CS Paper Radar

Sound Automatic Lock Placement for Concurrent Programs with Pointers

Nicolas Waldburger, Florian Faissole, Ryo Okabe, Denis Cousineau

cs.LO ·submitted 2026-11-12 09:08 UTC · v2
published

Abstract

We propose a lightweight method for automatic lock placement in concurrent POSIX programs with explicit pointer manipulation, such as C programs. Given a program that lacks sufficient user-placed mutexes, or contains none at all, our method introduces new mutexes to prevent data races. The method is formally proven to guarantee the absence of data races and mainly consists of three steps. The first step performs lockset analysis and may-happen-in-parallel analysis. The second step conducts a concurrent points-to analysis derived from a Steensgaard-like procedural analysis, where per-thread points-to graphs are unified using a special completion rule. The final step places locks to prevent data races while respecting a lock ordering to avoid deadlocks. In addition, user-annotated critical sections are protected through insertion of dedicated locks. Since lock placement is a complex and error-prone task, our method aims at helping developers write correct concurrent programs.

Comment
39 pages, 7 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Beyond Locks and Thread IDs: Static Data Race Detection Off The Beaten Path (Extended Version)

cs.PL cs.SE ·2026-08-31 ·Daniel Bund, Julian Erhard, Michael Petter, Michael Schwarz
similarity 0.71
Abstract · 49 pages, 12 figures, 6 tables

Maintaining an abstraction of the execution history of threads can improve the precision of data race detection in static analysis. Here, we extend the digest framework to handle concurrency constructs and synchronization mechanisms that have been ignored in static race detection. We introduce mechanisms for the commonly used thread barriers, as well as pthread_once, which allows to ensure that an action is executed only once. We also instantiate the framework with an abstraction of locksets held by ancestor threads. We propose a suite of litmus tests to evaluate analyses for these features and compare our implementation to state-of-the-art tools, finding that they lack support.

0.39

Automatically Detecting and Fixing Deadlocks in Go Code with GoDDaR

cs.PL cs.DCcs.SE ·2026-10-06 ·Gustavo Feio, Jorge Coelho, Miguel Flor, João M. Lourenço, António Ravara
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

The Go programming language provides a lightweight abstraction for concurrent programming through goroutines, which are prone to deadlocks. Go includes a runtime detector that aborts execution when all threads are blocked (a global deadlock). However, due to nondeterministic thread scheduling, this runtime mechanism only detects global deadlocks that manifest during execution and cannot identify partial deadlocks, where a subset of goroutines is permanently blocked while at least one remains runnable. Statically detecting local deadlocks is essential for developing dependable concurrent software. While several tools statically detect deadlocks in concurrent programs, few assist developers in fixing them. Detecting and resolving partial deadlocks requires reasoning about complex interleavings and communication patterns, an inherently challenging task. In this paper, we present GoDDaR, a tool that detects unobserved global or partial deadlocks in Go programs and suggests concrete fixes. GoDDaR translates Go source code into an intermediate representation reflecting message-passing communication events and composition patterns. Partial deadlocks are identified through symbolic analysis over this representation. To resolve detected deadlocks, our algorithms transform the intermediate representation to eliminate problematic synchronization patterns, allowing GoDDaR to generate fix suggestions for the original Go source code as a diff. We evaluate GoDDaR on a benchmark suite of representative deadlock examples from literature and git repositories to validate algorithm correctness and compare performance against the state of the art. Results demonstrate that GoDDaR is competitive with top approaches in partial deadlock detection and advances the state of the art in automated deadlock fixing.

0.20

Episodic Loops: Finitary Event Structures and Operational Semantics for C11 Programs with Retries

cs.PL ·2026-09-28 ·Christian Kissig, Jay Richards, Mark Batty
code/data similarity 0.62
Abstract · 115 pages (42 pages main text plus appendices), 19 figures, 2 tables. Reference implementation: https://github.com/christiankissig/mordor ; …

Lock-free synchronisation algorithms are often implemented with fallible operations, such as compare-and-swap (CAS), wrapped in unbounded retry loops. Verifying such algorithms requires considering arbitrarily many failing iterations, yielding large state spaces, compounded by the interleavings of concurrent threads. Prior work discarded failing iterations, arguing that they leave no trace in the post-loop state. Compilers and hardware reorder instructions, and load-store reorderings may cross the boundaries of failing iterations, introducing subtle concurrency bugs. We demonstrate one such bug, making use-after-free possible in a previously verified variant of Read-Copy-Update - a synchronisation primitive widely adopted in the Linux Kernel - and we provide and verify a fix. We find that practical retries in lock-free algorithms adhere to a common pattern. We introduce episodic loops, a semantic characterisation of unbounded retry loops which is syntactically recognisable in many practical cases, and synchronisation points, operations that bound both instruction reordering and state space within episodic loops. We show that SMRD - a symbolic event structure semantics for C11 programs which allows for load-store reordering - admits a finite representation in programs where unbounded loops are episodic. We further introduce a finitary operational semantics that allows safety properties to be verified in finitely many steps. For the use-after-free bug we demonstrate, verification takes a single pass over the program, linear in the program size. We provide a reference implementation of SMRD reproducing the bug and verifying the fix, and mechanise the operational semantics together with the minimal bug and its fix in Isabelle/HOL.

0.38

Nothing Is Shared Until You Synchronise: Reinterpreting Java for Data-Race Freedom

cs.PL ·2026-11-06 ·Luke Cheeseman, Elias Castegren, David Black-Schaffer, Erik Österlund, Tobias Wrigstad
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 30 pages, 11 figures

In mainstream shared-memory languages, programmers use synchronisation mechanisms such as locks to isolate shared data accesses across threads to avoid data races. Yet synchronisation enforces only a temporal ordering, while shared memory still communicates updates between threads at every ordinary read and write. To achieve isolation, programmers therefore need to understand the connection between ordering and communication, and to apply synchronisation correctly and consistently, while compilers and hardware optimise assuming they have. When programmers synchronise incorrectly, they lose isolation, and the semantics of their programs change without notice. We propose Sync-as-Share, a memory model built on isolation and communication rather than on the ordering of accesses to shared memory. We start from thread isolation, where each thread reads and writes a private view of memory, and reinterpret programs' existing synchronisation actions to also communicate updates explicitly. As nothing is communicated outside synchronisation actions, data races become impossible by construction. Instead, conflicting updates are detected at synchronisation points. Viewing synchronisation as explicit communication exposes the design decisions of what should be communicated, to whom, and what counts as a conflict. We propose two communication topologies with different trade-offs. We instantiate Sync-as-Share for Java by making the synchronisation actions already defined by its memory model the only points at which threads communicate, so Java programs can adopt Sync-as-Share unmodified. We formalise this instantiation as version-controlled memory, in which synchronisation actions push and pull updates between private views, and mechanise it in Rocq. We show that Java programs that are correctly synchronised under the Java memory model behave identically under shared memory and Sync-as-Share.

0.24

Validating Concurrent Correctness Witnesses with Ghosts by Thread-Modular Abstract Interpretation

cs.PL cs.SE ·2026-11-18 ·Michael Schwarz, Zhendong Ang, Umang Mathur
top venue similarity 0.60
Abstract · Accepted to POPL '27; Extended version with appendices

Concurrent programs are notoriously difficult to write and to reason about, and even tools based on sound theoretical foundations can produce incorrect results due to implementation bugs. Correctness witnesses have been proposed as a way to increase the confidence in the verdicts of software verifiers by enabling independent validation. Recently, correctness witnesses have been extended to the concurrent setting, by introducing ghost variables to allow encoding more expressive invariants. While different approaches to producing witnesses with ghosts exist, validation techniques are still lacking; instead of leveraging the information encoded in the ghosts to guide the validation process, validators merely treat ghost instrumentation and invariants over ghost variables as additional proof obligations. We propose a novel framework for the validation of concurrent correctness witnesses that exploits the semantic information encoded in ghost variables. It combines a checking phase, which establishes the semantic content of the ghost instrumentation, with an exploitation phase making use of this information. Both phases are formulated as thread-modular abstract interpretation. In particular, we consider two different classes of ghost variables and techniques for exploiting them, one based on resource invariants and one based on phases. Phase ghosts guide the degree to which the abstract interpretation considers interleavings instead of always abstracting them coarsely. In this way, the abstract interpreter can validate witnesses containing invariants beyond the reach of unguided thread-modular analysis, while still retaining its scalability benefits. We have implemented our framework in a static analyzer and evaluate it on witnesses encoding resource invariants obtained from a state-of-the-art software verifier, as well as on hand-crafted witnesses encoding phase information.

0.47

UnsafeChecker: Finding Soundness Bugs in Rust Safe Abstractions

cs.PL ·2026-09-09 ·Xizhe Yin, Yaokun Zhang, Yang Feng, Baowen Xu
benchmark similarity 0.58
Abstract

Rust guarantees memory safety without garbage collection through a strict ownership and borrowing system. However, for low-level systems programming, many widely used libraries rely on the unsafe keyword. These libraries encapsulate raw-pointer operations behind safe APIs to form safe abstractions. A single mistake in this internal unsafe code can break its safety contract, rendering the abstraction unsound and allowing safe clients to trigger undefined behavior. Detecting these potential soundness violations is challenging. Existing static analysis tools for C/C++ ignore Rust-specific safety contracts, while current Rust tools lack the deep semantic modeling required to track the contexts that raw pointers erase. To address this gap, we present UnsafeChecker, a compiler-integrated static analysis framework for detecting potential soundness violations in Rust safe abstractions. UnsafeChecker analyzes Rust MIR using a flow-sensitive abstract interpretation that maintains a shared state with three components: ownership, object validity, and layout. Each warning rule consumes the subset of facts needed for the corresponding Rust safety obligation. UnsafeChecker reports both instruction-level undefined behavior and boundary-level contract violations that may escape through safe APIs. We evaluate UnsafeChecker on a benchmark of 46 RustSec vulnerabilities, which contain 53 ground-truth bugs. UnsafeChecker outperforms several state-of-the-art tools, detecting 32 CVEs and covering 36 bugs (67.9% recall) with 51.6% alert-level precision. Furthermore, in a large-scale scan of real-world crates on crates.io, UnsafeChecker uncovered 114 previously unknown bugs across 83 crates, with 45 confirmed and 27 already fixed by maintainers.

0.09

XRust: Detecting Logical Races in Rust Linux Drivers

cs.SE ·2026-10-19 ·Qingxiao Xu, Ze Sheng, Zhicheng Chen, Arjun Manikandan, Jeff Huang
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Rust is increasingly used in Linux to improve memory safety, but its guarantees do not prevent logical races: individually synchronized operations can still interleave in ways that violate higher-level invariants. Detecting such bugs typically requires manually written specifications and carefully controlled execution environments. We present XRust, a technique for detecting logical races in Linux Rust drivers without manually specified invariants. Using Logical Happens-Before (LHB) analysis, XRust identifies shared-state accesses relevant to logical ordering, automatically constructs operation-pair harnesses, and uses serial differential oracles to detect concurrent executions inconsistent with either serial order. XRust also uses lightweight userspace abstractions to execute driver code under reproducible schedules. Applied to Linux 7.3-rc2, XRust identifies 17 shared objects across 102 Rust files from ten drivers, constructs 1,654 executable harnesses, and discovers two previously unknown logical races. The rnull block-driver race has been confirmed by Linux maintainers, with a fix accepted into the Linux block subsystem tree.

0.14

Blame-aware Recomposition for Secure Compilation Proofs of Low-Level Compartment Isolation

cs.PL cs.CR ·2026-10-19 ·Basile Schlosser, Jérémy Thibault, Catalin Hritcu
similarity 0.57
Abstract

The security guarantees of existing formally verified compilers for compartmentalized programs in unsafe languages like C stop at a rather high level, assuming a built-in protection mechanism and a block-based memory model. Verifying a concrete, low-level enforcement mechanism for compartment isolation is still a major challenge for current proof techniques. In particular, Abate et al.'s proof technique fails because one of their proof steps, recomposition, essentially requires hiding all information about the code of each compartment, which is not practically achievable at a low level. We propose an extension of their proof technique to a low-level setting where compartments can fully observe each other's code. To do so, we introduce an overlay semantics that allows us to characterize these observations as a form of undefined behaviour, and we use a novel variant of recomposition that we call blame-aware recomposition, which essentially allows recomposing executions as needed in the original high-level proof technique, even if the low-level context observes the code, because this context is ultimately going to be discarded. We apply this new proof to a compartment isolation mechanism that uses a programmable tag-based reference monitor.

0.26