CS Paper Radar

Network Coding Can Beat Routing in Undirected Multiple-Unicast Networks

Xindan Zhang, Baochun Li, Zongpeng Li

cs.IT ·submitted 2026-10-07 03:20 UTC · v1
theoryhighly cited

Abstract

Network coding lets the nodes of a network combine messages rather than merely forward them. In undirected networks, where the two directions of an edge share its capacity, Li and Li conjectured in 2004 that coding offers no advantage over fractional routing; the conjecture has been confirmed for many special classes but never settled in general. In this paper, we disprove it by constructing a finite connected simple undirected network with unit shared edge capacities, maximum degree three, and distinct leaf terminals, on which a binary linear block code achieves a common rate strictly above the maximum fractional routing rate. The construction turns a short completion-time code into a reversible circuit whose registers all carry independent messages, and a temporal metric on its wires yields the strict routing bound. The underlying integer-coefficient construction works over every finite field and every nontrivial finite abelian group; for deterministic fixed-schedule codes the common-rate supremum is one and the closure of the rate region is the unit cube. Amplifying the gap with a degree-preserving tensor construction and an even subdivision gives, for every $0<β<1$, an unbounded family of connected, simple, subcubic, bipartite networks with girth at least $n^β$ on which coding approaches rate one while routing is bounded by $K_β/(\log n)^c$, with one positive exponent $c$ independent of $β$. The finite counterexample and the family theorem are formalized in Lean.

Comment
17 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

The Multiple Unicast Conjecture is False

cs.IT cs.CCcs.DMcs.DS ·2026-10-07 ·Mark Braverman, Zhongtian He
theoryhighly cited similarity 0.70
Abstract

The undirected multiple-unicast conjecture [LL04] asserts that network coding offers no throughput advantage over multicommodity flow. We refute this conjecture by constructing a deterministic linear network code over $\mathbb{F}_9$ on a 182-vertex bipartite subgraph of the point-line incidence graph of $\mathrm{PG}(2,9)$. The construction supports $157$ independent unicast sessions at common coding rate at least $1$, while every fractional multicommodity flow has common rate at most $147/157$. By the amplification theorem of~[BGS17], this yields a family of undirected multiple-unicast instances with coding gap $Ω((\log n)^\varepsilon)$ for some $\varepsilon>0$. We also introduce a nondeterministic model of network coding based on locally verifiable certificates, which guides our construction and may be of independent interest. Building on the high-girth graph and error-correcting code framework of [BH25], we use GPT-6 to find a nondeterministic counterexample based on a new choice of Reed--Solomon local codes, and then convert this example into a causal code using an edge orientation and local search.

0.39

Undirected Multiple-Unicast Network Coding and Faster External-Memory Integer Sorting

cs.DS cs.CCcs.IT ·2026-10-14 ·Baochun Li, Zongpeng Li, Sirui Liu
code/data similarity 0.69
Abstract · 43 pages, 4 figures, 1 table. Lean 4 formalization and verification code: https://github.com/rtyu-1/coded-sorting-lean

In undirected multiple-unicast networks, where independent messages are sent between specified source--destination pairs, network coding allows intermediate nodes to combine messages, whereas fractional routing splits and forwards individual messages along paths without mixing them. Proposed in 2004 by Li and Li and independently by Harvey, Kleinberg, and Lehman, the multiple-unicast conjecture---a central conjecture in network coding with deep connections to computational complexity---asserts that network coding and fractional routing have the same achievable rate region. We construct a counterexample refuting this conjecture and use it to reduce block transfers in external-memory data rearrangement, thereby accelerating external-memory integer sorting and answering in the affirmative the longstanding question of Aggarwal and Vitter (1988) on whether integer operations can beat the comparison-sorting input/output (I/O) bound. Specifically, we give a deterministic sorting algorithm: for $N$ integers of $Θ(\log N)$ bits, a memory holding $M$ integers, and block transfers of $B$ integers, where $2B\le M\le N$, the number of block transfers is \[ O\!\left(\frac{N}{B}\left[1+ \frac{\log N}{(\log(M/B))^{1-\varepsilon}(\log M)^\varepsilon} \right]\right), \] where $\varepsilon=1.5\times10^{-5}$ is an absolute constant. This bound asymptotically improves on the classical $Θ\!\left(\frac{N}{B}\left[1+ \frac{\log(N/M)}{\log(M/B)}\right]\right)$ comparison-sorting bound in certain parameter regimes. Under the external-memory model specified in this paper, we have formally verified the algorithm's correctness and I/O complexity bound in Lean~4.

0.57

When Multiple-Unicast Feasibility Is Equivalent to Single-Sink Routability

cs.IT ·2026-10-24 ·Sirui Liu, Zongpeng Li, Baochun Li
theory similarity 0.68
Abstract · 14 pages, 3 figures. Revised exposition and proof presentation

In communication networks, network coding allows intermediate nodes to combine messages, achieving transmission rates unattainable by routing alone in many multicast settings. In multiple unicast, where each source sends a message only to its prescribed destination, a central question is under what conditions fractional routing suffices to attain the transmission rates supported by network coding. We prove that, for any given collection of multiple-unicast demands in an undirected network, if the maximum flow between every pair of distinct destinations is at least the total demand rate, then the following are equivalent in feasibility: multiple-unicast coding, multiple-unicast fractional routing, and simultaneous fractional routing of all source rates to any fixed destination. Verifying this pairwise maximum-flow condition and, when it holds, deciding feasibility of the given multiple-unicast demands require at most as many maximum-flow computations as there are destinations. As a direct corollary, we prove the Langberg--Médard conjecture: if a directed network supports coded multicast of independent source messages at a common rate to every destination, then removing arc directions without changing capacities permits simultaneous fractional routing at that rate for all prescribed source--destination pairs.

0.25

Linear Network Coding for Sum All-Reduce over Ring Networks

cs.IT ·2026-11-16 ·Yi Chen, Zhuoqi Tu, Shenghao Yang
publishedtheory similarity 0.60
Abstract

Sum All-Reduce is a fundamental collective communication primitive in which each node holds a local vector and every node must recover the componentwise sum of all vectors. In distributed training, this operation is often implemented over a ring topology using a reduce--multicast scheme. We study sum All-Reduce on directed rings via linear network coding, which includes reduce--multicast as a special case. We give a necessary and sufficient feasibility condition in terms of the coding matrices. For a ring with $N\geq 3$ nodes and unit-capacity links, where each node holds a vector containing $K$ symbols, we prove that the number of time units $T$ required by any feasible linear code satisfies $T\ge\max\bigl\{K+N-2,\ \lceil\frac{2(N-1)}{N}K\rceil\bigr\}$, giving a rate $K/T$ of at most $N/(2(N-1))$. The bound is tight over every field. When $K\ge N$, an interleaved reduce--multicast code achieves the bound; when $K<N$ and $K$ divides $N$, a reduce--partial-multicast code does. When $K<N$ and $K$ does not divide $N$, no coordinate-wise code---in particular, no reduce--multicast code---achieves the bound, while an explicit linear network code does.

0.40

Routing Optimality for Demand Graphs of Matching Number at Most Two

cs.IT ·2026-10-13 ·Xiaohong Cai, Yulin Chen
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract · This paper has been submitted to ITW 2027

We prove that network coding and fractional routing have the same capacity region in undirected networks whose demand graph has matching number at most two, that is, when no three demand edges have pairwise disjoint endpoints. The metric-packing reduction of Liu et al. reduces this problem to a distance-weighted communication inequality on the fixed graph $Γ_{3,3}$. We first prove two entropy inequalities for sessions between designated terminal pairs on $Γ_{3,3}$. We then extend this result to sessions with arbitrary endpoints to obtain the distance-weighted communication bound required by the reduction. The proof combines conditional entropy inequalities with two graph contractions and an information inequality for deterministic interaction. Combining this inequality with the existing reduction establishes routing optimality for this class of demand graphs.

0.33

Binary Cyclic Gradient Coding: Exact Recovery and Robustness to Compression

cs.IT ·2026-10-14 ·Hassan Ou-azzou, Imad Kissami, El Houcine Bergou
theory similarity 0.59
Abstract

We introduce binary cyclic gradient coding (BCGC), an exact gradient coding scheme for $n$ workers and up to $s$ stragglers. Its encoding matrix is binary, circulant when $(s+1)\mid n$ and nearly circulant otherwise, and the master decodes by a single summation. Like the fractional repetition coding scheme (FRC) and its generalized version (GFRC), BCGC splits the workers into $s+1$ classes that each cover the whole dataset, but it assigns the data through cyclic supports. Its encoding matrix has rank $n-s$, and $n-s-1$ workers keep the balanced load $s+1$, which is the largest possible number. We prove that encoding matrix of BCGC is not permutation-equivalent to those of FRC and GFRC schemes. Moreover, We also prove that a binary coded scheme with compression is equivalent to an uncoded compressed scheme on a coarser partition of the data. This explains why binary schemes remain stable under compression, whereas the large decoding coefficients of MDS codes amplify the compression error and lead to divergence in our experiments. For every contractive compressor, the standard convergence guarantee of compressed gradient descent holds on each coarse partition. FRC, GFRC and BCGC therefore share the same convergence guarantee and differ only in their partitions, with one partition for FRC, two for GFRC and $s+1$ distinct partitions for BCGC. Choosing among these partitions can recover the exact gradient in cases where FRC and GFRC cannot. Experiments on four datasets confirm the theory. BCGC matches GFRC, keeps its accuracy under top $κ$ sparsification while the MDS codes diverge, and on heterogeneous data its partition diversity reduces the compression error and improves the accuracy.

0.18

Threshold Saturation from a Bounded Region in Multidimensional Spatially Coupled Codes over the BEC

cs.IT ·2026-09-21 ·Kenta Kasai
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract · 26 pages

We prove that a bounded shortened region initiates decoding throughout multidimensional spatially coupled regular LDPC and MacKay--Neal (MN) codes over the binary erasure channel (BEC). In every fixed finite dimension, uniform hypercube coupling permits the coupling width and shortened region to be chosen independently of the total number $V$ of spatial positions. At fixed widths and dimension $d>1$, replacing a shortened slab by a bounded hypercube reduces the shortening fraction from order $V^{-1/d}$ to order $V^{-1}$, with the same improvement in the shortening term of the check-count rate bound. Regular LDPC codes decode below their uncoupled potential threshold. MN codes achieve capacity for every integer degree choice $\ell>r\geq2$, $g\geq2$: their actual transmitted rates tend to $r/\ell$ and their average bit-erasure probabilities under sum-product decoding vanish below $1-r/\ell$. The proof combines an endpoint-potential identity, removal of an auxiliary constraint, finite-time estimates uniform in direction, and a curvature comparison that transfers flat-boundary progress to expanding balls. For MN codes, elementary inequalities establish fixed-point positivity for all these degrees. Two-dimensional density-evolution examples illustrate the dependence on the initial shortened region; the general sufficient constants are not evaluated numerically.

0.22

MacKay-Neal Codes Achieve Capacity under MAP Decoding

cs.IT ·2026-10-07 ·Kenta Kasai
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract · 22 pages

Statistical-mechanical analyses predict that MacKay-Neal codes can achieve channel capacity at fixed degrees. We prove this prediction for the uncoupled $(\ell,3,3)$ MN socket ensemble for every fixed integer $\ell\ge4$. For each binary-input memoryless symmetric channel of capacity strictly greater than $3/\ell$, the ensemble-average block error probability under maximum a posteriori (MAP) decoding is $O(\log N/N)$, where $N$ is the transmitted blocklength. The actual transmitted rate converges to $3/\ell$. The result includes both punctured and transmitted variables and does not condition the sparse square matrix on invertibility. The proof establishes an entropy inequality for six bits subject to even parity by an analytic argument that reduces the domain by symmetry, restricts its interior stationary points, where both partial derivatives vanish, to the diagonal, and controls the resulting scalar functions by explicit polynomial bounds. Exact configuration counts then bound the conditional entropy on the binary symmetric channel. A standard comparison by mutual information extends the entropy bound to general symmetric channels; independent output erasures and a minimum-distance estimate for the transmitted code yield the bit and block error bounds.

0.43