CS Paper Radar

Are Caption Metrics Broken? Latency, Deaf and Hard of Hearing User Ratings, and Bias across Technologies

Bernard Thompson, James Waller, Luz Fanny Calderon Torres, Lu Ming, Mariana Arroyo Chavez, Dante Conway, Raja Kushalnagar, Christian Vogler

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-09-10 11:38 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Live captions on TV often contain errors and timing issues, making it hard for deaf and hard-of-hearing (DHH) viewers to follow dialog. It is essential that caption quality metrics reflect the lived DHH TV viewing experience. To this end, we describe a U.S.-based large-scale online survey with 216 validated participants, who provided 302 responses containing a cumulative 4,832 data points. Participants viewed videos drawn from a pool of 70 clips recorded from live TV, and were asked to rate the caption quality and subjective understanding of the content across four conditions: TV captions as originally recorded with up to 7-12 seconds delay, TV captions synchronized with audio, Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR)-generated captions synchronized with audio, and ASR captions with an average two-second delay. All captions were evaluated against the Word Error Rate (WER), Automated Caption Evaluation (ACE2) and Number, Edition and Recognition (NER) metrics. Results show that TV and ASR captions were rated similarly. For TV captions, all three metrics were moderately-to-highly correlated with viewer ratings, but far less so for ASR captions, making them far from technology-neutral. Additionally, caption latencies significantly impact the viewer experience, especially typical 7-12-second TV delays. We discuss the implications for the adoption of caption quality metrics.

Comment
Accepted for publication at ACM ASSETS 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Similar Scores, Opposite Failures: Human Correction as an Instrument for Video Caption Evaluation

cs.CV cs.CL ·2026-10-28 ·Ankit Khedia, Astitva Jaiswal, Chaitanya Prasad, Anisha Raju, Aangeeras
position similarity 0.70
Abstract · 29 pages, 10 figures, 17 tables. Analysis code included as ancillary files. Data available on request at https://data.deccan.ai

Video captioning models are increasingly evaluated with metrics designed for single-sentence image captions. We test whether those metrics recover human judgement on dense, multi-window video description, and find that they do not. Six frontier models captioned 196 short clips. Trained annotators post-edited every caption against a failure taxonomy fixed before annotation, once as a whole-clip overview and once window by window, and a quality-control reviewer checked each annotation, yielding 1,144 overview verdicts and 4,672 window verdicts. Reference-overlap metrics do not separate the captions reviewers accepted from those they rejected: BLEU-4 reaches an AUC of 0.510 and a CIDEr-style tf-idf cosine 0.528, and restricting references to reviewer corrections leaves BLEU-4 at 0.479 (95% CI 0.431-0.529), indistinguishable from chance. Review granularity changes what is detected. The same annotators record camera and shot errors on 2.7% of captions when reading the overview and on 12.8% when reading window by window, a 4.7x gap that holds across every robustness check we ran, on the mode most likely to need a near-total rewrite. Correct-overview rates span 54.1-72.7%, but only 4 of 15 pairwise gaps survive Bonferroni correction (5 after adjusting for reviewer and clip effects), and accuracy and derived severity order the models differently. Models with statistically indistinguishable accuracy have sharply different failure profiles, which no single scalar shows. We argue that caption evaluation should record what was wrong rather than only how often, and we report the taxonomy, the per-model profiles, the corpus properties that predict difficulty, and the code that regenerates every number in the paper.

0.18

From Visual Cues to Spoken Narration: Rethinking Audio Description

cs.CV ·2026-09-01 ·Akshita Gupta, Aditya Arora, Federico Tombari, Marcus Rohrbach, Anna Rohrbach
top venuebenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted to EMNLP main conference

Audio Description (AD) provides spoken narration of visual events during dialogue gaps, making movies accessible to visually impaired audiences. The problem requires determining both what (which visual event) and when (position for inserting the AD) to narrate, to achieve the best user experience. Prior work has largely reduced the problem to video captioning of pre-segmented video clips, i.e., what is largely predefined and when is ignored entirely. We propose Cue2Narrate, a two-stage pipeline that jointly predicts what and when to narrate in longer untrimmed movie clips. A dual-head audio-visual localizer predicts two temporally distinct windows per AD utterance: a visual cue window and a spoken narration window. A LoRA-adapted VLM then generates concise ADs from the predicted visual evidence, trained with a Description Ranking Loss that ranks captions (negative samples) of the same frames lower than the GT AD. To benchmark this new problem statement, we introduce the LongLSMDC benchmark with up to 8-min movie clips (~6.5min on average). On LongLSMDC, Cue2Narrate outperforms video-only and audio-only localization baselines by 5--12 points in avg. mAP. Under both predicted- and GT-window evaluation, Cue2Narrate improves AD generation over the corresponding fine-tuned base VLM. These results establish the first benchmark for multi-segment AD generation on long-form clips. Data & Code: https://github.com/multimodal-ai-lab/Cue2Narrate

0.58

Closing the Verification Loop: Self-Check Captioning for Long-Paragraph Detailed Audio Captioning

cs.SD ·2026-08-31 ·Fengji Ma, Yan Rong, Xu Li, Chen Zhang, Pengfei Wan +1 more
top venuecode/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · EMNLP2026

Long-paragraph detailed audio captioning, which requires dense and transcript-faithful descriptions of fine-grained audio content, remains unsolved for current audio-visual multimodal language models. We attribute this failure to two structural problems. The first is data poverty, as no public corpus jointly provides long clips, paragraph captions, and verbatim-transcript fidelity. The second is generation-mode failure, evidenced by a 44.8 to 46.4 percentage-point gap between right-audio and shuffled-audio multiple-choice question (MCQ) accuracy. We address both within Self-Check Captioning (SCC), a unified framework that instantiates audio-grounded question answering as the verification primitive at every lifecycle stage. SCC yields three artifacts. Long-paragraph Audio Caption 50k (LACap-50k) is a 50,222-clip audio-visual corpus with 491.5-word captions and a post-hoc automatic speech recognition (ASR) audit. Layer-Curvature Supervised Fine-Tuning (LC-SFT) is the first on-policy supervised fine-tuning method to weight tokens by intermediate-layer evidence, motivated by our identification of Late-Layer Semantic-Entropy Collapse (SEC). SCC-Verifier arbitrates among caption rollouts via audio-grounded self-answering at inference. Across multiple benchmarks, our system attains state-of-the-art among open-source captioners and is competitive with proprietary baselines. We release LACap-50k to fill the resource gap for long-paragraph detailed audio captioning research.

0.45

PhyRubric: Rubric-Grounded Diagnostic Evaluation of Physical Commonsense in Text-to-Video Generation

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-11-10 ·Huiyi Chen, Weitai Kang, Shicheng Fan, Xinshuo Wang, Zhixiang Shen +3 more
code/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · 34 pages, 19 figures

As text-to-video (T2V) models are increasingly positioned as world simulators, it is essential to evaluate whether their videos conform to physical commonsense. However, existing benchmarks rely on annotators who rate each video with a single score based on intuition, yielding ratings that are subjective and do not tell which physical principle is violated. We introduce PhyRubric, a rubric-grounded diagnostic framework for evaluating physical commonsense in T2V generation. For each caption, PhyRubric constructs a caption-specific rubric before any video is seen, decomposing the caption into semantic and physical items, and derives scores from item-level verdicts grounded in timestamped evidence. We instantiate this framework as PhyRubric-Bench, which spans 34 categories across five physical domains, and scale it up to PhyRubric-Train with 3,788 videos, on which we fine-tune the open-source PhyRubric-Judge. Empirical results across ten T2V models show that physical commonsense remains far from solved, and that PhyRubric-Judge correlates more closely with human judgments than existing open-source judges while matching the frontier proprietary Gemini 4 Argon. Further analysis provides actionable insights for T2V models.

0.36

Beyond Word Error Rate: A Failure Taxonomy of Streaming Dictation ASR

cs.CL cs.SD ·2026-11-12 ·Harras Mansoor, Muhammad Wisal, Hassan Bhatti, Masood Shakir
code/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · 35 pages, 27 tables, 2 figures. Code: https://github.com/heylemon-ai/streaming-dictation-asr Data: https://huggingface.co/datasets/hey-lemon…

Speech recognition (ASR) systems are usually compared by word error rate (WER) on recorded files, after punctuation, capital letters and number format are removed. In dictation, the audio is streamed live and the text goes into the user's message as written, so what matters is which mistakes the user has to fix. The test set, streamed to eleven ASR systems, comprises 106 scripted English dictations from one speaker (read in a quiet room, with a fan on, and whispered), 20 clips in each of eleven other language and dialect sets, and 400 recordings that join clips in two languages. Every error was sorted by a fixed rule into four levels: recognition, output formatting, language handling and, for the self-hosted models, audio dropped before the model. Systems with similar WER failed in different ways. Zoom Scribe and OpenAI's GPT-Live-Transcribe have almost the same WER on quiet English (7.4% and 7.3%), but 34.7% and 8.8% on whispered English. Zoom and both AssemblyAI models left out 26-28% of whispered words, and still 21-26% with their end-of-turn detection relaxed or off; seven other systems left out at most 3%. Qwen3-ASR's 32% came from the speech detection in our own deployment (6% when relaxed). Across 107 EARS speakers, the same four systems lost 7-31% of whispered words, while six others lost under 2%. With only English selected, Gemini, Deepgram and our self-hosted Whisper lost the non-English part of a two-language recording in 86-99% of recordings, against 33-46% with both languages selected, while GPT-Live-Transcribe, OpenAI's realtime Whisper and Meta lost it in at most 20%. Running Whisper behind a Silero voice activity detector that drops audio judged to be silence raised whispered WER from 10.1% to 51.4%. Most English results come from one read speaker. The code, the recordings, both references and every transcript are released.

0.39

Mind The Gap (MTG-AD): Dataset and Fine-grained Evaluation for End-to-End Inline Audio Descriptions

cs.CV cs.AIcs.HC ·2026-10-29 ·Subhashini Venugopalan, Jenny Tan, Taylor Roper, Jimmy Tobin, Anton Kast +3 more
top venuebenchmarkdatasetcode/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · NeurIPS 2026 Evaluations & Datasets Track, camera ready

Audio descriptions (AD) are essential for making visual media accessible to blind and low-vision (BLV) users. While Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) offer a scalable solution for generating audio descriptions on-demand, their performance on ``inline'' audio descriptions -- which must fit within existing silences in a video -- remains under-explored, particularly for diverse user-generated content (UGC). We present a comprehensive investigation into MLLM-generated inline audio descriptions. First, we introduce MTG-AD, a professionally annotated dataset of 36 hours of videos, each averaging $\sim$5 mins. and 8k+ descriptions in total, co-created by paired blind and sighted AD professionals to provide a high-quality benchmark for this task. Second, we propose MTG-AD-Eval, an evaluation framework based on audio description expert guidelines that provides fine-grained, reference-free actionable metrics for model improvement. Crucially, our framework evaluates the end-to-end task: it renders the generated scripts into audio tracks to assess their fit within the original video's natural silences, minimizing disruptive overlaps. Our analysis across frontier MLLMs reveals that while models accurately describe visual events and substantially reduce speech overlaps, gaps persist in narrative pacing and flow. Finally, we empirically validate that our automated and reference-free metrics correlate significantly with human quality ratings from sighted raters and 7 BLV participants, finding that while users narrowly prefer human-authored audio descriptions, they find MLLM-generated audio descriptions highly beneficial for comprehension. We provide actionable system design guidance and release MTG-AD at https://hf.co/datasets/google/mind-the-gap-inline-ad and MTG-AD-Eval at https://github.com/google/mtg-ad.

0.40

VocalEyes: Speaker-Aware Augmented Reality Captioning through In-Conversation Registration

cs.HC ·2026-09-26 ·Yuxiao Wang, Xulong Tang, Chen Chen, Rawan alghofaili
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Co-located augmented reality (AR) captions make speech readable, but they can separate an utterance from the person who produced it. In unfamiliar groups, losing that source complicates immediate responses and later review: users must recover not only what was said, but also who said it. Conventional diarization returns anonymous clusters, while speaker recognition typically assumes pre-meeting enrollment. We built VocalEyes, a speaker-aware AR captioning system that creates named voice profiles from natural self-introductions. The interface coordinates speaker-attributed captions, a fixed profile card, and a visual cue that marks the articulating face. In a controlled within-subjects study with 20 participants who reported typical hearing, VocalEyes identified speakers with 88.0% accuracy and increased participant speaker-tracking accuracy from 47.2% with caption-only AR to 87.3% with the complete interface. Participants also reported lower workload with the complete interface. These findings show how in-conversation registration can preserve speaker attribution across live captions and meeting records in scripted small-group meetings.

0.27

Comparing British and American Audio Description of Movies

cs.CL ·2026-08-10 ·Igor Sterner, Alex Lascarides, Frank Keller
similarity 0.63
Abstract · CMN 2026 Workshop

Narrating the visual component of movies is known as audio description. It is a narrative technique designed to enable blind and visually impaired individuals to follow the story. However, it is far more constrained than most narratives: the descriptions not only need to convey the story in the movie, but they must also fit into gaps between dialogue and they need to conform to guidelines that exist in each region. In this work, we compare audio description created in the United Kingdom against audio description created in the United States. We use guidelines written for these two regions, alongside the impressions from a practitioner in the field, to motivate specific hypotheses about the differences. We test these hypotheses against our pre-existing corpus, which provides both human-authored American and British audio description for each of 206 movies. Results provide quantitative evidence to uphold all tested hypotheses, including differences in lexicon, the use of the progressive aspect, the use of passive constructions, the use of subjective adjectives and modifiers, when characters are named, how scenes are cued, and degree of overlap with movie dialogue and music. Our work offers a quantitative lens into the narrative technique of audio description.

0.34