CS Paper Radar

Faithful Faithfulness Evaluations: Challenges & Pitfalls Learned from a Breast MRI Case Study

Peachapong Poolpol, Henrik H. J. Detjen, Eike Petersen

cs.CV cs.HCcs.LGeess.IV ·submitted 2026-09-22 10:34 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Saliency maps are widely used to explain deep learning predictions in medical imaging, yet visually plausible explanations do not necessarily reflect a model's true decision process and may therefore mislead clinicians. We investigate this problem using a Vision Transformer-based breast MRI classifier trained on the ODELIA Breast MRI Challenge dataset and evaluate multiple saliency methods, including Last-layer Attention, Attention Rollout, Grad-SAM, Gradient Attention Rollout, GMAR, Grad-CAM, and HiResCAM. Our study highlights two often-overlooked challenges in perturbation-based faithfulness evaluation. First, method rankings depend strongly on the perturbation strategy, varying across intensity-based perturbations and transformer-based attention masking. Second, benchmarking saliency methods requires distinguishing between class-specific and class-agnostic explanations. To enable fair comparisons, we introduce non-class-specific variants of gradient-based methods and evaluate both settings separately. Across protocols, Grad-CAM and Gradient Attention Rollout consistently emerged as the strongest class-specific methods, although their relative ranking depended on the evaluation design. These findings expose important limitations of current saliency-based explainability approaches and highlight the need for more robust and standardized evaluation frameworks for trustworthy clinical AI systems.

Comment
Accepted at MICCAI iMIMIC Workshop 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Learning from the Right Regions: Class-Conditioned Explanation Guidance for Medical Imaging

cs.CV cs.LG ·2026-10-17 ·Zubair Faruqui, Rahul Dubey
similarity 0.73
Abstract · Submitted to the Explainable and Trustworthy AI for Clinical Decision Support Systems Workshop, IEEE BIBM 2026

Deep neural networks can achieve strong predictive performance in medical imaging while relying on regions unrelated to the predicted finding. Explanation-guided learning can address this problem, but multi-label classification introduces a key challenge: multiple abnormalities may coexist in an image, requiring each prediction to align with its corresponding spatial evidence. We propose a class-conditioned explanation-guided learning framework that constructs a separate explanation for each positive class and penalizes evidence outside its class-specific annotated regions. We instantiate the framework using Gradient-weighted Class Activation Mapping (Grad-CAM) and evaluate it on 14 abnormalities using EfficientNet-B1, ViT-B/16, ViT-B/32, and Swin-B. Explanation guidance substantially improves annotation alignment across all architectures: All-Saliency Precision increases from 0.140 to 0.625, 0.052 to 0.551, 0.060 to 0.403, and 0.095 to 0.570, respectively. These improvements are accompanied by smaller, architecture-dependent changes in classification performance. Our results show that class-conditioned explanation guidance can substantially improve where multi-label classifiers concentrate their explanatory evidence while largely preserving predictive performance.

0.10

SAP-ViT: A Self-Attributing Patch Vision Transformer for Medical Image Classification

cs.AI ·2026-10-26 ·Wei Zhang, Wolfgang Nejdl, Ming Tang
similarity 0.71
Abstract

Vision Transformer (ViT) classifiers commonly rely on a global classification (CLS) token for image-level prediction, which is poorly aligned with local interpretability requirements in medical imaging. We propose SAP-ViT, a Self-Attributing Patch Vision Transformer that replaces CLS-based classification with direct aggregation of last-layer patch embeddings. This design makes class predictions decomposable into patch-level contributions as part of the forward pass. To encourage concise and readable evidence, SAP-ViT applies sparsity regularization to the patch-weight distribution. Since self-attention mixes information across patch tokens, we further introduce an input-space back-mapping mechanism to estimate which input patches contribute to influential output patch embeddings. We evaluate SAP-ViT qualitatively and quantitatively on multiple medical image classification datasets spanning different imaging modalities. The results show that SAP-ViT maintains strong classification performance while providing consistent and interpretable patch-level explanations across datasets. Ablation results further show that both sparsity regularization and the alignment component of input-space back-mapping contribute to the final explanation quality. Overall, SAP-ViT provides a favorable trade-off between predictive accuracy and interpretability for ViT-based medical image classification.

0.12

Localization Gains from Explanation Regularization Should Not Be Interpreted as Faithfulness Gains.

eess.IV ·2026-10-19 ·Amrin Akter, Mauro Dalla Mura, Diana Mateus, Dawood Al Chanti
position similarity 0.69
Abstract

Training-time explanation regularization is often evaluated by whether saliency maps become more concentrated within annotated regions. We argue that this criterion alone is insufficient: transformation consistency, lesion localization, and faithfulness to the classifier are distinct properties and should be evaluated separately, particularly in medical imaging. We examine this distinction through a case study of Contrastive Grad-CAM Consistency (CGC) in three-class brain tumor MRI classification. Using a single-channel ResNet-50 with five-fold patient-grouped cross-validation, we compare a cross-entropy baseline with CGC. CGC changes overall Pointing Game (PG) from $27.24\%$ to $36.02\%$ and Relevance Mass Accuracy (RMA) from $11.17\%$ to $18.01\%$, while classification accuracy changes from $93.63\%$ to $94.87\%$. Perturbation-based faithfulness metrics show inconsistent changes: Insertion Area Under the Curve (IAUC) changes from $0.73$ to $0.78$, whereas Deletion Area Under the Curve (DAUC) favors the baseline ($0.36$ versus $0.41$; lower is better), and overall Iterative Removal Of Features (IROF) is $0.57$ for both models. These results support our position that improved spatial agreement with pathology should not be interpreted as a general improvement in explanation faithfulness. We therefore recommend property-specific evaluation in which the property targeted by the explanation objective, spatial agreement with reference regions, and model reliance are measured and reported separately.

0.16

Explaining the Saliency Map Sparsity of Adversarially-Trained Neural Networks

cs.LG math.OCstat.ML ·2026-10-07 ·Yannick Lunk, Atell Yehor Krasnopolsky, Damien Garreau, Leon Bungert
theoryhighly cited similarity 0.68
Abstract

Understanding why deep neural networks make a given prediction is of great importance for their safe deployment. In computer vision, saliency maps, which highlight the image region most influential for a prediction, remain a widely-used form of explanation. An empirical observation is the apparent sparsity of gradient saliency maps of adversarially-trained neural networks. In this paper, we propose a theoretical explanation of this phenomenon for two-layer ReLU networks. We build on the established equivalence of adversarial training to the minimization of the empirical risk with weight-decay penalization and an added adversarial total variation term -- valid for certain loss functions. As the number of data points and neurons grows and the regularization parameters are sent to zero at appropriate rates, we prove that minimizers converge to a Bayes classifier with minimal gradient and Barron norm. Sparsity appears since for adversarial training with $\ell_\infty$-attacks the gradient norm is anisotropic and favors axis-aligned / sparse gradients. We illustrate our theoretical findings experimentally by evaluating the gradient $\ell_1$-norm and thresholded sparsity of naturally versus adversarially trained models.

0.46

Do Saliency Maps Fail Dense Breasts? A Chance-Normalized, Confounder-Aware Audit of Explanation Fairness in Mammography

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-11-04 ·Ahmed Jaheen
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Saliency maps, offered as evidence that mammography classifiers use the cancer, are untested in dense breasts, which can hide cancers. We tested whether they locate cancers worse there, and why. On 1,345 malignant CBIS-DDSM views, we scored three CNNs' Grad-CAM, Integrated Gradients and occlusion maps by whether their peak hits the lesion and a chance-normalized lesion-to-background saliency ratio (bits; +1 doubles it). Unadjusted gaps were large: Grad-CAM peaks hit 44% of dense vs. 58% of non-dense lesions. Case mix, chiefly more calcifications in dense breasts, explained about half or more of each gap. Occlusion kept a significant average of -0.56 bit gap. Controls also implicate the classifiers: unadjusted gaps exceeded an image-only conspicuity map's, and models relied less on dense-breast lesions. We recommend reporting density gaps before and after case-mix adjustment, per classifier, with conspicuity and lesion-reliance controls.

0.28

HiRA-CAM: Preserving Fine-Grained Spatial Relevance in Gradient-Based Visual Explanations

cs.CV cs.AIcs.LGcs.NE ·2026-08-19 ·Manasi Nerurkar, Ali A. Minai
published similarity 0.66
Abstract · IEEE World Congress on Computational Intelligence, Maastricht, Netherlands, June 2026

Deep Learning models can include billions of parameters or more, making it difficult to explain their internal transformations and outputs. However, explainability is increasing in importance due to the use of AI in crucial applications. This paper focuses on the interpretability of convolutional neural networks (CNNs). Building on the popular gradient based method LayerCAM for extracting internal features in CNNs, we propose an improved method named HiRA-CAM, and show that it outperforms both LayerCAM and Grad-CAM on creating useful saliency maps for object classification. The main feature of HiRA-CAM is its adaptive use of activation maps from all the layers of the CNN to arrive at a more focused saliency map.

0.21

Assessing Representation Semantics Under Language Pretraining in Fine-Grained Classification

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-10-20 ·Md Raisul Kibria, Sébastien Lafond
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Understanding how supervision signals shape semantic visual representations remains challenging, particularly in fine-grained, low-data settings. Standard evaluations of vision models rely on downstream accuracy, which often fails to capture structural differences in learned representations. We propose a compact explainability-driven framework for comparing encoders trained with classification-only and caption-generation supervision on CUB-200. Using a controlled two-stage protocol in which both encoders are ultimately optimized for the same classification task, we enable a direct comparison of the resulting representations. Saliency maps are generated using attention rollout and gradient-weighted rollout and evaluated with five metrics covering faithfulness (positive and negative perturbation) and localization (keypoint emphasis, background attribution, and Earth Mover's Distance). Across random seeds and explanation methods, caption supervision yields representations that are more sensitive to the removal of salient regions, better aligned with annotated object parts, and less reliant on background regions, whereas classification supervision produces representations that are slightly more robust to the removal of low-saliency regions. An ablation study on the Oxford-IIIT Pet dataset shows consistent trends across key metrics. These results demonstrate that the proposed framework makes supervision-induced representational differences observable and quantifiable beyond downstream accuracy alone. More broadly, it provides a systematic basis for assessing learned representations and comparing alternative training and transfer-learning strategies.

0.18

SpurCon: Weighted Supervised Contrastive Learning for Mitigating Spurious Cues in Medical Imaging

cs.CV ·2026-08-18 ·Shenhav Nadir, Meir Yossef Levi, Eyal Gofer, Guy Gilboa
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Despite the rapid progress of deep neural networks in visual recognition, their adoption in high-risk medical applications remains limited due to reliability and robustness concerns. Models may exploit spurious correlations, particularly in medical imaging, where devices or treatment artifacts often co-occur with pathology. In small or imbalanced datasets, such cues further reduce worst-group performance and undermine clinical trust. To solve these issues, two major challenges should be addressed: identifying dataset-specific spurious cues, which typically require domain knowledge, and mitigating reliance on them. To tackle both, we propose SpurCon, a lightweight framework based on a novel supervised contrastive loss formulation that leverages available metadata and predicted spurious labels to enhance robustness. We introduce a fast few-shot procedure, without network training, to estimate spurious labels using a small number of expert-annotated samples. We then propose a weighted supervised contrastive objective, WtSupCon, that reshapes the representation geometry by assigning sample-specific weights that depend on the [pathology, spurious, metadata] combination. For example, the highest weight is assigned to samples that differ only in their spurious label. This yields highly similar representations for images with the same metadata and pathology, differing only in the predicted spurious label. Our method operates on pretrained image encoders (such as BiomedCLIP) and trains only a lightweight projection head. We evaluate SpurCon on a synthetic setting and on Waterbirds, CheXpert, a chest X-ray classification dataset, and ISIC 2020, a skin cancer classification dataset. Our approach delivers the best spurious-mitigation performance, balancing well worst-group and overall accuracy on multiple datasets.

0.16