CS Paper Radar

Beyond Leaderboard Scores: A Deployment-Focused Protocol for Interpretable Tracking Evaluation in Pedestrian-Centric Environments

Dominik Wojcikiewicz, Diego Paez-Granados

cs.RO cs.CV ·submitted 2026-10-01 13:39 UTC · v1
benchmarkcode/data

Abstract

Mobile robots operating among pedestrians need trajectories that become available quickly, remain spatially credible through missed observations, preserve identity, and fit within an embedded computing budget. Aggregate tracking scores provide limited insight into when and how trajectories fail, while varying detector inputs can confound tracker and detector quality. We present a deployment-focused, tracker-only evaluation protocol that uses shared detections to isolate tracker behavior and directly evaluates initialization, detector-gap continuation, identity recovery, close-neighbor association, and load-dependent tracker-step runtime, while Higher Order Tracking Accuracy (HOTA) is retained as a complementary aggregate measure. We apply the protocol to the JackRabbot Dataset and Benchmark (JRDB) using six open-source trackers and our lightweight Pedestrian Reference Tracker (PedRefTrack), together with a GT-assisted variant that estimates the remaining tracker-side gap under idealized association and motion. Under fixed detections, the non-GT trackers span only 24.26%-29.67% HOTA yet exhibit markedly different capability profiles. After 1.0 s without detector support, no tracker without GT assistance maintains spatially correct, same-identity output in more than half of eligible cases, making missing-observation continuation the dominant limitation among the tested properties. Close-neighbor failures are smaller and increase mainly at the shortest separations. Tracker-step runtime on an NVIDIA Jetson Orin is heavy-tailed and load-sensitive, causing several trackers to fall below the 10 Hz real-time target in crowded frames. The protocol provides a reproducible way to characterize tracker behavior and deployment suitability in pedestrian-centric environments. Code and evaluation scripts are released at https://github.com/SCAI-Lab/tracker_eval.

Comment
8 pages, 7 figures; supplementary video provided as ancillary material. Submitted to IEEE Robotics and Automation Letters (RA-L)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

CrowdTraj: A Benchmark for Dense Crowd Trajectory Prediction in Realistic Crowded Environments

cs.CV ·2026-09-07 ·Antonius Bima Murti Wijaya, Paul Henderson, Marwa Mahmoud
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract

In real-world applications, pedestrian trajectory prediction models rely on inputs from detection and tracking systems. Prior trajectory prediction benchmarks either contain relatively sparse pedestrian interactions, assume perfect tracking inputs, or rely on overhead viewpoints that minimize occlusion and perspective distortion, limiting evaluation in realistic dense-crowd scenarios. We present CrowdTraj, a benchmark for pedestrian trajectory prediction in natural dense crowd scenes. Unlike previous datasets, CrowdTraj supports end-to-end evaluation from detection through tracking to trajectory prediction under severe occlusion in CCTV views. It also captures diverse, natural pedestrian behaviours, including abrupt directional changes rarely observed in existing benchmarks. CrowdTraj includes five diverse scenes, with an average of 1,146 unique pedestrians per scene, maximum frame-level densities ranging from 114 to 372 pedestrians, and over 3.2 million annotated head bounding boxes. CrowdTraj provides pixel and real-world coordinates via per-scene homography matrices for physically meaningful analysis. Our experimental results show that tracking accuracy (IDF1) drops to 0.68 to 0.70 in the densest scenes, compared with approximately 0.90 in less crowded scenes. Trajectory prediction training also becomes substantially more computationally expensive in dense scenes, with training times increasing by up to 8 times. These findings show that CrowdTraj exposes limitations in current trajectory prediction pipelines that remain hidden on existing sparse-crowd benchmarks, particularly in robustness to tracking noise and computational scalability.

0.30

The Impact of Detector Architecture, Model Scale, and Scene Density on Multi-Pedestrian Tracking

cs.CV cs.LG ·2026-10-14 ·Pedro Manoel Herminio Alves, Dalton Cézane Gomes Valadares, Cláudio de Souza Baptista
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 6

Pedestrian tracking in video is important for applications such as surveillance and scene analysis, but it becomes more challenging in crowded scenarios with frequent occlusions and rapid motion. This paper analyzes how detector architecture, model scale, scene density, and inference regime affect the tracking of multiple pedestrians. We compare the YOLO11, RT-DETR, and YOLO26 detector families with the ByteTrack and BoT-SORT trackers on sequences from the MOT17, MOT20, and SOMPT22 benchmarks. For YOLO26, we also compare traditional overlap filtering via Non-Maximum Suppression (NMS) with end-to-end inference. The RT-DETR family achieved the highest mean scores on the HOTA tracking quality metric across all three benchmarks with both trackers, with a more pronounced advantage on MOT20, albeit at a higher computational cost. On MOT17 and SOMPT22, YOLO26 variants, especially YOLO26-L with NMS, offered favorable combinations of quality and speed compared with RT-DETR. In the YOLO26 inference comparison, the end-to-end mode did not yield consistent tracking gains over the NMS-based regime. Taken together, these results provide a practical guide for selecting detectors and trackers for this task based on application priorities.

0.16

Beyond the Survey: A Systematic Empirical Study of Detection and Association in Visual MOT

cs.CV ·2026-09-14 ·Linh Van Ma, Juhua Hu, Wei Cheng, Unse Fatima, Moongu Jeon
top venuecode/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted for publication in Artificial Intelligence Review

This paper presents a comprehensive experimental evaluation and detailed analysis of state-of-the-art multi-object tracking algorithms, with an emphasis on quantifying the individual contributions of detection and association components to overall tracking performance. Unlike existing surveys that primarily offer theoretical categorizations or taxonomies of tracking methods, our work adopts a rigorous experimental perspective grounded in publicly available implementations, providing practical guidance for researchers and practitioners in method selection and system design. We introduce a unified pipeline diagram that consolidates the core components across the two main branches of visual multi-object tracking: tracking-by-detection and end-to-end deep learning paradigms, and systematically analyze the object detection, feature extraction, and data association modules. Through extensive empirical studies on standard benchmarks, including MOT16, MOT17, MOT20, SportsMOT, DanceTrack, and CrowdTrack datasets, we reveal critical insights: (1) detection quality dominates association strategy performance, with detector improvements yielding more than 10% gains compared to less than 5% from refined association strategies; (2) modern deep learning detectors paired with specialized re-identification models significantly outperform joint detection and embedding approaches; and (3) transformer-based end-to-end methods exhibit greater robustness to detection quality variations but at a substantial computational cost. Our findings from extensive experiments provide key insights into component-level effects in MOT, particularly the dominant influence of detection quality relative to association, while offering practical insights for designing and optimizing MOT systems under varying performance and robustness requirements. Code and experimental setups are available at github.com/linh-gist/VisualMOT.

0.49

DensePed-Lite: Quality-Aware Adaptive Detection for Dense Pedestrians under Occlusion

cs.CV ·2026-09-30 ·ZiAn Wang, MingZhe Liu, Chaoyi Guo, ChangChun Li, Fangming Gu
published similarity 0.63
Abstract · Accepted at WISE 2026

Pedestrian detection plays a crucial role in computer vision with applications in autonomous driving, surveillance, and public safety. However, real-world dense scenes bring severe challenges, including heavy occlusion, drastic scale variations, and strict real-time requirements. Existing lightweight detectors struggle to balance accuracy and efficiency while often neglecting quality-aware feature modeling and consistency between classification and localization, leading to unstable performance under crowded conditions. To address these issues, we propose DensePed-Lite, a unified framework built on a single principle: under occlusion the network should adapt its behavior to the quality of what it observes rather than assume complete information. This principle is realized at three points where occlusion does the most damage: unreliable confidence scoring (UQE), fragmented spatial coverage (MPSC), and incoherent multi-scale fusion (CTDM). The three mechanisms reinforce one another instead of acting in isolation, all without significantly increasing complexity. Experiments on CityPersons and CrowdHuman validate that DensePed-Lite achieves a superior accuracy-efficiency trade-off compared with recent state-of-the-art lightweight methods, making it suitable for real-time deployment in dense pedestrian scenarios.

0.21

HIVE-ECIA: Identity-Aware Historical Evidence Acquisition for Bandwidth-Efficient Multi-Object Tracking

cs.CV ·2026-11-15 ·Hai Nguyen, Tarik Taleb, Qize Guo
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Panoramic multi-object tracking (MOT) requires reliable identity association across a 360° field of view, yet bandwidth-constrained operation forces a trade-off between low-resolution (LR) identity ambiguity and costly high-resolution (HR) transmission. We propose HIVE-ECIA, an identity-aware framework that selectively retrieves historical HR evidence to recover fragmented identities without modifying detection boxes or the underlying tracker. An ECIA Base-Guided query policy determines when additional HR evidence is warranted; HIVE ranks historical LR observations to select an informative retrieval timestamp; and ECIA Full integrates the retrieved HR crop through learned gated fusion and conservative identity safeguards. We further introduce DualPano-MOT, a real-world dual-fisheye panoramic evaluation dataset featuring controlled pedestrian interactions, panorama-seam challenges, and occlusions, with model-assisted, manually verified tracking annotations. On held-out QuadTrack sequences and zero-shot DualPano-MOT, HIVE-ECIA improves identity association across four MOT trackers without tracker-specific retraining. Across these trackers, identity switches decrease by up to 21.8% and 23.4%, while the largest IDF1 gains reach 3.81 and 6.74 percentage points, respectively. Under an offline JPEG-based acquisition model, our framework reduces encoded data volume by 89.2% and 79.3% relative to continuous Full-HR acquisition.

0.12

Online Multi-Camera 3D Tracking via ID Prediction over Recurrent Sparse Queries

cs.CV ·2026-09-16 ·Pragyan Shrestha, Haruto Nakayama, Atom Scott
benchmark similarity 0.63
Abstract

Online multi camera 3D tracking must maintain scene global identities across synchronized views, yet query-based trackers carry these identities only implicitly in the instance bank, where they fragment upon query interruption. We present an online architecture that recovers association accuracy by predicting IDs explicitly over recurrent sparse queries. An outside-in Sparse4D detector fuses calibrated views into world frame 3D detections while propagating a sparse query bank, and a causal MOTIP ID decoder associates detections against a finite trajectory memory. We adapt MOTIP's relative-ID prediction and recycled slot runtime to globally fused 3D observations, and introduce metric spatial gating and proximity based newborn recovery. On the official 2026 AI City Challenge Track 1 test set, our method raises HOTA from 29.63 with native instance bank identities to 38.01, primarily through an AssA increase from 20.83 to 31.10, and ranks third on the public leaderboard. Full-sequence validation over all 9,000 frames of each scene shows that decoupled ID training improves HOTA over native identities, whereas continuing detector training alongside the detached ID objective produces scene-dependent gains and losses.

0.46

CLIFT: Contrastive LiDAR Instance Features for 3D Pedestrian Tracking

cs.CV ·2026-11-16 ·German Devchich, Timur Akhtyamov, Denis Fatykhoph, Gonzalo Ferrer
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.63
Abstract

A social robot has to keep track of the people around it over time to plan its motion, a task handled by 3D multi-object tracking. For the LiDAR modality, trackers usually sit on top of a detector and link its detections across frames with a separate motion model or re-identification network. We instead show how a 3D LiDAR detector itself can be turned into a tracker by adding an instance-level contrastive objective on its intermediate voxel features. Each embedding is read from the voxels inside a detected box, and boxes are matched across frames by cosine similarity and the Hungarian algorithm, without a motion model. The detector backbone is fine-tuned together with this objective, which learns identity-aware features while leaving detection accuracy essen- tially intact. Because the method uses only the voxel features that Li- DAR detectors already produce, it is backbone-agnostic. On the JRDB 3D tracking leaderboard our LiDAR-only tracker ranks first on HOTA (38.58) and IDF1 (37.99), 13.04 and 9.30 points above the next pub- lished method, and second on MOTA and OSPA. Code is available at https://hermak56.github.io/CLIFT/.

0.38

TrackFlood: Relocating Latency Attacks from NMS-Free Detectors to Real-Time Trackers

cs.CR ·2026-09-27 ·Zonghua Gu, Julian Singh-Smith, Junlin Liao, Di Liu, Amin Saremi
similarity 0.62
Abstract

We consider latency attacks on object detectors, where the attacker's goal is not to corrupt a prediction but to make the system fail to respond in time, targeting real-time applications such as autonomous driving. Modern object detectors eliminate Non-Maximum Suppression (NMS) through one-to-one assignment or set prediction, removing the classical detector-side latency bottleneck exploited by prior latency (``sponge'') attacks. We show that NMS-free does not mean latency-robust: this architectural change does not eliminate the attack surface but relocates it downstream to multi-object tracking, whose data-association cost remains content dependent. We present \emph{TrackFlood}, a unified white-box overload attack against NMS-free detect-then-track pipelines spanning both one-to-one detectors (YOLOv10 and YOLO26) and query-based detectors (RT-DETR). TrackFlood recovers differentiable confidence tensors and optimizes perturbations that flood the tracker with spatially distributed phantom detections while leaving detector inference unchanged. Evaluated entirely on an NVIDIA Jetson AGX Orin (TensorRT FP16), detector latency remains essentially constant, whereas tracker latency increases substantially. At a standard imperceptible budget ($L_\infty{=}8/255$), a universal perturbation produces clearly measurable tracker overload but only modest end-to-end slowdown, without deadline misses for the association-dominated trackers; a separate higher-budget stress test drives severe end-to-end slowdowns and sustained deadline misses. We further evaluate a lightweight, architecture-agnostic bounded-admission layer that caps the tracker workload and largely restores end-to-end latency, at a non-trivial cost in admitted clean detections. Our results demonstrate that evaluating NMS-free perception systems requires considering downstream tracking and end-to-end timing, not detector inference alone.

0.34