CS Paper Radar

Comparative Performance Analysis of OTFS and OFDM Modulations for Mobile Wireless Communications

J. Marcos Leal B. Filho, Danilo de S. Pena, Marília C. Muniz, Álvaro A. M. de Medeiros, Vicente A. de Sousa

cs.NI ·submitted 2026-09-10 14:37 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

This paper provides a quantitative performance comparison between Orthogonal Time Frequency Space (OTFS) and Orthogonal Frequency-Division Multiplexing (OFDM) modulation schemes, focusing on mobile wireless communication scenarios. We evaluate and compare both schemes based on critical communication scenarios and configurations such as mobility levels, modulation orders, multipath environments, and equalizers. The study systematically identifies conditions where OTFS and OFDM each exhibit optimal performance. Results from simulations demonstrate that OTFS outperforms OFDM consistently for high mobility scenarios and multipath environments. Depending on the modulation order, the performance gap between OTFS and OFDM might be very close or many orders of magnitude. Moreover, at low and mid values of SNR, the non-linear equalizer performs better than traditional linear equalizers for OTFS.

Journal ref
XLIII Simpósio Brasileiro de Telecomunicações e Processamento de Sinais (SBrT2025)
DOI
10.14209/sbrt.2025.1571156218

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A Novel Coexistence Scheme for OFDM and OTFS Waveforms for Uplink in 6G Networks

eess.SP ·2026-10-12 ·Badr Eddine Ouakouak, Salah Eddine Zegrar, Hüseyin Arslan
top venue similarity 0.66
Abstract · Published in IEEE Transactions on Communications, Date 2025/7/10, Volume 73, Isse 11, Page range 12008-12022

The upcoming sixth generation (6G) wireless networks are designed to support advanced applications that the current air interface based on orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) cannot accommodate, necessitating innovations in waveform design. Orthogonal time frequency space (OTFS) has emerged as a promising alternative, offering enhanced performance particularly in high-mobility channel environments. However, deploying fundamentally different waveforms over the same frequencies fails to exploit the mutual relationships between them. In this paper, a forward-compatible yet backward-compatible coexistence framework is proposed, where various OFDM waveform options are incorporated while seamlessly integrating OTFS within the same network. The proposed coexistence paradigm involves utilizing a specially designed spreading matrix in the delay-Doppler (DD) domain to process OTFS data. The matrix is tailored to establish orthogonality between OTFS and OFDM waveforms, effectively reducing cross-interference when both coexist within the same time-frequency (TF) resources. Our results demonstrate up to a 6 dB improvement in bit error rate (BER) performance for the OTFS waveform compared to other coexistence schemes. The proposed approach also shows greater interference resilience and approaches the upper bounds of achievable rates. By utilizing the full bandwidth and time duration, it enhances range and velocity resolutions, leading to improved sensing performance. These findings are supported by mathematical analysis and extensive simulations for uplink scenarios.

0.68

Synchronization and Channel Estimation of OTFS with RF Impairments

eess.SP ·2026-08-20 ·Sanoopkumar P. S., Mohsen Bayat, Stephen McWade, Arman Farhang
similarity 0.60
Abstract · Invited paper accepted for presentation at the 2026 IEEE 27th International Workshop on Signal Processing Advances in Wireless Communication…

Orthogonal Time Frequency Space (OTFS) modulation is a promising waveform for future wireless networks. However, its resilience to RF impairments remains relatively understudied. Low-cost RF front ends are crucial for next-generation wireless systems, yet their performance is often degraded by RF impairments such as transmit IQ imbalance (IQI), phase noise (PN), timing offset (TO), and carrier frequency offset (CFO). Hence, this paper addresses the estimation and compensation of these RF impairments in OTFS systems under high mobility. A unified system model is developed that incorporates TO, CFO, PN, IQI and other channel effects into an effective channel representation. Using the pilot with cyclic prefix (PCP), a low-peak to average power ratio (PAPR) pilot suitable for OTFS, we propose a pilot-aided synchronization and estimation framework. The dual periodicity of PCP is exploited in our proposed TO estimation technique. A maximum-likelihood-based technique is also proposed to jointly estimate the CFO and effective channel using a complex exponential basis expansion model (CE-BEM). Finally, a linear detection model is formulated in the delay-Doppler domain to mitigate residual interference caused by RF impairments. Our simulation results corroborate the efficacy of our proposed synchronization and channel estimation techniques.

0.24

Delay-Doppler Domain Aided OFDM (DD-a-OFDM): Pulsone Pilot and Cross-Domain Iterative Receiver Design

eess.SP ·2026-10-21 ·Rongrong Xin, Zhiqiang Wei, Zai Yang
similarity 0.58
Abstract

In high-mobility channels, the widely adopted orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) modulation waveform suffers from significant performance degradation due to channel variation and severe inter-carrier interference. Although delay-Doppler (DD) domain multicarrier (DDMC) modulation enjoys a higher channel estimation (CE) accuracy via exploiting the inherent DD-domain channel stability, sparsity, and separability, its high detection complexity limits its practical deployment, making OFDM still a promising waveform candidate for the sixth-generation (6G) cellular networks. To simultaneously harness the complementary strengths of DDMC and OFDM and mitigate their respective limitations, this paper proposes a DD-domain aided OFDM (DD-a-OFDM) framework, including a pulsone pilot (PP) design and a cross-domain iterative receiver design, to enhance the CE and detection performance of OFDM in high-mobility channels. Specifically, a pulsone pilot sequence is periodically inserted before the cyclic prefix (CP) for each OFDM symbol in the time-domain, which is equivalent to a single DD-domain pilot impulse and enables accurate DD-domain CE. Then, we propose a cross-domain iterative receiver in which the time-frequency (TF) domain detection results are transformed into the DD-domain for interference cancellation and CE; in turn, the DD-domain estimated channel is transformed into the TF-domain for channel reconstruction and symbol detection. The proposed cross-domain iterative receiver achieves a higher CE accuracy and detection performance with a much lower pilot overhead, compared to the conventional OFDM system. Simulation results validate the fast convergence and superior performance of the proposed DD-a-OFDM scheme and demonstrate that it maintains a robust CE and detection performance even in high-mobility channels.

0.16

Timing Misalignment and Its Impact on OTFS and Other Delay-Based Waveforms

eess.SP ·2026-10-13 ·Badr Eddine Ouakouak, Salah Eddine Zegrar, Hüseyin Arslan
top venuebenchmarkhot direction similarity 0.58
Abstract · Published in: IEEE Transactions on Communications. Date of Publication: 01 September 2026. Volume: 74. Page(s): 13657 - 13671. no ISSUE numb…

The shift towards 6G wireless networks calls for advanced waveforms to support emerging applications such as ultra-reliable and massive machine-type communications. Among the proposed candidates, OTFS, ODDM, OTSM, and OCDM share the common feature of exploiting the delay domain for data transmission. While these waveforms offer significant advantages in high-mobility and sensing scenarios, their integration into multi-user uplink systems reveals a critical challenge: timing misalignment (TM). Unlike OFDM, where residual timing offsets translate into phase rotations, delay-based waveforms experience actual shifts of resources, whose impact we investigate in this work. We show that the aforementioned waveforms can be unified under a time-invariant setup through a common input--output relation, which enables a unified analysis of TM in uplink resource allocation. The results reveal a fundamental trade-off between interference mitigation and guard overhead in the presence of TM. We further benchmark the observed behavior against OFDM under Doppler spread as a reference impairment and highlight the analogy between TM in delay-based allocation and Doppler spread in frequency-based allocation. The results show that delay-based waveforms can maintain a net performance advantage over OFDM in the considered setup. Beyond this unified Doppler-free analysis, we evaluate the joint impact of Doppler spread and TM on each waveform individually. We also investigate BER performance and show how coding can mitigate the resulting interference. This study therefore establishes a problem framework that motivates the development of future compensation and scheduling strategies for practical multi-user operation of delay-based waveforms.

0.44

Spectral-Efficient MIMO-OFDM: Low-Complexity Solution based on Random Multiplexing

eess.SP ·2026-08-27 ·Jie Yang, Wanchen Hu, Yi Song, Shuangyang Li, Burak Çakmak +3 more
similarity 0.58
Abstract

This paper presents a low-complexity precoded MIMO-OFDM system for achieving improved spectral efficiency (SE) via intentionally compressing information symbols among subcarriers. Particularly, the proposed scheme leverages the powerful random multiplexing mechanism for precoding, and adopts the linear-complexity orthogonal approximate message passing (OAMP) estimator for symbol detection, where the compatibility with the existing fifth generation (5G) architectures is fully preserved. We further provide the theoretical analysis based on the replica-symmetric (RS) formula. This analysis confirms the advantages of the proposed system with respect to the adopted compression ratios, where an interesting phase transition behavior is verified. Numerical results coincide with our analysis and demonstrate significant improvements in terms of achievable rates and bit error rate (BER) compared to conventional MIMO-OFDM counterpart, making the proposed scheme a promising solution to 6G and beyond wireless networks.

0.13

Delay-Doppler Duality: Simplifying Exact Equalization of Zak-OTFS in Time or in Frequency

cs.IT eess.SP ·2026-10-12 ·Mudasir Ahmad Sheikh, Robert Calderbank
similarity 0.55
Abstract · 12 pages, 9 figures, 3 tables

The Zak-OTFS carrier waveform is a pulse in the delay-Doppler (DD) domain, and given the input-output (I/O) relation at one DD point in a frame, we can predict the I/O relation at all other points. While it is simple to acquire the effective wireless channel with Zak-OTFS, the cost of embracing inter-carrier interference is equalization complexity. The cost of linear minimum mean-square error (LMMSE) equalization grows cubically with the frame size. We describe how to use channel knowledge to reduce equalization complexity. For any pulse shaping filter, and for fractional delays and Dopplers, we show that the DD channel matrix is unitarily similar, through the discrete Zak transform, to a time-domain (TD) matrix that is a weighted sum of cyclic delay and Doppler operators, where the weights are the taps of the effective channel. We also obtain a dual frequency-domain (FD) form through an additional Fourier transform. The TD matrix is banded with a width set by the delay spread that is independent of the Doppler spread, whereas the FD matrix is banded with a width set only by the Doppler spread. We design a receiver that reads off the two widths from the channel estimate, selects the cheaper domain, and solves the banded system exactly, using a bordered Cholesky factorization that treats the quasi-periodic wrap-around without sacrificing degrees of freedom. Filters that decay slowly need a few preconditioned conjugate gradient steps. We show that the complexity of equalization becomes linear in the frame size. Simulations match direct DD-LMMSE error rates with three to four orders of magnitude fewer multiplications. A single receiver handles channels with very different delay and Doppler characteristics.

0.26

FM-OFDM: A Constant-Envelope Sensing Waveform with Phase-Differencing Receiver Processing

eess.SP ·2026-09-22 ·Amir Bouziane, Hüseyin Arslan
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Cyclic-prefix orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (CP-OFDM) is widely adopted as a reference waveform for integrated sensing and communication (ISAC). However, its high peak-to-average power ratio (PAPR) requires power amplifier back-off, thereby reducing the available sensing link budget. Frequency-modulated OFDM (FM-OFDM) provides a constant-envelope signal with 0 dB PAPR and has demonstrated reliable communication performance in high-mobility scenarios, but its sensing characteristics remain largely unexplored. This paper characterizes FM-OFDM as a sensing waveform based on its bandwidth, ambiguity function, sidelobe behavior, and Doppler estimation capability. The analysis shows that its data dependent sidelobe floor is incoherent and decreases through across frame integration, whereas the corresponding CP-OFDM floor remains unchanged. Consequently, under equal occupied bandwidth and transmit power, frame-level integration reverses the single-symbol performance ordering and provides FM-OFDM with approximately 20 dB of additional dynamic range for weak-target detection. Moreover, the zero-delay cut of the FMOFDM ambiguity function is shown to be deterministic and independent of the transmitted data realization, in contrast to linearly modulated waveforms, while a closed-form expression is derived for the sidelobe floor away from the zero-delay cut. Since the nonlinear mapping between the data symbols and time-domain samples prevents the direct application of the conventional CP-OFDM range-Doppler processing chain, a weighted phase-increment Doppler estimator is developed. The proposed estimator enables closed-form prediction of the sensing floor and its crossover point with a minimum computational complexity.

0.31

Performance Analysis of AFDM Transceiver Under Practical IQ Imbalance

eess.SP ·2026-09-22 ·Rishikesh Bharti, Tonmoy Rajkhowa, Sanjeev Sharma, Kuntal Deka, Zilong Liu
similarity 0.54
Abstract

This paper investigates the impact of in-phase/quadrature (IQ) imbalance on signal detection in affine frequency-division multiplexing (AFDM) systems over doubly dispersive Rayleigh fading channels. The bit error rate (BER) performance of AFDM under various IQ mismatch conditions is evaluated and compared with that of an ideal transceiver. Simulation results show that, under ideal conditions, BER decreases rapidly with increasing signal-to-noise ratio (SNR). However, IQ imbalance introduces image interference that spreads across the affine domain, causing significant performance degradation. The results further highlight the impact of practical IQ imbalance on AFDM systems across different quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM) orders, channel scenarios, and comparisons with orthogonal frequency-division multiplexing (OFDM) and orthogonal time frequency space (OTFS) systems. In particular, higher-order QAM performance degrades significantly, indicating the need for IQ imbalance compensation techniques or impairment-aware detection algorithms to ensure robust operation in practical AFDM systems.

0.23