CS Paper Radar

Fairness Beyond a Single Run: Training-Seed Variability in Speech LLM Adaptation

Srishti Ginjala, Eric Fosler-Lussier, Srinivasan Parthasarathy

cs.CL ·submitted 2026-09-30 04:51 UTC · v1

Abstract

Demographic fairness gaps in automatic speech recognition are almost always reported from a single training run. We fine-tune the Q-former projector and LoRA adapters of a speech LLM at five audio compression factors and six random seeds, holding the encoder, base decoder, data and decoding fixed, and evaluate every run on Common Voice and Fair-Speech. At 460 h of clean LibriSpeech, the seed moves fairness metrics more than compression does on most demographic axes. A balanced 3x3 decomposition attributes 85.3% of the variation in Fair-Speech ethnicity normalized gap to the seed against 8.3% to compression (p = 0.009), though compression explains more on age and gender. Held-out LibriSpeech word error rate spreads by 0.04 points across those seeds while Common Voice spreads by 8.57, so these are not failed runs, and the effect survives controlling for accuracy and dropout. Scaling and diversifying the adaptation set to 960 h damps the effect but does not remove it. On Fair-Speech ethnicity, two single-run systems must differ by more than 0.30 in normalized gap to exceed seed variability.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Pruning for Efficiency, Paying in Fairness: Demographic Disparities in Pruned Speech-LLMs

cs.SD cs.CL ·2026-09-29 ·Ganesh Pavan Kartikeya Bharadwaj Kolluri, Michael Kampouridis, Ravi Shekhar
similarity 0.72
Abstract · Accepted to IMPACT-SPEECH@EMNLP'26

Speech-LLMs are expensive to run, making compression important for real-world deployment. However, compressed models are usually selected using aggregate word error rate (WER), which can hide how pruning affects different demographic groups. In this work, we systematically study the effect of audio encoder pruning on SLAM-ASR for different demographic groups. Using the Fair-Speech and Common Voice datasets, we found that the pruning does not affect all demographic groups equally; the gap between best- and worst-performing groups increases in fold. These disparities appear across all three encoder scales, but only the largest model initially hides them behind aggregate WER. LoRA adaptation improves WER for every group, but benefits groups already performing well more strongly and widens for certain groups. On Common Voice English, Danish, and Dutch, accent gaps persist but do not clearly widen, showing that the fairness effects of pruning vary across datasets and must be measured directly. Our findings suggest that for pruned models, deployment decisions should include per-group WER, with the worst-performing group's error rate as an explicit criterion.

0.23

Temporal Taxation Compounds Under Post-Training Compression of Whisper Models

cs.CL cs.SD ·2026-09-23 ·Srishti Ginjala, Eric Fosler-Lussier, Christopher W. Myers, Srinivasan Parthasarathy
hot direction similarity 0.70
Abstract · Accepted to IMPACT-SPEECH @ EMNLP 2026

Automatic speech recognition models are audited for demographic fairness at full precision, yet the models that ship to production have been quantized, pruned, and distilled. We ask whether post-training weight compression, which alters model weights rather than the audio signal or its feature representation, redistributes error burden across demographic groups. Across the Whisper family on Fair-Speech, Common Voice 25, and AfriSpeech-200, 50% Wanda pruning of Whisper-large-v3 sharply widens the Black/AA-vs-Asian temporal-taxation differential on Fair-Speech: the absolute word-error-rate gap between the worst- and best-served groups more than doubles; at an assumed cost of five seconds of correction effort per transcription error this is a rise from 30 to 64 seconds of correction time per minute of speech. This +111% relative increase is invariant to the assumed per-error cost, survives an audio-quality control, and is only partly mitigated by beam-search decoding, which still leaves an +86% increase. At edge model size, INT4 HQQ quantization compounds catastrophic transcript loops on West African accents by factors of five to seven. Distillation, by contrast, narrows demographic gaps in 21 of 27 evaluated settings (teacher-student pair, precision, and dataset), with the exceptions concentrated on a single model pair. We cast the temporal-taxation construct of Choi and Choi (2025) as a quantitative metric, and show that single-snapshot fairness audits on full-precision models do not capture the deployment-time burden that compression places on already-marginalized speakers.

0.39

A Probe Shift Is Not a Fairness Fix: The Limits of Representation Steering in Speech Models

cs.CL ·2026-09-16 ·Nicolas Bourrel, Abderrahmane Issam, Gerasimos Spanakis
similarity 0.69
Abstract · Accepted at IMPACT-SPEECH 2026

Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems exhibit unequal error rates across speaker groups, motivating interventions on their internal representations. We ask whether speaker-linked attributes that are linearly readable from pretrained ASR encoders yield useful directions for reducing group word-error-rate (WER) gaps. Across Whisper-medium, HuBERT-large, and Wav2Vec2-large on Common Voice and the Speech Accent Archive, we probe every encoder layer for metadata-derived sex/gender, age, and native/accent labels; construct centroid and probe-derived directions; inject them at selected layers; and compare downstream probe trajectories with matched WER changes. Sex labels are highly decodable (best macro-F1 0.924--0.941), native/accent labels are also above chance (0.544--0.696), and age is weaker (0.354--0.397). Of 22 post-selected reruns, nine have 95% paired-bootstrap intervals entirely below zero, yet every absolute source-group WER reduction is below 0.7 percentage points. Conversely, a local target-class probe rate can rise from 8.09% to 99.87% while WER worsens. Linear readability is therefore neither evidence of causal use nor a reliable mitigation method. Our results motivate evaluating speech-bias interventions jointly at representation, propagation, and task levels.

0.35

Clean-anchored excess-emission control for CTC adaptation under competing speech

cs.SD ·2026-11-02 ·Yuanbo Zhou, Junjie Xiong
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Competing speech can cause excess emissions in a connectionist temporal classification (CTC) recognizer. We penalize the amount by which the noisy student's expected collapsed token count exceeds a frozen teacher's count on the paired clean utterance. The one-sided objective caches one scalar per utterance and adds no inference module. With 147,456 trainable parameters in wav2vec 2.0, it improves competing-speech word error rate (WER) over matched CTC-only adaptation across three development seeds. On a locked LibriSpeech test, speech-interference WER falls from 45.198% to 44.323%, while clean WER changes by 0.004 percentage points. Unseen VCTK interferers yield a 0.307-point improvement. Ablations favor collapsed-count control over frame-mass regularization. Longer training increases the speech gain but worsens noise and music performance, identifying an insertion-deletion tradeoff rather than uniform robustness.

0.17

When Entanglement Lower-Bounds Disparity: Auditing and Repairing Demographic Fairness in Audio Understanding Models

cs.SD cs.CL ·2026-09-23 ·Kian Shamsaie, Iman Modarressi
published similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted by IEEE SLT 2026

Speech technology penalizes some voices: recognition errs nearly twice as often for Black speakers, and accuracy declines for second-language accents and older speakers. We introduce TRIAD, an audit grid crossing 120 texts, 24 rendered demographic voice profiles (gender, age band, accent), and ten expressive styles via controllable text-to-speech, isolating perceived demographic attributes from content and affect. For ten open-weights encoders we define axis-fidelity functionals, principal-angle leakage between axis subspaces, and group-conditional gaps; a proposition proves that average probe disparity grows with the same aggregate voice-semantic leakage $Λ$ we measure, and a corollary shows that peak leakage forces worst-case disparity inside an active region. The measured mean-square probe disparity tracks $Λ$ (Pearson r = 0.93), and a black-box protocol exposes the same signature in two closed-source models. ORCA, an adapter combining axis-specific contrastive heads, an orthogonality penalty, and group-balanced sampling, cuts leakage 72% and roughly halves the gaps.

0.33

InterCorrect: Intersection-Aware Correction of Demographic Model Merging for Fair ASR

cs.CL cs.SD ·2026-10-06 ·Ashley E. Bravo-Bravo, Yuchen Zhang, Haralambos Mouratidis, Ravi Shekhar, Monorama Swain
similarity 0.64
Abstract · Under Review

Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems often show uneven performance across demographic groups, and errors can be especially difficult to address for speakers belonging to multiple demographic groups. This work studies demographic-aware model merging for fair Speech-LLM-based ASR. Starting from a SLAM-ASR-based model, we fine-tune only the connector on demographic-specific subsets and merge the resulting subgroup-adapted connectors into a global model. We then identify critical cross-axis demographic pairs using subgroup WER and task-vector conflict, and apply intersection-specific correction vectors to the global merged model. Experiments on Fair-Speech show that global demographic merging improves overall WER over the base model, while intersection correction provides additional gains for several merging strategies. In particular, TIES with WER-based correction achieves the best overall WER, reducing it from 7.38\% to 5.13\%. Subgroup and disparity analyses further show that the proposed approach improves performance across demographic axes, while highlighting that lower average WER does not always imply reduced subgroup disparity.

0.41

SURE-Voice: A Front-End Baseline for Speech-Evidence Filtering in Speech LLMs

eess.AS cs.CLcs.SD ·2026-08-27 ·Mengzhe Geng
benchmark similarity 0.64
Abstract

Speech language models (speech LLMs) can generate plausible outputs from audio that contains no usable speech evidence. We study this failure as a pre-generation support-estimation problem and present SURE-Voice, a training-free front end that decides whether an audio prompt contains intelligible speech evidence before calling a speech LLM. We build SURE-Challenge with a 640-example SURE-Core split and a 1,920-example SURE-Extended split derived from 120 LibriSpeech source utterances. Using one fixed operating point, an energy screen plus Whisper token confidence raises unsupported accuracy on the held-out Extended test from 0.000--0.133 to 0.919 for six non-degenerate speech LLM backbones, while supported accuracy remains 0.919--0.970 and downstream calls fall from 480 to 287. A 500-clip ESC-50 sanity set shows the same pattern on real environmental audio, with vocal non-speech as a residual failure mode. An overlap diagnostic shows that source attribution remains separate from speech-evidence filtering. The evidence supports a controlled benchmark baseline and a deployment-oriented analysis; it does not establish universal robustness to semantic answerability, gain variation or natural conversations.

0.17

Measuring Fairness in Large Audio Language Models via Semantic-Aware Bias Estimation

cs.CL cs.AIcs.SD ·2026-08-13 ·Zhe Liu
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Large Audio Language Models (LALMs) have seen increasing use for audio understanding tasks such as speech recognition and audio question answering, raising concerns about fairness across demographic subgroups. Fairness evaluation in spoken-input settings is challenging due to confounding factors, including semantic variation in spoken content and speaker-specific characteristics. Ignoring these factors can result in misleading conclusions about model bias. We propose a semantic-aware mixed-effects regression framework for fairness evaluation in LALMs that explicitly accounts for these confounders. Our approach incorporates sentence-level semantic embeddings of reference text as covariates and models speaker identity as a random effect. Notably, semantic representations are extracted from the same LALM under evaluation, enabling semantic control over variation as perceived by the model itself. Experiments on simulated data and real-world benchmarks demonstrate that the proposed approach substantially reduces spurious fairness findings and yields more robust and interpretable estimates of subgroup performance differences.

0.04