CS Paper Radar

Low-level optimizations in high-level HDLs: Is there a benefit?

Oliver Keszocze, Tjark Petersen, Arved Friedemann, Matthias Bo Stuart

cs.AR ·submitted 2026-09-29 08:38 UTC · v1
code/data

Abstract

This paper explores the applicability of functional programming to the design of Application-specific Integrated Circuits (ASICs). We investigate the impact of designing ASICs using high-level, abstract Hardware Description Language (HDL) features versus employing low-level optimizations on the area of the synthesized circuits. The aim is to determine whether using low-level optimizations is beneficial and, if so, whether it is worth the added implementation effort. To carry out the investigation, we implement an unsigned bit-serial multiply-accumulate (MAC) unit in 16 different configurations using the functional HDL Clash. We make use of both low-level bit-manipulation techniques as well as Clash's high-level constructs for circuit design. The experimental evaluation shows that some high-level constructs of Clash have negligible influence on the resulting circuit size, suggesting that using the full power of functional programming is a viable approach to hardware design. To evaluate the impact of the used HDL itself, we also implemented versions of the MAC in Verilog. The experiments clearly show that there seems to be an inherent overhead in using Clash compared to Verilog code written by a seasoned engineer.

Comment
The corresponding source code is available on GitHub: https://github.com/keszocze/mac-clash-iwsbp26
Journal ref
Keszocze, Peterson, Proceedings of the 17th International Workshop on Boolean Problems, 2026, pp. 133-148

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Quantifying the Effect of HCLs on a Fixed-Microarchitecture MXFP4 Accelerator

cs.AR ·2026-09-16 ·Daniele Passaretti, Sajjad Tamimi, Nicola Dall'Ora
published similarity 0.65
Abstract

Hardware Construction Languages (HCLs) aim to improve hardware design productivity while generating register-transfer-level (RTL) circuits without changing the designer's microarchitecture. However, most comparisons between HCLs are either qualitative or evaluate quality of results (QoR) across different designs, making it difficult to separate language effects from design effects. This paper compares the most widely used HCLs using the same fixed design, the OCP MXFP4 block dot product, a quantization primitive at the heart of edge Physical-AI inference, implemented as a single 12-stage, II=1 pipeline. A SystemVerilog baseline is followed by implementations in Chisel, SpinalHDL, Amaranth, Clash, Bluespec, and C++ for high-level synthesis (HLS). Every variant goes through the same flow on the same Artix-7 device set at 100 MhZ, driven by a RISC-V soft core. With the micro-architecture held constant, the comparison is clean: every variant meets timing, and the HCLs match or even undercut hand-written RTL in area. The remaining differences stem not from the algorithm but from how each back end lowers arithmetic, and from a single width choice that silently toggles DSP inference. Unlike HLS, where design decisions are limited to pragmas, the HCLs achieve comparable area and timing. Therefore, the choice comes down to ecosystem fit and interface needs rather than QoR.

0.36

VHDLBench: Benchmarking and Fine-Tuning Large Language Models for VHDL-Based Chip Design

cs.AR cs.AI ·2026-10-19 ·Patrik Drazic, Benaoumeur Senouci, Boualem Benatallah
publishedcode/data similarity 0.63
Abstract · This paper is a long version of a paper accepted for the 4th International Conference on Foundation and Large Language Models, 2026

The rapid evolution of digital circuit complexity demands innovative approaches to hardware design automation. While Large Language Models (LLMs) have influenced software development, their application to Hardware Description Language (HDL) generation remains largely unexplored, particularly for VHDL. This paper presents a comprehensive study for AI-assisted digital circuit design, addressing gaps in current Electronic Design Automation workflows. The work introduces a VHDL dataset of 18,500+ syntax-verified examples from open-source repositories and converted Verilog designs. Five 7B-parameter LLMs were fine-tuned using parameter-efficient QLoRA technique, enabling deployment in resource-constrained environments. To evaluate model efficacy, a rigorous three-level pipeline was established: (1) syntax and synthesis validation, (2) functional simulation with testbenches, and (3) FPGA prototyping on Zynq SoCs. Results show fine-tuned models achieve up to 92% syntax correctness and 73% functional accuracy on common design tasks, with DeepSeek-Coder demonstrating the highest performance gains. Generated designs were successfully deployed on real hardware, confirming not only syntactic but operational viability. This work demonstrates that LLMs, when tailored with domain-specific data and lightweight fine-tuning can contribute meaningfully to the future of generative EDA workflows.

0.25

A State Augmented Approach to Paralle Modeling in High-Level Synthesis

cs.AR ·2026-10-27 ·Nicholas Kovacs, Hao Zheng
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

High-level synthesis (HLS) can schedule only the concurrency made legal by its input description. For feedback-coupled designs, a sequential behavioral model can obscure the architectural state boundaries and hazard resolution needed for efficient overlap. We develop an explicit architectural modeling methodology based on synchronous sequential processes that start in lockstep and synchronize completion before repeating. Persistent state, communication, and feedback control are represented in C++, while HLS schedules and binds operations within that structure. A five-stage RV32I processor illustrates three consequential modeling decisions: which version of a value a consumer reads, when it consumes that value, and how architectural memory actions map to port operations. On a Kintex UltraScale+ FPGA, the CPI-optimized configuration achieves 1.221 cycles per instruction at 220 MHz, compared with 4.000 for an algorithmic HLS baseline and 1.575 at 242 MHz for an Ibex reference. An area-optimized configuration reduces LUTs by 65\% and registers by 47\%, with 9.7\% more benchmark cycles and a 250 MHz achieved clock. These results demonstrate a separation between designer-controlled architecture and tool-controlled scheduling.

0.13

Can Agents Design Better Chips with a Higher Level Abstraction?

cs.AI cs.AR ·2026-09-17 ·Zijian Ding, Yang Zou, Yizhou Sun, Jason Cong
publishedbenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.62
Abstract · 7 pages, ICCAD'26 special session

Large Language Model (LLM) agents are increasingly being explored for chip design, but most existing approaches operate directly at RTL. We ask whether agents can design better chips by leveraging higher-level abstractions. We compare Direct RTL Design, Agent-based HLS Design, Post-Compiler HLS Refinement, and Post-HLS RTL Refinement, and combine Agent-based HLS Design with Post-HLS RTL Refinement as Agent-based HLS with RTL Refinement (AHRR). We use FPGAs as a practical, easy-to-deploy platform for end-to-end evaluation, but note that the design-flow tradeoffs we study are largely independent of the target technology. Across a diverse 11-tasks benchmark suite, AHRR achieves a 2.6$\times$ geometric-mean speedup over Direct RTL Design across our benchmark suite. Case studies show that HLS distills design knowledge into abstractions that agents can leverage, while RTL refinement recovers lower-level optimization opportunities. Together, these results make AHRR a promising workflow for agentic chip design. The code and evaluation artifacts are available at https://github.com/ZijD/AHRR.

0.57

Native FPGA Hard-Block Implementation from High-Level Synthesis

cs.AR ·2026-11-18 ·Mohamed Bouaziz, Mahmoud A. Elshenawy, Krishnan B. Iyer, Abdurauf Abdurakhmanov, Ammar M. Seliaman +1 more
similarity 0.62
Abstract

High-level synthesis (HLS) maps computations to FPGA hard blocks, yet often leaves their arithmetic modes, internal registers, and cascade links idle and recreates them in the fabric, costing area and timing. We present a C++ template library that reaches native hard-block implementations without modifying the HLS compiler. Templates fix source patterns, and an automatic flow picks scheduling settings and verified RTL patches. On AMD Versal, our matrix multiplication uses 2.4--4.5x fewer lookup tables (LUTs) than AutoSA systolic arrays at equal or higher estimated throughput. Our INT8 matrix--vector units reach the three multiply--accumulates per DSP of hand-written FINN RTL, versus at most 1.29 for HLS libraries. In hls4ml, Allo, and Stream-HLS, the templates cut LUTs by up to 2.7x and DSPs by up to 2x.

0.19

Heuristic-Driven Resource Optimization for Decoupled Memory Channels on FPGAs

cs.AR cs.DC ·2026-10-18 ·Arnab A. Purkayastha, Shobhit Aggarwal, Jay Tharwani
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · 6 pages. Accepted version of a paper published in the 2026 IEEE International Conference on Interdisciplinary Approaches in Technology and M…

Determining OpenCL channel depths for Decoupled Access-Execute (DAE) architectures in High-Level Synthesis (HLS) is critical for balancing performance and hardware efficiency. Conventional static analysis tools often over-provision these memory channels to ensure performance safety, leading to significant resource stranding. This paper presents an expansion of an LLVM-based static analysis framework, originally proposed for automated DAE generation, by introducing a hardware-aware refinement layer. We identify a counter-intuitive Performance Inversion Paradox linked to baseline memory stalls, where high-stall, grid-based kernels reach peak performance at minimal channel depths and suffer up to a 61% throughput degradation when depths are increased. We propose a Heuristic Refinement Layer that optimizes OpenCL channel depths based on this correlation between baseline stalls and performance saturation. Experimental results demonstrate that our expanded framework successfully identifies the Minimal Peak Performance point across various benchmarks. By avoiding the performance traps of standard over-provisioning, we achieve a 2.52x improvement in Resource Efficiency for an illustrative HotSpot application. This approach maintains peak execution speedup while ensuring the leanest possible hardware profile, outperforming conservative tool-based static predictions.

0.40

Benchmarking Agentic HLS Design Tasks With HLS-Eval

cs.AR ·2026-09-08 ·Stefan Abi-Karam, Callie Hao
publishedbenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · Presented at the Architecture 2.0 workshop at ISCA 2026

Large language models (LLMs) and AI agents are increasingly explored for hardware design, including high-level digital design. While most work targets code generation and editing for hardware description languages (HDLs), our prior work introduced HLS-Eval, an open-source benchmark for evaluating LLMs on high-level synthesis (HLS) design tasks. Those evaluations, however, focused on zero-shot generation and editing, leaving open how agents achieve HLS design tasks. We therefore extend HLS-Eval with an agentic evaluation flow built on the open-source mini-swe-agent framework. The flow lets HLS design agents use file-editing tools, invoke a C++ compiler for self-verification, and iteratively refine designs during inference, while logging agent traces for analysis of cost, token usage, and iteration count. We present initial results on the existing HLS-Eval benchmarks. In our initial evaluation, we find open-source LLMs paired with an agentic harness solve every simple HLS code generation task in our evaluation, underscoring the need to expand benchmark difficulty as model capabilities advance. Analyzing traces from passing and failing runs, we show how model size, token usage, and trajectory length relate to design pass rates. These results establish a foundation for agentic HLS design and motivate harder benchmarks and new agentic tooling as model capabilities progress.

0.45

SYNTLOG: FSM Benchmarks Evaluation for FPGA

cs.AR ·2026-08-24 ·Samary Baranov, Danila Gorodecky
benchmark similarity 0.60
Abstract

We introduce a curated benchmark collection of \num{101} FSM descriptions organized into five size classes (\emph{small}, \emph{medium}, \emph{large}, \emph{huge}, \emph{super-huge}), spanning tens to thousands of states and up to hundreds of inputs and outputs. Using these benchmarks we compare an architecture-independent synthesis tool SYNTLOG against Xilinx Vivado at the synthesis (technology-mapping) level, under six optimization strategies. We compare three post-synthesis parameters: number of LUTs, number of logic levels, and runtime. SYNTLOG in area-driven mode uses substantially fewer LUTs than Vivado's area baseline at every size ($-45\%$ to $-66\%$), and its delay-driven mode is simultaneously shallower in logic depth than Vivado's default synthesis mode. SYNTLOG synthesis includes embedded functional validation. Runtime of SYNTLOG is faster by one to two orders of magnitude than Vivado synthesis. The proposed tool synthesizes and validates every \emph{huge} and \emph{super-huge} circuit in minutes, whereas Vivado fails to terminate on these designs after hours.

0.21