CS Paper Radar

Beyond Word Error Rate: A Failure Taxonomy of Streaming Dictation ASR

Harras Mansoor, Muhammad Wisal, Hassan Bhatti, Masood Shakir

cs.CL cs.SD ·submitted 2026-11-12 15:09 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

Speech recognition (ASR) systems are usually compared by word error rate (WER) on recorded files, after punctuation, capital letters and number format are removed. In dictation, the audio is streamed live and the text goes into the user's message as written, so what matters is which mistakes the user has to fix. The test set, streamed to eleven ASR systems, comprises 106 scripted English dictations from one speaker (read in a quiet room, with a fan on, and whispered), 20 clips in each of eleven other language and dialect sets, and 400 recordings that join clips in two languages. Every error was sorted by a fixed rule into four levels: recognition, output formatting, language handling and, for the self-hosted models, audio dropped before the model. Systems with similar WER failed in different ways. Zoom Scribe and OpenAI's GPT-Live-Transcribe have almost the same WER on quiet English (7.4% and 7.3%), but 34.7% and 8.8% on whispered English. Zoom and both AssemblyAI models left out 26-28% of whispered words, and still 21-26% with their end-of-turn detection relaxed or off; seven other systems left out at most 3%. Qwen3-ASR's 32% came from the speech detection in our own deployment (6% when relaxed). Across 107 EARS speakers, the same four systems lost 7-31% of whispered words, while six others lost under 2%. With only English selected, Gemini, Deepgram and our self-hosted Whisper lost the non-English part of a two-language recording in 86-99% of recordings, against 33-46% with both languages selected, while GPT-Live-Transcribe, OpenAI's realtime Whisper and Meta lost it in at most 20%. Running Whisper behind a Silero voice activity detector that drops audio judged to be silence raised whispered WER from 10.1% to 51.4%. Most English results come from one read speaker. The code, the recordings, both references and every transcript are released.

Comment
35 pages, 27 tables, 2 figures. Code: https://github.com/heylemon-ai/streaming-dictation-asr Data: https://huggingface.co/datasets/hey-lemon/streaming-dictation-asr

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Sada-ASR: A Production Multidialectal Arabic Speech Recognition System

cs.CL cs.SDeess.AS ·2026-11-14 ·Mahmoud Khaled, Mohammed Abd-Elnaser, Mahmoud Mohsen, Hazem Ahmed, Abdelrahman Hafez
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.70
Abstract · 10 pages, 3 figures, 8 tables. Code: https://github.com/echonova-ai-solutions/arabic-asr-benchmark Dataset: https://huggingface.co/datasets/…

Callers to Arabic customer-service lines speak their own dialect, while speech recognizers are built and evaluated mainly on Modern Standard Arabic (MSA). A recognizer that mishears the dialect breaks the call before anything else can help. We present Sada-ASR, the speech recognizer of EchoNova's production Arabic voice agent. On a 120-hour test set of MSA and eight dialects, it has the lowest word and character error rates of twelve systems, against eleven from Microsoft, ElevenLabs, Google, OpenAI, Speechmatics, IFM, Cohere, NVIDIA and Audar: 11.69% word error rate against 13.51% for the strongest, Microsoft's MAI-Transcribe-2 (a lead of 0.74 points on clips unaffected by that system's fixed number and script conventions), and 15.52% against 16.96% averaged over varieties. Its largest margins are on Omani (4.30 points), Egyptian (3.78) and Saudi (2.19) speech; it is level on Syrian and loses on Lebanese (24.96% against 23.05%), mostly because it writes Lebanese words in MSA forms and is less verbatim. On six public test sets its average word error rate under the leaderboard's current scoring is 17.17%, below every published figure we found, among them Falcon-ASR (20.92%), Jais-ASR (22.85%) and Audar-ASR-V1-Turbo (23.17%), though none of these states that it used that scoring, so the comparison is indicative. We describe the data pipeline and methodology behind Sada-ASR and release a 20-hour subset of the test set with our scoring code.

0.27

VoiceCodeBench: Evaluating Exact Structured-Token Recovery in Automatic Speech Recognition

cs.CL ·2026-08-28 ·Tyler Baumgartner, Brandon Tai, Lisa Kaelin-Martin, Candice Fan, Luc Debaupte +2 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 7 pages, 1 figure, 9 tables

Automatic speech recognition is usually evaluated with word error rate (WER), although voice workflows often require exact written values. VoiceCodeBench measures whether transcripts preserve identifiers, paths, commands, and other structured tokens needed by downstream software. It contains 300 human-recorded English workplace segments (5.59 hours, 85 speakers) and 1,482 audited entities across 26 types and eight domains. Under a raw-audio-only protocol, we evaluate 19 batch and streaming systems using WER, Canonical Token/Entity Match (CTEM), and strict segment-level Task Success Rate (TSR). Across systems, WER has little rank agreement with CTEM (Spearman $ρ=-0.28$) or TSR ($ρ=-0.22$). The best CTEM and TSR are 91.8% and 68.7%. Even the strongest system therefore leaves nearly one-third of recordings with an unrecovered critical value. Symbol-, separator-, and boundary-sensitive entities account for most errors.

0.25

ASR-Roundtrip Evaluation Can Mask Context- and Convention-Dependent Reading Errors in Chinese News TTS

cs.CL ·2026-08-11 ·Shijun Luo, Lizhi Wan
code/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · 5 pages, 4 tables. Conference-format manuscript. Supporting materials are available at https://github.com/Jayden-X-L/cn-newstts-asr-roundtri…

ASR-roundtrip evaluation is widely used as a scalable proxy for text-to-speech (TTS) intelligibility, but it can produce false negatives for reading errors perceived by listeners. We study Chinese news TTS spans whose correct reading depends on context or domain conventions, such as sports scores, aircraft models, technical units, and membership names. In these cases, Raw TTS can choose a plausible but wrong reading while ASR transcribes the audio as the intended or surface-correct text. A targeted audit over 110 high-risk MiMo TTS cases, reported with a complete denominator, confirms 46 masked false negatives, 9 exposed TTS errors, and 55 cases with no Raw TTS error. A span-isolation diagnostic re-exposes 18/46 previously masked errors. A Raw-only CosyVoice audit on the same targeted pool confirms 51 masked cases. Across the 97 TTS-specific audio files labeled confirmed masked across the two audits, Qwen3-ASR surface-recovers 40 cases, whereas Paraformer does so in only 2. The results suggest that ASR-roundtrip is useful for screening but insufficient as standalone ground truth for Chinese news reading-risk evaluation.

0.57

Decode Early, Verify Late: Streaming Offline Speech Recognizers Without Accuracy Loss

cs.LG ·2026-11-15 ·Doyeob Kim
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 8 pages, 2 figures, 5 tables

Voice agents need accurate transcripts soon after a user stops speaking. We propose Decode Early, Verify Late (DEVL), a training-free framework for streaming inference with offline ASR models. The server keeps partial transcripts as drafts and verifies the latest against the complete audio in one forward pass at turn end. Under stated input and decoding conditions, the final equals the model's greedy offline output in exact arithmetic. We adapt DEVL to four model families. In our five-recognizer comparison, 95-100% of final transcripts are byte-identical to the offline transcripts, WER stays within 0.13 points of offline, and single-stream time to final falls 1.5-7.3x. Serving Qwen3-ASR-1.7B on one A100, DEVL returns finals a median 22-26 ms after turn end at up to 64 streams, 2.7-3.9x sooner than the official streaming mode. It is the only system we tested that meets a 100 ms p99 target, up to 80 streams on Pipecat-STT and 64 on WildASR.

0.20

Monsoon: Scalable Spontaneous Speech Collection for Low-Resource ASR in 50 Languages

cs.CL ·2026-10-19 ·Shobhit Banga, Manas Dhir, Aaditya Pareek, Amritansh Walecha, Bhaskar Singh +6 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract · Submitted to ICASSP 2027

For most languages, automatic speech recognition (ASR) is limited less by model architecture than by a lack of accurately transcribed spontaneous speech. We present Monsoon, a framework for collecting such data at scale. It elicits unscripted conversations between paired contributors, screens recordings with automated classifiers, corrects transcripts over five levels of human review, and selects segments for lexical and acoustic coverage. It has collected speech in 50 languages; we analyse seven 3,500-hour corpora. At equal volume, its quality stages reduce semantic word error rate (WER) by 10-39% relative to a conventional protocol. Compared with an architecture-matched baseline trained on public corpora, Whisper fine-tuned on Monsoon performs comparably on the baseline's own test sets and reduces semantic WER by 20-44 points on conversational benchmarks. The gains transfer to a second architecture and grow with data volume. We release the framework, its quality-control models, and the fine-tuned models.

0.11

Measuring the Verifier's Floor: How Much Apparent Rare-Word Text-to-Speech Error Is ASR Error?

cs.SD cs.CL ·2026-10-22 ·Kirill Borodin, Vasilii Kudryavtsev, Nikita Vasiliev, Grach Mkrtchian
similarity 0.65
Abstract · Submitted to IEEE ICASSP 2027

Text-to-speech (TTS) is usually evaluated by transcribing its output with an automatic speech recognition (ASR) system, so the word error rate also counts recognizer errors. We measure these errors on human recordings of the test sentences. On LibriSpeech and FLEURS, the evaluation recognizer misses 33-67% of very rare words even in human speech, and all three recognizers miss 22-42%. Checking every word with two more recognizer families lowers the apparent TTS error on words that at least one recognizer hears two- to three-fold (very rare LibriSpeech words: from 10-13% to 3-5%), yet very rare words remain the hardest. Ignoring words the recognizer misses in human speech is biased: the other recognizers find TTS errors far more often on these words (4-6% vs. 0.2-0.3%) and overturn about half of the errors this mask keeps. As half of the remaining adjudicated errors may be spelling variants, a listening test is needed.

0.27

Are Caption Metrics Broken? Latency, Deaf and Hard of Hearing User Ratings, and Bias across Technologies

cs.HC ·2026-09-10 ·Bernard Thompson, James Waller, Luz Fanny Calderon Torres, Lu Ming, Mariana Arroyo Chavez +3 more
published similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted for publication at ACM ASSETS 2026

Live captions on TV often contain errors and timing issues, making it hard for deaf and hard-of-hearing (DHH) viewers to follow dialog. It is essential that caption quality metrics reflect the lived DHH TV viewing experience. To this end, we describe a U.S.-based large-scale online survey with 216 validated participants, who provided 302 responses containing a cumulative 4,832 data points. Participants viewed videos drawn from a pool of 70 clips recorded from live TV, and were asked to rate the caption quality and subjective understanding of the content across four conditions: TV captions as originally recorded with up to 7-12 seconds delay, TV captions synchronized with audio, Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR)-generated captions synchronized with audio, and ASR captions with an average two-second delay. All captions were evaluated against the Word Error Rate (WER), Automated Caption Evaluation (ACE2) and Number, Edition and Recognition (NER) metrics. Results show that TV and ASR captions were rated similarly. For TV captions, all three metrics were moderately-to-highly correlated with viewer ratings, but far less so for ASR captions, making them far from technology-neutral. Additionally, caption latencies significantly impact the viewer experience, especially typical 7-12-second TV delays. We discuss the implications for the adoption of caption quality metrics.

0.39

Beyond Word Error Rate: A Switch Aware Evaluation of ASR and Audio Language Models on English Yoruba Code-Switched Speech

cs.CL cs.AI ·2026-09-10 ·Chibuzor Okocha, Christan Earl Grant
published similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted to IEEE Speech Language Tecnology

Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems and audio language models (audio LMs) now report low error rates on monolingual benchmarks, but their behavior on code switched speech in low resource, diacritic rich languages remains poorly characterized. We present a switch aware evaluation of eleven modern systems (six ASR models and five audio LMs) on English Yoruba code-switched speech, using a deterministic 2000 utterance evaluation set and a shared scoring pipeline. Beyond word error rate (WER), we report switch localized diagnostics: a switch entry token error rate (SETER), windowed switch point error rates, language specific error rates, and a diacritic insensitive WER. Our central finding is that aggregate WER hides code switching behavior. The best system by WER (an ASR model) is statistically indistinguishable from a leading audio LM on WER, yet the audio LM is significantly better on every switch localized metric. Across faithful systems, Yoruba token recognition collapses (error 0.97 for almost all systems) while English tokens are recognized far better, and errors concentrate sharply at switches into Yoruba. Several generative audio LMs fail as exact transcribers, producing translation, verbosity, and prompt leakage that are strongly prompt dependent. We release manifests, metric implementations, and evaluation scripts to support reproducible, switch aware benchmarking for African code switched speech.

0.51