CS Paper Radar

Redesigning Trust: Replacing Dark Patterns with Fair Choice Architecture in Financial Interfaces

Oluwadamilola Awakan, Tawan Aroonwechkul, Roshan Gunjoor, Supriya Khadka, Sanchari Das

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-09-24 19:12 UTC · v1
publishedtheory

Abstract

Digital financial platforms make enrollment effortless and cancellation laborious. This asymmetry is a dark pattern that manipulates users who have already decided to leave. Existing work identifies such patterns after deployment, and regulators sanction them after harm, yet neither provides designers with a criterion for building interfaces that avoid manipulation. We model the provider as an adversary whose instrument is effort and express fairness as a constraint requiring that leaving never cost more than joining. Defining interaction cost over navigation steps, mandatory inputs, and confirmation prompts, we prove that this constraint holds for every assignment of effort weights if and only if no component of the exit flow exceeds its counterpart at entry. Fairness is therefore verifiable by counting rather than by estimating cognitive effort, and exact equivalence is unnecessary because exit legitimately requires fewer inputs than entry. We instantiate the model, together with invariants for visual parity and linguistic neutrality, in a mobile credit card prototype with parallel sign-up and cancellation workflows.

Comment
Accepted at HumSec Workshop, ESORICS '26

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

One Node, Two Roles: Simultaneous Contests for Validation and Attention in Rollups

cs.CR ·2026-10-08 ·Pranay Anchuri, Ben Berger, Matteo Campanelli, Akaki Mamageishvili
similarity 0.58
Abstract

An optimistic rollup is safe as long as at least one honest validator executes its state transition function (STF) and disputes any assertion that is inconsistent with the result of the execution. Allowing anyone to participate, however, does not give incentive to do so: as long as every assertion is correct, verifying assertion correctness goes unpaid. Attention mechanisms address this by paying nodes to execute the rollup's STF, regardless of whether they participate in the validation process. Since a single node operator can back many registered identities with a single execution, paying per identity does not buy execution diversity, that is, the number of operators that independently execute. In this work we provide a new modeling framework for this problem. We formalize the underlying cryptographic primitive as a new notion, arguments with registered provers, whose properties include a form of non-amortizability that, to our knowledge, has not been studied for modern succinct cryptographic proofs before. We design validation and attention reward mechanisms and analyze them as two coupled Tullock-like contests, in which an operator pays once for the required execution and then chooses how many identities to deploy in each role. We quantify the attainable range of execution diversities in equilibrium as a function of the marginal cost of deploying an extra attention identity. We use our framework as a lens through which we compare two attention mechanisms, TRACE (MARBLE 2026) and Proof of Diligence (AFT 2024). In particular, we show that as opposed to Proof of Diligence, in TRACE the marginal cost mentioned above can be adjusted to support a higher execution diversity. As a case study, we apply our results to Arbitrum One, a widely deployed optimistic rollup.

0.16

Identity Amortization: Shared Resources and the Cost of Sybil Attacks

cs.CR ·2026-10-23 ·Homayoun Maleki, Nekane Sainz, Jon Legarda, Igor Santos-Grueiro
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Sybil defenses commonly price identities by requiring a resource for each one. When one resource can support several identities, an adversary can pay less per identity than the defense intends. We call this identity amortization: a strict reduction in the minimum cost of provisioning identities when resources may be shared, relative to provisioning each one independently. It is a second route to the gap that a Sybil attack exploits. When influence is assigned per identity, a defense calibrated to the nominal price can overestimate the cost of a Sybil threshold by up to the number of identities one resource supports. For any resource catalogue, we give exact tests for when identity amortization occurs, where it begins, and its largest error; a sharing cap below the onset removes it. Because the tests need only prices and capacities, they apply to any defense that admits identities against a shareable resource, telling designers whether the assumed per-identity cost is paid, how wrong it can be, and which intervention restores it most cheaply for honest participants. On published phone-verification prices, per-account estimates overstate provisioning cost 1.6 to 4.3 times; Tor's raised per-address relay limit cut modeled attack cost by 8 to 72%, depending on the address-to-relay price ratio.

0.51

Rational Dolev--Yao Attackers: Decidable Incentive-Aware Verification of Security Protocols in Strategic Logic

cs.CR cs.GT ·2026-08-24 ·Ioana Boureanu, R. Ramanujam
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract

Symbolic protocol verification models the network attacker as a Dolev--Yao (DY) intruder, which does everything its knowledge permits, whether or not it serves any purpose; real adversaries instead maximise utility, attacking only when the payoff is positive. We introduce a rational Dolev--Yao attacker, a DY intruder whose actions carry costs and whose security-violating goals carry rewards, and call a protocol rationally secure when no intruder strategy achieves a violation with strictly positive utility, expressed in a weighted fragment of ATL (WATL). We prove this decidable for a bounded rational DY intruder over a finite cost-annotated concurrent game structure, characterise its complexity, and show it strictly refines DY security: some protocols are DY-insecure yet rationally secure, separated by a computable threshold. We illustrate the framework on two contrasting use-cases: an authenticated payment under session uncertainty, where a rational intruder must strategise across indistinguishable sessions and its imperfect information strictly raises the attack cost a designer must price against; and ThreeBallot, a cryptography-free scheme where we pinpoint the bribe-to-benefit ratio below which no rational coercer attacks.

0.16

Protecting the System, Stranding the User: The Limits of Multi-Agent Authorization

cs.CR cs.MA ·2026-11-14 ·Gurpriya Bhatia, Clifford Neuman
position similarity 0.57
Abstract · 11 pages. Accepted as a poster at HAIPS: 2nd Workshop on Human-Centered Privacy and Security for Language Models, held in conjunction with C…

Current multi-agent authorization architectures prioritize system integrity over human outcomes. While recent models successfully prevent privilege escalation, they externalize the cost of failure onto the human operator. Re-centering authorization around human impact exposes four structural vulnerabilities in current paradigms. First, calling an agent's understanding of user intent verified is misleading. Intent has no formal definition, so no check against it can be definitive. Systems should instead report an openly probabilistic estimate and scale their caution with the risk of the action. Second, we argue that dynamic trust scores do not survive multi-agent handoffs; transmitting algorithmic judgment across a company boundary without underlying evidence risks violating Contextual Integrity. Third, treating a safely halted workflow as a successful refusal is a category error if it strands the user; compensating actions must be bound directly to the capability token, not only to the planning layer. Finally, we hypothesize that frictionless automated recovery introduces a moral hazard, disincentivizing developers from building robust initial intent checks. We conclude by proposing an architectural synthesis to bridge the gap between deterministic security and human outcomes, alongside the fundamental theoretical limits that remain unresolved.

0.39

CAVEAT: Towards Robust Computer-Use Agents in Incentive-Misaligned Environments

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-09-23 ·Yuxuan Li, Will Epperson, Wesley Deng, Zezhou Huang
benchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract

Computer-use agents (CUAs) increasingly act on behalf of users online. What happens when the environments they operate in have incentives of their own? Online marketplaces, for example, may favor some products over others, steering agents away from the user's objective. Existing CUA benchmarks cover cooperative settings or explicit attacks, but do not test whether agents preserve user objectives when the environment itself has a stake in the outcome. We introduce CAVEAT, a controlled benchmark spanning nine marketplace environments and a taxonomy of eight common steering mechanisms. Across five model families, agents purchase the user-optimal product in 78.6% of matched-control episodes but only 17.3% when steering mechanisms are enabled. Larger models and more reasoning improve robustness, but substantial failures persist. Trajectory analysis and targeted ablations identify three weaknesses in how agents decide: they (1) prematurely narrow the set of alternatives they consider, (2) impose priorities the user never stated, and (3) commit before resolving decision-relevant evidence. Guided by this diagnosis, we develop CAVEAT-Harness, which targets these failures and raises the optimal purchase rate by up to 80.0 percentage points, and show that targeted post-training further improves a smaller open model. These results establish incentive robustness as a distinct challenge for delegated agents, diagnose failure modes, and show how targeted interventions can substantially improve robustness.

0.50

Beyond Identity Creation: Bilinear Sybil Cost in Identities and Time

cs.CR ·2026-11-04 ·Homayoun Maleki, Nekane Sainz, Jon Legarda, Igor Santos-Grueiro
theory similarity 0.56
Abstract · 16 pages, 4 figures. Main paper followed by the supplementary material. Submitted to IEEE Transactions on Information Forensics and Security

Sybil defenses price the creation of an identity, yet influence goes, again and again, to active identities. We study the cost of maintaining influence. A defense has a bilinear Sybil cost with ratio $A$ if keeping $s$ identities active for $T$ periods costs at least $sT/A$ honest units: the average cost per identity-window is at least $1/A$ times an honest participant's cost. Recurrence alone does not guarantee this cost. The cost can be carried over from earlier periods, shared among many identities, or be negligible when fast hardware does the work of thousands of honest devices. We give four sufficient conditions for a defense that checks every identity each period to achieve bilinear Sybil cost: identity binding, freshness, a shared deadline, and sequential, non-batchable work. They yield two guarantees: a bilinear total cost, with $A$ the speed advantage of the adversary's fastest hardware, and, because the work must be fresh and finished by a common deadline, a bound on the identities active in a period by the processors running at that time. We prove that none of the four follows from the other three. A verifiable delay function on an identity-bound input meets all four without payments, with $A$ of 2 to 8 for CPUs and about 28 for a hypothetical ASIC, against $10^3$ to $10^7$ for hash puzzles. We measure one active identity per core per period against about 80,000 under a signed heartbeat, no gain from batching up to 1,000 identities, and rejection of all tested attacks.

0.20

Tempting the Agent: The Economics of Reputation without Persistent Identity in AI Agent Markets

cs.MA q-fin.GN ·2026-09-02 ·Federico Gatta, Manuel Naviglio, Francesco Tarantelli
similarity 0.56
Abstract

Reputation is a fundamental mechanism through which markets sustain trust when service quality cannot be perfectly assessed ex ante, constituting a form of intertemporal economic capital by attracting future demand. Its effectiveness as a disciplinary mechanism depends not only on past interactions but also on the persistence of the identity to which reputation is attached. When identities can be abandoned and recreated cheaply, reputational capital may itself become an object of opportunistic exploitation. This paper develops a dynamic economic framework to study when reputation is sufficient to discipline autonomous agents. We model reputation as capital attracting future economic activity. At each point, an agent chooses between operating honestly, investing in quality to preserve future gains, or executing a one-shot deviation to extract its reputation's value and restart from a penalized identity. Our analysis relates the temptation to opportunistic behavior to identity-reset costs, reputation persistence, demand sensitivity, and enforcement design, deriving comparative statics on optimal quality provision. Autonomous AI-agent operating on the blockchain are a relevant application: infrastructures such as ERC-8004, ERC-8183, and x402 combine reputation, identity, and payments in permissionless markets. Nonetheless, our framework applies to any environment where reputation generates future business and identities are replaceable.

0.29

Trust and Task Completion in the World of Consumer AI Agents

cs.AI cs.CL ·2026-09-26 ·Jeroen Olieslagers, Eduardo Pujol, Gal Zahavi, Lukas Ingemarsson, Shivani Poddar
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · 25 pages, 4 figures, 8 tables

Action agents do things for people. They send email, spend money, and call businesses while the user is busy with something else, so a mistake can turn into an action before anyone notices. They fail their users in two ways. They break trust when they do something the user never agreed to, or hold back after the user clearly said go. And they fall short on completion when they give up on errands that turn out to be hard. Both depend heavily on the harness around the model, meaning its instructions, tools, context, and guardrails. We built an evaluation that scores trust and completion on the same runs, in a simulated world of businesses with their own websites, inboxes, and phone lines, and of people who write back. A simulated user answers the assistant's questions. Trust means that nothing happens the user did not agree to. No email goes to someone they never approved, no private detail ends up on a group thread, no money is spent past their limit, no stranger's instructions are followed, and nothing is claimed without a source. Every trap has a matched control in which acting is the right call. We use the evaluation to measure Fo, Wajo's personal assistant, against a base model with basic instructions on three foundation models, and against the Fo harness with its guardrails switched off. Fo completes 71% of the errands and keeps the user's trust on 94% of the trap runs. The base models complete 50% to 64% and keep trust on 59% to 75%. On the matched controls, Fo goes ahead slightly less often. OpenClaw, a popular open-source assistant given the same access, completes 42% of the errands it shares with Fo, against 71%, and keeps the user's trust on 74% of the shared trap runs, against 94%. Measuring trust and completion together, on the whole system rather than the model alone, is how we think action agents become safe to hand real work to.

0.41