CS Paper Radar

LLM-as-a-Judge Version Shift: The Instrument Changed, Not the Standard

Guijia Zhang, Harry Yang

cs.CY cs.CL ·submitted 2026-09-07 08:30 UTC · v1

Abstract

Automated research pipelines increasingly rely on fixed LLM judges to rank, filter, and revise proposals, yet these judges are routinely replaced by newer versions. We study whether such replacements preserve the underlying measurement standard. Using a preregistered, frozen-weight design, we evaluate three adjacent same-family transitions across Qwen, Gemma, and Mistral on frozen ML research proposals under randomized information conditions. The common assumption that newer judges are simply harsher fails: two transitions shift toward greater leniency, while the third shifts in the opposite direction on anchors but attenuates off-anchor. More importantly, version changes can alter not only score location but also criterion geometry and resolution; one transition collapses clean-flawed discrimination, placing 93% of pool scores on a single value. Supplying identical facts does not close the version gap, placebo-controlled interventions show that observed packet effects are largely format-driven rather than content-driven, and global recalibration repairs the mean while explaining little object-level dispersion. We organize these failures with a measurement model in which a judge replacement can change its origin, criterion geometry, or resolution. A small stratified anchor audit of about 200 calls identifies the failure class before deployment, and frozen thresholds correctly diagnose two post-registration API judge replacements. We release six preregistration locks and the full audit trail of 14882 judge calls.

Comment
25 pages, 5 figures, 14 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Anchoring Bias in LLM-as-a-Judge Systems: Prior Scores Compromise Evaluation Independence

cs.CL ·2026-08-26 ·Ante Kapetanovic, Kemal Altwlkany, Andro Mercep, Tomislav Duricic, Emanuel Lacic
top venuehighly cited similarity 0.66
Abstract · 10 pages, full research paper, to appear in proceedings of the 35th ACM International Conference on Information and Knowledge Management (CI…

Large language models (LLMs) increasingly assess generated content, giving rise to the LLM-as-a-Judge paradigm. These systems now score outputs, filter content, and gate iterative refinement in production pipelines, where each judgment is often assumed to be independent of earlier evaluations. We test this assumption using three prompt conditions: no metadata, revision framing, and anchored metadata containing revision, attempt, and prior-score fields. We show that prior scores, even when included only as context metadata, anchor judgments and systematically shift ratings toward their values. Across 192,000 attempted evaluations (185,271 successful), seven out of the eight evaluated models have 95% task-stratified bootstrap intervals below zero for the total anchored-metadata effect on 20 fixed texts. Cohen's $d$, a standardized measure of the difference between score distributions, reaches an absolute value of 0.71. Token-level analysis of selected model-task probes suggests a threshold-like response pattern: introducing anchored metadata produces a marked redistribution of output-score probabilities, while changing the anchor value within the tested below-threshold range produces comparatively little additional variation. On categorical industry data with human-labeled ground truth, anchored metadata blocks 48% of error corrections and flips 10.18% of correct judgments toward an assigned wrong label, demonstrating the bias extends beyond numerical scoring to categorical decisions. Neither Chain-of-Thought nor a metadata-disregard warning reduces the total effect, although the warning improves the paired accuracy effect relative to baseline in the industry experiment. Reliable LLM evaluation demands careful context engineering rather than an assumption of impartiality. Effective mitigation must be validated for the intended model and task or domain.

0.67

When Accuracy Gaps Fail to Certify: Auditing Cross-Domain Recalibration of LLM Judges

cs.LG ·2026-08-23 ·Fariya Afrin, Ibne Farabi Shihab
theory similarity 0.65
Abstract

A scalar recalibration map fitted for an LLM judge on one task can fail when the task distribution changes, but the source-target accuracy gap is often treated as a proxy for that failure. We test what this gap can predict and what it can certify across thirteen judges, two generators, eight domains, and 1,176 predeclared transfers. After accounting for mean score shift, the gap yields a population lower bound on target calibration error, yet identical gaps can induce opposite transfer outcomes. Exact importance weighting recovers target proper loss under covariate shift, so failure of an estimated weighting pipeline does not by itself establish conditional shift. A finite-sample simultaneous lower certificate converts the population bound into a one-sided rejection rule using audit labels disjoint from evaluation outcomes. The leak-free gap correlation is 0.25 (95% CI [-0.09, 0.55]), falls to 0.09 on the second generator, and does not support a generator-invariant association. The certificate retains nominal coverage but has power 0.13 even at m=1024, whereas target-domain temperature scaling with 16 labels reaches harm rate 0.09, compared with 0.34 for source-fitted Platt scaling. Accuracy gaps are therefore weak warning signals for scalar probability transfer, not deployment certificates.

0.26

Can LLMs in Draft-Verify-Revise Pipelines Resolve Deictic Ambiguity?

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-09-10 ·Obinna I. Ekekezie
code/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · 86 pages including supplementary materials, 4 figures, 10 supplementary figures, 17 supplementary tables, 11 supplementary exemplars. Code a…

Draft-verify-revise is a common LLM orchestration pattern for scaling inference-time compute. One LLM drafts, a second critiques the draft and provides feedback, and a third uses that feedback to revise the draft into the final output. As context cascades between stages, LLMs at different stages can resolve a context-dependent expression such as "previous" differently. When that happens, the expression undergoes a deictic shift, a change in what it refers to. This phenomenon was studied with a synthetic dataset of 10 base examples, each rendered in three conditions. Holding the shared components constant, the conditions varied whether the draft stage LLM (the assistant) or the verify stage LLM (the grader) resolved the expression correctly, and how much independent reasoning the revise stage LLM (the meta-evaluator) needed to determine which reading was correct. Six models from three providers were tested across 21 reasoning effort configurations using e-values for sequential testing, in a primary experiment and an ablation experiment that removed error classification labels from the grader's feedback. A separate LLM analyzed the meta-evaluator's stated rationale for each wrong verdict. Balanced accuracy (the unweighted mean of sensitivity and specificity) ranged from 0.156, below chance, to near-perfect. GPT-5.2 rose from 0.156 without reasoning to 0.942 at its highest reasoning effort level, while Gemini 3 Pro stayed above 0.94 at every level. Gemini 3 Pro at low reasoning effort outscored GPT-5.2 at xhigh reasoning effort for roughly 5% of the cost per trial. When the meta-evaluator erred, it tended to rely on surface cues rather than operational reasoning. Context engineers implementing draft-verify-revise pipelines should be wary of deictic shifts and make the intended referent explicit at each stage.

0.42

Debiasing as a Measurement Intervention: Calibrated Ties and Resolution Loss in LLM-as-a-Judge Evaluation

cs.DL cs.AI ·2026-09-11 ·Liang Zhao, Yong Wang, Jiangzhe Chen
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted at Emnlp 2026

LLM-as-a-judge protocols are commonly debiased by instructing judges to ignore presentation cues such as citation formatting, source labels, and evidence-display style. We show that this intervention can suppress bias while damaging the resolution of the measurement instrument. We introduce TraceJudgeBench, a diagnostic benchmark for auditing citation-like artifacts in RAG and agent-workflow evaluation, covering content-equivalent pairs, citation ablations, correctness conflicts, human-validated soft and moderate quality gaps, prompt-strength ladders, decoupled judging, and a controlled workflow-ranking probe. Across GPT-5.5, Claude Sonnet 4.6, and DeepSeek V4-Flash, stronger anti-citation prompts reduce worse-cited wins from up to 50.5% to 0%; yet some operating points already convert validated moderate-gap decisions into Tie before the strict stress-test endpoint, while correctness-conflict accuracy remains at or above 93.0%. A second, 50-pair FinQA moderate-gap construction reproduces the qualitative frontier, and open-weight Qwen2.5-14B-Instruct-AWQ and Gemma-3-12B-IT runs reproduce the central HotpotQA frontier. TRACE-style decoupling recovers 96.5-100.0% better-plain resolution across the reported settings. Human validation separates three meanings of Tie: correct equivalence Tie, calibrated soft-boundary Tie, and resolution-destroying Tie on validated quality gaps. We frame debiasing as a measurement intervention whose bias suppression, resolution retention, Tie cost, and protocol cost must be reported jointly. The supplementary artifact contains benchmark splits, prompts, raw judge outputs, validation summaries, and analysis.

0.37

Phantom Gains: Auditing Self-Improvement Against a Measured Null

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-08-20 ·Cheng Xu, Nan Yan, Liming Chen, M-Tahar Kechadi
code/datahighly cited similarity 0.63
Abstract · Code and evaluation artifacts are available at https://github.com/chengxuphd/phantom-gains

Whether a language model has improved itself is increasingly judged not by mean accuracy but by which individual problems it gains and loses. Tracking these transitions means differencing two noisy estimates, leaving them vulnerable to measurement artifacts. Auditing three rounds of rank-$32$ LoRA self-training on Qwen3-8B against a frozen control pushed through the identical pipeline, we identify seven measurement failures, each of which inverts a reported finding when its control is absent. Several are standard practice. A ledger built on a single greedy decode manufactures capability changes on an untrained model, largely an artifact of inference batching; the expansion statistic separating acquisition from sharpening assigns that same model a rate of $0.280$. The natural threshold repair does not survive replication: estimated across the frozen comparisons such a design already contains, its null stays non-zero. We replace it with a per-problem exact test against a pooled baseline under false-discovery-rate control, which detects nothing on any held-out replicate and is unchanged under the multiple-testing rule, error rate and pool size. Applied to a ladder of arms matched in stream, volume and evaluation, the audit finds that external distillation improves problems the base model rarely reaches while three forms of self-training do not; a regression rejects this asymmetry as a by-product of distillation's larger overall gain ($p < 10^{-8}$). On the far smaller set of problems the base model never reaches, the evidence is inconclusive, while self-training corrupts problems solved at baseline at rates well above the measured floor. Transition-level auditing therefore requires a separately measured null for every statistic it reports: nulls that cost no new experiments, built from baseline replicates a multi-arm study already owns, though not from as few as most possess.

0.66

Pinned and Still Unstable: Within-Judge Verdict Variance and the Noise Floor of LLM-as-Judge Leaderboards

cs.CL ·2026-09-27 ·Krishna Chytanya Ayyagari
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract · v2: corrects reporting details (claim provenance, candidate generation cap, top-K ties, data completeness, abort threshold, model aliases) a…

Modern LLM evaluation assumes that pinning a judge to a fixed model version and decoding at temperature zero yields reproducible verdicts. We show this assumption fails as a property of how LLM-as-Judge is operationalized on cloud serving infrastructure, not of any particular model family. Across four frontier judges served via a single major enterprise cloud platform and three standard benchmarks (Arena-Hard, AlpacaEval 2, MT-Bench), identical inputs to the same temperature-zero judge, at a constant serving-reported model version, produce different verdicts across re-runs: per-item flip rates of roughly 5% on average and about 40% on the close-call items that decide leaderboard margins, with a per-judge magnitude spanning a 40x range (0.13% to nearly 10%). We introduce metrics tailored to this instability: per-item flip rate, a two-part stability profile (waver fraction and conditional intensity), and adjacency separability. For the principal judge the aggregate ranking is stable (0% top-K instability, 0% pooled winner flip); what degrades is precision: under a paired hierarchical bootstrap, roughly one-fifth to three-quarters of adjacent leaderboard positions are statistically indistinguishable, a noise floor driven mainly by finite prompt sampling rather than the judge. Across judges, leaderboards agree on the coarse ordering but diverge in the middle (Kendall's tau of 0.42-0.64 between Gemini and Sonnet judges on Arena-Hard, values sensitive to answers truncated at the generation cap). Of 15 expected head-to-head orderings we re-judge, 12 survive every re-run of the principal judge but only 8 survive every judge. Leaderboards thus report unhedged point estimates that overstate their precision. We propose a minimal, low-cost reporting protocol: several judge re-runs, published stability profiles and adjacency intervals, and results under at least two judges from different families.

0.59

The Impact of Backbone Evolution on LLM-Based Relevance Assessments

cs.IR ·2026-10-07 ·Chuting Yu, Guido Zuccon, Teerapong Leelanupab
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 12 pages main content

LLMs are evolving rapidly, with newer models offering stronger capabilities. This suggests that in LLM-based relevance judging, more capable models will achieve higher agreement with human judgements under the same prompt. We challenge this understanding by investigating the behavior of LLM-based relevance judges under backbone evolution. Keeping the prompts fixed, we evaluate a representative single-prompt (UMBRELA) and a rubric-based prompt (EXAM) across sequential model versions of commercial (Gemini, GPT) and open-weight (Qwen, Llama) models. Overall, we find no consistent evidence that newer versions lead to better relevance judges. Crucially, similar or improved aggregate performance does not imply judgment stability: correct judgements made by an earlier version of an LLM backbone are not necessarily preserved by later versions. We investigate the potential drivers of these regressions. Our findings caution against the assumption that judging prompts designed and validated for one backbone version will perform equivalently or better when the model is updated, even within the same family.

0.23

Conditional Accuracy Profiles: Diagnosing LLM Judges across Deployment Conditions

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-10-06 ·Wenqi Li, Bin Liu, Mindi Ruan, Chuanbo Hu, Minglei Yin +1 more
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.60
Abstract

LLM-as-judge is now a standard tool for scalable evaluation, but judge performance is still often summarized by a single accuracy number. This aggregate view hides the deployment conditions under which a judge succeeds or fails. We introduce \textbf{Conditional Accuracy Profiling} (CAP), a post-hoc diagnostic framework that decomposes pairwise LLM-judge accuracy into eight conditions organized into content sensitivity, robustness, and rationale quality. CAP is benchmark-agnostic: it can be applied directly when a benchmark provides the required annotations, approximately through task-subset proxies, or through controlled augmentation when perturbation pairs can be generated. We instantiate CAP on seven LLM judges across six pairwise judging benchmarks, including \textsc{judgerEva-Standard}, a controlled testbed we created to support all eight conditions. CAP exposes profile differences hidden by aggregate accuracy: on \textsc{judgerEva}'s judge-independent Hard-Constructed subset, the two judges most sensitive to omitted qualifications rank in the bottom three of seven by overall accuracy, so omission sensitivity is not predicted by aggregate accuracy. Across benchmarks, Position Robustness shows the strongest rank stability (mean Spearman $\barρ{=}0.87$) but is itself fragile under JudgeBench-Pro adversarial stress, showing the largest mean accuracy drop among the shared conditions, though the dominant degradation channel varies by judge. Condition-level profiles provide a more actionable basis than aggregate accuracy for selecting LLM judges.

0.29