/MeteoSwiss/Varda-single-1.0

We present Varda-single-1.0, a medium-range data-driven weather prediction system built for the Alpine domain. It provides hourly deterministic regional forecasts on a mesh of 1 km resolution and global forecasts on a 31 km mesh. The system comprises two independently trained stretched-grid Graph Transformer models with encoder-processor-decoder architecture, developed in the Anemoi framework: a 6-hourly autoregressive forecaster and a temporal downscaler reconstructing hourly forecasts between the forecaster's steps. Its training curriculum includes pre-training on ERA5 reanalysis data, followed by training on a 20-year kilometre-scale regional reanalysis, and finally fine-tuning on operational kilometre-scale analyses. Verified over one year against operational analyses and surface station observations, Varda-single is competitive with or improves on MeteoSwiss' operational numerical weather prediction baselines for most headline scores and variables. It broadly matches the skill of the high-resolution 1 km ICON-CH1-EPS control at lead times up to +33 h and generally outperforms the 2 km ICON-CH2-EPS control at lead times up to +120 h. Despite competitive aggregate scores, Varda-single underestimates some local wind maxima and produces overly smooth convective precipitation fields, consistent with the smoothing associated with squared-error training. To gain insight into the model's behaviour, we investigate three case studies beyond the aggregated headline scores, and find particular weaknesses in Varda-single's representation of local winds over complex terrain. Varda-single represents an important step in the development of high-resolution ML forecasting over complex terrain, in complementing the operational regional numerical weather prediction models of MeteoSwiss with data-driven models and in providing a pretrained model for researchers and user-specific applications.

0.33