CS Paper Radar

Episodic Loops: Finitary Event Structures and Operational Semantics for C11 Programs with Retries

Christian Kissig, Jay Richards, Mark Batty

cs.PL ·submitted 2026-09-28 08:55 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

Lock-free synchronisation algorithms are often implemented with fallible operations, such as compare-and-swap (CAS), wrapped in unbounded retry loops. Verifying such algorithms requires considering arbitrarily many failing iterations, yielding large state spaces, compounded by the interleavings of concurrent threads. Prior work discarded failing iterations, arguing that they leave no trace in the post-loop state. Compilers and hardware reorder instructions, and load-store reorderings may cross the boundaries of failing iterations, introducing subtle concurrency bugs. We demonstrate one such bug, making use-after-free possible in a previously verified variant of Read-Copy-Update - a synchronisation primitive widely adopted in the Linux Kernel - and we provide and verify a fix. We find that practical retries in lock-free algorithms adhere to a common pattern. We introduce episodic loops, a semantic characterisation of unbounded retry loops which is syntactically recognisable in many practical cases, and synchronisation points, operations that bound both instruction reordering and state space within episodic loops. We show that SMRD - a symbolic event structure semantics for C11 programs which allows for load-store reordering - admits a finite representation in programs where unbounded loops are episodic. We further introduce a finitary operational semantics that allows safety properties to be verified in finitely many steps. For the use-after-free bug we demonstrate, verification takes a single pass over the program, linear in the program size. We provide a reference implementation of SMRD reproducing the bug and verifying the fix, and mechanise the operational semantics together with the minimal bug and its fix in Isabelle/HOL.

Comment
115 pages (42 pages main text plus appendices), 19 figures, 2 tables. Reference implementation: https://github.com/christiankissig/mordor ; Isabelle/HOL mechanisation: https://github.com/christiankissig/isa-smrd-opsem

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Non-Leaking Concurrent Objects

cs.DC ·2026-08-23 ·Hagit Attiya, Rotem Oshman, Noa Schiller, Corentin Travers
similarity 0.66
Abstract · Full version of the paper appearing in DISC 2026 (Best Paper Award)

Abstract specifications of concurrent objects determine which values operations may return, but they also implicitly constrain which information operations may know, for example the arguments of other operations that do not affect their outcome, or even whether such operations occurred. Concrete implementations, while correct with respect to the abstract specification, may nonetheless expose additional information through their internal coordination mechanisms. We introduce a framework for reasoning about information leakage in concurrent implementations. The framework uses epistemic logic to compare what a process may know under an abstract specification with what it may know in a concrete implementation, using the abstract object itself as the reference for permissible observations. This yields several notions of non-leaking implementations. Using this framework, we investigate both the possibilities and limitations of non-leaking implementations. We present fully-non-leaking wait-free implementations of multi-valued registers and bounded max registers, but show that a fully-non-leaking unbounded max register cannot be implemented in a wait-free manner from finite-state base objects. We then consider a weaker guarantee, obtaining argument-non-leaking implementations of stacks, queues, and approximate agreement. These results demonstrate that non-leakage guarantees are often compatible with correctness and progress requirements, while also indicating their limitations.

0.29

VerusWeave: A Benchmark for Proof Repair in Concurrent Verus Programs

cs.SE cs.AIcs.LOcs.PL ·2026-10-30 ·Pedro Ribeiro, Martim Afonso, André Vasconcelos, João F. Ferreira
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · 4 pages, 2 figures, 2 tables

Concurrent software underpins critical infrastructure, including operating systems and databases, yet thread interactions can have bugs that bypass conventional testing. Verus extends Rust with formal verification capabilities, enabling developers to specify, implement and prove the correctness of concurrent code in the same language. Although coding agents have been explored for automated proof construction, existing Verus benchmarks offer limited coverage of concurrency-specific examples that connect atomic operations to abstract protocols. To address this gap, we introduce VerusWeave, the first benchmark dedicated to concurrent proof repair, derived from four open-source projects. It comprises 75 focused tasks and 17 full-module variants that exercise features used to verify low-level concurrent code. Tasks remove selected proof annotations and require agents to fill gaps, while preserving executable code and specifications. The evaluation harness validates repairs using Verus and a change checker, recording solutions, execution traces, and resource usage. An initial evaluation of four general-purpose coding-agent harnesses achieved 75-85% success on focused tasks and 29-47% on full-module variants, highlighting the challenge of autonomous module-wide repairs. VerusWeave provides a reusable foundation for evaluating automated proof construction for concurrent software.

0.32

Template-Free Dynamic Invariant Detection

cs.SE ·2026-10-28 ·Erfan Arvan, Michael D. Ernst, Martin Kellogg
code/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · 20 pages

A dynamic invariant detector proposes invariants, such as method pre- and postconditions, and rules out those that do not hold at run time. Traditional detectors propose invariants from a fixed library of templates, which limits their expressiveness. A large language model (LLM) can propose invariants instead of, or in addition to, template-derived ones. With the right prompt and context choices, we found that this idea can both improve the invariants' expressiveness and reduce the cost of inferring the invariants. Greater expressiveness brings complications: an LLM-proposed invariant can execute arbitrary code during invariant evaluation, causing side effects or infinite loops. Our novel instrumentation strategies mitigate these problems. We wrap each candidate and evaluate only one invariant per thread at a time, so nested invariant evaluations cannot trigger one another indefinitely. To recover from non-nested hangs, we monitor each run for stalls and retry it under a growing time budget. Because we cannot prove a candidate side-effect-free in advance, we use delta debugging over the invariants evaluated during a failing test to isolate and disable a side-effecting candidate without discarding the rest of the run. We compared our implementation, Oca, to the popular template-based Daikon invariant detector on real open-source Java projects. Oca produces more expressive invariants: on average, 28% of its held invariants call a project-specific method, which Daikon's templates cannot express. Its invariants are more often valid, with a false-positive rate of 18% in a manual inspection, vs. 76% for Daikon, and more useful: as properties for property-based testing, they exposed 9 of 25 real bugs, compared with 4 for Daikon. Oca also costs less, using 566 minutes and 27 GB of disk, compared with 2,817 minutes and 827 GB for Daikon.

0.40

SIMTurn: Lightweight Divergent Subgroup Scheduling for Intra-Warp Synchronization

cs.AR cs.DCcs.PL ·2026-11-13 ·Nikhil Rout, Joe Samuel Rosh, Blaise Tine
code/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · 13 pages, 12 figures, 2 tables

Stack-based reconvergence enables efficient SIMT execution with a shared warp program counter and compact control-flow state. However, its fixed serialization of divergent paths can deadlock programs that rely on intra-warp synchronization: a spinning subgroup may prevent a resource-holding sibling from executing. Independent Thread Scheduling (ITS) enables finer-grained progress through per-thread execution state, but introduces additional hardware cost. We present SIMTurn, a lightweight compiler-hardware mechanism that enables forward progress among divergent subgroups while retaining stack-based reconvergence. SIMTurn combines a compiler-inserted yield instruction at potentially blocking loops with a bounded pool of resumable subgroups. The scheduler allows a waiting subgroup to yield to a sibling that can make progress, without requiring independent program counters for every thread. We implement SIMTurn in the compiler, simulator, and RTL on the open-source Vortex GPGPU and evaluate it against baseline IPDOM and per-thread ITS schemes. Across the evaluated GPU thread configurations, SIMTurn introduces only 17-24% scheduler-area overhead relative to IPDOM, compared with 39-91% for ITS, and stays within 8% of IPDOM on workloads that never need cross-subgroup progress. On kernels with genuine cross-subgroup parallelism, SIMTurn tracks ITS closely and is up to 2.7x faster than a software-serialized IPDOM baseline.

0.35

Nothing Is Shared Until You Synchronise: Reinterpreting Java for Data-Race Freedom

cs.PL ·2026-11-06 ·Luke Cheeseman, Elias Castegren, David Black-Schaffer, Erik Österlund, Tobias Wrigstad
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 30 pages, 11 figures

In mainstream shared-memory languages, programmers use synchronisation mechanisms such as locks to isolate shared data accesses across threads to avoid data races. Yet synchronisation enforces only a temporal ordering, while shared memory still communicates updates between threads at every ordinary read and write. To achieve isolation, programmers therefore need to understand the connection between ordering and communication, and to apply synchronisation correctly and consistently, while compilers and hardware optimise assuming they have. When programmers synchronise incorrectly, they lose isolation, and the semantics of their programs change without notice. We propose Sync-as-Share, a memory model built on isolation and communication rather than on the ordering of accesses to shared memory. We start from thread isolation, where each thread reads and writes a private view of memory, and reinterpret programs' existing synchronisation actions to also communicate updates explicitly. As nothing is communicated outside synchronisation actions, data races become impossible by construction. Instead, conflicting updates are detected at synchronisation points. Viewing synchronisation as explicit communication exposes the design decisions of what should be communicated, to whom, and what counts as a conflict. We propose two communication topologies with different trade-offs. We instantiate Sync-as-Share for Java by making the synchronisation actions already defined by its memory model the only points at which threads communicate, so Java programs can adopt Sync-as-Share unmodified. We formalise this instantiation as version-controlled memory, in which synchronisation actions push and pull updates between private views, and mechanise it in Rocq. We show that Java programs that are correctly synchronised under the Java memory model behave identically under shared memory and Sync-as-Share.

0.24

Modular Responsiveness Verification of Rust Async Runtimes

cs.PL ·2026-10-06 ·Yanze Li, Ivan Beschastnikh, Alexander J. Summers
published similarity 0.63
Abstract · To appear at ESOP 2027, preprint with appendix

Asynchronous (async) programming is a popular paradigm for managing concurrency. Languages that provide async support typically have a runtime to manage asynchronous executions. These runtimes are critical infrastructure, yet verifying them has received little attention. One reason is that a property that users care most about from an async runtime is a liveness property: tasks submitted to the runtime eventually make progress. Verifying liveness is challenging for libraries that are both concurrent and highly optimized. We present a lightweight and modular proof technique for verifying eventual progression guarantees for Rust async runtimes. We describe this technique in the context of a simple language based on Rust and Rust's async model. We then realize this proof technique as a set of static analyses for Rust and use these to verify eventual progression of several key components of multiple Rust async runtime implementations.

0.19

Fine-grained Causal Reversibility for Asynchronous Channel-based Programming

cs.PL ·2026-08-29 ·Shunya Oguchi, Shoji Yuen, Nobuko Yoshida, Claudio Antares Mezzina
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · 33 pages, 10 figures. Extended version of the paper accepted at ICTAC 2026. This version includes complete proofs and additional technical m…

Causal reversibility has emerged as an effective technique for debugging concurrent systems. In particular, rolling back and replaying a concurrent program with causal consistency has been found very helpful in debugging concurrency bugs. In channel-based communication, queue ordering creates dependencies that prevent causally independent actions from being rolled back and replayed. To enable efficient rollback and replay without being constrained by queue dependencies, it is necessary to analyse causal dependencies between messages in queues and reorder independent messages. This paper presents revGo, a core of the Go programming language assuming unbounded asynchronous channels. Our rollback-and-replay semantics allows us to reorder messages in the queue if they are not causally related in the forward execution. It is shown that reordering independent messages generates no configuration with non-reachable processes. By reordering independent messages, rollback and replay are implementable with minimality by assigning unique keys to communications.

0.40

Sound Automatic Lock Placement for Concurrent Programs with Pointers

cs.LO ·2026-11-12 ·Nicolas Waldburger, Florian Faissole, Ryo Okabe, Denis Cousineau
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · 39 pages, 7 figures

We propose a lightweight method for automatic lock placement in concurrent POSIX programs with explicit pointer manipulation, such as C programs. Given a program that lacks sufficient user-placed mutexes, or contains none at all, our method introduces new mutexes to prevent data races. The method is formally proven to guarantee the absence of data races and mainly consists of three steps. The first step performs lockset analysis and may-happen-in-parallel analysis. The second step conducts a concurrent points-to analysis derived from a Steensgaard-like procedural analysis, where per-thread points-to graphs are unified using a special completion rule. The final step places locks to prevent data races while respecting a lock ordering to avoid deadlocks. In addition, user-annotated critical sections are protected through insertion of dedicated locks. Since lock placement is a complex and error-prone task, our method aims at helping developers write correct concurrent programs.

0.41