CS Paper Radar

A Procedure for Classifying Attachments and Affective Social Bonds in Human-Robot Dyads

Imran Khan, Elisabeth Blagrove

cs.HC cs.RO ·submitted 2026-09-24 05:52 UTC · v1

Abstract

Human-robot interaction (HRI) claims that people form attachments and social bonds with artificial agents, yet the terms are often applied without the behavioural and physiological criteria that give them content in their source disciplines. Without this empirical grounding, studies deploy widely divergent methods, frequently producing expansive relational claims that far outstrip their underlying evidence. To address this, we propose a standardised four-question procedure, grounded in criteria established in the developmental, ethological, and neuroendocrine literatures, that classifies a given human-robot tie as an attachment, an affective social bond, or no relationship, with intermediate classifications when evidence is incomplete. We specify minimum evidential requirements for each question, and provide candidate HRI study designs, adapted from validated human-human, human-animal, and animal-animal paradigms. We then demonstrate the procedure by applying it to a representative set of published HRI studies, showing how often relational claims outstrip what the reported designs can establish. Finally, we discuss the ethical and regulatory burdens created when artificial agents engage human biobehavioural systems. By replacing the divergent operationalisations with a unified, criterion-based classification, this paper gives HRI practitioners a standardised basis for evaluating, classifying, and comparing human-robot relationships, and sets out the experimental rigour that each classification demands. We therefore call on researchers of human-robot relationships to adopt such rigour, or to consider alternative terminology in their descriptions of these ties.

Comment
25 pages plus references; in review

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A Robot Among People:From Social Imitation to the Social Becoming of Human Groups

cs.RO cs.CYcs.HC ·2026-09-11 ·Victor Tuan Vu Pham, Judith Dörrenbächer, Thomas H. Weisswange, Marc Hassenzahl
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Robots designed to mediate human groups often fall into the solutionist trap: they are framed as sociable agents that fix problems such as conflict, disengagement, or lack of coordination. We suggest a different way of thinking. Rather than discrete agents, robots can be understood as situated elements of shared environments; catalysts and carriers of group experience whose meaning emerges through how people position, interpret, and interact with them. From this perspective, robots are not there to repair some ostensible dysfunctionality, but to enable group-level sense-making around care, norms, and identity. Our prior work on robotic street furniture suggests that this does not happen by imitating human sociality but by taking the shape of deliberately constrained, group-facing entities that happen and act for \textit{us} without being socially entangled as one of us. We thus understand robots in public spaces not in terms of autonomy or intelligence, but as a relational capacity. This implies designing robots not in our image or for our utility, but grounded in our needs in being and becoming together.

0.09

Why did My Robot Just Change Personality? Prompting Guidelines for a Grounded Robot Persona in LLM-Based HRI

cs.AI cs.HCcs.RO ·2026-08-21 ·Ashita Ashok, Franziska Babel, Patrick Holthaus, Rucha Khot, Karla Bransky +5 more
publishedsurveyposition similarity 0.61
Abstract · Accepted for publication at the 35th IEEE International Conference on Robot and Human Interactive Communication (RO-MAN 2026)

Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used for verbal interaction in social robots, yet prompt design in human-robot interaction (HRI) remains underspecified. As a result, robots may present hallucinated capabilities, unclear behavioural boundaries, and misleading personas. This paper develops a framework for prompt design in LLM-based robots and introduces a structured prompt template comprising eight functional components through which robot behaviour can be specified, bounded, and adapted. The framework is grounded in a review of prior LLM-based HRI work and complemented by survey and discussion data from HRI experts gathered at the Robo-Identity workshop at IEEE RO-MAN 2025 (N=27). The qualitative findings highlight limited legibility of robot personality, the need for user adaptation, and strong ethical concerns about safety, deception, and governance. Based on these findings, we present prompting guidelines accompanied by proof-of-concept template as a structured design and reporting aid for HRI research. We argue that prompt design should be treated as a socio-technical problem rather than a minor implementation detail, requiring explicit capability boundaries, transparent behavioural assumptions, and context-sensitive safeguards to support reliable and interpretable HRI.

0.33

Synchrony, Affect, and Perceived Autonomy in Virtual Robot-Facilitated Anxiety Support Groups

cs.HC ·2026-11-16 ·A'di Dust, Mohammad Soleymani, Mina Kian, Maja Matarić
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 17 pages, 7 figures

Socially assistive robots could expand access to group-based mental health support when skilled human facilitators are unavailable. However, their effectiveness will depend on whether they foster productive interactions among participants. We examined dyadic head-movement synchrony among 96 participants across 18 virtual robot-facilitated anxiety support group sessions. A human-controlled virtual robot, via a Wizard-of-Oz (WoZ) system, facilitated all sessions. We found that stronger peak synchrony predicted lower post-session negative affect. In contrast, speakers who more often followed listeners' movements reported higher negative affect and state anxiety, demonstrating that synchrony strength and direction capture distinct interpersonal processes. Participants who believed the robot was autonomous showed more genuine synchrony and stronger peaks than those who believed it was human-operated; more negative attitudes toward robots also predicted greater synchrony. These findings support synchrony as an objective, behaviorally grounded measure for evaluating robot-facilitated groups and a potential signal for guiding future autonomous facilitators.

0.19

InterSocialBench: Benchmarking Human and LLM Preferences for Companion-Robot Social Behavior

cs.RO ·2026-09-14 ·Yaodan Xu, Boyang Guo, Yuqing Gu, Qingxin Zhang, Yiwen Deng +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.59
Abstract · 6 pages, 4 figures, 3 tables

Companion robots face everyday situations in which several feasible behaviors may be appropriate, yet different people prefer different responses. We introduce InterSocialBench, a benchmark of 210 domestic scenarios and 18 high-level behaviors, pairing judgments from 100 human participants with 23,520 responses from seven large language models under 16 personality conditions. Each human annotation preserves a preferred action alongside explicitly appropriate and inappropriate candidates. A structured construction pipeline covers behavioral alternatives, competing situational cues, and relevant history and future tasks. Evaluation distinguishes preferred-choice agreement from explicit rejection, using scenario-grouped splits for trainable predictors. Simple frequency and persona-voting baselines illustrate these objectives. Across the tested prompts, model and human behavior distributions differ, and the diversity gap remains after matching response counts: humans exhibit 4.68 distinct choices per scenario, compared with 2.06--3.46 for the models. Human scenario-level plurality agreement is 51.5%, describing disagreement rather than a universal prediction ceiling. InterSocialBench supports evaluating social behavior selection without replacing individual judgments with a single consensus label.

0.23

Understanding Human-Robot Collaboration through Joint Action

cs.HC cs.RO ·2026-10-27 ·Chengwen Zhang, Jianyang Wang, Chang Liu, Yukun Wang, Yuan Xu +4 more
survey similarity 0.59
Abstract · 26 pages, 5 figures, 32 tables

Human-robot collaboration requires partners to coordinate interdependent contributions toward a shared goal. Joint Action theory provides concepts for understanding this coordination, but how these concepts are instantiated and combined across empirical research remains fragmented. We conducted a systematic review following PRISMA 2020, identifying 83 empirical papers published between 2021 and 2026. Through theory-driven framework analysis, we organized the literature into nine constructs across three capacities: Representation, Prediction, and Integration. We analyze how these constructs are distributed and co-occur across studies, revealing where empirical evidence concentrates and where it is absent. By mapping empirical HRC research onto a unified Joint Action framework, this review offers a coherent overview of HRC studies, identifies gaps in current evidence, and provides guidelines for future research.

0.29

Designing Social Robots for Social-Cognition Training with Autistic Adults

cs.HC cs.RO ·2026-08-19 ·Yuval Zohar, Mordi Benhamou, Guy Laban
publishedhot direction similarity 0.59
Abstract · Accepted for publication at the 35th IEEE International Conference on Robot and Human Interactive Communication (RO-MAN 2026)

Social robots have been widely explored as tools for autism intervention, yet this literature has focused predominantly on children and has rarely involved autistic adults as active contributors to design. This creates a mismatch between existing systems and the social-cognitive challenges autistic adults actually face in everyday life, including navigating ambiguous interpersonal contexts, managing conversational timing, and interpreting implied emotional meaning. To address this gap, we conducted an online focus group and co-design session with five autistic adults to explore what a social robot for social-cognition training should do, how it should interact, and under what conditions it would be genuinely useful. The 90-minute session combined open discussion with structured co-design activities on a shared digital whiteboard, and the resulting verbal and visual data were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. The analysis yielded seven themes that define core design requirements: the robot should function as a scaffold rather than a substitute, prioritise authenticity over comfort, provide personalised and user-controlled feedback, accommodate emotional self-awareness gaps, respect privacy and contextual boundaries, support rehearsal for real-world social situations, and remain configurable in identity, form, and expression. Together, the findings suggest that autistic adults envision the robot not as a companion or live social assistant, but as a private, configurable rehearsal partner designed to support independence over time.

0.37

Understanding Engagement and Intrusiveness in Assistive Human-Robot Interaction Using Individual Traits

cs.RO ·2026-09-18 ·Valerio Bo, Lavinia Hriscu, Alberto Sanfeliu, Anaís Garrell
publishedposition similarity 0.59
Abstract · Accepted for publication at the 35th IEEE International Conference on Robot and Human Interactive Communication (RO-MAN 2026)

Robot assistance is particularly crucial in unfamiliar tasks, where users must understand task requirements while coordinating with the robot. Previous research offers mixed evidence on the role of robot proxemics in user engagement: some studies suggest closer proximity enhances interaction, while others report it can feel intrusive. In this work, we argue that perceptions of intrusiveness depend not only on proxemics but also on the frequency of robot interventions, and are strongly influenced by individual traits such as personality and demographics. We conducted an experiment with 32 participants who interacted with two assistive robots that provided similar task support but differed in their intervention strategies. Results indicate that overall engagement remains stable across conditions, yet affective responses and perceived intrusiveness vary significantly with personality traits. Moreover, personality shapes interaction dynamics differently depending on the robot's behavior. These findings emphasize that effective human-robot interaction should account for individual differences, tailoring robot behavior to maintain engagement while respecting each user's unique affective and behavioral profile.

0.41

Beyond Tasks: A Vision for Reproducing an Animal-like Behavioral Substrate Using Modern Robot Learning Techniques

cs.RO cs.AIcs.HC ·2026-09-27 ·Samiyuru Menik, Hemadri Jayalath
positionhot direction similarity 0.58
Abstract · Vision paper

Recent advances in robot learning have produced increasingly capable embodied agents. Yet comparatively less attention has been given to a more basic form of competence that animals exhibit continuously: the ability to remain situated, responsive, and behaviorally coherent as physical, environmental, and social demands change over time. We propose the ethological behavioral substrate as a conceptual lens for studying this form of competence in artificial agents. Rather than treating these behaviors that animals exhibit as a set of isolated skills, we argue that their continual coordination under competing demands constitutes an important and underexplored target for modern robot learning. We further propose robotic animal companions as a useful research setting for studying sustained interaction and adaptation in human-centered environments. Such systems provide an opportunity to investigate how social behavior, memory, and continual learning develop over long periods of interaction. This perspective motivates further investigation of how such persistent behavioral competence may complement higher-level capabilities in embodied agents.

0.32