CS Paper Radar

Game-Based versus Training-Based Virtual Reality for Cognitive Rehabilitation in Mild Cognitive Impairment and Dementia: A Systematization of Design Paradigms, Outcomes, and Evaluation Rigor

Anowarul Faruk Shishir, M. Rasel Mahmud

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-09-29 20:36 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Therapeutic exercises can help slow cognitive decline in dementia, but conventional programs are often tedious and difficult to sustain. Virtual reality (VR) offers an alternative through game-based approaches designed to improve engagement and training-based approaches focused on structured functional recovery. Prior reviews report inconsistent findings about these paradigms, while it remains unclear whether the labels represent systems that are technologically distinct. Following PRISMA 2020 guidelines, we systematize 34 studies published between 2015 and 2026, including 16 controlled efficacy trials and 18 design and feasibility studies involving mild cognitive impairment, dementia and Alzheimer's disease. We develop a taxonomy covering design paradigm, immersion, feedback modality, difficulty adaptation and hardware. Our analysis shows substantial overlap between game-based and training-based systems, suggesting that these labels do not clearly distinguish their technological characteristics. We also introduce VR-RES, a seven-dimensional framework for evaluating study quality. Its application highlights recurring limitations in the evidence base, particularly limited follow-up, poor reproducibility and insufficient analysis of demographic factors such as age, sex and education. Based on these findings, we provide recommendations for future VR cognitive rehabilitation research, emphasizing specific design features, rigorous evaluation and improved reporting practices.

Comment
Accepted at the 32nd ACM Symposium on Virtual Reality Software and Technology (VRST 2026)
DOI
10.1145/3822517.3848720

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Trail Making Tests in Extended Reality: A Critical Review with Implications for Cognitive Ageing

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-11-08 ·Panagiotis Kourtesis
similarity 0.65
Abstract · Review article. 22 pages, 1 figure, 4 tables; Supplementary Materials (19 pages); ancillary files: the Supplementary Materials (PDF), File S…

Extended reality (XR) versions of the Trail Making Test and Color Trails Test are promising for assessing and training cognition in older adults. However, each XR adaptation is a new instrument, whose display, interaction technique, timing rules and layouts may change what it measures. This critical narrative review maps these implementations by software lineage and appraises their evidence for assessment and training against common criteria. The Trail Making Test in Virtual Reality (TMT-VR), whose source code was inspected, serves as a measurement case. XR trail-making tests showed convergence with paper and computerised versions, varying by test part and sample, and clinical group differences (e.g., Parkinson's disease, mild cognitive impairment). However, gaps in reliability (e.g., randomised forms), validation (e.g., norms, prospective samples) and reporting (e.g., error handling, build identity) emerged, and no training benefit attributable to the trail-making component was identified. The TMT-VR case shows how interaction technique, timing rule, error handling and unlogged layouts shape a score's meaning. Future tests should log layouts and events, estimate alternate-form reliability and undergo prospective validation, and training trials should isolate the trail-making component. Several XR trail-making tests have moved beyond feasibility, and reported tolerability during supervised sessions supports further evaluation in older adults.

0.13

Usability, User Experience, and Acceptability of the Trail Making Test in Virtual Reality in Younger and Older Adults

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-10-16 ·Panagiotis Kourtesis, Dante O'Connor, Sarah E. MacPherson
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 20 pages, 3 figures, 4 tables, supplementary material are included

Immersive virtual reality (VR) adaptations of neuropsychological tests change how a test operates. Before their scores are interpreted, the individuals they are intended to assess should find them usable, acceptable and tolerable, and for older adults this evidence is usually missing. This study evaluated the experience of the Trail Making Test in Virtual Reality (TMT-VR), a head-gaze adaptation of the Trail Making Test that requires no hand-held controller, in 47 younger (20-38 years) and 44 older adults (64-81 years). After the task, participants rated usability, pragmatic and hedonic user experience, acceptability, and cybersickness. The study had three aims: to compare the two age groups on these ratings; to examine whether the ratings were associated with age group, gaming and technology experience, and whether cybersickness was associated with motion sickness susceptibility; and to examine whether the ratings were related to TMT-VR completion and error-adjusted times. Both groups rated the TMT-VR as highly usable, acceptable and pleasant to use. Older adults gave slightly lower usability and pragmatic ratings, but neither the age-group differences nor the associations with age group or previous experience were statistically significant after correction. Cybersickness was low, with 38 of the 91 participants reporting no symptoms; it did not differ between the age groups and was not associated with motion sickness susceptibility. No correlation between the ratings and TMT-VR performance survived correction. The TMT-VR with head-gaze selection is therefore usable, acceptable and well tolerated by older as well as younger adults. Because the ratings were favourable across the whole range of TMT-VR scores, slower or less accurate performance is unlikely to reflect difficulty with the interface.

0.37

C-LISTEN: Cognitive Load Impacts of Sensory-Triggered Environmental Navigation in Virtual Reality

cs.HC ·2026-09-29 ·Md. Monowar Hossain, M. Rasel Mahmud
top venue similarity 0.61
Abstract · 6 pages. Published in AIVR 2026, The Third International Conference on Artificial Intelligence and Immersive Virtual Reality, Lisbon, Portug…

Nowadays, Virtual Reality (VR) systems are more helpful for making decisions, training, and rehabilitation. Multimodal settings in these systems impose a significant balance and cognitive difficulties. Additionally, decreased performance, higher cognitive load, user overwhelm, and limited accessibility of VR technology can be caused by excessive auditory, visual, and sensory stimulation. In our pilot study, we examine the strategic design of directional auditory cues to improve cognitive load and enhance user experience in virtual environments. This research also enhances fundamental knowledge that auditory feedback reduces cognitive load in VR, with statistical analysis confirming this improvement (p = .0011). This study investigates how postural balance and pupil diameter correlate with cognitive load while the users navigate. Moreover, this study provides realistic overview design guidelines for accessibility, which will make VR experiences safer and more useful for everyone, including people with cognitive impairments.

0.49

Ageing, Digital Literacy, and Interaction Modality in Immer-sive Virtual Reality: Psychomotor Performance, Cognitive Flexibility, and Their Processing-Speed Association

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-09-17 ·Panagiotis Kourtesis, Katerina Denaxa, Lydia Asimakopoulou, Petros Roussos, Maria Roussou
published similarity 0.58
Abstract · 27 pages, 5 figures, 6 Tables

Extended reality (XR) increasingly supports training and cognitive assessment, yet the age sensitivity of its interaction techniques is unclear. This study examined age, digital literacy, and interaction modality as correlates of psychomotor and cognitive-flexibility performance in immersive virtual reality (VR). Two hundred and two adults (19-90 years) completed a five-mode Fitts' law task (eye-gaze, head-gaze, controller ray-casting, virtual finger, and controller direct touch), the Trail Making Test in VR (TMT-VR), and a digital-literacy questionnaire. Age was associated with slower task times across modes, but controller direct touch carried the steepest relative age gradient yet remained among the fastest in absolute terms; technique altered relative age sensitivity without determining absolute efficiency. Higher digital literacy was associated with faster TMT-VR completion but not Fitts task times. A Fitts-derived speed score predicted TMT-VR performance beyond age and partly accounted for its age association, consistent with shared processing-speed variance; an exploratory full-battery extension confined the Fitts-score association to completion-time and error-adjusted-time indices and the digital-literacy association to error-adjusted-time indices, not wrong-target errors, mean selection distance, or relative Part B indices. Age-inclusive XR assessment should standardise interaction modality, evaluate rather than exclude mid-air direct selection, and interpret cognitive scores alongside digital literacy and psychomotor speed.

0.50

Moving Beyond the Flat Screen: Opportunities and Challenges of Extended Reality for Studying Human Brain and Behavior

cs.HC ·2026-10-13 ·Tom Bullock, Radha Kumaran, You-Jin Kim, Emily Machniak, Tobias Höllerer +1 more
published similarity 0.57
Abstract · 4 pages, 1 figure. Workshop paper presented at the NeuroXR 2026 Workshop at IEEE ISMAR 2026 (ISMAR-Adjunct)

Much of what we know about human perception and cognition comes from austere experimental settings: static stimuli presented to sedentary observers on flat monitors, complex responses reduced to simple button presses, and brain activity recorded from immobilized heads using EEG or fMRI. These highly controlled paradigms have provided remarkable insights, but capture a small and often unusual slice of behavior, raising questions about how well the findings generalize to the real world. Extended reality (XR), spanning both immersive virtual reality (VR) and augmented reality (AR) that overlays digital content on the real world, offers a way beyond these constraints, supporting controlled, reproducible experiments in which participants actively engage with three-dimensional tasks. Drawing on a growing body of VR and AR studies of attention, memory, and language -- our own and others', some involving EEG -- we outline what XR makes newly possible for cognitive neuroscience and reflect on the practical and conceptual obstacles that remain. The opportunities are substantial, but realizing them requires solving practical problems of hardware, timing, and measurement, and being realistic about what a virtual or augmented world can and cannot stand in for.

0.40

Virtual Placebo: a scoping review of control conditions in randomized controlled trials of psychological immersive virtual reality interventions

cs.HC q-bio.NC ·2026-10-23 ·Madis Vasser, Mary-Ann Kubre, Kadi Tulver, Jaan Aru
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Research on immersive virtual reality (IVR) as a therapeutic tool is growing rapidly, with randomized controlled trials (RCTs) now commonplace. Yet the control conditions in many of these studies that claim strong specific IVR effects vary from usual care to active immersive experiences, making it difficult to draw clinically meaningful conclusions. We conducted a scoping review of recent literature on psychological IVR interventions to assess the main forms of control conditions used and their relations to study outcomes. In this paper, we make the case that most of the recent RCTs studying the effects of specific IVR interventions compare active immersive VR to usual care with no multimedia component. This can lead to strong yet potentially misleading study outcomes and can potentially inflate the IVR interventions' effect. Namely, the lack of an appropriate immersive control condition may risk misattributing general effects of VR devices to the specific content of the intervention. In this review, we discuss the implications of these design choices and propose strategies for including a suitable "virtual placebo" condition to improve the methodological rigor and interpretability of results.

0.19

Signal-Driven Pervasive Game Design: The LifeSync-Games Framework as a Player Experience Integration Layer

cs.HC ·2026-09-02 ·J. Macías-Cáceres, F. Gutiérrez-Vela, P. Paderewski-Rodriguez, R. González-Ibáñez
unusual similarity 0.54
Abstract · 16 pages, 2 figures, 4 tables

Pervasive games extend the magic circle across spatial, temporal, and social dimensions, yet treat the player's physiological and cognitive state as a passive receptor rather than an active signal. This paper presents LifeSync-Games (LSG), a framework that (unlike proposals treating player signals as an additional dimension), operationalizes them as a Player Experience Integration Layer (PEIL) acting transversally across the three existing pervasive dimensions through verified real-world signals: physical activity, sleep quality, memory, and decision speed. The framework introduces a gamified integration artifact (the LSG portal) that mediates the real <-> virtual exchange through redeemable points, real-world missions, and structural gamification. Five HCI design principles grounded in Self-Determination Theory and Flow Theory are proposed, instantiated across six commercial video games, together with a study protocol (n = 70-80 participants, quasi-experimental design). This paper reports the design stage of LSG: rule thresholds and portal parameters are design decisions pending empirical calibration; no data collection has yet been conducted. The main contribution is a theoretically grounded framework and validation protocol positioning player-sensitive integration as the mechanism enabling pervasive games to respond to the player's actual biological and cognitive state.

0.30

A Serious Game for Training Civil Participation in Flood Crisis Management

cs.HC ·2026-11-12 ·Solmaz Goodarzi, Arseni Ivanov, David Maruscsák, Diana Quitéria Sousa
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Floods are among the most frequent and destructive natural disasters, requiring citizens to make critical decisions under rapidly changing conditions. Most serious games related to flooding emphasize awareness, preparedness, and education in flood management, but there is still a research gap on how to train citizens to act under pressure, uncertainty, and stress. In this paper, we position Virtual Reality (VR) serious games as a promising approach to addressing this gap by providing experiential and immersive training opportunities for citizens. We propose a conceptual VR serious game that enables participants to experience realistic flood scenarios, practice decision-making, rehearse appropriate response behaviors, and develop response-related skills in a safe and controlled environment. In addition, we suggest a research agenda and an evaluation framework focused on flood risk awareness, response capabilities, and stress-related outcomes. The framework thoughtfully integrates subjective, objective, and physiological measures to assess the effectiveness of immersive flood-response training. Finally, we present design, methodological, ethical, and user-experience considerations in VR-based disaster training, and outline future research directions for the development and evaluation of immersive serious games for flood emergency response. The present study aims to contribute to the growing intersection of serious games, extended reality, and disaster risk reduction by establishing citizen-centered response training as a significant yet under-researched field.

0.26