CS Paper Radar

An ecology of participation for fusion energy development

Aditi Verma, Katie Snyder, Andrea Morales Coto, Nathan Kawamoto, Daniel Hoover, Ana Kova, Sara Eskandari, Stephanie O'Malley, Jared Owens, Mahmud Farooque, Gabrielle Hoelzle, Stephanie Diem, Kevin Daley

cs.CY physics.soc-phcs.HC ·submitted 2026-10-07 21:12 UTC · v1
position

Abstract

Decisions that will shape future fusion facilities, including the production of waste, the management of tritium, the achievement of safety, and impacts on land, water, and local communities, are increasingly becoming sociotechnical in nature. For prior energy technologies, fission among them, such decisions were made top-down and met sustained public opposition. Research shows such opposition is rarely a deficit of public understanding and is instead rooted in place-specific environmental, health, sociocultural, and economic concerns and in distrust of how technologies are selected and sited. We argue that fusion developers have an opportunity to design differently, and we propose an ecology of participation: multiple, complementary modalities of engagement sustained over time, replacing the one-off public consultations now typical of large infrastructure projects. We synthesize human- and environment-centered design frameworks and introduce a framework that reinterprets opposition as a divergence between communities and technology developers in values, norms, or design characteristics. We present six case studies from our work: participatory technology assessment focus groups, participatory design workshops, immersive virtual-reality models of a fusion facility, the Global Fusion Forum platform, the Imaginary Energies speculative design platform, and Heartbeat, an arts-based sound installation. Mapping these onto the values-norms-design framework shows how each interrogates or closes a different part of the expert-public gap, and exposes two limitations of fusion public engagement efforts writ large: developers are seldom asked to articulate their own values and norms, and the environment is represented only indirectly. We close with five guiding questions for fusion researchers building their own participatory engagements.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Repertoires of Contention: Building computational tools and infrastructures for community resistance to bitcoin mining

cs.CY cs.HC ·2026-11-10 ·Marina Johnson-Zafiris, Owen Marshall, Jen Liu, Joseph Ferdinando, Steven J. Jackson +1 more
position similarity 0.57
Abstract · As submitted to ACM CHI 2025

Recent work in human-computer interaction and allied fields has sought to engage community members as co-designers, facilitators, and decision makers to challenge structural power barriers and knowledge gaps. In this paper, we apply a diverse set of computational techniques to engage and address community concerns surrounding the socio-environmental impacts of the Greenidge Bitcoin mining power plant facility in upstate New York. Through collaborative interactions with community groups, addressing problems ranging from regulatory inertia to thermal water pollution, we aim to facilitate not just the production of new and critical environmental knowledge but also new computationally-supported repertoires of contention: means of contesting the unequal relations of knowledge and power that structure and often determine the outcomes of environmental controversies. We argue such engagements can help support more politically engaged forms of HCI, oriented towards efforts to redress and repair disparities in wealth, knowledge, and influence through strategic sociotechnical interventions and alliances.

0.35

"You Can't Just Automate It": Negotiating and Sustaining a "Good" Family Life Through Energy Practices

cs.HC ·2026-09-24 ·Yang Hong, Ying-Yu Chen, Wei-Chien Chang, Yu-Hsin Chou, Sharifa Sultana
similarity 0.54
Abstract

This study examines how Taiwanese parent-child families negotiate a "good" family life through everyday energy use and imagine future smart homes that support it. We conducted in-home interviews and co-design sessions with 21 families, including 46 parents and children. We found that families pursued a good life through energy practices shaped by thrift, comfort, care, safety, and enjoyment. These arrangements were continually adapted and responded to changing bodies, schedules, people, and infrastructures. This adaptive work was unevenly distributed, which in turn shaped different smart-home imaginaries. Drawing on the lens of Nearby and adversarial design, we conceptualize adaptation as situated sociotechnical work through which families continually rework energy arrangements. We further distinguish collective goods from plural and contestable goods to show why family IoT must support shared values while preserving opportunities to question and revise household arrangements. We offer theoretical and design directions for more adaptive, participatory, and contestable family IoT.

0.28

Scoring and Gamification to Encourage Sustainable Use of Compute Clusters

cs.HC ·2026-08-19 ·Maximilian MacDonald, Chris McCaig, Sean MacAvaney, Matthew Barr, Lauritz Thamsen
similarity 0.54
Abstract · 5 pages, 1 figures. Accepted at the 2nd International Workshop on Low Carbon Computing (LOCO 2026), Lancaster University, United Kingdom, 10…

The environmental cost of computing continues to grow, yet behaviour change remains limited. We present a composite sustainability score integrating average carbon intensity, resource utilisation, and embodied emissions into a single 0-100 metric designed for gamified feedback. Each component rewards a different dimension of sustainable behaviour: carbon-aware workload shifting, high resource utilisation, and selecting hardware that is commonly underutilised. This scoring system is built into an existing cluster management interface and underpins three dashboard conditions: raw metrics, composite score, and a gamified tree visualisation, which we are planning to evaluate in a 12-week within-subjects study with approximately 35 researchers. Furthermore, we open the discussion on the challenge of defining computational work `goodness' in the context of sustainability scores.

0.34

Appearing Legitimate is Not Enough: Interrogating Synthetic Agents in Representational Processes through a Participatory Design Lens

cs.HC cs.CY ·2026-08-17 ·Aditya Nayak, Aditi Vashistha, Alissa Centivany, Aakash Gautam
publishedposition similarity 0.51
Abstract · 13 pages total, 4 figures, accepted to the 9th AAAI Conference on AI, Ethics, and Society (AIES 2026)

Synthetic agents built atop LLM-based foundation models are gaining popularity as substitutes for human participants across research contexts, including user-testing, market-research, computational social science, surveys, and qualitative research. We are also witnessing an extension of synthetic agents into experimental implementations of policy consultation, jury deliberation, humanitarian diplomacy, and similar contexts where human participation and representation are central to the perceived legitimacy of the institutional processes. The value of participation extends beyond informational contributions and consensus generation; participation is a necessary, legitimizing condition for democratic political institutions and processes. Treating synthetic agents as human substitutes raises serious political, representational, and ethical concerns. Participatory Design's modes of engagement --- probing, priming, understanding, and generating --- offer helpful tools for engaging with representational questions of personhood. We apply the lens to three case studies of synthetic agents substituting for personhood at varying representational scales: local policy, enterprise jury deliberation, and global diplomacy. We argue that legitimacy and personhood are integral and mutually constitutive while identifying the ethical, representational, and methodological risks of using synthetic agents in representational processes. We conclude by proposing soft and hard boundaries for designing oversight on LLMs and synthetic agents in representational processes.

0.28

WebXR and Commercial Game Engines for the Metaverse: A Socio-Technical Analysis of Openness, Interoperability, and Sustainability

cs.CY ·2026-09-03 ·Luca Turchet, Michel Buffa
position similarity 0.50
Abstract · IEEE International Symposium on Emerging Metaverse 2026

The Metaverse is often framed as a persistent, interoperable, and embodied network of virtual and augmented environments. Yet, most contemporary XR applications are developed through commercial game engines and distributed through proprietary app stores, creating tensions between openness and platform dependency. This paper critically examines open WebXR technologies with conventional commercial game-engine pipelines, with particular attention to XR hardware, software architectures, developer workflows, governance, ethics, interoperability, and sustainability. We argue that WebXR may provide a viable route toward a more accessible, device-independent, and institutionally sustainable Metaverse, especially for education, research, cultural heritage, prototyping, and public-interest applications. At the same time, commercial engines remain advantageous for graphically intensive, low-latency, deeply integrated, and large-scale XR products. The paper concludes that the choice should not be framed as WebXR versus engines, but as a continuum: WebXR is preferable when accessibility, interoperability, low-friction deployment, and long-term maintainability are primary goals, whereas native engines remain preferable when performance, platform-specific hardware access, and production-grade tooling dominate.

0.26

Climate Physicalization: Bridging Tangible Interaction and Data Visualization for Environmental Communication

cs.HC ·2026-10-15 ·Milena Vuckovic, Marlene Huber, Fabrizia Bando-Bechtold, Daniel Cornel, Daniel Pahr
similarity 0.50
Abstract · 10 pages

Raising awareness of climate topics, such as urban heat mitigation, requires communicating complex data to a broad audience. Data physicalization has emerged as a novel method to connect audiences to such complex topics through tangible forms while also leveraging interactivity to foster deeper engagement. This paper introduces an situated geospatial thermal physicalization prototype, designed to enhance communication and education of environmental information through hands-on engagement. The physical model depicts a 3D model of an urban neighborhood, with radiation data represented as a layered contour structure. The model incorporates three interchangeable climate adaptation scenarios, alongside an externally mounted, electronically driven solar path representation featuring multiple discrete LEDs that can be switched on and off at will. To investigate how people engage with the model, we conducted a hands-on qualitative lab study with 16 participants, using think-aloud, observational, and questionnaire protocols. Overall, participants responded very favorably to the model, highlighting the novelty of the visualization approach and its capacity to improve the interpretability of the presented information.

0.24

Developer Attitudes and Practices Towards Optimizing Software Energy Consumption

cs.SE ·2026-08-31 ·Max Weber, Alina Mailach, Florian Sattler, Sven Apel, Norbert Siegmund
similarity 0.50
Abstract · 36 pages, journal paper

Context: Software significantly influences the efficiency with which hardware resources are utilized, yet software energy consumption is seldom treated as a first-class concern in day-to-day development practice. Objective: This study investigates professional developers' attitudes, decision-making, and development practices related to software energy consumption, with particular emphasis on how energy considerations are recognized, assessed, and acted upon during software development. Method: To this end, we conduct an online survey with 134 software developers. Our study combines quantitative analyses with a qualitative open-card sorting of free-text responses to characterize perceptions, practices, and reasoning patterns around energy consumption. Findings: Energy consumption is explicitly considered in only a minority of projects. More commonly, developers influence energy use indirectly by optimizing proxy properties such as execution time and CPU utilization. Responses to scenario-based questions reveal systematic blind spots in this mental model, including cases in which performance improvements increase energy consumption or exhibit no correlation. We also identify organizational disincentives, limited tooling, and educational gaps as major barriers to adoption. Implications: (1) Institutionalize energy-aware approaches through visible flagship deployments that demonstrate value, (2) expand research and education on energy-performance trade-offs, and (3) develop practical, developer-oriented measurement and feedback tools that lower adoption barriers.

0.26

No One Left Behind: Cross-Level Analysis for Sustainable Software Engineering

cs.SE ·2026-09-03 ·Masoum Salehi, Sandro Schulze, Jacob Krüger
top venueposition similarity 0.50
Abstract · Accepted for publication at the 2026 IEEE International Conference on Software Maintenance and Evolution (ICSME)

Software engineers expect a software system to be efficient, maintainable, economically viable, and socially responsible throughout its lifecycle. Unfortunately, decisions made at the organizational, process, or product levels of software development - even when they improve one of these goals - often have unintended long-term consequences at other levels. In response, software-engineering research has explored different ways to achieve software sustainability, including energy efficiency, resource optimization, and code maintainability. However, existing research offers limited explanations for how sustainability problems emerge and reinforce one another across the socio-technical levels of software engineering. Moreover, we argue that sustainability challenges are not isolated but rather systemic: They stem from interactions among organizational priorities, development practices, and technical conditions. In this vision paper, we introduce the concept of sustainability antipatterns to capture conditions that systematically produce unsustainable outcomes. We demonstrate how this concept can help expose cross-level misalignments between socio-technical levels and sustainability dimensions that remain difficult to recognize through artifact-centric or dimension-specific analyses. To guide future research, we outline concrete directions for identifying, formalizing, detecting, and mitigating sustainability anti-patterns. We envision sustainability anti-patterns as a foundation for an integrated and actionable research agenda on sustainable software engineering.

0.40