CS Paper Radar

When Accuracy Gaps Fail to Certify: Auditing Cross-Domain Recalibration of LLM Judges

Fariya Afrin, Ibne Farabi Shihab

cs.LG ·submitted 2026-08-23 06:51 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

A scalar recalibration map fitted for an LLM judge on one task can fail when the task distribution changes, but the source-target accuracy gap is often treated as a proxy for that failure. We test what this gap can predict and what it can certify across thirteen judges, two generators, eight domains, and 1,176 predeclared transfers. After accounting for mean score shift, the gap yields a population lower bound on target calibration error, yet identical gaps can induce opposite transfer outcomes. Exact importance weighting recovers target proper loss under covariate shift, so failure of an estimated weighting pipeline does not by itself establish conditional shift. A finite-sample simultaneous lower certificate converts the population bound into a one-sided rejection rule using audit labels disjoint from evaluation outcomes. The leak-free gap correlation is 0.25 (95% CI [-0.09, 0.55]), falls to 0.09 on the second generator, and does not support a generator-invariant association. The certificate retains nominal coverage but has power 0.13 even at m=1024, whereas target-domain temperature scaling with 16 labels reaches harm rate 0.09, compared with 0.34 for source-fitted Platt scaling. Accuracy gaps are therefore weak warning signals for scalar probability transfer, not deployment certificates.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

ProxyGuard: Direct Reliability Inference for Randomized Data Release Mechanisms with Shared Targets

cs.LG stat.MEstat.ML ·2026-08-19 ·Dipesh Tharu Mahato, Pramod Dhungana
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Researchers often choose a proxy dataset from many releases, transformations, or seeds. Search can make an invalid release appear adequate, while one adequate release does not establish that its generator is reliable. ProxyGuard controls both errors using prespecified bounded risks and a sealed target set. Named-release mode corrects for multiplicity and certifies specific releases. Direct shared-target mode evaluates independent mechanism draws on a common target, lower-bounds their favorable-score rate, and subtracts a bound on favorable scores contributed by invalid releases. Conditional on the target, release scores are independent, yielding a finite-sample mechanism-reliability guarantee without independent target batches or assumptions on release-level $p$-value dependence. We show that the mean-only penalty is sharp and derive a smooth-score certificate with additive target concentration. In a registered three-requirement study, direct mode raises power from $5.6\%$ to $64.2\%$ at reliability $0.95$, while named mode remains stronger under high-signal evidence. Prospective audits span full-pipeline Rice--TVAE, which retrains on every draw, and a non-tabular text mechanism.

0.28

LLM-as-a-Judge Version Shift: The Instrument Changed, Not the Standard

cs.CY cs.CL ·2026-09-07 ·Guijia Zhang, Harry Yang
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 25 pages, 5 figures, 14 tables

Automated research pipelines increasingly rely on fixed LLM judges to rank, filter, and revise proposals, yet these judges are routinely replaced by newer versions. We study whether such replacements preserve the underlying measurement standard. Using a preregistered, frozen-weight design, we evaluate three adjacent same-family transitions across Qwen, Gemma, and Mistral on frozen ML research proposals under randomized information conditions. The common assumption that newer judges are simply harsher fails: two transitions shift toward greater leniency, while the third shifts in the opposite direction on anchors but attenuates off-anchor. More importantly, version changes can alter not only score location but also criterion geometry and resolution; one transition collapses clean-flawed discrimination, placing 93% of pool scores on a single value. Supplying identical facts does not close the version gap, placebo-controlled interventions show that observed packet effects are largely format-driven rather than content-driven, and global recalibration repairs the mean while explaining little object-level dispersion. We organize these failures with a measurement model in which a judge replacement can change its origin, criterion geometry, or resolution. A small stratified anchor audit of about 200 calls identifies the failure class before deployment, and frozen thresholds correctly diagnose two post-registration API judge replacements. We release six preregistration locks and the full audit trail of 14882 judge calls.

0.45

Auditing Failure Attribution: Label Predictability and Judge Behavior

cs.CL cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-10-13 ·Tianyang Xu, Jing Gao
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 26 pages

Failure-attribution benchmarks ask an LLM judge which step or agent caused a failure. A high score should mean the judge checked the faulty step against the run (a cross-step check). However, spurious signals (surface cues) that predict the annotation can produce a high score. In this paper, we propose four tests to separate checking from cue use. Input restriction asks whether partial input predicts the annotation. Cue following checks whether moved cues change answers. Residual accuracy scores judges where cue-only predictors fail. Aggregation asks whether the failure mix or metric changes rankings. Real observations motivate these tests: on three benchmarks, simple predictors match or beat GPT-4.1. In two Who&When Pro systems, a classifier reading one step's reasoning finds 95-100% of faulty steps, motivating input restriction. In one of them, error injection leaves no reasoning after the faulty step; judges fine-tuned on its labels beat GPT-4.1 by 41 points. Adding task-related reasoning after that step moves this cue: fine-tuned judges lose 31-99 points, but zero-shot judges lose at most 9, motivating cue following. On Aegis, blaming every agent matches GPT-4.1 on micro-F1 but trails by 19 points in exact-set accuracy, motivating aggregation. We recommend reporting these tests when developing failure-attribution benchmarks.

0.47

Testing-Driven Reliability Audit of Trajectory-Based Early Outcome Prediction for LLM Agents: Target-Specific Calibration Transfer Persists Within a Single Benchmark

cs.AI ·2026-09-22 ·YanZe Cao
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract · 26 pages, 4 figures, 3 tables

Predicting early outcomes based on trajectory can decrease the expenses associated with agent evaluation by terminating a run once the outcome becomes sufficiently predictable, assuming that the predictor's confidence is properly calibrated. Calibration is at risk when a predictor is applied to an agent on which it was never trained, but it is not known whether such transfer failures are broad across agent systems or concentrated in specific target agent/head combinations. Using public SWE-bench Verified trajectories and a frozen dual-head early-outcome prediction pipeline, we ran a leave-one-agent-out calibration audit, a shared-predictor leave-two-agents-out control, oracle prior correction, and a robustness battery over training cohorts, task resampling, task halves, jackknife, and thresholds. Fixed-scaffold TerminalBench analysis served as a pre-registered boundary test. Broad same-predictor pairwise heterogeneity was not supported; the median pairwise corrected-gap differences were 0.0180 (SUCCESS head, 45 pairs) and 0.0385 (FAILURE head, 35 pairs), and the pre-registered heterogeneity criterion was not met on either head. Two specific combinations, gpt-5-mini/SUCCESS and claude-opus-4.6/FAILURE, showed persistent calibration-transfer errors (median corrected gaps 0.1377 and 0.1107) without a sign reversal under any frozen control. TerminalBench did not establish cross-benchmark replication: the success target produced zero decisions (INDETERMINATE), and the failure target did not satisfy the pre-registered persistence criterion. Therefore, a strong target-specific calibration-transfer error can exist within one frozen environment, but the evidence does not establish that the error is intrinsic to the model or general across benchmarks.

0.52

Can We Trust LLM Judges: A Study of Capability-Dependent Biases and Multi-Judge Ensemble for Bias Calibration

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-09-10 ·Gemma Zhang, Prachi Badarayani, Asmi Kumar, Sadid Hasan, Sulaiman Vesal
similarity 0.61
Abstract

LLMs are increasingly used as automated judges for model training and evaluation, yet individual judges exhibit systematic biases that undermine reliability. Much of prior work has studied biases in pairwise LLM-as-a-judge settings; in this paper, we focus on absolute scoring tasks, which mirror more realistic use cases. Across four benchmarks and six models (36 judge-examinee pairs), we show that a model's task accuracy strongly predicts its judging accuracy (Pearson $r \geq 0.90$ on most models) and inversely predicts its directional bias ($r \leq -0.83$), but that accuracy alone does not ensure fair evaluation: more capable examinee models consistently receive more lenient judgments from all judges ($r \geq 0.83$). To address this, we propose calibrated weighted majority voting (WMV), an ensemble evaluation method that aggregates multiple LLM judges weighted by online estimates of their false-positive and false-negative rates. We introduce a disagreement-based estimator that derives these error rates purely from inter-judge agreement patterns, requiring no ground-truth labels or task metadata. In a simulated experiment with shifting task distributions, our label-free WMV tracks an oracle with perfect error-rate knowledge to within 0.5 percentage points on average, outperforming both individual judges and unweighted majority voting. These results demonstrate that principled multi-judge calibration can simultaneously improve accuracy and correct for systematic leniency without requiring labeled data, offering a scalable path to reliable automated evaluation as model capabilities increase.

0.12

Clean Engineering, Unstable Measurement: A Preregistered Reliability Failure of Black-Box LLM Observers on Shared Endpoints

cs.AI cs.LG ·2026-09-03 ·Haoyaun Zhu, Jie Zhang
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Language-model judges now gate training data, score generations, and drive leaderboards. The judge is then a measurement instrument, resting on one rarely stated assumption: the same request, sent to the same model name, reads the same tomorrow. We audited that assumption in two preregistered campaigns with every threshold fixed in advance; neither got past validating its instrument. Across 52,988 audited request attempts, same-window repeat rankings agreed at Spearman 0.400 against a required 0.90, and byte-identical next-day replays agreed at 0.78 against a required 0.99, each time with the execution record at ceiling. Three mechanisms explain the gap: a label-to-meaning mapping that biased readouts as strongly as the signal; candidate gaps seven orders of magnitude below the instrument's own noise floor; and byte-identical inputs returning different rankings, a noise that exact-permutation readouts compound. Neither metric substitution nor sampling repaired it on the tested grid. Preregistered follow-ups bound the problem: waiting did not help on the days sampled (0.805 versus 0.800, replicated over five further days); switching providers did not help (four providers share the floor, medians 0.74 to 0.88, predicted by none of the metadata fields they expose); self-hosting on batch-invariant kernels helped only while the server was quiet; and on constructed errors with known gaps, the readout's separation tracks error type, not size. We distill the evidence into a three-level snapshot-identity ladder, eight design rules, and a reporting checklist; a pilot at roughly 2% of the study's call volume would have exposed both unreachable gates in advance. All results concern externally measured behaviour on shared serving infrastructure. On a shared endpoint, a model name is not a frozen instrument; a preregistered evaluation must measure its instrument before freezing any gate on it.

0.39

Certified Selective Automation of LLM Agent Evaluation

cs.CL ·2026-09-28 ·Chengguang Gan, Yunhao Liang, Qinghao Zhang, Shiwen Ni
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Evaluating LLM agents still ends with a human reading trajectories, because automatic judges carry no guarantee on how often they are wrong. We ask the operational question: what fraction of agent evaluation can a judge take over, with a certificate that the error rate among auto-decided trajectories stays below a budget alpha? Agent corpora resist the standard answer: many agents attempt the same tasks, so trajectories arrive in correlated clusters, and the i.i.d. certificates of existing selective-judging methods can overstate what is safe: a naive certificate can claim 98% automation while its realized error exceeds the budget in 17.5% of task resamples. We introduce a task-level bootstrap certificate that is valid in every regime we test while matching the naive certificate's coverage; finite-sample cluster-valid alternatives certify nothing at realistic task counts. Under this certificate, a 4B logprob judge trained with SFT and reject-weighted GRPO certifies 0.30-0.59 of evaluation on tool-use and web corpora at alpha=0.1, the only judge, among strongly elicited frontier models, certifying on both headline corpora. Certified coverage is predictable before training from base rate and discrimination alone (leave-one-corpus-out R^2=0.96). Finally, the certificate doubles as a self-training filter: pseudo-labels harvested inside certified regions have contamination bounded by alpha by construction (realized 0.000-0.041 across six harvests), letting a judge enter an unseen domain at in-domain strength with zero target training labels.

0.25

Conditional Accuracy Profiles: Diagnosing LLM Judges across Deployment Conditions

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-10-06 ·Wenqi Li, Bin Liu, Mindi Ruan, Chuanbo Hu, Minglei Yin +1 more
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.59
Abstract

LLM-as-judge is now a standard tool for scalable evaluation, but judge performance is still often summarized by a single accuracy number. This aggregate view hides the deployment conditions under which a judge succeeds or fails. We introduce \textbf{Conditional Accuracy Profiling} (CAP), a post-hoc diagnostic framework that decomposes pairwise LLM-judge accuracy into eight conditions organized into content sensitivity, robustness, and rationale quality. CAP is benchmark-agnostic: it can be applied directly when a benchmark provides the required annotations, approximately through task-subset proxies, or through controlled augmentation when perturbation pairs can be generated. We instantiate CAP on seven LLM judges across six pairwise judging benchmarks, including \textsc{judgerEva-Standard}, a controlled testbed we created to support all eight conditions. CAP exposes profile differences hidden by aggregate accuracy: on \textsc{judgerEva}'s judge-independent Hard-Constructed subset, the two judges most sensitive to omitted qualifications rank in the bottom three of seven by overall accuracy, so omission sensitivity is not predicted by aggregate accuracy. Across benchmarks, Position Robustness shows the strongest rank stability (mean Spearman $\barρ{=}0.87$) but is itself fragile under JudgeBench-Pro adversarial stress, showing the largest mean accuracy drop among the shared conditions, though the dominant degradation channel varies by judge. Condition-level profiles provide a more actionable basis than aggregate accuracy for selecting LLM judges.

0.29