CS Paper Radar

The Multiple Unicast Conjecture is False

Mark Braverman, Zhongtian He

cs.IT cs.CCcs.DMcs.DS ·submitted 2026-10-07 13:59 UTC · v1
theoryhighly cited

Abstract

The undirected multiple-unicast conjecture [LL04] asserts that network coding offers no throughput advantage over multicommodity flow. We refute this conjecture by constructing a deterministic linear network code over $\mathbb{F}_9$ on a 182-vertex bipartite subgraph of the point-line incidence graph of $\mathrm{PG}(2,9)$. The construction supports $157$ independent unicast sessions at common coding rate at least $1$, while every fractional multicommodity flow has common rate at most $147/157$. By the amplification theorem of~[BGS17], this yields a family of undirected multiple-unicast instances with coding gap $Ω((\log n)^\varepsilon)$ for some $\varepsilon>0$. We also introduce a nondeterministic model of network coding based on locally verifiable certificates, which guides our construction and may be of independent interest. Building on the high-girth graph and error-correcting code framework of [BH25], we use GPT-6 to find a nondeterministic counterexample based on a new choice of Reed--Solomon local codes, and then convert this example into a causal code using an edge orientation and local search.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Network Coding Can Beat Routing in Undirected Multiple-Unicast Networks

cs.IT ·2026-10-07 ·Xindan Zhang, Baochun Li, Zongpeng Li
theoryhighly cited similarity 0.70
Abstract · 17 pages

Network coding lets the nodes of a network combine messages rather than merely forward them. In undirected networks, where the two directions of an edge share its capacity, Li and Li conjectured in 2004 that coding offers no advantage over fractional routing; the conjecture has been confirmed for many special classes but never settled in general. In this paper, we disprove it by constructing a finite connected simple undirected network with unit shared edge capacities, maximum degree three, and distinct leaf terminals, on which a binary linear block code achieves a common rate strictly above the maximum fractional routing rate. The construction turns a short completion-time code into a reversible circuit whose registers all carry independent messages, and a temporal metric on its wires yields the strict routing bound. The underlying integer-coefficient construction works over every finite field and every nontrivial finite abelian group; for deterministic fixed-schedule codes the common-rate supremum is one and the closure of the rate region is the unit cube. Amplifying the gap with a degree-preserving tensor construction and an even subdivision gives, for every $0<β<1$, an unbounded family of connected, simple, subcubic, bipartite networks with girth at least $n^β$ on which coding approaches rate one while routing is bounded by $K_β/(\log n)^c$, with one positive exponent $c$ independent of $β$. The finite counterexample and the family theorem are formalized in Lean.

0.65

Binary Multiple-Node-Erasure-Correcting Codes over Complete Graphs: Constructions, q-Ary Metric Balls, and Duality

cs.IT math.CO ·2026-09-01 ·Aryeh Lev Zabokritskiy
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 44 pages

Codes over graphs store symbols on edges of a complete undirected graph on $n$ vertices with a self-loop at each vertex; erasing a node removes all its incident edges. Extending Yohananov, Efron, and Yaakobi's construction, we obtain binary codes correcting any three node erasures at infinitely many prime lengths $n$, unconditionally, with redundancy $3n-2$, one bit above the graph Singleton bound. The earlier construction has the same redundancy but requires $2$ to be primitive modulo $n$, which is not known for infinitely many primes. We give a deterministic decoder for these triple-node codes using $O(n^2)$ binary operations and construct Singleton-optimal binary triple-node codes at $n=6,8,10,12$. When $2$ is primitive modulo an odd prime $n$, we extend their double- and triple-node codes to binary codes correcting $ρ$ node erasures with redundancy $ρn-(ρ-1)$ for $2\leqρ\leq(n+1)/2$, saving $ρ-1$ bits over the binary symmetric rank-metric construction when $ρ<(n+1)/2$. Over every finite field of size $q$, the node weight of a word is the least number of vertices whose erasure removes its support. We give exact formulas for ball volumes in this node metric and prove that, for fixed $q,t$, the radius-$t$ volume is asymptotic to $\binom nt q^{tn-\binom t2}$ as $n\to\infty$. We obtain existence and covering bounds; for fixed $q,ρ$, we show that linear $ρ$-node-erasure-correcting codes exist with redundancy at most $ρ\log_q n+O_{q,ρ}(1)$ above the graph Singleton bound. Finally, reformulating Yohananov and Yaakobi's criterion, we show that a linear code over any finite field is Singleton-optimal for $ρ$ node erasures if and only if its dual is Singleton-optimal for erasures of the coordinates inside any $n-ρ$ vertices.

0.31

Undirected Multiple-Unicast Network Coding and Faster External-Memory Integer Sorting

cs.DS cs.CCcs.IT ·2026-10-14 ·Baochun Li, Zongpeng Li, Sirui Liu
code/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · 43 pages, 4 figures, 1 table. Lean 4 formalization and verification code: https://github.com/rtyu-1/coded-sorting-lean

In undirected multiple-unicast networks, where independent messages are sent between specified source--destination pairs, network coding allows intermediate nodes to combine messages, whereas fractional routing splits and forwards individual messages along paths without mixing them. Proposed in 2004 by Li and Li and independently by Harvey, Kleinberg, and Lehman, the multiple-unicast conjecture---a central conjecture in network coding with deep connections to computational complexity---asserts that network coding and fractional routing have the same achievable rate region. We construct a counterexample refuting this conjecture and use it to reduce block transfers in external-memory data rearrangement, thereby accelerating external-memory integer sorting and answering in the affirmative the longstanding question of Aggarwal and Vitter (1988) on whether integer operations can beat the comparison-sorting input/output (I/O) bound. Specifically, we give a deterministic sorting algorithm: for $N$ integers of $Θ(\log N)$ bits, a memory holding $M$ integers, and block transfers of $B$ integers, where $2B\le M\le N$, the number of block transfers is \[ O\!\left(\frac{N}{B}\left[1+ \frac{\log N}{(\log(M/B))^{1-\varepsilon}(\log M)^\varepsilon} \right]\right), \] where $\varepsilon=1.5\times10^{-5}$ is an absolute constant. This bound asymptotically improves on the classical $Θ\!\left(\frac{N}{B}\left[1+ \frac{\log(N/M)}{\log(M/B)}\right]\right)$ comparison-sorting bound in certain parameter regimes. Under the external-memory model specified in this paper, we have formally verified the algorithm's correctness and I/O complexity bound in Lean~4.

0.57

Settling Nondeterministic Communication Complexity of Graph Connectivity

cs.CC ·2026-10-23 ·Zhijun Zhang
publishedtheory similarity 0.62
Abstract

Determining the communication complexity of graph connectivity has been one of the longest standing open problems in communication complexity since the seminal work of Babai, Frankl, and Simon [FOCS'86]. A simple protocol transmits a spanning forest using $O(N\log N)$ communication on $N$-vertex graphs. While this was shown optimal for deterministic protocols by Hajnal, Maass, and Turán [STOC'88], the optimal nondeterministic and randomized complexities have remained unresolved for decades. We settle the nondeterministic communication complexity of graph connectivity by proving an optimal $Ω(N\log N)$ lower bound. The best prior bound was $Ω(N\log\log N)$ due to Raz and Spieker [Combinatorica'95]. Our bound is shown by upper bounding the maximum size of $1$-monochromatic rectangles. Generalizing our techniques to weighted, almost $1$-monochromatic rectangles yields an $Ω(N \cdot \log(\min(1/\varepsilon,N)))$ lower bound for randomized protocols with error probability $\varepsilon$. In particular, this bound is optimal for any polynomially small $\varepsilon$. For constant error probability, we also prove that any $r$-round protocol requires $Ω(N/r \cdot \log N)$ communication, which is optimal for every constant $r$. Previously, optimal $Ω(N\log N)$ lower bounds for graph connectivity were known only for $1$-round [Sun, Woodruff; APPROX/RANDOM'15] and $2$-round protocols [Radhakrishnan, Reddy, Venkat; ITCS'26]. Our proof introduces a new communication problem which can be viewed as a composition of inner product and pointer chasing problems. Our lower bounds can be extended to other fundamental graph properties, and also imply optimality of known query and streaming algorithms for related problems.

0.31

When Multiple-Unicast Feasibility Is Equivalent to Single-Sink Routability

cs.IT ·2026-10-24 ·Sirui Liu, Zongpeng Li, Baochun Li
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract · 14 pages, 3 figures. Revised exposition and proof presentation

In communication networks, network coding allows intermediate nodes to combine messages, achieving transmission rates unattainable by routing alone in many multicast settings. In multiple unicast, where each source sends a message only to its prescribed destination, a central question is under what conditions fractional routing suffices to attain the transmission rates supported by network coding. We prove that, for any given collection of multiple-unicast demands in an undirected network, if the maximum flow between every pair of distinct destinations is at least the total demand rate, then the following are equivalent in feasibility: multiple-unicast coding, multiple-unicast fractional routing, and simultaneous fractional routing of all source rates to any fixed destination. Verifying this pairwise maximum-flow condition and, when it holds, deciding feasibility of the given multiple-unicast demands require at most as many maximum-flow computations as there are destinations. As a direct corollary, we prove the Langberg--Médard conjecture: if a directed network supports coded multicast of independent source messages at a common rate to every destination, then removing arc directions without changing capacities permits simultaneous fractional routing at that rate for all prescribed source--destination pairs.

0.25

On the Vertices That Belong to All Minimum Identifying Codes

cs.DM math.CO ·2026-09-09 ·Ville Junnila, Tero Laihonen, Havu Miikonen
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract

Identifying codes in graphs have been widely studied since their introduction by Karpovsky, Chakrabarty and Levitin in 1998. In this paper, we consider the vertices that are in every minimum identifying code in a graph. There are two types of such vertices: \emph{always-forced} vertices that belong to all identifying codes (minimum or not) and \emph{min-forced} vertices that belong to all minimum identifying codes. A vertex is called \emph{proper-min-forced} if it is min-forced but not always-forced. We show an upper bound $2n/3$ for the number of such proper-min-forced vertices in a closed-twin-free graph of order $n$. Moreover, for integers $n$ divisible by three, we construct an infinite family of graphs in which there are $2n/3-1$ such vertices. In addition, we determine the maximum number of edges in a graph of even order such that the graph contains proper-min-forced vertices. We also show that the decision problem of determining whether a given vertex in a graph is proper-min-forced is co-NP-hard.

0.20

The Deterministic Broadcast Channel Revisited: A Bipartite Graph Approach

cs.IT ·2026-09-20 ·Yiyu Qiu, Wei Chen, H. Vincent Poor
published similarity 0.61
Abstract

The general broadcast channel (BC) has attracted considerable attention because it is a central problem in network or multi-user information theory. The deterministic BC (det-BC), in which both output symbols are functions of the input symbol, plays a vital role in understanding general BCs. In the 1970s, Marton and Pinsker investigated the det-BC independently using a random coding approach and hence quantified its capacity region as functions of the entropy of output symbols. In this paper, we present a purely deterministic and combinatorial treatment of the deterministic BC, which is in contrast to Marton and Pinsker's probabilistic treatment. In particular, we show that each det-BC can be uniquely and completely characterized by a bipartite graph. Based on the bipartite graph model, we present the explicit capacity region of the general det-BC and a deterministic capacity-achieving coding scheme. Specifically, each point on the capacity region boundary is expressed as an explicit function of the degree sequences of the two parts, with boundary coordinates parametrized by the tangent slope. As a result, a closed-form capacity region, which was previously unknown except for special cases such as the Blackwell channel, can be analytically determined, without optimizing the probability distribution of input symbols numerically. For a bipartite graph consisting of multiple isolated subgraphs, there can exist a commonly decodable message while preserving the maximum achievable sum rate, and its achievable rate is explicitly characterized. Finally, the bipartite-graph formulation allows us to construct optimal finite-blocklength coding for the det-BC through binary linear programming.

0.40

Six Families of Binary Codes Arising from Ding's Conjectures

cs.IT ·2026-09-29 ·Xiaoqiang Wang, Shiyan Xiong, Mu yuan, Jing Qiu, Dabin Zheng +1 more
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract

Ding \cite{Ding2016} proposed ten conjectures on binary linear codes arising from Boolean functions. Four of them, namely Conjectures 38--41, were subsequently proved by Göloğlu and Krasnayová \cite{GologluKrasnayova2019}. In this paper, we investigate the remaining six conjectures, namely Conjectures 19, 27, 30, 33, 34, and 37. For Conjectures~19 and~27, we obtain common weight restrictions and several infinite five-weight families. For Conjecture~30, we prove that every admissible code has three, four, or five nonzero weights, and an explicit four-weight example disproves the original ``three or five weights'' assertion. For Conjecture~33, an infinite five-weight family is obtained. For Conjecture~34, we obtain a general $(2h+1)$-weight upper bound and give an explicit six-weight counterexample, showing that the original ``three or five weights'' assertion is false in general, where $h$ is a positive integer. The case $h=3$ with $3\nmid m$ is also completely determined. Finally, Conjecture~37 is completely resolved by combining the known results of Ahmadi and Shafaeiabr \cite{AhmadiShafaeiabr2023} with the treatment of the two remaining classes $(a)$ and $(b)$.

0.04