CS Paper Radar

Window Size Matters: Benchmarking Voice Activity Detectors in Noise

Alok Kumar, Mohit Srivastava, Anupam Purwar, Kuldeep Kumar Nigam, Yash Anchaliya, Pranav Wadhwa, Debrup Paul

cs.SD ·submitted 2026-10-10 05:51 UTC · v2
benchmark

Abstract

Voice activity detection (VAD) sits in front of almost every streaming speech recognizer, yet the choice of detector is often made by feel rather than by measurement. We report a frame-level offline benchmark of three detectors on the test-clean split of LibriVAD-small: the neural TEN VAD, the neural Silero VAD and a simple RMS energy baseline. The evaluation covers 2,214 noisy utterances (about 7.1 hours) built from LibriSpeech, nine noise families and six SNR levels from -5 to 20 dB. At a 16 ms hop, TEN VAD reaches a ROC AUC of 0.917, an average precision of 0.968 and an F1 of 0.913. A sweep over 20, 30, 40 and 50 ms windows shows TEN to be almost insensitive to frame length (AUC 0.916 to 0.919), while RMS stays near 0.75 to 0.77. Silero matches TEN only near its native 32 ms input size and drops to 0.63 at 20 ms. We hypothesize that this is likely caused by our fixed-frame protocol rather than by the model itself. Zero padding, sub-chunk averaging and unreset model state are the likely factors, but we have not ablated them. In a per-condition breakdown of TEN, babble noise at low SNR stays close to chance. We also show that F1 at a fixed 0.5 threshold is a weak metric on this data, because a trivial all-speech detector already scores 0.854. All settings needed to reproduce the results are given in the paper.

Comment
Offline frame-level benchmark of TEN VAD, Silero VAD and an RMS energy baseline on LibriVAD

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Low-Latency State Space Voice Activity Detection with Robust Onset Time Evaluation

eess.AS ·2026-09-10 ·Elad Cohen, Arnon Netzer, Hai Victor Habi
hot direction similarity 0.63
Abstract · 8 pages, 4 Figure

Voice Activity Detection (VAD) systems are commonly evaluated using metrics such as the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC), but these metrics do not account for temporal responsiveness. For low-latency applications, however, accurately measuring speech onset delay is essential. This is particularly challenging because onset latency evaluation is affected by noise and systematic misalignment in annotation timestamps. In this work, we introduce a probabilistic framework for evaluating VAD onset time under noisy temporal labels. We model annotated onset times as noisy observations of latent acoustic onsets and estimate the resulting discrepancy distribution from data. We show that this approach provides a more stable and robust estimate of algorithmic latency. In addition, we introduce S4VAD, the first state-space-model-based (SSM-based) VAD architecture. S4VAD supports efficient streaming inference while directly controlling the decay of past acoustic evidence, enabling fast and responsive speech-onset detection. We evaluate VAD onset latency across several low-latency architectures, including CNN, Transformer, and RNN models. Our proposed VAD achieves the lowest latency while maintaining a competitive AUROC.

0.32

Perceptually Better, Semantically Worse: Measuring Speech Enhancement Impact on LLM-Based Voice Systems

cs.SD eess.AS ·2026-08-31 ·Randy Frans Fela, Pejman Mowlaee
top venuebenchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract · Accepted at EMNLP 2026. 12 pages, 4 figures, 8 tables

Speech enhancement (SE) is commonly applied as a preprocessing step in spoken AI pipelines under the assumption that better audio quality improves downstream task performance. Whether SE-induced distortions propagate to downstream LLM task performance remains an open question. We introduce Output Divergence Rate (ODR), which measures how often SE changes an LLM's intent classification relative to clean speech, and benchmark five conditions on 2,974 SLURP clips using Whisper large-v3 and wav2vec2-large cascades. Every condition produces ODR significantly above zero ($p < 0.001$, binomial test). MetricGAN{+} more than doubles ODR versus unenhanced noisy speech (0.318 vs. 0.135) despite improving PESQ, and unmitigated echo reaches an ODR of 0.836 through speaker substitution, a failure WER cannot capture. Audio quality metrics range from near-zero to moderate correlation with ODR (SQUIM-MOS $ρ=-0.068$, PESQ $ρ=-0.467$). The MetricGAN{+} and echo results replicate across ASR architectures, indicating that standard audio quality metrics are insufficient for LLM pipeline quality.

0.47

Clean-anchored excess-emission control for CTC adaptation under competing speech

cs.SD ·2026-11-02 ·Yuanbo Zhou, Junjie Xiong
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Competing speech can cause excess emissions in a connectionist temporal classification (CTC) recognizer. We penalize the amount by which the noisy student's expected collapsed token count exceeds a frozen teacher's count on the paired clean utterance. The one-sided objective caches one scalar per utterance and adds no inference module. With 147,456 trainable parameters in wav2vec 2.0, it improves competing-speech word error rate (WER) over matched CTC-only adaptation across three development seeds. On a locked LibriSpeech test, speech-interference WER falls from 45.198% to 44.323%, while clean WER changes by 0.004 percentage points. Unseen VCTK interferers yield a 0.307-point improvement. Ablations favor collapsed-count control over frame-mass regularization. Longer training increases the speech gain but worsens noise and music performance, identifying an insertion-deletion tradeoff rather than uniform robustness.

0.17

SURE-Voice: A Front-End Baseline for Speech-Evidence Filtering in Speech LLMs

eess.AS cs.CLcs.SD ·2026-08-27 ·Mengzhe Geng
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

Speech language models (speech LLMs) can generate plausible outputs from audio that contains no usable speech evidence. We study this failure as a pre-generation support-estimation problem and present SURE-Voice, a training-free front end that decides whether an audio prompt contains intelligible speech evidence before calling a speech LLM. We build SURE-Challenge with a 640-example SURE-Core split and a 1,920-example SURE-Extended split derived from 120 LibriSpeech source utterances. Using one fixed operating point, an energy screen plus Whisper token confidence raises unsupported accuracy on the held-out Extended test from 0.000--0.133 to 0.919 for six non-degenerate speech LLM backbones, while supported accuracy remains 0.919--0.970 and downstream calls fall from 480 to 287. A 500-clip ESC-50 sanity set shows the same pattern on real environmental audio, with vocal non-speech as a residual failure mode. An overlap diagnostic shows that source attribution remains separate from speech-evidence filtering. The evidence supports a controlled benchmark baseline and a deployment-oriented analysis; it does not establish universal robustness to semantic answerability, gain variation or natural conversations.

0.17

The Last Mile of Deepfake Speech Detection: An Industry-Academia Experience Report

cs.SD cs.CR ·2026-08-18 ·Anton Firc, Kamil Malinka, Vojtěch Staněk, Miroslav Hlaváček, Marek Bartoň
top venue similarity 0.61
Abstract · Accepted at the 6th Symposium on Security and Privacy in Speech Communication (SPSC 2026)

Synthetic speech detection benchmarks now report sub-1% error rates on some in-domain evaluations, yet performance degrades under unseen attacks, channel mismatch, and distribution shift. Based on a three-year effort with Phonexia, a commercial speaker-recognition vendor, we report barriers encountered while building and deploying a detector. Many public benchmarks are not licensed for commercial model development. Real inputs are not four-second clean clips but long, codec-degraded, sometimes partially synthetic recordings. And when a calibrated system returns a log-likelihood ratio of 2.5, no one can tell the customer what it means for their decision. Rather than proposing a new model, we connect these barriers to concrete research and coordination proposals: shared standards for commercially usable datasets, realistic deployment benchmarks, and scores that non-experts can act on. These observations come from one project and should be tested in other settings.

0.51

Quieter Than the Room: Representation Drift and Task Robustness in Speech Encoders

cs.SD cs.CL ·2026-09-23 ·Vsevolod Kovalev, Pranay Manocha
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Non-speech interference can change a speech representation without causing comparable task loss. We test eight frozen encoders on four tasks, adding non-speech sounds throughout recordings, during speech, or in pauses. Under whole-recording interference, embedding drift tracks task loss across seven sounds, with mean Spearman correlations of 0.81-0.88. Moving the same sound between speech and pauses changes this pattern. At quiet to moderate levels, pause interference produces larger drift, while speech interference usually causes greater loss on intent recognition, speaker verification and speech recognition. Emotion recognition shows a weaker placement effect. Pause interference also changes speech-frame representations beyond the injected region. Even below the estimated recording background, interference can change embeddings as much as repeated speech takes do. Drift helps rank the effects of different sounds, but larger drift does not consistently indicate greater task loss.

0.28

VoxLock: Target-Speaker Extraction for Voice Agents Without an Enrollment Step

eess.AS ·2026-10-29 ·Arbaz Siddiqui
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 4 pages, 4 tables. Model, code and per-file scores: https://github.com/arbazsiddiqui/voxlock

A voice agent's speech recognizer transcribes everyone near the microphone, including people other than the caller. I fine-tuned a public causal target-speaker extraction model (REAL-TSE, 27M parameters) on one GPU to work from a voice sample cut from the call itself, and released it as VoxLock. I score it by what a recognizer writes on real recordings. On Krisp's 265-recording benchmark it reaches 4.95% WER against 23.21% unprocessed and lets 9 background words into the transcript over 85 minutes of background-only speech. Its WER is not significantly different from Krisp's best filters and is significantly lower than the other commercial and open systems I tested. On 400 AMI meeting windows built and frozen before scoring, it cuts WER from 42.95% to 10.63%. The 8-bit model runs a live call on 77% of one CPU thread with 24 ms of algorithmic latency. Model, code and per-file scores are open.

0.40

BanglaTurn: A Benchmark and Whisper-Based Model for End-of-Turn Detection in Bangla Speech

cs.CL ·2026-09-24 ·Mizbaul Haque Maruf
benchmark similarity 0.61
Abstract

This paper presents BanglaTurn, a corpus for end-of-turn detection in Bangla conversational speech, and a model trained on it. The corpus holds 35,374 samples of 3 to 15 s of podcast speech, labelled for turn state by combining speaker diarization with an LLM pass, with every label then checked by a human annotator. The model pairs a Whisper encoder with task-specific classification heads. On a class-balanced test set drawn from a held-out podcast, it reaches 84.33% accuracy (95% CI 80.3 to 88.1) against 69.28% for the Smart-Turn v3 baseline, and lowers the false negative rate from 51.57% to 7.55% at the cost of a higher false positive rate. We report what encoder layer fine-tuning, multi-scale pooling and INT8 quantization each contribute, and latency stays within 165 to 191 ms end to end on CPU.

0.25