CS Paper Radar

Understanding Human-Robot Collaboration through Joint Action

Chengwen Zhang, Jianyang Wang, Chang Liu, Yukun Wang, Yuan Xu, Zhoutong Ye, Jie Cai, Chun Yu, Yuanchun Shi

cs.HC cs.RO ·submitted 2026-10-27 14:20 UTC · v1
survey

Abstract

Human-robot collaboration requires partners to coordinate interdependent contributions toward a shared goal. Joint Action theory provides concepts for understanding this coordination, but how these concepts are instantiated and combined across empirical research remains fragmented. We conducted a systematic review following PRISMA 2020, identifying 83 empirical papers published between 2021 and 2026. Through theory-driven framework analysis, we organized the literature into nine constructs across three capacities: Representation, Prediction, and Integration. We analyze how these constructs are distributed and co-occur across studies, revealing where empirical evidence concentrates and where it is absent. By mapping empirical HRC research onto a unified Joint Action framework, this review offers a coherent overview of HRC studies, identifies gaps in current evidence, and provides guidelines for future research.

Comment
26 pages, 5 figures, 32 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

A Scoping Review and Experimental Study on Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback for Human-Robot Collaboration

cs.HC cs.AIcs.RO ·2026-10-07 ·Alexandra Coroiu, Andrea Vogt, Viktor Werbilo, Andreas Poppele, Johann Christensen +1 more
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Human-Robot Collaboration (HRC) can facilitate mass customisation in Industry 4.0, with Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) representing a promising approach for developing safe AI-based robots. Practical challenges remain regarding safety during AI development, human feedback quality, and bidirectional human-robot adaptation. We conducted a scoping review of RLHF in HRC systems, mapping methods that address these challenges. Following PRISMA guidelines, we screened 199 records and included 20 peer-reviewed publications (2020-2025) spanning multiple HRC domains. To our knowledge, this is the first review focused on the bidirectional, closed-loop design of RLHF. Our review found multiple feedback modalities enabling data collection in various feedback formats. Collected data can be integrated at different stages of AI training, resulting in a multi-step development process. Pilot experiments are commonly used to evaluate HRC systems based on both human and robot metrics. To empirically test a key gap identified in the review, we conducted a between-subjects VR experiment comparing system- and user-initiated feedback on robot proxemic behaviour for safe navigation. Using Bayesian models, we analysed the relation between the collected feedback and safety metrics: psychological safety (post-experiment questionnaire) and physical safety (inverse time-to-collision). Results show that user-initiated feedback captures perceived safety better than system-initiated feedback, indicating that feedback timing directly affects feedback quality. Our review and experiment findings show that RLHF relies on appropriate feedback methods to ensure AI safety in HRC, and future RLHF research should prioritise realistic HRC experiments evaluating the effects of feedback collection methods on relevant human and robot metrics.

0.13

Examining the Difference in Human Behavior Between Virtual and Real-World Human-Robot Teaming

cs.RO cs.HC ·2026-09-16 ·Sean Dallas, Absalat Getachew, Motaz AbuHijleh, Andrea Macklem-Zabel, Douglas Zytko +2 more
published similarity 0.60
Abstract · 8 pages, 2 figures, 1 table, IROS 2026

Prototyping and evaluating human-robot teaming (HRT) scenarios in the real-world is costly. Virtual simulation of HRT scenarios has been adopted as an alternative to conducting user studies in the real-world to investigate user perceptions, behaviors, and performance during human-robot interactions. The consistency of human behavior between the real and virtual-worlds is integral to the validity of utilizing such virtual experimentation. This paper presents a user study examining the difference in human behavior between an HRT scenario conducted in a virtual vs real environment. We employed mixed-methods to examine team performance and human factors during the HRT. Our quantitative results showed a significant difference in workload between the two modalities. Our qualitative analysis expanded on the quantitative results and found differences in participants' strategy, their mental model of robots, and the type of trust they had for robots between modalities.

0.36

A Procedure for Classifying Attachments and Affective Social Bonds in Human-Robot Dyads

cs.HC cs.RO ·2026-09-24 ·Imran Khan, Elisabeth Blagrove
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 25 pages plus references; in review

Human-robot interaction (HRI) claims that people form attachments and social bonds with artificial agents, yet the terms are often applied without the behavioural and physiological criteria that give them content in their source disciplines. Without this empirical grounding, studies deploy widely divergent methods, frequently producing expansive relational claims that far outstrip their underlying evidence. To address this, we propose a standardised four-question procedure, grounded in criteria established in the developmental, ethological, and neuroendocrine literatures, that classifies a given human-robot tie as an attachment, an affective social bond, or no relationship, with intermediate classifications when evidence is incomplete. We specify minimum evidential requirements for each question, and provide candidate HRI study designs, adapted from validated human-human, human-animal, and animal-animal paradigms. We then demonstrate the procedure by applying it to a representative set of published HRI studies, showing how often relational claims outstrip what the reported designs can establish. Finally, we discuss the ethical and regulatory burdens created when artificial agents engage human biobehavioural systems. By replacing the divergent operationalisations with a unified, criterion-based classification, this paper gives HRI practitioners a standardised basis for evaluating, classifying, and comparing human-robot relationships, and sets out the experimental rigour that each classification demands. We therefore call on researchers of human-robot relationships to adopt such rigour, or to consider alternative terminology in their descriptions of these ties.

0.33

Pluralistic Human-Robot Interaction: Designing for Robot Interaction with Diverse Communities

cs.HC cs.CYcs.RO ·2026-08-17 ·Raj Korpan
similarity 0.57
Abstract · Accepted to the Broadening the Users - A Cross-Disciplinary Roadmap for Social Humanoid Interaction (BU-SHI) Workshop at IEEE RO-MAN 2026

Social robots are being developed for homes, schools, and other environments where they will interact with diverse users. While Human-Robot Interaction (HRI) research often emphasizes natural communication, engagement, personalization, and task success, these goals do not fully address the social complexity of real-world deployment. This paper proposes \emph{Pluralistic HRI}, a framework for designing social robots that treat human diversity as a foundational design concern. The framework brings together pluralism, civic dialogue, perspective-taking, empathy, intercultural competence, cultural humility, and moral imagination to guide inclusive, adaptive, and ethically grounded interaction. We outline how pluralistic HRI can inform design, evaluation, and deployment in diverse human communities.

0.38

When "No Worries" Went Wrong: HRI Lessons for Foundation-Model Robots

cs.RO ·2026-10-28 ·Eliahu Khalastchi
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 8 pages, 5 figures, 1 table. Submitted to IEEE Robotics & Automation Magazine

When a person declined our robot's invitation to play, Alice turned her shoulder away and said "No worries, it's all good." Only after a brief pause did she drive off. The words and gestures were plausible but their order changed the message. In another episode, Alice informed a host that his visitor had arrived---while the visitor stood right beside him. Both came from a three-year ROS 2 HRI consortium that integrated large language and vision models as they emerged. Today's foundation models give robots broader capabilities to perceive their surroundings, reason about situations and generate behavior. Yet capability alone does not ensure that a changed situation shapes the action that reaches a person. Evidence may never be acquired, or a purpose or constraint may fail to survive planning and execution. A system may even report Success when an action no longer serves its intended purpose. Drawing on the consortium's engineering experience, we develop five design lessons about attention, knowledge, commitments, embodied timing and action authority. We then introduce TRACE, a lightweight review that changes one interaction premise, follows it to a decision or enforcement boundary, and produces an actionable architecture finding. A bounded analysis of a published LLM-generated behavior-tree system illustrates how an available clarification mechanism can go unused. The engineering lesson is to preserve accountability boundaries, not the computational pipelines that once exposed them.

0.19

Awaken-HI: Scaling Humanoid Intelligence with Whole-Body Human Experience

cs.RO cs.AIcs.CV ·2026-11-19 ·EngineAI
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · project page: https://engineai-robotics.github.io/Awaken-HI

A central goal of humanoid robotics is for robots to perform the everyday work people do in homes and workplaces. Existing egocentric video datasets cover many of these activities but provide little synchronized whole-body motion data for learning loco-manipulation at scale. We build Awaken-Human, which pairs approximately 50,000 hours of egocentric stereo video with synchronized whole-body human motion and covers more than 100 skills. Building on this, we also introduce Awaken-HI (Humanoid Intelligence), a vision-language-action model for humanoid loco-manipulation that jointly predicts original human motion and retargeted robot actions through a shared action expert. We show that loco-manipulation skills transfer more effectively from people to humanoids when human trajectories directly supervise the shared action expert. Increasing human pretraining data reduces held-out robot action prediction error according to an empirical scaling law and raises the mean success rate on downstream real-robot tasks. After full-corpus pretraining and T800 adaptation, Awaken-HI achieves a mean success rate of 93.75% across eight individual tasks and outperforms GR00T N1.7 and $π_{0.5}$ in both individual and long-horizon evaluations. The same policy generalizes to objects unseen during robot post-training and to new pairings of familiar objects and destinations.

0.33

Evaluating Social Reasoning in Embodied Vision-Language Models

cs.RO cs.HC ·2026-10-20 ·Daniel Weiner, Raj Korpan
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.55
Abstract · Accepted at Workshop on Foundation Models for Multi-Robot Systems (FM-MRS), IROS 2026

Foundation models now serve as reasoning layers for robot teams, but it remains unclear whether embodiment-specialized vision-language models (VLMs) preserve the social-reasoning capabilities of general-purpose VLMs. We evaluate Gemini Robotics-ER on SHREC, a benchmark of real human-robot social interactions, and compare it with published general-purpose VLM baselines. Robotics-ER outperforms GPT-4o-mini on error/competence detection but performs worse on detailed social-attribute judgments; adding a visual frame helps one task while hurting the other. These results suggest embodiment-specialized models may perform differently on social judgments that can be read more directly from observable interaction cues versus those requiring more inference about a person's internal state. Because the comparison spans model families, these differences cannot be attributed to embodiment specialization alone. This matters for multi-robot systems, where a shared foundation model could cause systematic social-perception errors to influence multiple coordination decisions. This work presents an initial evaluation, with broader cross-context and video-based analyses left for future work.

0.26

Visual Proactivity: Enhancing Human-Robot Collaboration Through Intent Communication

cs.RO ·2026-09-18 ·Valerio Bo, Edison Bejarano, Anaís Garrell, Alberto Sanfeliu
top venue similarity 0.55
Abstract · Accepted for publication at the 2026 IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA)

As robots transition from performing repetitive tasks to collaborating with humans, understanding human intent becomes crucial to effective interaction. Anticipation enables robots to predict human actions, while proactivity allows them to take initiative and guide human behavior toward optimal outcomes. Although research has largely focused on how robots infer and respond to human intentions, less attention has been paid to how robots communicate their own intent. This paper introduces visual proactivity, a novel, simple yet effective approach that enables robots to communicate their intentions through visual feedback, influencing human behavior and enhancing transparency and fluency. We develop and evaluate proactive robotic behaviors in a human-to-robot handover scenario, where a user study validates human perception of reactive, anticipatory, and proactive behaviors. The results demonstrate that effective visual proactivity fosters better alignment and coordination, paving the way for more intuitive human-robot collaboration.

0.46