CS Paper Radar

Equilibria of Round-Robin: Computational Hardness and Fairness for Few Subadditive Agents

Paul W. Goldberg, Alexandros Hollender, Giannis Tyrovolas

cs.GT cs.CCcs.DS ·submitted 2026-09-16 08:31 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

The round-robin procedure is a simple and well-studied fair division mechanism where agents pick goods in turns. Motivated by draft mechanisms in sports leagues, we investigate strategic behaviour in online round-robin for subadditive agents. This gives rise to an extensive-form game, and we study the computational problem of computing a subgame perfect Nash equilibrium (SPNE). We show that for just two submodular agents, computing an SPNE is $\mathsf{PSPACE}$-hard. Even for the class of $\mathit{OXS}$ utilities, which are a special case of submodular utilities, computing an SPNE remains $\mathsf{NP}$-hard for a small number of agents. We complement our computational results with normative results. We show that for just three additive agents, there exist instances where every equilibrium violates EF1. This separates the online and the direct revelation games. On the positive side, we show that for additive agents every equilibrium allocation is proportional up to one good (PROP1) and for two additive agents it is also EF1. Finally, by showing that round-robin is bossy at equilibrium, we prove that the number of equilibrium allocations can be exponential even if agents have lexicographic preferences.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Revisiting the Fairness of Pure Nash Equilibria of Round-Robin

cs.GT ·2026-10-16 ·Georgios Amanatidis, Haris Aziz, Georgios Birmpas, Federico Fusco, Stefano Leonardi +1 more
theory similarity 0.72
Abstract · Corrects the claim in arXiv:2109.08644 (WINE 2021; Math. Oper. Res. 49(4), 2024) that every pure Nash equilibrium of Round-Robin is EF1. We …

We prove that for additive valuations, not every pure Nash equilibrium of the Round-Robin mechanism induces an allocation that is envy-free up to one good (EF1) with respect to the agents' true valuations. This corrects an earlier claim of Amanatidis et al. (WINE 2021; Math. Oper. Res. 2024). On the positive side, every pure Nash equilibrium of every fixed recursively balanced picking sequence mechanism induces an allocation that is $1/2$-EF1 and proportional up to one good (PROP1). We prove the approximate EF1 guarantee through a potential function comparing two executions, and the proportionality guarantee via a deviation that preserves the agent's most valuable goods. We also give a family of Round Robin equilibria showing that it is not possible to have a strictly better guarantee than $2/3$-EF1 for all equilibria.

0.06

Closing Gaps in Online Fair Division

cs.GT ·2026-09-04 ·Tzeh Yuan Neoh, Nicholas Teh
theoryhighly cited similarity 0.70
Abstract

We study the online fair division of indivisible items, where items arrive one at a time and must be allocated immediately and irrevocably. We address three central open questions in the literature. First, we show that for every $n\ge 2$ agents, every fixed $k\ge 1$, and every $α\in(0,1]$, no online algorithm can guarantee $α$-PROP$k$ against an adaptive adversary. This remains true even when the total number of goods is known in advance, all values lie in $[0,1]$, and every good is positively valued by at most two agents. The impossibility extends to a broad range of standard envy-based, proportionality-based, and share-based fairness notions. We also establish an analogous impossibility for chores. Second, in the setting with predictions, a lightweight form of future information, the maximum item value, was previously known to guarantee only $1/n$-PROP1, leaving open whether the dependence on $n$ is necessary. We give a deterministic $19/30$-PROP1 algorithm against adaptive adversaries that does not require knowing the total number of goods. Given an additional upper bound $κ\in[2,n]$ on the number of agents who value any good positively, the guarantee improves to $\max \{ 19/30, n/(n+κ) \}$. The guarantee remains a positive constant under any fixed one-sided prediction error below one. When predictions are exact and the total number of goods $m\ge n\log n$ is known in advance, a deterministic algorithm achieves the same $19/30$-PROP1 factor together with $O(\sqrt{m\log n/n})$ maximum additive envy after normalizing each agent's values by their maximum item value. Third, against a non-adaptive adversary, we determine the tight high-probability PROP1 guarantee of the classical Like rule, which assigns each good uniformly among the agents who value it positively. Its guarantee improves when fewer agents value the same good, unlike uniform random allocation.

0.43

Temporal Fair Division of Indivisible Mixed Manna: Tractable Settings

cs.GT ·2026-08-20 ·Kui-Wang Choi, Minming Li, Nicholas Teh
highly cited similarity 0.68
Abstract

We study temporal fair division of indivisible mixed manna. Items arrive over time and must be allocated irrevocably; an item may be a good for some agents, a chore for others, and neutral for the rest. We require the cumulative allocation after every round to be envy-free up to one item (TEF1). Although deciding whether a TEF1 allocation exists is NP-hard even for goods, we identify several tractable settings. First, with at most $k$ item types, an online cyclic rule guarantees EF$\lceil k/2\rceil$ after every item arrival. Thus, every instance with at most two types admits an online TEF1 allocation; moreover, when the numbers of agents and types are fixed, TEF1 existence can be decided in polynomial time. Second, under agreement after agent-specific scaling, provided that the scaling factors are known before arrivals begin, an online rule produces an allocation that is EF1 and Pareto optimal after every item arrival. Third, for a two-part arrival sequence with common rankings, we give a rule that is EF1 after every item arrival. Fourth, when the number of agents is fixed and values are bounded integers, we give an exact pseudo-polynomial algorithm for deciding TEF1 existence. Finally, for goods, every TEF1 allocation gives each agent at least $1/n$ of her maximin share after every round; this factor is tight even for identical valuations and two rounds. Deciding whether an exact temporal maximin-share allocation exists is NP-hard for both goods and chores, even with identical valuations, two agents, and two rounds.

0.30

Closing Gaps in Temporal Fair Division for Chores

cs.GT ·2026-11-19 ·Nicholas Teh
similarity 0.68
Abstract

We study the fair division of indivisible chores that must be assigned in a prescribed order. The complete instance is known in advance, but assignments cannot be changed. Temporal envy-freeness up to one chore (TEF1) requires envy-freeness up to one chore after every arrival. For goods, TEF1 allocations need not exist, and deciding whether one exists is NP-hard. For chores, Elkind et al. (AAMAS 2025) showed that TEF1 allocations exist for two agents, but left open whether they always exist, conjecturing that they do not, and whether deciding their existence is hard. We resolve both questions, confirming the conjecture in a strong form: for every $n\ge3$ and every finite factor, some $n$-agent instance admits no allocation satisfying TEF1 even up to that factor. This holds even when all agents have the same multiset of individual chore costs, with nine chores sufficing for three agents. Deciding TEF1 existence is NP-complete for every fixed $n\ge3$, even when all costs lie within a factor $1+2^{-m}$ of one another, where $m$ is the number of chores. Instances without TEF1 allocations exist arbitrarily close to the uniform cost matrix with $O(n\log n)$ chores, and just nineteen for three agents. We then relate fairness to social cost. Even when a TEF1 allocation is supplied, minimizing social cost subject to TEF1 admits no polynomial-time approximation within any factor polynomial in the number of chores unless P$=$NP, already for three agents with strictly positive normalized costs. In contrast, for every fixed number of agents, we give an FPTAS for the optimal temporal EF1 factor, the smallest factor up to which TEF1 can be satisfied, whose output has social cost no larger than that of the cheapest allocation attaining this factor. Thus a slight relaxation of fairness permits a social-cost guarantee that, unless P$=$NP, no polynomial-time algorithm can provide under exact TEF1.

0.27

Simultaneous Envy and Equitability Guarantees

cs.GT cs.AIecon.TH ·2026-08-26 ·Hadi Hosseini, Shraddha Pathak, Lirong Xia, Chengkai Zhang
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 43 pages

Recent work in fair division has focused on either simultaneously satisfying closely related fairness notions or achieving a single notion across the ex-ante and ex-post worlds. We study the compatibility of two fundamentally different fairness notions: envy-freeness and equitability. For indivisible goods-only and chores-only settings, we study the existence and complexity of simultaneously satisfying their relaxations, revealing sharp contrasts between the two settings. For normalized binary goods, we give a polynomial-time algorithm for computing an EF1+EQ1 allocation with at most seven agents, but also construct a normalized instance with a larger number of agents for which no such allocation exists. In sharp contrast, binary chores admit the stronger EFX+EQX guarantee for any number of agents, even without normalization. We further initiate the study of cross-notion ex-ante and ex-post guarantees, asking whether randomized allocations can provide ex-ante guarantees for one notion while preserving ex-post guarantees for another.

0.41

On Existence and Computational Complexity of Quasi-strict Equilibria

cs.GT ·2026-11-04 ·Kristoffer Arnsfelt Hansen, Xinhao Nie
similarity 0.68
Abstract

Quasi-strict Nash equilibrium, introduced by Harsanyi in 1973, is the Nash equilibrium refinement that requires every pure best response to be played with positive probability. Norde established that any bimatrix game admits a quasi-strict Nash equilibrium. We give a substantially simpler proof of this result that in particular avoids an intricate limit argument used in the final step of the proof by Norde. Our existence proof allows us to positively resolve the outstanding open question of PPAD membership of the problem of computing a quasi-strict Nash equilibrium, thereby settling its precise complexity. In games with three or more players, a quasi-strict Nash equilibrium is not guaranteed to exist, leading to the natural problem of deciding the existence of a quasi-strict Nash equilibrium in a given strategic form game. We show that this problem is $\exists\mathbb{R}$-complete, strengthening a previous NP-hardness result.

0.07

Core nonemptiness for $2/3$-convex games

cs.GT econ.TH ·2026-11-12 ·Keisuke Bando, Toshiyuki Hirai, Kenzo Imamura, Ryuhei Mizutani
similarity 0.68
Abstract

We study the core of $2/3$-convex games, a class of transferable-utility (TU) games that generalizes convex games, which requires at least two of any three distinct coalitions satisfy the supermodular inequality. We show that every $2/3$-convex game admits a marginal worth vector in the core, and hence has a nonempty core. Our proof is constructive and yields a linear-time algorithm for finding such a core allocation. We also show that $2/3$-convexity does not imply permutational convexity in general, while the implication holds under an additional superadditivity condition on pairs of singletons. As an application, we introduce a TU model motivated by the OSCE's consensus-minus-two procedure and show that the resulting game is $2/3$-convex but need not be convex.

0.05

Exact Hill Shares Are Simultaneous Guarantees

cs.GT ·2026-09-18 ·Bo Li, Hanyu Li, Chenghua Liu
benchmarktheory similarity 0.67
Abstract

Fair division of indivisible bads seeks allocations that guarantee every agent a bundle whose cost is no larger than a meaningful fairness benchmark. The canonical minimax share has widely been used; unfortunately, it is not a simultaneous guarantee. Hill (Ann. Probab., 1987) initiated a complementary approach in which the share depends only on the number of agents and the largest possible single-item value. Li et al. (ACM Trans. Econ. Comput., 2024) gave the exact Hill formula and proved that its monotone closure is a simultaneous guarantee. The closure treats the largest-item cost only as an upper bound and can be strictly larger than the share conditioned on the \emph{actual} largest item. They asked whether this smaller exact share is itself simultaneously guaranteed for three or more agents. We resolve this open question affirmatively. For any number of agents and arbitrary heterogeneous largest-item costs, there is one allocation that satisfies every agent's exact Hill's share. We further provide a polynomial-time algorithm computes such an allocation. Our algorithm combines an ordered moving knife with a tail-domination invariant, and a one-sided trimmed subset-sum routine for the two-agent endpoint without computing an exact minimax partition.

0.16