CS Paper Radar

Sociotechnical Aspects of Tor Relay Rejection

Jules Dejaeghere, Lionel Goffaux, Pierre Luycx, Hosam Elkoulak, Florentin Rochet

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-14 08:12 UTC · v1

Abstract

In 2019, the Tor Project enforced an end-of-life (EoL) policy for Tor versions, leading to the rejection of outdated relays, amounting to a notable fraction of consensus weight. While this policy aids network maintenance, reduces backporting efforts, and shortens vulnerability exposure, its sociotechnical implications remain unstudied. A user study ($N=26$) reveals that relay operators, though not universally aware of the EoL policy, generally view it favorably. Operational practices vary, occasionally excluding newly installed relays from the network. Network simulations, grounded in historical data, assess the policy's immediate impact on Tor clients against common adversaries. Results indicate a marginal adversarial advantage, with network churn (i.e., relays entering and exiting) exerting a more pronounced effect on user anonymity. Security metrics are introduced to evaluate relay contributions against two adversary models, enabling ranking by individual utility and security. Analysis of four exclusion rounds shows that a minority of rejected relays typically account for over 50% of the security provided by all excluded relays. Recommendations for EoL policy implementation are proposed to mitigate potential drawbacks.

Comment
arXiv version, extended from the WPES. 17 pages, 11 figures, 1 table
Journal ref
Jules Dejaeghere, Lionel Goffaux, Pierre Luycx, Hosam Elkoulak, and Florentin Rochet. 2026. Sociotechnical Aspects of Tor Relay Rejection. In 25th Workshop on Privacy in the Electronic Society (WPES '26)
DOI
10.1145/3847192.3847370

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

The Cost of Stability: Deanonymizing Onion Services Long-Lived Introduction Circuits

cs.CR ·2026-09-27 ·Nicolas Constantinides, Mahdi Rahimi
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Tor is a widely used anonymity network that provides network privacy by routing client communications through a sequence of relays to their destinations. An adversary observing a single Tor relay cannot readily link clients to their destinations, as doing so requires identifying the other relays along the client circuit. Identifying these relays from traffic observed at the monitored relay alone is challenging: each relay carries traffic for many circuits simultaneously, and client circuits typically last only about 10 min, limiting observations of a given circuit. In contrast, Tor onion services use introduction circuits that remain fixed for 18 to 24 h. We develop an intersection attack that exploits this design, allowing an adaptive adversary observing one Tor relay at a time to identify the network location of an onion service. We evaluate the attack on the live Tor network against a self-operated onion service carrying genuine third-party traffic. Across nine end-to-end experiments, the attack reconstructs the complete Tor circuit in every run, with an estimated median time of 2.2 h. To mitigate this attack, we propose a mechanism that periodically rebuilds internal introduction circuits to limit evidence accumulation without changing publicly advertised information.

0.21

On the Effectiveness of NetFlow-Based Deanonymization of Tor Onion Services (Extended Version)

cs.CR ·2026-10-10 ·Jinseo Lee, Jongkook Han, Yixin Sun, Min Suk Kang
top venue similarity 0.63
Abstract · To appear at IEEE Symposium on Security and Privacy 2027

In the context of Tor, deanonymization attacks via traffic correlation have long been studied for both clients and onion services. Complementing prior investigations that utilize fine-grained flow metadata such as packet sizes and timings, we study a relatively less explored yet easier-to-obtain adversarial capability: deanonymization using only coarse NetFlow-style telemetry, such as one-minute, 1-out-of-1,000 sampled packet counts. We first revisit active NetFlow-based traffic analysis attacks against Tor onion services and show, through large-scale experiments with live Tor data, that coarse telemetry is sufficient to deanonymize a targeted onion service when the adversary can induce discernible traffic patterns through controlled downloads. We then introduce a stronger active attack based on controlled introduction requests, which removes application-specific assumptions and gives adversaries more flexibility while achieving comparable success rates. Finally, we present a passive deanonymization attack that sends zero traffic to target onion services. The attack exploits Tor's puzzle-based DoS defense as a side channel: public puzzle difficulty reveals service-load changes that can be semantically matched against NetFlow traces. Our findings show that coarse network telemetry poses a practical deanonymization threat to onion services today and call for proactive mitigations and a redesign of the globally visible defense signals that may leak service-load information.

0.24

Evaluating Practical Enumeration and Blocking Attacks on the Snowflake Circumvention System

cs.CR ·2026-09-10 ·Linden Chen, Ryan Sangha, Cecylia Bocovich, Ram Sundara Raman
top venue similarity 0.59
Abstract · Accepted to 2026 ACM CCS

Proxy-based Internet censorship circumvention tools like Snowflake rely on large, dynamic pools of third-party proxies to resist IP-based blocking. We focus on two assumptions underpinning the security of Snowflake: that adversaries cannot easily enumerate proxy IPs, and that blocking those proxies would incur unacceptable collateral damage. In this paper, we test these assumptions by studying practical enumeration and blocking attacks against Snowflake conducted by malicious clients. We combine bounded, ethical real-world measurements with large-scale simulation to evaluate both present-day enumeration and blocking risk and broader attacker capabilities. Over 48 days of real-world measurements from May--June 2025, our attack enumerated over 21,000 unique proxy IP addresses belonging to almost 1,000 autonomous systems. Despite this high number, we find that proxy churn limits the overall effectiveness of enumeration over time, and reduces the impact on clients of individual proxy addresses being blocked. However, at the network level, blocking the top 1% of observed autonomous systems blocks more than 30% of observed Snowflakes while affecting 0% of Tranco Top 100 domains and ~2.5% of Top 1M domains. We discover that the broker's load-aware matching reveals stable, high-capacity proxies to attackers early, especially during periods of elevated demand such as the censorship even in Iran of June 2025, subsequently exposing the networks that contribute disproportionately to system connectivity. In simulation, increasing attacker scale sharply improves both enumeration and blocking success, while higher proxy churn significantly reduces blocking effectiveness. We conclude by discussing and evaluating practical mitigations, some of which have been integrated into Snowflake.

0.53

Expanding Access, Exposing Risk: A Short Study of Exposed Starlink Hosts

cs.NI ·2026-08-17 ·Omar Elamri, Isaac-Neil Zanoria, Jacob Zhi, Ben Du, Liz Izhikevich
publishedunusual similarity 0.56
Abstract

In this very short paper, we present a measurement-driven analysis of the security characteristics of Starlink-connected hosts and uncover several concerning trends. We find that Starlink hosts are more likely to run outdated or vulnerable operating systems and network protocols than non-Starlink hosts. Regions like Latin America, Southeast Asia, and Eastern Europe show disproportionately higher risk. Our findings raise important questions for the Internet measurement and policy communities.

0.42

Garlic in a Box: I2P Network Emulator

cs.NI ·2026-10-25 ·Siddique Abubakr Muntaka, Faiza Hussein, Boutros Farah, Anthony Kashi, Jacques Bou Abdo +1 more
published similarity 0.56
Abstract · Accepted at the 2026 Workshop on Cyber Security Experimentation and Test (CSET 2026), co-located with ACSAC. 8 pages

The Invisible Internet Project (I2P) is a peer-to-peer anonymity network whose routing and peer-selection mechanics underlie a growing family of state-sponsored covert relay architectures. Studying these mechanics demands a controlled, reproducible environment. We present Garlic-in-a-Box, an installable emulator that deploys a fully isolated network of unmodified I2P Java routers on a single host or cluster of hosts. Each router runs in its own Linux network namespace. A filesystem bootstrap removes the dependency on signed reseed servers, and synthetic geographic diversity activates the same location-aware peer-selection code paths present on the live network. A fifty-router deployment across five geographic locations stabilises in about twenty-five minutes and uses roughly 21 GB of memory. To demonstrate the platform's value, we model I2P peer selection as a two-stage process and conduct a reputation attack. Across five independent trials, the attack promotes the adversary into the victim's eligible selection set with perfect consistency, and the adversary is chosen for 1.38x more tunnels than matched controls. The platform and its measurement pipeline are released to support reproducible I2P security research and hands-on cyber-defence training.

0.36

Does Client Diversity Protect the Lightning Network? Evidence from the 2026 Core Lightning Shutdown

cs.CR ·2026-10-14 ·Saurabh Kumar
code/dataunusual similarity 0.53
Abstract · v2: client inference rules v4 (CLN and Eclair separated by feature bit 5 instead of keysend) with a rules table; node shares and reachabilit…

Client diversity is often cited as the Lightning Network's defence against a bug in any one implementation, yet LND runs 80% of public nodes (84% counting one operator's fleet of about 2,000 tiny nodes) and holds 84% of public channel capacity, a capacity share that has barely moved since 2023. We test what diversity buys with a natural experiment. On 26 August 2026, amid security fixes in every implementation, Core Lightning (CLN) maintainers told operators who could not upgrade to disconnect their nodes. Using 805 daily gossip snapshots, 132,360 on-chain channel closes and a client classifier validated against self-identifying aliases and against the wallet that builds each node's funding transactions, we find that 22% of CLN nodes went dark overnight, ten times the usual rate, mostly Tor-reachable ones; a third were still dark five weeks later. The rest of the network barely noticed. Reachability among all node pairs fell by 7.8 percentage points, a loss exceeded in 4 of 94 ordinary two-day windows and half that of a Tor denial-of-service wave in July, while among CLN pairs it fell by 24.5 points, more than in any ordinary window. Calibrated failure scenarios explain the containment: the blast radius depends on whether a failure reaches the hubs, not on how many nodes run the failing software. Losing ACINQ's Eclair node alone costs the surviving network four times the reachability lost with all 619 routable CLN nodes, and minority clients' reliance on LND for connectivity is what their size implies; CLN nodes in fact peer with each other more than chance. Diversity statistics that count nodes mislead; the quantity to track is which software the hubs run.

0.61

Reward Hacking and Agent Containment Failure: A Monte Carlo Study Based on the 2026 Hugging Face Incident

cs.AI cs.CR ·2026-09-26 ·Murat Ozer, Bulent Erenay, Ibrahim Berber
similarity 0.52
Abstract · 14 pages, research paper, and two figures

The July 2026 intrusion into Hugging Face production infrastructure showed how reward hacking can become an external cybersecurity incident when a capable agent encounters weak containment boundaries. This study develops a probabilistic risk model linking five stages: reward hacking, containment escape, usable access, persistence, and failure of detection. A Monte Carlo simulation evaluates 100,000 runs under each of four control configurations. Input distributions represent explicit uncertainty and are used for comparative analysis rather than real-world frequency prediction. Under the stated assumptions, layered controls reduce simulated external-incident probability substantially more than network isolation or monitoring used alone, an ordering that holds under independent plus/minus 25% perturbation of every coefficient in the model across 300 draws. Sensitivity analysis shows that agent capability and weaknesses in monitoring, authorization, and credential control exert the greatest influence on modeled risk. Human temporal discounting and metric gaming provide a behavioral analogy for short-horizon optimization, but the study does not infer that AI agents experience gratification or human motivation. The results support treating cyber-capable agent evaluations as hostile security zones in which indirect egress, shared infrastructure, credentials, and evaluation artifacts must remain outside the agent's effective authority.

0.45

Lacan: Making Accountability in Anonymous Networks Real

cs.NI cs.CR ·2026-09-01 ·Naoya Takada, Yutaro Yoshinaka, Kentaro Kita, Junji Takemasa, Yuki Koizumi +1 more
similarity 0.50
Abstract

Anonymity and accountability are essential properties for our everyday activity on the Internet. However, they appear contradictory, and their reconciliation remains far from reality. Existing approaches fall short in this regard, as they either rely on an on-path trustee, per-packet authorization, per-packet public-key cryptography, or per-session intervention by a central authority. We propose Lacan, a protocol that reconciles anonymity and accountability within a realistic design. In Lacan, a sender enjoys anonymity provided by on-path relays, as long as she complies with a contract established with the receiver. Upon a contract violation, the verifier, an off-path trustee on behalf of the receiver, links the malicious message to the sender's identity indirectly via the packet, path, and session, thereby reducing public-key operations from per-packet to per-session. This linkage remains robust even against malicious relays and receivers, grounded in our novel chain of successor proofs for accountable path reconstruction, together with traceable signatures, path validation, and key-committing encryption. We analyze the anonymity and accountability, implement the protocol, and evaluate the performance.

0.12