CS Paper Radar

RISK: Auditing Industrial Control Systems for Too-Late-to-Recover Vulnerabilities

Syed Ghazanfar Abbas, Gang Wang, Dongyan Xu

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-09-29 20:45 UTC · v1

Abstract

The security of industrial control systems (ICS) is important. Yet most ICS security efforts focus on the detection of ICS attacks, with much less attention to the recovery after detection. In this paper, we address this underexplored area by jointly auditing the detection and recovery of ICS. Specifically, we define the too-late-to-recover (TLTR) vulnerability, which allows an attack to drain the available recovery margin before being detected, such that the subsequent recovery procedure will fail to bring the ICS back to a safe state due to the insufficient margin. To audit an ICS for TLTR vulnerabilities, we develop RISK, an automated framework that discovers and validates possible TLTR attack scenarios. RISK holistically models and analyzes, statically and dynamically, the PLC control logic, attack detection policies, recovery procedures, and operational behaviors of an ICS to generate TLTR attack scenarios with concrete attack parameters. We evaluate RISK on three ICS testbeds as well as a real-world fertilizer production plant. Across the three testbeds, a total of 392 TLTR attacks are generated and confirmed, whereas only a small fraction of them can be discovered by existing ICS vetting tools. In the real-world plant, RISK identified a critical TLTR vulnerability which was validated by plant engineers.

Comment
17 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

XPhysICS: Cross-Physical-Domain Threat Grounding for Industrial Control Systems Security

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-09-25 ·Sangshin Park, Jainta Paul, Lawrence Ponce, Md Raihan Ahmed, Mu Zhang +1 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 35 pages, 5 figures, 12 tables; revised abstract, overview figure, method description, and appendix layout

Industrial control system attacks are usually documented in terms of the plant where they occurred: its sensors, actuators, process stages, and control logic. Yet many attacks express a more general physical pattern--such as suppressing flow, corrupting chemical dosing, or driving a vessel toward overflow--that may also matter in a different plant. The challenge is deciding when such a threat remains meaningful on a new system rather than relying on similar component names or broad semantic labels. We present XPhysICS, a methodology for grounding documented cyber-physical threats onto a specific target system. XPhysICS converts source evidence into a provenance-linked description of what is manipulated, what physical consequence is expected, and what observations the evidence calls for. Once this analyst-guided abstraction, its vocabulary and schema version, and a target contract are fixed, XPhysICS applies deterministic grounding checks. An accepted result can be represented as a validation slice that records the mapped roles, signals, dependencies, and context intended to support later evaluation. We study 83 threat abstractions across continuous-process and manufacturing sources using separate evaluation denominators. The continuous-process study evaluates 78 abstractions against target contracts spanning water treatment, water distribution, hydropower, and chemical processes. Selected cases are exercised through controlled perturbations of simulator-role signals. We also test compatibility with several analysis styles, including the released upstream GeCo implementation, and conduct a three-objective, one-target realizability study using a paper-derived search reproduction. Across these evaluated settings, the results support treating explicit target checks and traceable evidence as separate from semantic similarity alone.

0.40

MARS: Detecting Unauthorized Variable Manipulations in Multi-Application PLC Runtimes

cs.CR ·2026-09-05 ·Syed Ghazanfar Abbas, Dongyan Xu
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 15 pages

Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs) increasingly run multiple applications alongside the main control program, with shared access to PLC variables. Yet, Industrial Control System (ICS) defenses primarily detect malicious updates by checking whether variable values violate expected bounds, without considering which application performed the update. A malicious application can exploit this gap by modifying variables within normal bounds while still driving the physical process toward an unsafe state. Even when such manipulation is detected, operators cannot identify the responsible application because PLCs do not associate variable updates with application identity. We present MARS, an automated framework for application-level authorization and attribution of PLC variable manipulations. MARS profiles applications on an isolated virtual PLC (vPLC) to derive application-specific variable-access policies and uses a shadow vPLC during operation to attribute production-PLC updates to individual applications without instrumenting the production controller. MARS also detects manipulations that occur only on the production PLC and therefore have no corresponding update on the shadow vPLC. We evaluate MARS on manufacturing, chemical, and water-treatment systems against attacks in which unauthorized applications manipulate PLC variables while remaining within normal bounds. Our results show that MARS detects these manipulations and identifies the responsible application.

0.19

Towards Model-based Run-time Cybersecurity: On Control-Flow Anomaly Detection, Attack Identification, and Hardware Monitoring

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-08-12 ·Martin Sachenbacher, Martin Leucker, Alexander Weiss, Aliyu Tanko Ali
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 14 pages

Methods to increase the resilience of systems to cyber-attacks become increasingly important. Control-flow monitoring provides a principled basis to ensure integrity and detect possible anomalies at run-time. Once anomalies have been detected, so-called attack trees can be used to identify possible types of attacks. However, this approach is vulnerable to camouflage, by which attackers try to evade detection (and correct identification) by deliberately manipulating also the system's observed control flow. In this paper, we outline a model-based approach that provides more robust intrusion detection and attack identification through an architecture that combines software- with hardware-based monitoring. In this approach, software-level observation indicates suspicious activities, while hardware-level monitoring checks them separately in more detail, making it much harder for attacks to camouflage themselves and go undetected. We illustrate the approach with an authentication-service example that captures a realistic failure mode: a software-level observer sees an anomalous but apparently harmless control-flow deviation, maps it to a benign root cause in an attack tree, but misses the true intrusion. A second, independent hardware control-flow monitor observes the actual transition sequence and thereby changes the attack-tree diagnosis from a low-severity configuration or maintenance issue to a high-confidence code-injection or control-flow hijack. In this scenario, the proposed combination of control-flow anomaly detection, attack-tree based intrusion identification, and hardware-based monitoring can improve not only anomaly detection, but also the diagnostic precision of attack-tree-based cyber-attack identification.

0.10

No-Box Vulnerability Analysis: Description-only Detection of Indirect Prompt Injection Vulnerabilities in MCP Servers

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-09-09 ·Zehua Zhang, Jie Hu, Pratham Hegde, Aditya Maheshbhai Gabani, Souradip Nath +11 more
similarity 0.64
Abstract

Conventional vulnerability analysis relies on either system access or dynamic interaction, all of which may be unavailable to third-party analysts auditing closed-source, remotely hosted, critical in situ systems, or commercially gated software. Therefore, we propose a new paradigm of no-box vulnerability analysis in which neither access nor runtime interaction is available, and only functionality metadata is available. Such metadata defines the intended behavior of the system, including its inputs, outputs, and side effects, while constraining the space of implementations consistent with that behavior. We propose hypothesizing about vulnerabilities that exist across all possible implementations of a given system metadata, without observing or interacting with the target system. An analyst can later validate these hypotheses when additional access is available. We showcase the feasibility of no-box vulnerability analysis through implementing a prototype called MCPSEC, which audits Model Context Protocol (MCP) servers for indirect prompt injection vulnerabilities using only the tool metadata exposed at server registration time. We evaluate MCPSEC on 20 widely deployed MCP servers comprising 177 tools, among which human evaluators confirm 95 vulnerable tools. MCPSEC identified 143 tools as vulnerable, and for each vulnerable tool, it produced a hypothesized vulnerability along with exploitation technique. Using metadata alone, MCPSEC predicted 94 (98.9% recall) real verified vulnerabilities, compared against an LLM baseline with 80 (84.2% recall). Overall, our results introduce no-box vulnerability analysis as a new analysis paradigm and demonstrate its practical feasibility in realistic systems.

0.23

Blocking at the Boundary: Auditing Long-Horizon Agents against Staged Prompt Injection

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-10-04 ·Jingkai Liu, Yufei Han, Xiaoting Lyu, Wei Wang, Ting Yu
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract · 29 pages, 10 figures, 20 tables. Code and data: https://anonymous.4open.science/r/audit-artifact-E593

Long-horizon agents consume external content, invoke tools, and modify persistent state. Indirect prompt injection can exploit task-specific context, propagate across causally connected stages, and alter a consequential action while the workflow continues; we term this staged prompt injection. We build an automated, feedback-guided attack generation pipeline and apply it to Claude Code and Codex in their native runtimes. The confirmed attacks span eight workflow scenarios, seven attack goals, and six injection surfaces, showing that production agents are vulnerable to context-aware, multi-step injection over long horizons. Stopping such attacks requires a decision before each consequential action: input screening and completed-run evaluation cannot locate the intervention point, and existing pre-action methods use incompatible units and labels. We therefore formulate boundary action auditing: given initial context, a trajectory prefix, and a fully specified pending message or tool call, an auditor predicts Pass or Block before its effect occurs. Pairing attacked and benign executions yields a 479-pair, 3,112-unit benchmark. We further propose Path-Aligned Attribution (PAA), a training-free auditor that decomposes pending actions into operative elements and traces what supplied each value and guided each decision. PAA blocks only when the model attributes an unwarranted, material effect on an element to an attacker-reachable source that either provides unqualified steering or conflicts with visible evidence. Under full-benchmark fail-open scoring with Claude Sonnet 5, PAA reaches 86% Block recall at a 6-8% false-block rate (FBR), whereas ARGUS reaches 44-47% recall at 16-33% FBR. Under the same backend, on the tool calls that all three auditors natively support, PAA has higher recall and lower FBR than VIGIL and ARGUS; all paired 95% confidence intervals exclude zero.

0.29

PLCBench: Can Autonomous LLM Agents Turn PLC Access into Sustained Physical Impact?

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-08-27 ·Yitian Zhou, Jingyu Zheng, Qiliang Jiang, Linkang Du, Haoming Liu +4 more
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 36 pages, 13 figures

Industrial control systems (ICSs) rely on programmable logic controllers (PLCs) to connect networked computation with physical control. Tool-using large language model (LLM) agents represent an emerging attack threat: can an autonomous agent convert a network-reachable PLC into sustained adverse physical impact? However, existing evaluations focus on digital tasks or individual stages of PLC testing. In ICSs, evaluations that stop at software exploitation, an accepted write, or tool access may therefore mischaracterize physical risk. We present PLCBENCH, to our knowledge, the first real-PLC hardware-in-the-loop (HIL) framework for characterizing this cyber-to-physical capability and its boundaries. It combines vendor-native interaction, commercial PLC execution, closed-loop reduced-order process simulation, and independent outcome verification. A deterministic evaluator applies fixed rules to runner, communication, PLC-object, and process records to assign six hidden diagnostic flags, distinguishing usable PLC interaction, process-linked manipulation, and sustained physical impact. We instantiate PLCBENCH on four commercial PLCs crossed with four closed-loop workloads. Across five LLM families and 240 real-PLC episodes, 75 episodes (31.3%) sustain their respective physical objectives. Stagewise results show that 98 episodes stop before a valid native read, whereas 62 reach a process-linked write but do not sustain the final objective. Notably, richer process observation is associated with an increase in conditional objective attainment after a process-linked write from 44.2% to 64.0%. These measurements localize failure in configured PLC-process deployments and identify intervention points for future defense evaluation. To support reproducibility, we release the safely disclosable PLCBENCH code and a software-only reproduction pipeline through the accompanying artifact.

0.19

Poster: Towards Selecting Threat Appropriate Industrial Intrusion Detection Systems

cs.CR ·2026-09-11 ·Stefan Lenz, Johannes Weidmann, Martin Henze
top venue similarity 0.62
Abstract

As the threat landscape against industrial control systems is dynamic, effective security requires detection strategies capable of timely reactions to these evolving threat situations. To address this problem, we propose the idea of a counter-threat intelligence sharing based mechanism to select appropriate detectors for current circumstances. To highlight the potential of this mechanism, we conduct attack-level performance evaluations of various intrusion detection systems. Results show the variance of intrusion detection performance depending on the attack scenario, emphasizing the benefits of such a mechanism for industrial control system security

0.53

SoK: When Safe Agents Fail Together: The Security of Multi Agent LLM Systems

cs.CR cs.AI ·2026-09-01 ·Rui Yang, Junjie Xu, Zhengyu Liu, Neil Fendley, Yang Hong +2 more
surveybenchmarkhighly cited similarity 0.62
Abstract · 21 pages

Safe agents can fail together. Multi-agent LLM systems (MAS) move information, state, decisions, and authority across principal boundaries, creating failures that local checks may miss. Without an execution-level view, a multi-agent setting can easily be mistaken for evidence of a genuinely multi-agent security effect. We thus systematize MAS security through an execution-centered analysis of 197 works, covering six interaction interfaces, four adversary positions, seven system-level risks, and eight recurring attack paths. We introduce an A-I-R framework that organizes attacks by adversary position, interaction interface, and resulting system-level risk, unifying otherwise fragmented attack mechanisms across MAS. We organize defenses through a five-part contract covering path target, observation, intervention, trust boundary, and recovery, and identify path closure and recovery as key challenges. We audit 44 evaluation and benchmark works and identify open challenges in isolating interaction effects, designing comparable and diagnostic metrics, supporting reuse across MAS designs, and evaluating open-system operation. Together, these findings motivate an interaction-aware view of MAS security: trace attacks end to end, test whether defenses close those paths, and evaluate system-level effects with appropriate counterfactuals.

0.40