CS Paper Radar

Does Client Diversity Protect the Lightning Network? Evidence from the 2026 Core Lightning Shutdown

Saurabh Kumar

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-10-14 21:22 UTC · v2
code/dataunusual

Abstract

Client diversity is often cited as the Lightning Network's defence against a bug in any one implementation, yet LND runs 80% of public nodes (84% counting one operator's fleet of about 2,000 tiny nodes) and holds 84% of public channel capacity, a capacity share that has barely moved since 2023. We test what diversity buys with a natural experiment. On 26 August 2026, amid security fixes in every implementation, Core Lightning (CLN) maintainers told operators who could not upgrade to disconnect their nodes. Using 805 daily gossip snapshots, 132,360 on-chain channel closes and a client classifier validated against self-identifying aliases and against the wallet that builds each node's funding transactions, we find that 22% of CLN nodes went dark overnight, ten times the usual rate, mostly Tor-reachable ones; a third were still dark five weeks later. The rest of the network barely noticed. Reachability among all node pairs fell by 7.8 percentage points, a loss exceeded in 4 of 94 ordinary two-day windows and half that of a Tor denial-of-service wave in July, while among CLN pairs it fell by 24.5 points, more than in any ordinary window. Calibrated failure scenarios explain the containment: the blast radius depends on whether a failure reaches the hubs, not on how many nodes run the failing software. Losing ACINQ's Eclair node alone costs the surviving network four times the reachability lost with all 619 routable CLN nodes, and minority clients' reliance on LND for connectivity is what their size implies; CLN nodes in fact peer with each other more than chance. Diversity statistics that count nodes mislead; the quantity to track is which software the hubs run.

Comment
v2: client inference rules v4 (CLN and Eclair separated by feature bit 5 instead of keysend) with a rules table; node shares and reachability reported with and without one operator's managed fleet of small LND nodes. 11 pages, 8 figures, 7 tables. Code and aggregate data: https://github.com/bitcoindatalabs/ln-client-diversity

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Who Patches the Lightning Network? Evidence from Release Lines in Gossip, 2023-2026

cs.CR cs.NI ·2026-10-21 ·Saurabh Kumar
code/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · 13 pages, 7 figures, 5 tables. Code and aggregate data: https://github.com/bitcoindatalabs/ln-upgrade-dynamics

Every implementation of Bitcoin's Lightning payment network disclosed security vulnerabilities in 2026, and every advisory told operators to upgrade. Whether they do has never been measured, because Lightning gossip carries no software version. Matching the feature bits a node announces against the source of every LND, Core Lightning, Eclair and LDK release, we show that gossip reveals a node's release line after all. Where Core Lightning nodes state their version, the inferred line is exact for 132 of 136 node-line pairs. Across 814 daily snapshots of the public graph from 2023 to 2026, the network patches on release and platform schedules, not on disclosures. Half of LND nodes upgrade within 88 days of a release; small nodes and those that skipped releases lag far behind. The three largest upgrade waves came about a day after the Umbrel app store shipped a new LND version. Since June 2025, 17% of LND upgrades came in the 48 hours after a platform release, windows that cover 4.4% of the time. Disclosures, a median 256 days after the fix, moved few operators: of 12 we can test, only Core Lightning's of July 2026 sped up upgrades, and only among nodes one release line behind. Its later call to restart offline was followed mostly by nodes already patched. Two months after Lightning Labs' August 2026 batch, 71% of the LND nodes exposed at disclosure still ran an affected release. For maintainers, the lever on the nodes that lag is the platforms that package their releases.

0.40

Sluice: Global Invariant, Local Enforcement for Pooled Payment-Channel Liquidity

cs.CR cs.DC ·2026-09-24 ·Yueqi Wu, Huiping Sun, Peilu Guo, Yiming Zhu, Zhong Chen
unusual similarity 0.56
Abstract

A routing node on the Lightning Network holds its liquidity in separate channels, so a payment can fail at a channel whose outbound balance is exhausted while the node's other channels still hold balance. Pooling the channels into one reserve fixes this only if the node's draws across all channels stay within the reserve: a global invariant that each counterparty must enforce from its own channel, with no shared counter that off-chain draws can update. A node must therefore split the reserve into per-channel quotas in advance or coordinate every draw with every counterparty. On three Lightning snapshots the advance split forfeits $16$ to $67\%$ of the pooling gain over unpooled channels, and the loss grows with channel count. Sluice recovers $19$ to $65\%$ of that loss with a nested reservation: each channel keeps an exclusive base that its counterparty checks alone, and the rest is a shared overflow drawn on with certificates from a capacity-weighted quorum of the node's counterparties. Two conflicting certificates share an honest signer, so over-drawing is prevented without a slashable stake, under a stated bound on the capacity the node controls in the signing set. Sluice loses at most $1.3$ points of payment success to coordination where deployed coin movers lose up to $10.3$, and improves them in eleven of twelve cells when stacked on them. Re-creating every base output each epoch costs $2.8$ to $5.1$ times Lightning's on-chain bytes; re-creating only those that overflowed costs $0.5$ to $1.2$ times and keeps part of the gain.

0.50

What Does It Cost to Force-Close a Lightning Channel? Evidence from 974,000 Channel Closes, 2018-2026

cs.CR cs.NI ·2026-11-12 ·Saurabh Kumar
code/dataunusual similarity 0.56
Abstract · 14 pages, 8 figures, 8 tables. Code and aggregate data: https://github.com/bitcoindatalabs/ln-force-close-costs

Bitcoin's Lightning payment network returns the funds of a channel that cannot close cooperatively through pre-signed transactions whose fees and delays fall on its operators. That fee design is being replaced: Bitcoin Core 31.0 removed the mempool rule anchor channels relied on, and the Lightning specification adopted zero-fee commitments in May 2026. What the old design costs has never been measured across fee regimes. We trace every public channel close and every force close on-chain from January 2018 to October 2026, 973,581 closes, and follow each output to its spend. A separate chain index confirms all 698,476 public closes we could compare. Fee spikes did not bring a wave of force closes. Force closes in a spike week and the next were 0.97 times the four weeks before, against 1.02 after ordinary weeks of the same years. A force close costs 2-6 times a cooperative close in fees and locks the closer's balance for days, which outweighs the fees only in low-fee years. When fees are high, pending payments are exposed: in 2023, 18.2% of HTLC timeouts confirmed more than 40 blocks after expiry. Yet since 2021, forwarding nodes lost only 38 payments, each with the preimage already on-chain. Anchor outputs cut late timeouts in fee spikes (20.6% against 30.5%), yet owners rarely bump commitments with them, and miners take most of what third parties sweep. Zero-fee commitments would save only 12% of the anchor mechanism's block space; they should be judged by how promptly payments resolve when fees spike.

0.59

Scaling the Lightning Network with Practical Set Reconciliation

cs.NI ·2026-08-16 ·Xingyu Chen, Anish Sinha, David Starobinski, Ari Trachtenberg
published similarity 0.53
Abstract · Published in the 2026 IEEE International Conference on Blockchain and Cryptocurrency (ICBC 2026)

The Lightning Network (LN) utilizes gossip to share network topology, channel announcements and updates, and node announcements among its local constituents. Yet, our measurements show that this flooding-based gossip reconciliation is fundamentally inefficient. We propose, instead, to use set reconciliation protocols for sharing this information, and we systematically evaluate existing approaches under realistic network conditions. We further propose ADAPTIVEIBLT, a novel adaptive IBLT (Invertible Bloom Lookup Table) protocol with a partial-decoding enhancement. By simulating reconciliation in Core-Lightning and evaluating real gossip snapshots, we demonstrate the practical benefits of reconciliation in scaling gossip reconciliation from hours down to a few minutes.

0.28

Sociotechnical Aspects of Tor Relay Rejection

cs.CR ·2026-09-14 ·Jules Dejaeghere, Lionel Goffaux, Pierre Luycx, Hosam Elkoulak, Florentin Rochet
similarity 0.53
Abstract · arXiv version, extended from the WPES. 17 pages, 11 figures, 1 table

In 2019, the Tor Project enforced an end-of-life (EoL) policy for Tor versions, leading to the rejection of outdated relays, amounting to a notable fraction of consensus weight. While this policy aids network maintenance, reduces backporting efforts, and shortens vulnerability exposure, its sociotechnical implications remain unstudied. A user study ($N=26$) reveals that relay operators, though not universally aware of the EoL policy, generally view it favorably. Operational practices vary, occasionally excluding newly installed relays from the network. Network simulations, grounded in historical data, assess the policy's immediate impact on Tor clients against common adversaries. Results indicate a marginal adversarial advantage, with network churn (i.e., relays entering and exiting) exerting a more pronounced effect on user anonymity. Security metrics are introduced to evaluate relay contributions against two adversary models, enabling ranking by individual utility and security. Analysis of four exclusion rounds shows that a minority of rejected relays typically account for over 50% of the security provided by all excluded relays. Recommendations for EoL policy implementation are proposed to mitigate potential drawbacks.

0.39

Checking DER Commands Against Grid Context Catches Credentialed Attacks Static Checks Miss

cs.CR ·2026-11-09 ·Benjamin Blakely
similarity 0.53
Abstract

Authorization of distributed energy resource (DER) commands judges a command by who sent it and whether its value has been seen before. An attacker holding a legitimate credential who writes ordinary values passes both tests. We add a check that judges each DER write against the grid's operating context: the bus voltages around the target, the hour, the day- ahead price, system load, and irradiance, compared with what operators wrote under similar conditions in the feeder's own benign history. We evaluate it live on the IEEE 123-bus and 8500-node feeders, driven by a measured 2024 year of price, load, and irradiance, against nine attack scenarios. A lookup trained on the same history catches none of the writes of the four scenarios that send values already familiar on the targeted device; the context check refuses 91.7% of insider-abuse writes and 64.4% of DER-aggregation writes while denying 1.28% of benign writes. In an offline test that replays recorded moments with curtailment setpoints drawn from the benign range, issued at a positive price, it refuses 47.3% and 50.5% on the two feeders, against 18.5% and 16.0% for the same check without context; live, the few setpoints tested were mostly shallow and were mostly allowed. The context check complements the lookup.

0.40

Privacy Failure in Split-LLM Training, The Returned Gradient Nullifies the Decoys

cs.CR cs.DCcs.LG ·2026-09-03 ·Georgios Politis, Evangelos Pappas
similarity 0.51
Abstract

We present a systems-security case study of a two-node split-LLM training system whose privacy evaluation passed while leaving an observable channel untested. The Trusted Local Node (TLN) sends protected activations to the Untrusted Cloud Node (UCN), the UCN returns its output, and TLN, holding the private loss, returns the output gradient. The frame the UCN receives mixes real rows with decoys, and the loss ignores the decoys. Their gradients are exactly zero, so the pattern of zeros reveals which rows were real. We measure it with a protocol fixed in advance: a leak injected at known strength to prove the instrument can see one, a shuffled-label control to prove it does not report absent leaks, and a threshold set before the runs. Across nine seeds, the zeros identified the real rows on every frame, 4,096 of 4,096 per run. An attack on the frame contents recovered about one extra token per hundred over a constant-guess baseline (+0.65 to +1.50 percentage points); the shuffled controls recovered nothing. A second set of runs repeated this on a configuration that keeps model quality within budget, so the finding is not confined to a setting nobody would deploy. On both datasets, every such run passed the forward-channel privacy check and the quality check, yet failed that same check once the returned gradient was included. Clipping and noising each row of the gradient closed the leak for about 0.01 nats of held-out cross-entropy. The system is not thereby safe: five classes of attack, including those accumulating observations across training steps, were never measured.

0.50

Are Unreachable Nodes Truly Safe? Fully Eclipsing Monero's P2P Network!

cs.CR ·2026-09-09 ·Ruisheng Shi, Jiaqi Zeng, Lina Lan, Shihan Zhang, Bing Han +4 more
top venue similarity 0.51
Abstract · Accepted by ACM CCS'26 (The Hague, The Netherlands)

Eclipse attacks isolate a blockchain node by monopolizing its network connections. Existing attacks on Monero (NDSS'25), Bitcoin (USENIX'15/21, S&P'20) and Ethereum (WWW'26) implicitly assume that the adversary can establish inbound connections, thereby excluding a large and practically dominant class of nodes: \textit{unreachable nodes} operating behind NATs. Such nodes are widely believed to enjoy stronger networks. We challenge this assumption and show that unreachability does NOT imply the expected resilience! We present the first eclipse attacks tailored to unreachable nodes in Monero's P2P network. Our attacks require no inbound access to the victim. Instead, they first poison the peerlist of reachable nodes, which subsequently act as propagation relays to contaminate unreachable nodes' whitelists. The adversary then exploits Monero's built-in outbound connection refresh logic to evict benign neighbors and eventually monopolize all outbound connections. We instantiate this strategy in two attacks: Nyx, which targets long-running unreachable nodes and achieves a complete and persistent eclipse through network-wide poisoning; and Moros, a stealthier attack that exploits the bootstrapping phase to rapidly eclipse newly joined unreachable nodes. We ethically evaluate both attacks. Nyx is validated via large-scale simulations on a Monero network constructed using the SEED Emulator, while Moros is demonstrated on the Monero mainnet against controlled targets. Our results show that unreachable nodes can be reliably driven into stable, long-lived eclipse states. We also propose countermeasures.

0.43